Atty. Renato N. Bantug Jr.
S00001President, the presiding officer, and senator-judges of the impeachment court.
Report correctionTimed transcript
Read the working transcript while watching the official Senate video. Search by speaker or spoken text without losing the surrounding conversation.
Timed working transcript
Click a timestamp to cue the embedded source. Speaker names reflect the current reviewed attribution.
Find in this record
All 1975 turns remain in view
President, the presiding officer, and senator-judges of the impeachment court.
Report correctionThe sergeant at arms is directed to make a proclamation.
Report correctionAll persons are commanded to keep silent under pain of penalty while the impeachment court is in session for the trial of Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte.
Report correctionThe impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte is hereby called to order. Let's bow our heads and pray. Heavenly Father, we thank you for the gift of another day and another opportunity to do your will. We gather in this August Chamber to fulfill our constitutional duties as senator-judges and serve the people from whom we owe our mandate. Lend us your wisdom. Keep us from acting out of self-interest and set our sights only on the pursuit of justice. The strengthening of our democratic institutions and the creation of good governance for future generations.
Report correctionBuksan mo ang aming isip, puso at diwa sa katotohanan. Gawian mo kami na ipagtanggol namin ang batas at higit sa lahat kung ano ang tama. This we pray in your holy name. Amen.
Report correctionJudge Cayetano Alan, Sen. Judge Cayetano Pia, Sen. Judge De La Rosa, Sen. Judge Ejercito, Sen. Judge Estrada, Sen. Judge Go, Sen. Judge Hontiveros, Sen. Judge Lacson, Sen. Judge Lapid, Sen. Judge Legarda, Sen. Judge Marcoleta, Sen. Judge Marcos, Sen. Judge Padilla, Sen. Judge Pangilinan, Sen. Judge Sotto III. Senator Judge Tulfo Erwin, Senator Judge Tulfo Raffy, Senator Judge Villanueva, Senator Judge Villar Camille, Senator Judge Villar Mark, Senator Judge Zubiri, The Presiding Officer Senator Judge Escudero, The Senate President Senator Judge Gatchalian.
Report correctionWith 13 Senator Judges present, the Chair declares the presence of a quorum. In accordance with the Rules of Procedure on Impeachment Trials, the Chair now recognizes the newly elected Presiding Officer to preside over the proceedings of the Impeachment Court.
Report correctionThank you, Mr. Senate President. If there are no objections, we shall dispense with the reading of the November 19, 2026 Journal of the Senate, sitting as an impeachment court, and consider the same. That's approved. The clerk will please call the case before the impeachment court.
Report correctionCase number 004-2026, in the matter of impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte.
Report correctionGood morning, Your Honors. For the prosecution, we are ready.
Report correctionGood morning, Honorable Ridon. For the respondent.
Report correctionGood morning, your honors. Same appearance for the respondent accused.
Report correctionWho will handle the next witness, Dr. Rodolfo Atty. Sheila?
Report correctionAtty. Justin, good morning. Call your witness.
Report correctionYes, your honor. Good morning. For our next witness, your honor. May we call to the witness stand Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, Your Honor.
Report correctionKindly situate Mr. Rodolfo to the witness stand. Clerk is directed to administer the oath as soon as he is so situated.
Report correctionWhile he is on his way to the witness stand, Chair would like to place on record in relation to the testimony of the witness yesterday. For the information once again of the parties, the senator judges, and the public. that the AMLC records offered and admitted by the court together with the other exhibits were classified under the order of this court on November 6, 2026 and the AMLC records are classified as sealed and under supervised access for senator judges, the parties, and authorized individuals only for the information and guidance of all concerned. Clerk may proceed with administering the oath.
Report correctionSir, kindly raise your right hand. You, Ceferino S. Rodolfo, do swear that the evidence you shall give in the case now pending between the Philippines and Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte shall be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. So help you God.
Report correctionKindly sit down. Dr. Rodolfo, ano po inyong palayaw kung paano namin kayo i-address?
Report correctionAnd you are a doctor because you have a doctorate or you're a medical doctor?
Report correctionDr. Perry, naunawaan niyo po ba inyong pinanumpaan kaugnay sa testimonyang ibibigay niyo sa harap ng impeachment court na ito?
Report correctionSalamat po. Kindly make your offer, Atty. Justin.
Report correctionWhat is the pleasure of Sen. Judge Erwin with the indulgence of Atty. Justin?
Report correctionMr. Presiding Officer, good morning and to all the Senator Judges. Ako po ay magtatanong sa sana and I'd like to comment
Report correctionregarding these statements na binibitiwan po ng tagapagsalita po ng vice-presidente si Atty. Panelo discrediting witness credibility ng mga senator-judges. Can we do something about this, Mr. Presiding Officer? I mean, he's not party to this case, pero siya po ang tagapagsalita ng vicepresidente. Tama po ba yun? I mean, parang, I believe, parang meron mong problema po rito. I mean, you are the spokesperson of the vicepresident na on trial here, and then magkukomento ka hinggil sa mga senator judges, the impeachment court.
Report correctionAttorney Panelo is neither a lawyer of record nor a witness to this impeachment court. Neither is he a party and therefore not covered by Rule 18. However, given the suppletory application of the Rules of Court, particularly Rule 71 on contempt, He may be covered or under the authority of this Court not under Rule 18 of our Impeachment Rules but under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court and therefore susceptible to any orders that this Court may issue us against him in relation to speech or action made by him in connection with this Impeachment Court.
Report correctionYes, presiding officer. May I suggest that we ask for his explanation or probably summon in this court? Kasi hindi yung maganda tignan being the spokesperson. Baka nakakalimutan niya on trial here is yung boss niya, yung vice president and he's the spokesperson. Parang hindi naman po yata tama, Mr. presiding officer.
Report correctionPrepared to say that the rules on agency would apply given that he is the spokesperson of the respondent, the chair will instead use simply the suppletory application of Rule 71. And if I understand the motion, instead of asking him to explain, it will be in the form of a show-cause order. Honorable Senator Judge Erwin, is that your pleasure, sir?
Report correctionI will therefore file a motion to issue a show cause order for the spokesperson of the Vice President.
Report correctionMotion is hereby approved. Clerk of Court is directed to issue a show cause order to Attorney Paolo Panelo, in regard to his remarks made yesterday afternoon, if I'm not mistaken. Yes,
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. Thank you. Turning back to my offer, Your Honor. Again, we are offering the testimony of the witness for the following purposes. Number one, that he is the Department of Trade and Industry, or DTI, Undersecretary for Industry Development and Investment Promotion. and as well the vice chairman and managing head of the board of investments number two pursuant to his authority under board resolution number 28-02 series of 2016 he issued CALE88 foods corporation certificate of registration number 2021-186 As an export enterprise engaged in PSIC 10309 manufacture of food products, export of producer of banana chips. Number three, CALE88 Foods Corporation is a duly registered export enterprise with a board of investments and is engaged in the lawful and legitimate business of producing and exporting banana chips. 4. That as a duly registered export enterprise with a board of investments, Calia 88 Foods Corporation is legally entitled to the following incentives. 1. Income Tax Holiday 2. Special Corporate Income Tax 3. Duty Exemption 4. VAT Exemption and Zero Rating Number 5, to disprove the material allegations under Article 2 of the Articles of Impeachment and the supposed forensic report of Atty. Alexander B. Cabrera to identify documents as well as to testify on matters related to the foregoing.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. For offer number one, we stipulate with regard to the position of this witness in the DTI. We We are amenable to stipulate on that. As to the rest, subject to cross, Your Honor.
Report correctionAttorney Justin, you may proceed accordingly in regard to the stipulation already made as to the qualification, position, and current job of the witness.
Report correctionUnderstood, Your Honor. Thank you for the stipulation, Attorney.
Report correctionDoc? Can you please tell us para malamang na natin what the Department of Trade and Industry is?
Report correctionThe DTI is a national government agency po that is in charge of several functions including number one yung consumer protection and number two po yung international trade relations po natin. Tapos number three po as it relates po dun sa grupo kung saan ako nakabilang. Yun pong tinatawag natin na industry development and investment promotion.
Report correctionThank you, sir. And sir, how long have you been connected with the Department of Trade and Industry, sir? If you could please tell us.
Report correctionSa pagkakaalala ko po, ako po ay naupo bilang una assistant secretary noong March 2013. Tapos po na-appoint po akong Undersecretary noong February 2016. Tapos hanggang ngayon po nandun po ako sa position na ito. Nabago lang po ng konti yung ginagampanan kong tungkulin. Pero dito po sa pinag-uusapan ngayon yung pagiging Managing Head ng Board of Investments since February 2016.
Report correctionThank you, sir. You mentioned about your position in the Board of Investments, sir. Para lang po malaman at maintindihan po nating lahat, ano po itong Board of Investments, sir?
Report correctionAng Board of Investments po, ito yung tinatawag natin na Lead Investment Promotion Agency ng gobyerno. Pag sinabi po nating investment promotion, Ang pananaw po namin dito ay hindi lang po siya promotion na marketing. Napakalaga ho na yung pagtingin namin dun sa promotion ay capital letter P. Meaning promoting the development of industries. Kasama po dyan yung policies, kasama po dyan yung capacity development, at saka po yung promotion. Kadugtong lang po yun.
Report correctionDagdag ko lang po. Ginagampanan ng Board of Investments yung pong pag-promulgate ng Strategic Investment Priorities Plan na doon po ay sinasabi po kung ano yung mga activities na priority ng gobyerno for incentives under the different incentive laws po ng gobyerno kamukha po ng Create More Law.
Report correctionAno po ang relasyon between the DTI and Board of Investments kung mayroon man, Sir?
Report correctionYung DTI po ang mother agency ng BOI. Kami po ay attached sa DTI. Ang kalihim po ng DTI ay nagsisilbing chairperson ng Board of Investments.
Report correctionMaraming salamat po, Sir. Sir, pakiulit na lang po. Sorry, Atty. Erwin, I know this is stipulated but I'll just ask the witness. Dito po sa DTI, ano po yung position nyo?
Report correctionAko po ay Undersecretary for Industrial Development and Investment Promotion.
Report correctionNow, in relation to your position as an Undersecretary in the Department of Trade and Industry, ano po yung duties and responsibilities natin, sir?
Report correctionKasama po dito yung pag-oversee ng several bureaus po. Isa po ay yung Export Marketing Bureau. Yung isa po ay yung Bureau of Import Services. Tapos po ang isa po where I also serve as the head of agency ay yung Board of Investments.
Report correctionOkay. Na-stipulate na rin po na ikaw po yung Vice Chairman and Managing Head ng Board of Investments. Pwede niyo po bang sabihin sa amin kung ano yung duties and responsibilities niyo kaugnay sa position na iyan, Sir?
Report correctionBasically po, as Managing Head ng Board of Investments, eto po yung day-to-day operation ng Board of Investments supervising apat na Functional groups sa Board of Investments. Meron po tayong Management Services Group. Meron po tayong Industry Development Services Group. Meron po tayong Investment Promotions Group. At saka po, meron din po tayong Investor Assistance Services Group.
Report correctionMaraming salamat, Sir. Sir, may sapi na pong in-issue yung Impeachment Court sa inyo at sa opisina nyo. In-instruct po kayo mag-produce ng certified true copies. Ang unang tanong po, kaugnay sa mga sapina na yun, ano yung mga letters na pinadala nyo sa impeachment court kaugnay sa pagsumite ng mga dokumento, sir? Kung mayroon man.
Report correctionMeron po tayong pinadalang letter, November 18, addressed to the honorable presiding officer ng court po in compliance of the sapina. Enumerate ko po yung mga pinadala naming dokumento, subpoena documents.
Report correctionSige po. Let's go to that letter dated November 18, 2026 po. Ano po ang mga nakasabi ng mga dokumento na ipinadala ng opisina niyo sa impeachment court na ito, kung mayroon man sir?
Report correctionOpo. Letter A po ay BOI Certificate of Registration No. 2021-186 dated December 9, 2021, issued to CALE88 Foods Corporation. Letter B po yung site inspection report. Letter C, report submitted by the firm on the project start of commercial operations. Letter D po ay yung annual reports consisting of the following. Form S1 for taxable years 2023, 2024, and 2025. Audited financial statements for Taxable Year 2023, 2024, 2025. Letter E po ay VAT Zero Rating Certification for Taxable Year 2024 and 2026. Attached with Application Form, Bank Certification of Deposit and Sales Report. Letter F, Letter Request for Endorsement of Good Standing dated April 29, 2026. Letter G, travel order for site inspection approved on April 29, 2026. Letter H,
Report correctionreport on site inspection undertaken on May 18, 2026. Letter I, endorsement of good standing dated June 16, 2026. Letter J, Certificate of Income Tax Holiday Incentive Entitlement issued to CALE88 Foods Corporation for taxable year 2024. Letter K, Letter Request for Change in the Ownership dated July 8, 2026 with the following attachment, General Information Sheet for 2024 and 2025. and letter L, letter of approval of the request for change in ownership.
Report correctionMaraming salamat po, sir. Sir, sa baba, can we just request the tech not to take it down? Sa baba po ng letter na iyon, meron pong, there is a signature above the printed name, Dr. Ceferino Rodolfo po. Kaninong lagda po iyan kung alam niyo?
Report correctionAno po yung dokumento na sinubintin nyo sa impeachment court? Certified true copy or original ba?
Report correctionYour Honor, we would just like to manifest that we will be marking the Board of Investments letter dated November 18, 2026 to this impeachment court and we request that it be marked as Exhibit D-2-1-CALE88, Your Honor.
Report correctionAttorney Justin, we are also in receipt of a letter dated November 20, 2026 signed by the witness as well with the corresponding list of documents.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. I have been furnished by the court.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. But we would like to manifest that we just received the letter and the attached documents this morning, Your Honor. Just for the record, Your Honor.
Report correctionYes, we also received it and it was dated on even date.
Report correctionSir, bukod sa BOI letter dated November 18, 2026, ano pong ibang letter ang ipinadala nyo sa impeachment court na ito patungkol sa pinanana-issue ng impeachment court na ito po? Kung mayroon man.
Report correctionMayroon po. Naka-date nga ako ng November 20, 2026. Kanina lang po namin inaabot po ito. Again, addressed to the Honorable Francis Escudero as the Presiding Officer of this Honorable Court. We have submitted the following documents. Number one po, memo request for printing of the Certificate of Registration dated December 14, 2021, signed by the
Report correctionOur BOI Extension Office in Davao. Chief, si Gil Dureza.
Report correctionNumber 2. Sir, pardon, sorry to cut you. May we just request, Your Honor, that the document be flashed as well. I understand this was just recently.
Report correctionBy the way, continuing authority, or rather authority and continuing authority to assisting counsel to approach with this at any point in time during this testimony is given.
Report correctionWe are requesting that the letter dated November 20, 2026.
Report correctionIt is the letter dated 20 November 2026. I think the
Report correctionUSB, Your Honor, is still with the court. Or, it's there.
Report correctionIn any way, Your Honor, just as not to delay the proceedings, I will proceed, Your Honor, with a hard copy with the witness.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor, we confirm. Sir, pardon, let's just continue. Can you please enumerate? The documents contained in the letter dated November 20, 2026 of the Board of Investments as you have mentioned earlier.
Report correctionNumber one, memo request for printing of the certificate of registration dated December 14, 2021. Number two, final compliance with prerequisites for issuance of certificate of registration. Number three, BOI approval letter dated December 7, 2021. Number four, official receipts of filing and registration fees. Number 5, assessment bills. Number 6, secretary certificate signed by Myrie Leaño on December 9, 2021. Number 7, affidavit of Dr. Lebosada, dated December 9, 2021. Number 8, company's contact details. Number 9, final evaluation report, AFER, compliance with documentary requirements. Number 10, project approval sheet. Number 11, application for registration filed on December 6, 2021. Number 12, the integrity pledge. Number 13, secretary certificate signed by Myrie Leaño on November 11, 2021. Number 14, financial projections. Number 15, business model. Number 16, SCIT or special corporate income tax letter of intent signed by Lourdes Lebosada. Number 17, DNR Certificate of Non-Coverage. And number 18, Basic Information on Approved MSE Project or Micro and Small Enterprise Project, CALE88.
Report correctionMaraming salamat, sir. Sir, sa baba ng letra na yan, sa letter na yan, there again appears a signature above the printed name, Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo. Whose signature is that, sir, if you know?
Report correctionAnd what is the nature of that document, sir? Is it original or certified?
Report correctionYour Honor, we request that the Board of Investments letter dated November 20, 2026 be marked as Exhibit D-2-1-A-CALE88 for the defense, Your Honor.
Report correctionSo ordered. Before you proceed, Atty. Justin, Atty. Erwin? Are you willing to stipulate as to the authenticity existence of these documents as well as the fact that they are part of the official records?
Report correctionIn order to avoid or obviate individual identification by the witness of the separate documents?
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. Your Honor, may I just clarify the extent of the stipulation of the prosecution? Are they willing to testify that the documents Stipulate that the documents submitted by the Board of Investments by virtue of the subpoena with respect to their existence, authenticity, and due execution.
Report correctionWe are willing to stipulate that these are public records and therefore there is no need to have the witness identify and authenticate the signatures in these documents.
Report correctionPardon, Your Honor. I will have to request for a clear stipulation. The request for stipulation from the defense is that the documents submitted are authentic, That they exist and that they are duly executed or they're due execution wrong. Otherwise, we would be constrained.
Report correctionI think that's fair, Attorney Erwin, but not as to the truth of the facts stated in those documents.
Report correctionOnly that they were submitted to the BOI in the regular course of business and operation, both of CALE88 and of the DTI and BOI.
Report correctionAnd that the witness has ability to identify and authenticate these documents.
Report correctionOkay. We thank the prosecution, Your Honor. We will proceed accordingly.
Report correctionFor the record, and to abbreviate the proceedings, since this is a court of record, may we just ask the marking and state and manifest the markings of each documents, Your Honor. So as we dispense with this in the course of the proceedings. Your Honor, for the record, we would like to request the marking of the following documents. BOI Letter dated November 18, 2026 to the Impeachment Court. We already requested that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-1-CALE88. And the letter dated November 20, 2026 of the BOI, we requested that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-1-A-CALE88. Proceeding to the following documents, Board of Investments Letter. dated December 9, 2021 to Dr. Lebosada. We request that this document be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-2-CALE88. Next, CALE88 Foods Corporation's Certificate of Registration as an Export Enterprise number 2021-186 dated December 9, 2021. We request that this be marked as Exhibit D-2-3-CALE88.
Report correctionNext, the specific terms and conditions for export enterprise number 2021-186. We request that this be marked as defense exhibit D-2-4-CALE88. Next, the general terms and conditions for export enterprise number 2021-186. We request that this be marked as defense exhibit D-2-5-CALE88. Next, the external contact report in close parenthesis plant visit on December 3, 2021. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-6-CALE88. Next, the CALE88 Foods Corporation's report on actual date of start of commercial operations, initial investment, and employment. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-7-CALE88. Next is CALE88 Foods Corporation's BOI Form S-1 in close parenthesis, Annual Report on Actual Operations for the Year 2023. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-8-CALE88. Next is CALE88 Foods Corporation's BOI Form S-1 in close parenthesis, Annual Report on Actual Operations for the Year 2024. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-9-CALE88. Next is CALE88 Food Corporation's BOI Form S-1. In close parenthesis, Annual Report on Actual Operations for the Year 2025. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-10-CALE88. Next is CALE88 Food Corporation's Audited Financial Statement for the Year 2023 as submitted to the Board of Investments. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-11-CALE88.
Report correctionYour Honor, may I interrupt for a bit? I see that the list is quite lengthy. If we're going to enumerate each and every document, it might take time so perhaps we can do this before the Clerk of Court, Your Honor.
Report correctionYour Honor, our position is that this is a court of record, Your Honor.
Report correctionWe'll allow it, counsel, in order to place and spread into the records the fact that all of these documents exist in relation to Callie. Dr. Perry, do you know for a fact na Callie 88 talaga ang pronunciation nito or Kale 88 or you're only guessing to?
Report correctionSorry, Honorable Senator. Nung pong tinanong po namin yung Davao BOI Extension Office, ang sabi po sa amin, yung Kale daw po. Kasi yung CA, yun po yung apelido ni...
Report correctionTapos po yung LT, Lebosada. Kaya Kale 88. Yung 8 daw po ay Infinity. Kaya Kale 88 daw po.
Report correctionSo Kale 88 talagang pronunciation? Okay. At least we're pronouncing it correctly. Atty. Justin, you may proceed with the indulgence of Atty. Erwin.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. We just ask the patience of the prosecution. But we understand where they're coming from. Next, Your Honor, is CALE88 Food Corporation's audited financial statement for the year 2024. That would be Defense Exhibit D-2-12-CALE88. Next, Your Honor, is CALE88 Food Corporation's audited financial statement for the year 2025 as submitted to the BOI. We request that it be marked as D-2-13-CALE88. Next is CALE88 Foods Corporation's VAT Zero Rate Certification, dated May 2, 2024, and they attach relevant supporting documents. We request that it be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-14-CALE88 and series, considering that this is a lump of documents. Next. CALE88 Food Corporation's VAT Zero Rate Certification dated April 10, 2026 and the attached relevant supporting documents, we request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-15-CALE88 and Series. Next would be CALE88 Foods Corporation letter dated April 29, 2026. In close parenthesis, for Certificate of Good Standing, we request that this be marked as Exhibit D-2-16-CALE88. Next is the Board of Investments Travel Order Number 2026-168 dated April 28, 2026. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-17-CALE88. Next is the Board of Investments Report on Site Inspection dated May 18, 2026. We request that this be marked as D-2-18-CALE88. Next would be the endorsement of good standing or the letter dated June 16, 2026. We request that this be marked as defense exhibit D-2-19-CALE88. Next is the certificate of income tax holiday incentive, rather, in close parenthesis CETI, dated April 22, 2025. We request that this be marked. as Defense Exhibit D-2-20-CALE88. Next is the letter request for change in ownership dated July 8, 2026 with attachments of CALE88 Food Corporation's General Information Sheet in the year 2024 and CALE88 Food Corporation's General Information Sheet in the year 2025. We request that this be marked as D-2-21-CALE88 and series.
Report correctionThe letter of approval of request for change of ownership dated October 29, 2026. We request that this be marked as D-2-CALE88. Next, Your Honor, we would like to refer to the document submitted in relation to the November 20, 2026 letter. The memo MSE application dated December 16, 2021 signed by Dureza. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-22, sorry, D-2-23, rather, Your Honor, -CALE88. The final compliance with three requisite for issuance of certificate of registration signed by Dureza. We request that it be marked as D-2-24-CALE88. The BOI approval letter dated December 7, 2021, we request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-25-CALE88. The OR of filing, the official receipts to be specific of filing and registration fees, we request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-26-CALE88. The assessment bills or number 5 as stated in the letter. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-27-CALE88. Next is the Secretary Certificate signed by Myrie Leaño on December 9, 2021. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-28-CALE88. Next is the affidavit of Dr. Lebosada, dated December 9, 2021. We request that this be marked as D-2-29-CALE88. Next would be the company's contact details. We request that this be marked as Exhibit D-2-30-CALE88. Next is the FER compliance with documentary requirements. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-31-CALE88
Report correctionNext is the Project Approval Sheet. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-32-CALE88. Next is the Application for Registration filed on December 6, 2021. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-33-CALE88. Next is the Integrity Pledge. Submitted to the Board of Investments, we request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-34-CALE88. Next is the Secretary Certificate signed by Myrie Leaño on November 11, 2021. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-35-CALE88. Next is the financial projections of CALE88 as submitted to the Board of Investments. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-36-CALE88. For next would be the business model as submitted to the Board of Investments. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-37-[unclear]. The next is the SCIT letter of intent signed by Dr. Lourdes Lebosada We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-38-CALE88. Next would be the DNR Certificate of Non-Coverage. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-39-CALE88. And lastly for this witness. Insofar as the letters are concerned, the basic information on approved MSE project CALE88 would request that this be marked as defense exhibit D-2-40-CALE88, Your Honor. Thank you for the patience, Your Honor.
Report correctionYes, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Riza?
Report correctionSalamat po, Mr. Presiding Officer. Hindi pa po natatanggap ng representasyong ito yung mga dokumentong binanggit ng defense. So, kumari lamang pong hilingin sa Clerk of Court na ipadala po sa amin para mapag-aralan na po namin. Salamat po, Presiding Officer.
Report correctionKindly furnish Senator Risa and other senator judges who request a copy of the document. Attorney Justin, with the indulgence of Attorney Erwin, I allowed the narration, basically, of the enumeration of the documents In the hope of being able to abbreviate the proceedings because the articles of impeachment only made mention of CALE88 as a possible source of funds of the Vice President. I believe the questions pertaining to CALE88, either not having enough employees or having a low payment rate for their electric bill,
Report correctionInsinuating that it is not an ongoing business came from some of the senator judges. And number three, mention was made in the Cabrera report, namely pages 34 and 35. Basically also insinuating that CALE88 is not a real functioning business.
Report correctionThe exact term, Your Honor, if I may, stated by the supposed forensic expert is that CALE88 is allegedly an implausible business model that is found on page 36 of the forensic report.
Report correction36, yes. And that is what you are trying, for the information of the senator, judges, and the public, that is what you are trying to establish with this witness and the succeeding witness.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. And of course, among other things, including the insinuation or accusation in the forensic report under Table 39, that monies were received by Mans Carpio from this corporation, Your Honor.
Report correctionWithout any consideration or products being sold?
Report correctionThank you, Your Honor. We thank the prosecution and the court's patience.
Report correctionSir, magandang umaga. Balik po tayo. Isa sa mga dokumento na sinubuti niyo po is itong BOI letter dated December 9, 2021, addressed to Dr. Lebosada.
Report correctionWhat is this letter about if you know? May we request the tech to zoom please?
Report correctionIto po yung letter galing po sa aming board secretary informing si Dr. Lebosada na yung in-apply po nila na proyekto. For registration sa Board of Investments as an exporter of banana chips under the CREATE law ay na-approve na po. Tapos po, inattach din po dito yung certificate of registration at saka po yung terms and conditions nung kanilang registration. Pati rin po kung ano yung incentives na makukuha nila during a certain period po, 10-year period from the start of commercial operation.
Report correctionSorry for interrupting, sir. Thank you, sir. Now, in that letter dated December 9, 2021 of the Board of Investment, it states, and I quote, "New export producer of banana chips under Republic Act 11534." Sir, could you please explain what that sentence means, sir? Oo.
Report correctionIbig sabihin po kasi yung RA-11534 is the CREATE law. Yun po ang Corporate Recovery and Tax Incentives for Enterprises Act. Yun po yung nagsasaad kung ano yung mga incentive na pwedeng makuha ng mga activities na magre-register sa mga investment promotion agencies.
Report correctionYung naman pong eligibility kung sino yung mga activities na yun ay manggagaling po yun sa strategic investment priorities plan. So, yung export production po ay kasama doon sa priority industries, priority activities.
Report correctionYes, sir. And just to clarify, sir, meron po kasing attorney Elyjean DC Portoza, na nakapirma sa letrang yan. Sino po sila, sir? In relation to the Board of Investments.
Report correctionNung panahon na ito po siya po yung Director for Legal Services. Tapos po siya rin po yung tumatay yung Board Secretary ng Board.
Report correctionI hope I'll be allowed this question. Direktsyohin ko na sir. The letter who issued this office, Davao branch ba ng Board of Investments or national office niyo po?
Report correctionThank you sir. Now... One of the documents that you produced today as well is, and attached to that letter actually, is CALE88 Food Corporation Certificate of Registration as an Export Enterprise No. 2021-186 dated December 9, 2021. Nakikita niyo po, sir?
Report correctionNasa inyo na po. Thank you, sir. Sir, can you please explain to us all? What this certificate of registration is for sir?
Report correctionIto lang po yung nagpapatunay na si CALE88 ay narehistro na po yung proyekto na inapply niya po sa Board of Investments. Sinasabi din po dito at yung pong specific activity niya ay yung pagmanufacture ng banana chips na iye-export po niya. Pagkatapos po, nakalagay din po dito kung ano yung mga incentives na entitled po siya, including po yung income tax holiday for 6 years, pagkatapos po yung special corporate income tax for 10 years, tapos po duty exemption, tsaka VAT exemption, and zero rating.
Report correctionMaraming salamat, Sir. At again, to clarify, sino po nag-issue ng Certificate of Registration na ito?
Report correctionNow, if you know sir, ano po yung mga requirements to secure this Certificate of Registration as an export enterpriser?
Report correctionPag mag-a-apply po sila, kailangan po nilang mag- Mag-fill up po ng BOI Form 501 na tinatawag namin. Ito po yung application for registration. Tapos kailangan nilang mag-attach ng secretary's certificate authorizing yung representative nila to apply. Tapos yung business registration kagaya po ng SEC incorporation papers po nila. Financial projections for five years. Yung business model po, yung integrity pledge, yung endorsement certification or other documents required po under dun sa guidelines po ng strategic investment priority plan. Google map po na magpapakita kung saan yung lugar nung production. Tapos po yung Notice na na-post na po ito sa BOI website. Ipo-post po namin sa BOI website. Tapos po yung payment ng filing fee.
Report correctionIf I may interrupt, I just noticed that the witness is reading from notes which are handwritten. May we just know what the document is?
Report correctionIto po yung nilista lang po namin kung ano yung mga document requirements.
Report correctionThank you, Your Honor. Thank you, Your Honor. We will proceed, Your Honor.
Report correctionNow, sinabi niyo po may mga requirements. Saan po kailangan isumite yung lahat ng mga requirements na yan?
Report correctionIto po ay MSME po kasi siya eh. Dahil po dun po sa project cost niya, below 15 million pesos po siya. In-streamline po natin yung sistema sa BOI. Kung di ako nagkakamali, 2016 may in-issue po kaming board resolution na para po sa mga Micro and Small Enterprises na delegated function na po yung pag-evaluate at saka pag-approve doon po kung nasa Luzon po ay doon po sa Executive Director ng Industry Development Service. Pagka nandun naman po sa labas ng Luzon, depende po kung sino yung BOI Extension Office na may jurisdiction. Para dito po, ito pong BOI Extension Office sa Davao po yun. Nag-evaluate at saka nag-approve. So si... So sa kanila po sinubmit.
Report correctionAt ano na naman po ang mga assessment na sinasagawa ng ating Board of Investments bago po maaprubahan ang isang Certificate of Registration of an Export Enterpriser?
Report correctionMeron po tayong final evaluation report na ginagawa po doon sa application po. May sinasubmit din po. Yun namang in this particular case yung Davao office po natin yung nagsubmit noon.
Report correctionOkay. Sinabi niyo po sir na kayo po yung nakapirma sa Certificate of Registration pero yung nag-assess po ay yung Davao office. Ano po ba talaga ang sistema natin sa Board of Investments po?
Report correctionPara po sa MSME so kasi delegated function po yung pag-assess at saka pag-approve. Pag na-approve na po nila ay kinocompile po yun every First board meeting of the month. Tapos nire-report po yun sa board for notation. Tapos po, on that basis po, tsaka ini-issue yung certificate of registration.
Report correctionAt this point, sir, may papakita po kami na isang publicly available document downloaded from the Board of Investments website. Ito po yung registering with the BOI. This is a PDF brochure. Can you please look over that document? And we request the tech to scan on the first page first before proceeding to that part. First page.
Report correctionSir, what, if you know, what is this online brochure that is downloadable in the Board of Investments website, sir?
Report correctionAh, okay. Ito po yung mga documents na para mapadali yung pagpapaalam sa mga publiko kung paano mag-register sa BOI.
Report correctionNow, we proceed to the page 8 to 9 of that publicly available document from the BOI. Can we zoom in on that portion please? It states sa upper left corner You only need five simple steps in registering with us. But what I'm interested in is actually step number two, sir. It states that a copy of the notice of publication for publication in any newspaper of general circulation. Sir, baka pwede niyo pong i-explain sa amin ano po itong notice of publication in relation to an application, sir, with the Board of Investments.
Report correctionPara po malaman ng publiko na meron pong nag-a-apply na isang kompanya tungkol po sa isang proyekto, tapos o mabigyan po sila ng pagkakataon na mag-register ng komento. Kung halimbawa po may magsasabi na o hindi dapat yan i-register o ganun. Pwedeng ilinaw ko lang po. Kasi po yung nakalagay dito, for publication in any newspaper of general circulation, As it applies po sa CALE88, hindi po ito nag-apply dahil po micro-small enterprise nga po itong CALE88. Kaya ang ginawa po natin dito, pwede na po na ibigay po nila sa amin yung notice tapos ipopost po namin sa BOI website dahil medyo mahal din pong mag-publish siya newspaper of general circulation.
Report correctionSir, may ipapakita din kami sa inyo na Screenshot ng BOI website of the publication pertaining to the application of CALE88. May we request the tech to please flash that screenshot and zoom in.
Report correctionAs you can see sir, notice of publication for CALE88 Food Corporation. Tapos sa lower right corner, it states that it was uploaded on a certain date. and it is a downloadable notice, sir. What relation does this screenshot have to the one that you referred to, sir, na hindi po applicable yung publication sa CALE88 sa Newspaper of General Circulation?
Report correctionIto na po yung in place of that publication in a Newspaper of General Circulation, ito po yung nire-require namin sa mga MSMEs.
Report correctionNow, we actually downloaded the notice stated there, sir. And it actually states a second paragraph. Can we confront the witness and flash the notice? And I quote, rather, Any person with valid objections on the above-mentioned project may file his or her objection in writing under oath with the Board of Investments within three days from the date of this publication slash posting. Yung tanong po namin sir, based po sa records ng ating Board of Investments, ano po ang mga objection na i-file patungkol or related to the application of CALE88 Foods Corporation?
Report correctionDahil po sa na-register po siya, i-assume ko lang po na wala pong nakuwang objection yung Davao office po natin. At wala po akong nakitang dun sa kanilang evaluation report na merong nag-object.
Report correctionYour Honor, we just request that the screenshot that we just confronted to the witness and the notice of publication as referred to in the testimony be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-41-CALE88 and D-2-42-CALE88, Your Honor.
Report correctionThank you, Your Honor. Now, balikan po natin yung Certificate of Registration po na issue. Sinabi niyo po kanina, Sir, That there are requirements before you can be issued a Certificate of Registration as an Export Enterprise. You confirmed that there is actually a Certificate of Registration of Export Enterprise. What does that mean, sir, in relation to CALE88's Foods Corporation's application with the Board of Investments?
Report correctionAng ibig sabihin nun, na-comply niya po yung mga requirements po for registration.
Report correctionYes, sir. And then, next, sir, I understand, sorry.
Report correctionNow, in the certification directly, sir, Certificate of Registration No. 2021-186 dated December 9, 2021. For the record, can you just please tell us when this was issued based on that document?
Report correctionAnd can you please, for the record, tell us the expiry date? or the extent of validity of that document, sir?
Report correctionUnless canceled in the future, but dito po sa certificate of registration, wala po.
Report correctionOkay. Now, in that the same certificate of registration, sir, it states that, and I quote, this is to certify that the Board of Investments pursuant to its chapter and title 8 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1998 as amended by Republic Act No. 11534 or the Corporate Recovery and Tax Incentive for Enterprise has duly registered CALE88 Foods Corporation with Tax Identification No. 602-289-083-0000 as an export enterprise. Para po maintindihan ng lahat, Ano po ang isang export enterprise sa mata ng Board of Investment, sir? And under the law?
Report correctionIto po ay isang enterprise na nag-e-export ng at least 70% ng kanyang production.
Report correctionAnd when you say 70% of production, sir, what does that refer to, sir?
Report correctionOkay. Now, on the same document, sir, still on Certificate of Registration Number 2021-186, dated December 9, 2028, issued in favor of CALE88 Foods Corporation, it states that, and I quote, PSIC 10309, manufacturer of food products, in close parenthesis, new export producer of banana chips. Para sa amin po na hindi masyadong pamilyar, ano ang ibig sabihin ng PSIC 10309, Sir? What does that stand for?
Report correctionIto po yung Philippine Standard Industrial Classification Code or System sa atin pong Philippine Statistics Authority.
Report correctionMeron pong mga specific codes that corresponds to specific industries. Para po pag naglilikom sila ng mga reports, tama hong maiswak yung mga numero, yung mga data doon sa particular activity na iyon.
Report correctionMaraming salamat sir. Now puntahan po natin yung bottom portion ng Certificate of Registration number 2021-186 dated December 9, 2021. It states and I quote, The aforementioned registered project or activity is entitled to the following incentives. Income tax holiday, special corporate income tax, duty exemption, and VAT exemption and zero rating. Bago po natin puntahan yung bawat na incentives na yan sir. Gusto ko lang po at namin malaman, bakit po ba binibigyan natin ng mga incentives yung mga export enterprise natin?
Report correctionDahil po sa nakakapag-generate po sila ng trabaho, dahil po sa tingin natin yung value addition po dito sa mga ginagawa po nila ay may kinabang po ang ekonomiya po natin.
Report correctionAnd just to give us an idea sir, how many export enterprises do we have in the Philippines currently?
Report correctionOkay, that's okay sir. Next. Let's go specifically to the incentives. It states there that CALE88 Foods Corporation is entitled to income tax holiday. Ano po yung meaning ng income tax holiday, sir?
Report correctionYung income tax holiday po ibig sabihin po, so pag nag-ooperate ka, meron ka pong kita, may revenue ka, ileles mo po yung mga cost mo, pagkatapos po sa pinakababa po, meron kang net income. Yung net income mo po ordinarily kung hindi ka nakaregister for incentives, you will be subjected to an income tax. Yung income tax po natin pagka ang alam ko po sa CREATE law, 25% yun yung normal income tax, nagiging 20% po pagka micro-small enterprises ka po.
Report correctionSinabi niyo po na 20% if SM... On the part of CALE88, kasi sinabi dito na entitled siya to income tax holiday, what is the repercussion? Ano pong epekto nito?
Report correctionHindi po siya magbabayad ng income tax. Sa limbawa po, pag nag-start na po siya ng commercial operation, kung ano man po yung net income niya na dapat masubject ng 20% income tax, hindi na po niya babayaran yun for a period of 6 years.
Report correctionActually, that was my next question, sir. Next, sir. Okay. So, just to confirm, sir, the income tax holiday that CALE88 Foods Corporation is entitled to, how long, sir? Just for the record.
Report correctionOkay. And yung anim na taon, san po yan rekond, po?
Report correctionSo, hindi sa issuance ng Certificate of Registration?
Report correctionThank you, sir. Next. Yung pangalawang benefit na nakasabi dito or incentive to be accurate is special corporate income tax. Again sir, para maunawaan natin, ano po ang ibig sabihin itong special corporate income tax?
Report correctionPagkatapos niyang ma-exhaust yung 6 na taon na income tax holiday, susundan po yun, magbabayad na po siya ng tax. Pero ang tax na babayaran niya po ay special. Ito pong tinatawag natin na SCIT for 10 years. Ang SCIT po ay 5% tax on gross income.
Report correctionThank you, sir. Now, sinabi niyo po na SCIT is, the entitlement to SCIT is 10 years. When do you recon the start of that 10 years, sir?
Report correctionAfter po mag-expire yung... ITH, yung income tax holiday.
Report correctionSo on the 6th year from start of commercial operation, yun po yung last year na may kinabang po siya dun sa totally walang income tax. On the 7th year, magsisimula na po yung 5% tax on the gross.
Report correctionYes sir. And for the record sir, if you just know, when was the actual start of operations of CALE88 Foods Corporation?
Report correctionInitially po sa application nila sa atin, sabi niya po ang start of commercial operation niya ay January 2022 pero pinamove niya po to January 2023. So ang reckoning po namin January 2023.
Report correctionYes sir. So on the basis of that document sir, stating that the Actual start of operations of CALE88 Foods Corporation is January 1, 2023. Until when is it entitled to an income tax holiday?
Report correctionAnd until when is it entitled to a special corporate income tax?
Report correctionThank you, sir. Pasensya na pa-compute ko po kayo. Next, sir. It also states that one of the incentives given to CALE88 Foods Corporation is duty exemption. Can you please explain to us po what this duty exemption means?
Report correctionKung dito po sa create law, pagka po mag-i-import siya ng mga capital equipment, exempted po yun from paying duties o mga taripa.
Report correctionAt bakit po binibigyan natin ng duty exemption itong mga export enterprise natin?
Report correctionAgain, kasama po ito dun sa mga incentive para sa mga sectors and activities that we are promoting.
Report correctionNext is a VAT exemption and zero rating, sir. Can you please explain to us what a VAT exemption and zero rating means?
Report correctionMahalaga po ito dahil po ordinarily, Magbabayad ka po yung supplier mo po kasama doon sa mga ibibili sa iyo na pag bumili ka ng materyales kasama po yung VAT. Ipapasa niya po sa iyo yun. Pagka meron kang VAT zero rating na certificate, yun pong supplier mo hindi ka na pagbabayari ng VAT. So I think 12% din po yung VAT na yun. So makakatipid ka po doon.
Report correctionOkay. And ano po ang entitlement ni CALE88 sa income tax, holiday, special corporate income tax, duty exemption, and VAT exemption zero rating to this day, sir?
Report correctionNow, you mentioned we also tackled all these incentives, sir. Now, what relation do the specific terms and conditions and the general terms of conditions That you produced in your subpoena have to those incentives, sir? Ano po ang relasyon nila?
Report correctionYun pong specific terms and conditions niya. Kailangan po compliance siya dun sa mga inagreehan niya ho na specific terms and conditions para maging eligible po siya dun to receive the incentives.
Report correctionAt ano naman po yung, meron din po kasi akong nakitang dokumento na general terms and conditions. Ano po yung pagkaiba niya sa special terms and conditions?
Report correctionYung general terms and conditions, ito po yung applicable sa lahat. Pero para sa project na po ito, dahil doon siya sa specific item po na export producer, so ito po yung requirement. As it applies to the project po, ito po yung requirement niya.
Report correctionThe next document we'll discuss, sir, is the external contact report or plant visit. We request the tech to prepare the document as well. You confirm na isa din po ito sa mga dokumento na you submitted to this impeachment court, sir?
Report correctionYes. Now, puntahan po natin Under the label details, sir, may checkmark d'yon po sa box na quote-unquote plant visit. Ano pong ibig sabihin nito, sir?
Report correctionBinisita po rin nila yung planta. Kaya lang po dahil pandemic noon, on-site po ang pag-visit. Sorry, sorry. Virtual po ang naging pag-bisita po.
Report correctionNagkaroon ng... Hindi ko alam kung Zoom ang ginamit o Teams na meeting tapos pinakita doon sa ating mga taga BOI yun pong facilities.
Report correctionYes. And sir, how is this site visit important sir in respect to an application for a BOI certificate of registration?
Report correctionOkay. Next sir, let's go to the label under highlights of the activity of the same document. It states there, during the conduct of the virtual plant visit via Google Meet, it was verified that the proposed project, export producer of banana, may qualify under underlined new activity based on the following findings below. First, the company's building is still under construction, around 90% completed. Second, some of the listed equipment, sorting table, sieving machine, metal detector, slicing machine, genset are still for acquisition. There were no raw materials, e.g., cardava banana, carton boxes, packaging material seen during the inspection.
Report correctionNow, what makes me curious is how do you reconcile Those findings during the site inspection and the eventual issuance of a certificate of registration number 2021-186 on December 9, 2021 by the BOI in favor of CALE88. Kasi parang dyan sir, may kulang sir.
Report correctionPag tinanggap po nila yung terms and conditions, ibig sabihin po, sinasabi po nila, okay, sinasabi lang po namin, registered ka. Pero bago ka makakuha ng incentives mo, sorry, maalala niyo po may start of commercial operation ka. Yun pong incentive mo, papakinabangan mo lang po pag nag start of commercial operation ka na po. So bago po siya mag start of commercial operation and makinabang siya dun sa mga incentive, kailangan po nakaayos na po itong mga ito.
Report correctionOn page 2 of that same document, sir. It also states under subtitle C, start of commercial operation, the firm proposes to commence its commercial operation on December 2021, original target. However, due to COVID-19 pandemic, the construction of the building was delayed and the movement of people, construction workers, was hampered. The BOI Davao team advised the firm relative to the assessment of the building to move the start of commercial operation to a later date. e.g. January 2022 to give ample time for completion of the building and installation. Ano po ang ibig sabihin ng part na ito ng report, sir?
Report correctionIbig sabihin lang po na na-move po yung start, yung kanyang target ng start of commercial operation but eventually po ang naging start ng commercial operation niya is 2023, January 2020. Pinapayagan naman po yun eh because you have three years from date of registration for you to have your SEO.
Report correctionThank you, sir. Now, on the last page of this external contact report plant visit on December 3, 2021, we request the tech to flash the photos. There appears to be photos of a Google meeting. Can we zoom in on the people? And that first. What is this? What is the relevance of this? screenshot or photo documentation in relation to the inspection sir?
Report correctionPinapakita lang po niya na nagkaroon talaga po sila ng inspection meeting although virtual. Tapos sinasubmit din po ito doon sa Manila office sa amin po.
Report correctionAt kung alam niyo lang po sir, On the bottom left portion of that Google Meet, there appears a person wearing a green polo with having a floral pattern. Do you know this? Who is this person if you know, sir?
Report correctionHindi ko siya personally kilala pero tinanong ko yung ating mga taga-Davao na officials kung sino po siya.
Report correctionAnd sino po according to your Davao officials, sir?
Report correctionOkay. Now, we ask the tech to scroll down to the other photos. Now, as you can see displayed on the screen, sir, there appears to be structures or photos of structures attached to your inspection report. Can we also see the other photos for the consumption of the public and our senator judges? What are these photos for, sir, in relation to the inspection conducted by the Board of Investments?
Report correctionIto po yung mga pinadalang litrato ng CALE88 na ito po yung tinatayo nilang facility para dun sa project.
Report correctionAnd when you say facility and project, sir, can we be specific? What does that mean, sir?
Report correctionIto po yung for the manufacture of banana chips for export purposes.
Report correctionAt yung mga structure, mga planta ba yan, sir? Can we please be clarified on what those photos pertain to?
Report correctionSpeculative. The witness would not be competent to identify what these photos are.
Report correctionYour Honor, these photos are submitted to their office, Your Honor. And they stipulated on these documents.
Report correctionIt would be hearsay, Your Honor. He wasn't part of the people who made this virtual inspection.
Report correctionCourt will allow it as part of the official records submitted to his office.
Report correctionThank you, Your Honor. Sir, if you could explain these photos, sir, what these structures are.
Report correctionSa sinabi po ng ating Davao office, ito po yung landing area. May kita niyo po kung saan i-receive yung mga raw materials. Pagkatapos po, ito po puro external structure po itong napakita rito. Pero sinasabi po na yung nasa loob yun po yung merong facilities, yung mga lutuan para doon sa mag-manufacture ng banana chips. Based on representation po sa amin nung Davao office po namin.
Report correctionSorry for interrupting sir and maraming salamat. Next naman sir, one of the documents that you submitted is also CALE88 Food Corporation's report on actual date of start of commercial operations, initial investment, and employment. Can you please explain what this document is about sir?
Report correctionIto po yung requirement ng BOI. na i-submit po nila isang notarized document para ma-trigger po sa amin na oh nag-i-start na itong project na ito ng commercial operation.
Report correctionAnd why does the Board of Investments have this document on file on its record, sir? What is the importance of this document?
Report correctionPara ko alam namin yung reckoning date kung saan po siya nag-start ng commercial operation for purposes. of monitoring ng eligibility niya dun sa kanyang mga incentives.
Report correctionThank you, sir. And as appearing on that document, sir, what is the actual start of commercial operations?
Report correctionAnd under the subparagraph on employment, can we please focus it on the tech booth as well? Can you please tell us the number of labor at the actual start of operations as reported in that notarized? Report, sir?
Report correctionAnd ilan po ang administrative in sales na nalatay ko?
Report correctionNow, on the right side, on the rightmost column, it states payroll. What is that? What does that pertain to, sir?
Report correctionIto po yung sweldo ng mga naka-indicate po na number ng mga tao na nandun po sa middle column.
Report correctionThank you, sir. Now, one of the documents that you submitted as well to this impeachment court is CALE88 Foods Corporation's Board of Investment Form S-1 or the Annual Report on Actual Operations for the year 2023. Before we go into that document, sir, can you please tell us more about what the Board of Investment Form S-1 is?
Report correctionIto po yung isang importanteng dokumento po dahil ito yung nirequire po natin sa mga registered business enterprises to submit to us na notarized para namomonitor po natin yung compliance din nila doon sa kanilang mga pinangako at tinanggap na specific terms and conditions.
Report correctionAnd what information is contained in that BOI form S-1, if any, sir?
Report correctionMeron po dito, siyempre po, yung basic information about the project. Tapos po, yung mga equity profile, yung gross income niya po for the year. Ito po kasi sinasubmit ito dapat bago mag April 30 of the succeeding year. Kasi po,
Report correctionNakatapat din po yun dun sa pag-file niya po ng income tax return po niya.
Report correctionMaraming salamat, sir. Puntaan po natin yung BOI Form S-1 for the year 2023, sir. We request the tech as well. Specifically on page 4 thereof, sir. My question is, if you could see it, sir, under the table labeled as labor generation, Specifically on the aggregate number of employees, how many are the aggregate number of administrative slash sales employees of CALE88 Foods Corporation as reported in the year 2023 sir? Can we request the tech booth to zoom the numbers?
Report correctionThe number of administrative and sales employees, sir, as indicated in that report?
Report correctionOkay. And again, sir, ano po yung annual payroll expense of the aggregate number of employees? What does that column mean?
Report correctionIto po yung sweldo ng mga empleyado po na inindicate nila.
Report correctionAnd this is notarized and submitted with the Board of Investments, sir. Tama po ba? Just clarification. Now, let's go to page number 5 of the same document, sir. Sir, sabihin nyo lang po if kailangan nyo ng breaks. Kasi nakita ko yung mata nyo na. You're okay, sir?
Report correctionOn page 5, sir, under the table, performance data. Ano po yung meaning ng table na yan, sir? Yung performance data.
Report correctionIto po yung sinasabi nila sa atin kung ano yung kanilang production, sales, tapos naka-disaggregate between domestic sales at saka export sales. Importante din sa atin yung export sales kasi yun yung makikita natin kung compliance sila dun sa 70-30 requirement po natin na ratio.
Report correctionOkay sir. Let's go first to may nakalagay kasi total production value. and then unit measurement. What does this refer to, sir?
Report correctionYung total production, yung na-produce niya ho na banana chips.
Report correctionNow, next, sir, on the same table, if you can look at below that total production, it also states export sales. Now, there is an indication, volume of export sales. What does that mean, sir?
Report correctionIto po yung quantity as expressed dito po in kilograms.
Report correctionAnd according to this report made by CALE88 Foods Corporation, what is the volume of export sales in the year 2023 of banana chips, sir?
Report correctionNow, below that number is value. What is that number? What does that number pertain to, sir?
Report correctionYun pong revenue niya dahil naibenta niya po sa labas dahil export po ito yung 216,000 kilograms na yan.
Report correctionOkay. Sir, you also submitted other BOI form S-1 for the subsequent years, sir. Tama po ba?
Report correctionOkay. Now... I will no longer belabor the other forms but my only question sir is if you look at the BOI form S-1 for the year 2025, it appears to be different than those in the prior years 2023 and 2024. Can you please explain to us sir why there is a difference between those forms?
Report correctionOkay. Now, next sir, you also submitted audited financial statements of CALE88 Foods Corporation specifically for the years 2023, 2024, and 2025. How is this related or relevant to the earlier BOI Form S-1 that were submitted by CALE88 Foods Corporation? If at all, sir.
Report correctionSubmitted din po ito sa amin ng CALE88. Part 2 ng requirements namin for monitoring, kailangan nila mag-submit ng S-1 at saka ng audited financial statements po.
Report correctionAnd what is the reason that they need to submit that together with the S-1, sir?
Report correctionBinabangga din po natin yung mga numero na nakikita po natin doon sa S-1 po nila, doon sa kanila, audited financial statements, kung nagtutugma po.
Report correctionYes, thank you, sir. Next, you also submitted as part of the documents that you submitted to the impeachment court, CALE88 Foods Corporations VAT zero rate certification dated May 2, 2024 and another one VAT zero rate certification dated April 10, 2026. At meron po itong mga supporting documents. Do you have those documents with you now, sir?
Report correctionNow, unahin po natin yung na unang zero VAT certification dated May 2, 2024.
Report correctionSir, can you please tell us who issues this VAT zero rate certification in the first place, sir?
Report correctionYun pong ating Executive Director sa BOI in charge of management services.
Report correctionDahil... Under din po ng kanyang management services yung ating mga legal service at yung ating incentives and compliance division po.
Report correctionAnd kanino pong VAT zero rate certification yan based on the document sir?
Report correctionNow at the bottom of that document sir, can we scroll down? There's a signature above the printed name, Atty. Bobby G. Fondevilla. Again, sir, can we clarify? Fondevilla. Can you please tell us what his position is and what his authority is to sign that?
Report correctionAt that time po siya po yung Executive Director ng Management Services.
Report correctionNow, on the right side, sir, there also appears a QR code. What is the purpose of that QR code, sir?
Report correctionPara pag po binaril po ito, ilalabas din niyo po niya yung BOI VAT Certificate na ito po.
Report correctionThank you, sir. We now have seen that in the year 2024, there's actually a VAT zero rate certification. What is the purpose of this VAT zero rate certification in relation to CALE88, sir?
Report correctionPara po ito yung papakita ni CALE88 dun sa kanyang mga suppliers na inindicate din po niya sa kanyang VAT zero rating application form para po hindi siya singilin ng VAT nung suppliers na yun.
Report correctionAgain sir, why is it important that our enterprises are given this incentive sir? Para lang po malaman natin.
Report correctionPara po hindi siya sisingilin ng 12% VAT, hindi ipapasa sa CALE88. So mas makakatipid po siya nung pag bumili po siya nung in this particular case po ay gagamitin niya po ito for
Report correctionoil, coconut oil, carton boxes, tsaka plastics na kanyang mga bibilin po.
Report correctionThank you, sir. And sir, what are the requirements for the Board of Investments to issue that VAT zero rate certification in general, sir? And if you know.
Report correctionAno po, nung time na nag-apply po siya nito, nung 2024, duly accomplished application form, notarized affidavit signed by the firm's authorized representative, enumerating the documents submitted to BOI, duly notarized sales performance report for the year.
Report correctionFor the year immediately preceding the period to be covered by the certification. Ibig sabihin po kung 2024 po ito, yung pong kanyang mga sales performance is for 2023. Duly notarized detailed export sales report and annual production for the year. immediately preceding the period to be covered by the certification. Original and notarized bank certifications explicitly indicating inward remittances due to export proceeds. Copy of annual report of operations, yung S1 po natin. Latest audited financial statement.
Report correctionBarangay and Unaudited income statement for the year preceding the period to be covered by the certification. Barangay certification indicating that the firm is existing and operating. Mayor's permit, business permit. Pictures of the production area and signage of plant factory. Copy of BOI certificate of registration with specific terms and conditions. Copy of sworn declaration affidavits per BIR template. Pero in-streamline na natin ito rin noong 2026.
Report correctionOkay, sir. Now, after CALE88, Foods Corporation submitted its requirements. What process does the Board of Investment do prior to granting? What is the assessment that it makes essentially?
Report correctionUna, tinitignan niya kung na-submit itong mga ito. Tapos pangalawa, importante lang din ito kasi titignan niya kung na-meet niya po yung 70-30 na export sales requirement. Dabangga din niya yung bank certificate na nagpapatunay na may mga inward remittances siya galing sa kanyang mga Buyers from abroad.
Report correctionSo, this is confirmatory, sir. Talagang ina-assess at kinuscrutinize ng board investments yung application. Thank you, sir. Let's go to Annex A of that VAT 0 certification, sir. It's one of the documents you attached. I think that would be the document after that certification. Ano po itong dokumento na ito, sir?
Report correctionNire-refer lang ko nito, naka-attach ko ito dun sa certification. Mas detalyade lang ko ito, sinasabi niya kung ano yung registered activity, tapos ano yung tax incentive entitlement niya, tapos ano yung performance conditions, tapos saan mga goods niya pwedeng ibangga ito, yung attributable goods and services.
Report correctionPasensya sir. Thank you sir. Sinabi niyo po naka-attach. Sino pong nag-prepare ng dokumento na yan?
Report correctionOkay. Sir, let's go still to that document. If you look at the lower right portion, if my memory serves me right, sinabi po yan terms and conditions. Tapos, can we please zoom in on that portion?
Report correctionThat would be on the fifth or fourth column. Thank you. Now, in the terms of conditions, on the right column, it says status remarks compliant. What does that mean in relation to CALE88 Foods Corporation?
Report correctionNa-complied po siya dito sa mga terms and conditions ng kanyang registration. Performance commitment.
Report correctionOkay, yung performance commitment tapos merong 70%, what does that... Part of the table means, sir. Can you please explain?
Report correctionIbig sabihin po yung kanyang benta sa export is within 70% ng kanyang total sales. Nakocomply niya po yun.
Report correctionAnd the Board of Investments kinoconfirm yung export, sir.
Report correctionBasit po dun sa mga sinabit niya sa aming mga dokumento.
Report correctionNow, below that, it's regulatory compliance and it states complied.
Report correctionGeneral term kasi sir. Sorry. Yung performance commitment po pala, ang tingin ko ito yung sa employment. Kasi may nakaseparate na export ratio tayong nakalagay sa...
Report correctionOkay sir. In the regulatory compliance, it says complied. What does that mean sir?
Report correctionNow what... Now, sinabi niyo po may mga pruweba. Now, one of the documents I noticed in the documents in relation to VAT zero certification are bank statements. Tama po ba, sir?
Report correctionWhat is the relevance of these bank statements from CALE88 Foods Corporation in relation to its application for a VAT zero rate certification? May we request that that bank statement be flashed?
Report correctionAno po ang relevance niyan sa application? Why is it important?
Report correctionPara mapatunayan namin na meron siyang pumapasok na foreign exchange na galing sa labas. Dahil kasi kung mag-iexport siya, normally yung bayad is foreign exchange tapos pumapasok sa banko. So pinapatunayan lang po nito na may pumasok po.
Report correctionNow, in relation to those as well, there are affidavits. May we request the tech to refer to those affidavits.
Report correctionSino po ang mga nakapirma ng mga affidavit in relation to the VAT zero rate certification dated May 2, 2024 issued by the Board of Investments?
Report correctionAnd ano po ang date ng notarization ng sworn affidavit na yan?
Report correctionAnd ano po ang relasyon ng sworn affidavit na yan sa application for zero-rate certification?
Report correctionKailangan po ito para dun sa ano? Kailangan niya pong i-attach ito dun sa kanyang application form.
Report correctionNow, meron din po kayong sinubmit na CALE88 Foods Corporation VAT zero-rate certification dated April 10, 2026 at may mga supporting documents. Now, again, just to confirm, sino yung nag-issue ng certificate na yan, sir?
Report correctionAt sino po si Executive Director Fe Del Rosario po?
Report correctionSiya na po yung Executive Director ng Management Services ng BOI. Okay. Nung in-issue po ito.
Report correctionNow, sinabi nyo na po kanina na one of the documents that you need to submit, To be entitled to a VAT zero rate certificate are affidavits sir. Tama po ba? At ano po itong mga affidavits na to nga sir?
Report correctionItong dito po yung affidavit po na nagsasabi na limbawa po dito po sa for this particular can I read na lang po?
Report correctionFor this particular 2020-2026 submission Afidavit po ito ni Salvador Leo Sacurom na sinasabi na siya yung current na accounting and compliance officer ng CALE88 that inauthorize siya ng mga board of directors to transact business with us na siya po yung authorized representative ng CALE88 for their application for VAT zero rating. Tapos na siya rin po yung nag-prepare at nag-submit ng mga forms that we were requiring for this VAT zero rating application.
Report correctionThank you, sir. Now, we don't need to flash these documents for the 2026 with respect to the banks to protect the privacy. But my question, sir, if you look at the documents you submitted, in the certificate of inward remittance, Meron pong mga remitter dyan na naka-indicate. Do you see that, sir?
Report correctionNow, marami po kasing Zhengzhou Food Call Limited. What is the reason why these remittances should be reported, sir, in relation to VAT zero certification?
Report correctionPara ma-identify lang po kung sino yung mga nag-re-remit ng mga customer po niyan. Pinagbentahan po ng kumpanya.
Report correctionNow, meron pa rin... We don't need to flash this, but there's also a certificate of inward remittance from security bank. Meron ding mga what appears to be Chinese corporations. What is the importance of CALE88 Foods Corporation submitting these inward remittances to the Board of Investments?
Report correctionAgain po, para mapatunayan po namin na may pumapasok sa kanya na export revenues. Hindi po namin nire-require kung galing sa ang bansa.
Report correctionThank you, sir. Now, another document submitted is also CALE88 Foods Corporation's Detailed Export Sales and Annual Production Report. Do you have that, sir?
Report correctionOpo, yes. Now, I've actually reviewed that document, sir. And very many product exports were done to Chinese companies or to China. With corresponding sales volume and sales value. What is the relevance of that document in relation to an application for VAT zero rate certifications?
Report correctionSo, para ma-establish lang po na meron siyang export sales.
Report correctionNow, sinabi niyo po kanina sir, before a VAT zero rate certification is issued na na-issue naman po ng BOI, nag-a-assess po.
Report correctionirregularities, if any, did the BOI find in relation to those China-related transactions or exports, if at all?
Report correctionAng pinaka tinitignan lang po namin dito ay kung pasok po siya dun sa 70% na export na requirement po niya. Sinisigurado lang namin na yung exports niya hindi bababa sa 70%.
Report correctionSo to confirm sir, the BOI found no issue in exportations relation to China.
Report correctionThank you sir. Now, one of the documents that you also submitted is CALE88 Foods Corporation's letter dated April 29, 2026. May we just request the tech to flash that document?
Report correctionDo you have it with you sir? Now, can you please explain to us what the purpose of this letter request is as it is addressed to Attorney Elyjean DC Portoza, sir?
Report correctionOpo, eto po ay nagre-request po si CALE88 ng Certification of Good Standing dahil po si CALE88 ay Nagpapa rin yun yung kanyang accreditation dun sa parang client profile system ng Bureau of Customs para ho tuloy-tuloy ho yung kanyang capability to import and export. Requirement po kasi yun ng Bureau of Customs na may certificate of good standing po siya galing sa amin.
Report correctionThank you, sir. Now, naka-address po yung letter ng CALE88 Foods Corporation dated April 29, 2026 kay Atty. Elyjean DC Portoza. Sino po itong si Atty. Elyjean DC Portoza? Can you please explain why the letter had to be addressed to her?
Report correctionSiya po yung director ng aming legal and compliance services. So sila po yung mga nagmo-monitor ng standing po ng mga registered business enterprises.
Report correctionOkay. Now, alam natin sir na ito po yung letter na ipinadala ni CALE88 Foods Corporation sa Board of Investments. Can you please tell us what a certificate of good standing or endorsement of good standing means, sir?
Report correctionYour Honor, I'd have to object to this line of questioning on the ground of relevance. In the first place, Your Honor, this document already pertains to April 29, 2026. which is outside the period covered by the charges in the articles. It doesn't even pertain to taxable year 2025. It pertains to 2026, Your Honor.
Report correctionWe note the manifestation of Attorney Erwin. May we proceed, Attorney Justin? Thank
Report correctionyou, Your Honor. Ulitin ko po, sir, ano po yung meaning ng Certificate of Good Standing or what does that mean when the Board of Investment issues such certificate?
Report correctionThat it is compliant with the specific terms and conditions at saka po dun sa mga hinihingi po nating reports from the company.
Report correctionAnd tanong lang po, would the Board of Investments issue a certificate of good standing to an implausible business model, sir?
Report correctionAno pong ibig sabihin ng... In the context nung sinabi niyo po ng implausible business model.
Report correctionJust as it is, sir. As you understand the term that I just said, sir.
Report correctionSa pagkakaintindi ko lang po dito, inisuan po siya on the basis nung kanyang commitments po sa amin. As to whether that is referring to implausible or not implausible, I apologize. Hindi ko masasagot.
Report correctionThank you, sir. Let's move on sir. One of the documents that you submitted as well is a Board of Investments Travel Order No. 2026-168 dated April 28, 2026. Can you please explain to us sir what the relevance of this document is and why you submitted this to the court?
Report correctionOpo, kasi po in connection dun po sa request po ng kumpanya for Certificate of Good Standing, binisita rin po siya Nung aming legal and compliance service. So pinuntahan niya po yung firm na ito.
Report correctionNow what is the importance of visiting the firm sir in relation to that?
Report correctionOpo. Para po makita talaga kung ano yung estado tapos matanong din po siya. Lalo na po dito dahil po nung nagdo-documentary check po tayo nakita po natin na bumaba yung employment na nireport po niya. Dun sa ating S-1 from I think 200 noong previous year. Mga nasa 200 po siya noong 2024 po yata eh. Tapos bumaba po to 50 or 51 the following year. So gusto lang po makita talaga ng ating mga compliance officers at matanong kung bakit po bumaba.
Report correctionThank you sir. Sa BOI travel order naman sir, it states that sa purpose of travel, it states the travel for the purpose of the verification of status and operations. How is this related to the one that you explained sir to confirm the operations of the business?
Report correctionPara makita po nila yung actual na estado, makausap yung mga tao po na involved.
Report correctionBakit kailangan ng travel orders yung mga tauhan ng ating board of investment?
Report correctionKasi po galing po sila sa Manila at pupunta po sila. May mga galing po dito sa Manila.
Report correctionSo, okay. Next, sir. Let's go to the next document. You also submitted to this impeachment court a board of investment report on site inspection dated May 18, 2026, sir. Do you confirm submitting that document, sir?
Report correctionNow... What is this plant inspection report, sir? Can you please elaborate to us what this document is?
Report correctionIto po yung in relation po dun sa travel order. So, binisita na po nila tapos po ito po yung report nung naging pagbisita po nila.
Report correctionNow, on the document, it states under attendees to the plant inspection, quote-unquote, BOILCS. What does that mean, sir?
Report correctionNow, meron pong mga pangalan under that table. Si Atty. Elyjean DC Portoza and etc. Sino po ito, sir?
Report correctionSiya po yung Director ng Legal and Compliance Service.
Report correctionAt bakit po nakalagay yung pangalan niya sa report na yan?
Report correctionSiya po yung pumunta dun sa kasama niya po yung dalawa pang tao.
Report correctionNow, sa baba na table, sir, meron ding nakalabel na CFC. Ano pong ibig sabihin yan, sir?
Report correctionOkay. At sino naman po ang mga pangalan na nakalagay sa baba, sir? Sino po sila?
Report correctionIto na po yung mga bagong may-ari, bagong presidente nung CALE88 Foods Corporation.
Report correctionSorry, sir. Pakuulit po yung sinabi nyo. Sino po ito sila? Sorry.
Report correctionSiya po niyang, ito pong si Lolita Paimalan, Chris Chu. Tsaka si Leo Sacurom. Ito na po yung mga bagong mga opisyalis ng CALE88 na okay lang ho ba. Nung pagpunta ko kasi natin doon, doon po natin alaman din na nagbago na pala ng may-ari po yung CALE88.
Report correctionIto na po yung mga bagong yun. Kaya po sinabihan din natin sila na oh kung nagbago kayo ng may-ari, kayo na pala. Meron kaming requirement din po na kailangan i-inform niyo ang BOI ng change in beneficial ownership. So may mga form din po ron, may proseso din po para ma-reflect din po natin sa records natin.
Report correctionSir, balikan lang natin yung naunang table which is under BOI-LCS. In number two, who is Ms. Lorna D. Garcia, sir?
Report correctionTaga Manila po namin ito na isa sa mga specialist po natin sa BOI.
Report correctionAnd what is the importance of a senior investment specialist attending in that plant inspection sir?
Report correctionSiya rin po yung nakakaalam ng proyekto. Familiar po siya dun sa mga dokumento po in addition dun po sa ating Davao.
Report correctionwhat is her division, sir, as stated in that document?
Report correctionOkay. Next, sir, it also states a Ms. Marian Gay U. Liwanag. Who is this person, sir?
Report correctionIsa din po siyang empleyado ng BOI under the Legal and Compliance Service Division.
Report correctionAnd from what office of the Board of Investment, sir?
Report correctionYun po. Compliance Service Division po. Compliance Division.
Report correctionOkay. And what is her... It states there investment specialist, sir. What is the importance of an investment specialist in a plant inspection, sir?
Report correctionGanon din po. Meron po siyang kaalaman doon sa mga requirements ni BOI at saka po, yun, sa mga requirements ni BOI.
Report correctionNow... Balikan natin si Atty. Elyjean DC Portoza. Sir, sinabi niyo po, Director of Legal and Compliance. Where is her office, sir?
Report correctionOkay. So, just to emphasize and conclude on this point, ang lahat na nag-inspect, taga-Maynila po?
Report correctionPwede po ba ako magtanong din kung may nakasamang taga-BIO sa aking mga kasamahan?
Report correctionNo need, Dr. Perry. The question was with respect to only the three people mentioned in the document. Salamat po.
Report correctionOkay. Let's go to item number two of that same report, sir. Can you please read to us the finding under number 1, sir? As stated in the document. Can you please read it out loud, sir?
Report correctionDuring the inspection, the firm's compliance with its terms and conditions has been discussed, particularly its direct labor commitment. For 2025, which is year 3, the firm had to maintain direct labor of 39. Yun po kasi yung nakalagay dun sa kanyang specific terms and conditions na kinomit po sa atin sa gobyerno.
Report correctionSo, but based on the 2025 BOI Form S-1, the firm had an actual labor of 50 while in 2024, they had reported 201. In response to the inquiry on the reduction of the number of labor from 2024 to 2025, the firm explained that it was attributable to a period of non-operation in 2025 due to the change in management and ownership.
Report correctionWhat was the response of the Board of Investment as stated on the paragraph after that, sir? Can you please read it out loud?
Report correctionAng sinabi po namin, noting the change in ownership, the LCS advised the firm to submit a request letter for said change, stating the reason therefore, Presenting the previous and current ownership structures and attaching relevant documents including the general information sheets before and after the change.
Report correctionOkay. Now sir, sinabi niyo po na may inspection and na-discuss po ang mga employee. What is the participation of the Board of Investments in respect to the assessment of the employees on the ground, sir?
Report correctionNow, in the ground inspection, sir, what do you find or what do you assess, sir, on the ground in the location itself of the project?
Report correctionBiasi po dun sa report, tinitignan din po nila kung ano yung, kung nag-ooperate po ba. Hindi ko lang alam kung talagang binilang nila isa-isa na may 50 ngang tao na nandun.
Report correctionFinally, the LCS has reminded the firm on the timely submission of its annual reports, BOI Form S1, the annual financial statements, income tax return.
Report correctionOtherwise, it would incur penalty. The LCS also advised the firm to use the new BOI Form S1. which may be downloaded from the BOI website.
Report correctionWhat is the importance of that finding in the inspection?
Report correctionKasi po, kumisang nauhuli daw siya sa mga pag-submit niya ng mga report. Kaya kailangan natin silang i-remind na mag-submit ka on time.
Report correctionAt the last page of that document, there appears to be photographs as well. Can we please zoom in? We ask that the... Tech display, a clearer picture of that. What are these photos, sir, if you know?
Report correctionIto po yung documentation na po na kinunan nung ating team nung bumisita po sila doon sa production facility ng CALE88.
Report correctionAnd to clarify, sir, it's the Board of Investments team who took these photos, sir?
Report correctionHindi ko alam kung kanino camera pero ang nag-attach po nito dito sa report ay yung team po namin.
Report correctionAnd what, can you please tell us what is this, what is shown in those photos?
Report correctionI can only interpret based on what I see din po. Pero yan po, nakikita na meron po silang operation, tapos naka, this is a food company, naka, tawag doon, siguro parang gowns sila to ensure the Cleanliness. Tapos may nakita silang mga inventaryo dito po sa kumpanya. Mga saging.
Report correctionPero sir, ito under new management na itong sinasabi ko.
Report correctionYour Honor, may I just respectfully inquire if we still have time, Your Honor? I still have a few five pages in my direct examination, Your Honor.
Report correctionWould this be a good time to pause, Attorney Justin? Or you want to consume the remaining four minutes?
Report correctionI prefer that we pause for the meantime, Your Honor, with the court's indulgence.
Report correctionOkay. And you need approximately less than an hour when you resume?
Report correctionAtty. Justin, you may proceed with your direct examination of the witness, Dr. Perry.
Report correctionThank you, Your Honor. Before I proceed with my, continue with my direct examination, Your Honor, just a manifestation from the defense, Your Honor. There were changes in the markings with respect to prior markings such that the markings that were made during the marking sessions beyond the trial were different from those manifested. During the trial itself, Your Honor, we just request, Your Honor, that the markings done before the Clerk of Court be adopted, Your Honor. Just for the record, Your Honor.
Report correctionThank you, Your Honor. Continuing with my direct examination.
Report correctionMagandang hapon po. Good afternoon, Sir. Sir, let's go to one of the documents that you submitted before this impeachment court. That would be the endorsement of good standing. From the Board of Investments to the Bureau of Customs, sir. Do you have that document, sir?
Report correctionYes, sir. Now, can you please tell us what this letter is all about, sir? Specifically, why the Board of Investments needed to send this letter to the Bureau of Customs in relation, of course, to CALE88 Foods Corporation?
Report correctionNag-request po si CALE88 nitong certification na to para makapag-register siya dun sa client profile registration system ng Bureau of Customs. Tapos po tinignan natin yung kanyang record kaya po ang sinabi natin dito the firm is compliant with the terms and conditions of its registration kaya hence it is of good standing.
Report correctionExcuse me. Why did the Board of Investment send it directly to the Bureau of Customs, sir?
Report correctionGanon po talaga yung proseso po natin na kailangan sila yung sa kanila po ipadala.
Report correctionCan we please go to the bottom portion of that, the same letter, please?
Report correctionLetter, sir. It appears to be signed by Atty. Elyjean DC Portoza, sir. How is that person related to the person who conducted the site inspection in CALE88 Foods Corporation, sir, in Tagum, Davao?
Report correctionSiya din po ang nag-site inspection. Pero hindi naman po talaga kailangan na siya rin yung nagkataon lang po ito.
Report correctionNow sir, if you recall, there were findings in the BOI site inspection, yung mga diniscuss po natin. And that report was dated May 18, 2026. We also have now an endorsement of good standing dated June 16, 2026. How do you reconcile the issuance of both documents, sir? On one hand, we have a BOI site inspection report. Making findings in relation to CALE88 Foods Corporation's operation and on the other.
Report correctionNonetheless, the BOI issued an endorsement of good standing dated June 16, 2026.
Report correctionConsistent pa rin naman po dahil ang tinignan po natin dito ay yung mga nakalagay sa specific terms and conditions. Number one po halimbawa yung kanyang Labor na sinasabi. Tapos po nakita naman po natin base dun sa S-1 niya. Ang pagpunta po dun, ito pong Certificate of Good Standing, hindi lang po ito base dun sa actual inspection. Kasama din po dito yung pag-review ng kanyang mga documentary requirements at saka yung pong nilagay niyang mga information dun. Nakita naman po natin na compliant pa rin po siya base po dun sa mga sinubmit po niya. Kaya po nag-issue tayo nitong Certificate of Good Standing.
Report correctionThank you, sir. One of the documents you also submitted before this impeachment court is a Certificate of Income Tax Holiday Incentive or CETI dated April 22, 2026. Do you have it with you now, sir? April 22, 2025, rather.
Report correctionCan you please tell us sir for the record when this was issued?
Report correctionAnd who issued that Certificate of Income Tax Holiday Incentives sir?
Report correctionAnd what is his or her authority to issue said certificate sir?
Report correctionMay we also request that it be flashed on the screen? Now my question sir, can you please explain to us what this document or what the purpose of this document is?
Report correctionPagka po kasi magfafile ng income tax return ang isang registered business enterprise, sinasama niya po ito. Naka-attach po ito dun sa ITR. Kasi po di ba pag nag-submit kayo ng income tax return sa BIR, dapat dun meron na nakalagay na nagbayad kayo. Tapos may bank receipt na nagbayad kayo. So in lieu of that po, ito yung ilalagay niya. Para ma-indicate na hindi pa ako nagbayad kasi entitled ako to tax incentives. Tapos magko-compute po ngayon sila. Babalik ko yun sa amin tapos mag-i-issue po kami ng another endorsement naman of the tax incentives na i-dedicate naman po nila doon sa kanilang isasubmit sa BIR.
Report correctionAnd this is confirmatory sir. Evidensya lang po ito para to prove na hindi po kailangan magbayad ng tax yung kumpanya. And in this case, CALE88 Foods Corporation.
Report correctionPero ito, ano lang ito, certification. Hindi pa ito'y nakalagay kung magkano yung kanyang hindi dapat bayaran. May isang proseso pa po doon.
Report correctionNow, one of the documents that you submitted earlier is the certificate of registration, di ba? Natalakay na po natin. Ano ang relasyon dyan ng certificate of registration? Enterprise Number 2021-1-86 at nung Certificate of Income Tax Holiday Incentive dated April 22, 2025 na tinalakay lang po natin. What is the relationship of these two documents?
Report correctionIto po yung nag-ooperationalize nung sa Certificate of Registration po naka-enumerate doon yung mga incentives na available para sa kanya. Yung letter A po ay income tax holiday for 6 years. So ito po sinasabi lang na oh, itong kumpanya to ay registered sa amin tapos entitled siya to tax incentives.
Report correctionNow, another set of documents that the Board of Investments submitted to this impeachment court is a letter request for change in ownership dated July 8, 2026. We request that it be flashed with attachments. of CALE88 Foods Corporation's General Information Sheet in the year 2024 and CALE88 Foods Corporation's General Information Sheet in the year 2025. Can we just zoom in please on the portions? Sir, if you know what is this letter all about sir, can you please tell us?
Report correctionKung maalala niyo po doon po sa site inspection report, nalaman din po ng BOI na iba na ho yung may-ari ng CALE88. Kaya po pinayuhan natin sila na you are required to submit the new ownership to BOI.
Report correctionYes sir. So in short sir, what is the relationship of this letter to the earlier Board of Investment Report on Site Inspection dated May 18, 2026. To be specific, sir.
Report correctionIto po yung sagot nila doon sa ating pagpayo sa kanila, meaning si CALE88, na kailangan ninyong i-reflect sa records na amin na kayo na yung bagong owners ng CALE88.
Report correctionAnd what is the relevance in the submission that you made before this impeachment, sir? There are attachments which are the 2024 General Information Sheet. and 2025 General Information Sheet of CALE88 Foods Corporation. What is the relevance of those SEC documents in relation to this letter request for change in ownership dated July 8, 2026, if any, sir? Yun
Report correctionpo ay yung sa GIS po, eto yung mga nagre-reflect naman nung nasa SEC ay na-transfer na po, na-reflect na po dun sa kanyang incorporation na Sila na po yung bagong owners. So, iyon po yung patunay na kailangan nilang i-attach dun sa letter nila para iyon po yung pagbasehan namin na iba na nga yung may-ari nitong CALE88.
Report correctionAnd can we please go to the signature page of that letter? And in the document that you have with you now, sir, and that appearing on screen, who is the person who signed the letter on behalf of CALE88 Foods Corporation, sir?
Report correctionDito po kung titignan po natin doon sa capital structure annex B naka-attach po dito sa letter din nila ng July 8. Ito pong si Lolita Paimalan. Sana po yung nakalagay na may ownership ng 5% CALE88. Tapos tignan ko lang ako ng reflect dun sa GIS. Alam ko siya na yung presidente ng CALE88.
Report correctionAnd before siya sir, sino po ang base sa mga documents na sinumiti ng CALE88 Foods Corporation?
Report correctionI-check ko lang ko kung si Manases Carpio o kung si Lourdes Lemusada.
Report correctionSa GIS po ay si, ng 2024 ay si Manases R. Carpio yung presidente po.
Report correctionAt sino po ba ang iba na mga officers ng kumpanya?
Report correctionSi Lourdes Lebosada po ang tumatay yung treasurer. Tapos si Myrie Ellenniel Leaño ang corporate secretary po.
Report correctionPuntahan po natin yung stock holdings. Ano po yung stock holdings dyan sir sa 2024?
Report correctionSa stock holdings niya po si Manases R. Carpio ay may ownership na 47.5%. Si Lourdes Lebosada 47.5% at si Myrie Leaño ay 5%.
Report correctionUlitin ko lang sir for clarification. Anong taon po yung kakasabi nyo lang?
Report correctionPuntaan po natin yung 2025 sir. Sino po yung stockholders ng CALE88 Foods Corporation sa 2025 general information sheet na isinumite ng kumpanya sa Board of Investments?
Report correctionOkay po. Punta natin yung stockholding sir. Ano po yung stockholding sa taon na yan? Yung 2025 general information.
Report correctionSi Lolita Paimalan po ay 5%. Tapos po si... Piki mong Philippines ay 95%.
Report correctionOkay, sir. And again, sir, para lang for the record, bakit po kailangan mag-send ng letter na ito sa Board of Investments?
Report correctionTalaga pong nire-require namin para malaman namin kung sino yung beneficial ownership. Although, mas importante ito dun sa mga sectors na merong Restriction sa foreign equity. Kaya mas kailangan namin yan.
Report correctionAt dito naman po sir, kung alam niyo po sa Export Enterprise na in-issue ng BOI sa CALE, 88 Foods Corporation, meron po bang restrictions on foreign equity?
Report correctionin the letter that you submitted to this impeachment court dated November 18, 2026, the last document is actually A letter of approval of the request for change of ownership dated October 29, 2026. You confirm that, sir? That is the last document indicated in that letter?
Report correctionAnd what is the relationship of this letter, sir, to the earlier request or letter sent by CALE88 Foods Corporation for change of ownership, if any, sir?
Report correctionIto na po yung... nag... Approved. Teka lang. Evaluation. Noting. Noting the change in ownership undertaken by the following persons from Kila Carpio, Lebosada, and Leaño to Paimalan and Pikimong-Pikimong Corporation.
Report correctionSo nasa records na po. Ninote na po natin at ito na po yung nasa records ni BOI ngayon na new owners nun po.
Report correctionThank you, sir. Puntahan naman natin, sir, yung... Letter dated November 20, 2026 na you submitted to the impeachment court, sir. These are the new set of documents, sir. I just have a few questions in relation to these documents, sir.
Report correctionSir, bakit po ba na, ano po yung reason or what is the reason why you had to submit these additional documents, sir?
Report correctionIto lang po yung mga supporting documents related dun sa Certificate of Registration nung una po silang nag-apply para po kumpleto. Ito po yung mga internal na documents na nasa amin po in relation doon sa approval ng application po nila tsaka pag-issue ng Certificate of Registration.
Report correctionAnd this is just confirmatory sir. You're saying that ito po yung mga sinubmit nila sa application process nila to be issued the Certificate of Registration.
Report correctionHindi lang po. Kasi po, limbawa itong una, memo request for the printing of certificate of registration. Internal po ito sa amin. So, internal request po noong director na o i-print na tapos para mapirmahan na po.
Report correctionSo, just in general, sir, please explain. Documents 1 to 18. What relation does this have to CALE88 Foods Corporation and its registration with the Board of Investments?
Report correctionSo ito po yung mga dokumento na either in support po noon sa application ni CALE88. o kaya po kasama din po dito yung kanilang mga affidavit, kasama din po dito yung kanilang halimbawa dito at the very beginning kasi kailangan sabihin nila sa BOI kung ano yung pinipili nilang incentive. Halimbawa SCIT ba yan o enhanced deduction. May mga ganun kasi silang choices. So, ito yung mga dokumento na sinubmit nila in relation to their acceptance at saka pag-issue namin nung kanilang registration.
Report correctionOkay, sir. Now, nag-aral po kasi ako tungkol sa BOI at sa structure ng ating government institution. I note that under Chapter 2, Article 7 of Executive Order 226, The Omnibus Investments Code of 1987, the Board of Investment has the following powers. Number 7, periodically check and verify the compliance by registered enterprises with the relevant provisions of this code, with the rules and regulations promulgated under this code, and with the terms and conditions of registration. The next power, or subparagraph 8, after due notice, the Board of Investment has the power to, after due notice, Cancel the registration or suspend the enjoyment of incentives, benefits of any registered enterprise, and or require refund of incentives enjoyed by such enterprise, including interest and monetary penalties for a. failure to maintain the qualifications required by this Code for registration with the Board and b. for violation of any provision of this Code of the Rules and Regulations issued under this Code. of the terms and conditions of registration or of loss for the protection of labor or the consuming public. There is a proviso after that. But I will not ask you about the provision of the law sir. My specific question to the Board of Investment is this. Given the several documents that were submitted by CALE88 Foods Corporation, the course of its application, registration, and even to this date 2026 or from 2021, to 2026. What cancellation of registration did the Board of Investments do to CALE88 Foods Corporation, if any?
Report correctionWala po kami on record na in-issue na about cancellation ng registration nila.
Report correctionHow about the suspension of enjoyment of incentives? What suspension did the Board of Investments issue in relation to CALE88 Foods Corporation from 2021? It's start of operation January 1, 2023 to the present.
Report correctionSinubmit ninyo sa impeachment court. Unahin natin itong external contact report which is letter B dito sa transmittal letter dated November 18, 2026.
Report correctionConfirm ko lang, nabanggit nyo na rin naman kanina na nakalagay dito sa external contact report ng inspection. Nung supposed plant or project site ng CALE88 ay virtual.
Report correctionSo ibig sabihin ko ng virtual, walang physical inspection ng mga tao. Hindi rin po kayo kasama?
Report correctionHindi nakawakan ng BOI employees yung building, yung pader, hindi nila na-test yung floor?
Report correctionNakalagay sa external contact report na 90% completed na daw yung building. May engineer ho bang sumama dun sa inspection?
Report correctionBase po sa discussion. Siguro po ah. Kasi nung discussion po nila, maaari pong sinabi rin nung kumpanya tapos visual ko na lang po yung nakita.
Report correctionGaling sa kumpanya. Yung representation 90% completed. And hindi nyo po alam kung natapos itong building? Correct. Hindi nyo po nakita na natapos ang building. Personally, kayo po.
Report correctionHindi nyo po alam kung talagang, kasi 90%, hindi nyo alam kung nakompleto. Personally.
Report correctionPersonally, kayo po hindi nyo alam. Thank you. Puntahan natin yung report on actual date of start of commercial operations, initial investments and employment, which is letter C nung...
Report correctionBy the way, kailan po dapat sinasubmit ang report on actual, on the actual date of start of commercial operations? 30 days after actual start, tama po ba?
Report correctionHindi ko alam kung ano yung exacto po, pero dapat to malapit dun sa kanilang pag-start ng commercial operations.
Report correctionActually, I have yung primer po ninyo, BOI primer. May we ask the tech booth to flash that on the start of commercial operations, the BOI primer. Or can we just show to the witness the primer?
Report correctionCan you just confirm po na dapat malapit sa date? Nung actual, would you agree na 30 days yan?
Report correctionYour Honor, asked and answered. The witness already answered that.
Report correctionPero hindi naman po dapat aabot ng one year. Kasi sabi niyo close to the date nung start of actual operations.
Report correctionMas maganda ho kung malapit talaga. Kasi po, ang magiging operating issue po dyan is Pagka nag-a-avail na po siya ng kanyang incentive. So kung wala po sa record namin na nag-submit siya ng start of commercial operation, hindi po namin siya pwedeng bigyan ng incentive.
Report correctionSo ganun ka-important po yung report na yan. Actually, andito na po yung sa primer na nababangkit ko kanina. Pakibasa ko, pa-confirm po kung tama, accurate ba yan, yung nasa primer ng BOI.
Report correctionKasi yun nga po, kailangan masubmit agad para mag-start na yung mabilang na kung kailan magsastart yung income tax holiday.
Report correctionOpo. Makapag-avail na siya. Kasi po, sa kanya din magiging kalimbawa po, Yung pag-record po namin nung kanyang ano po yung sa mga revenues niya yung entitled to income tax holiday. So hindi rin po namin mare-record kaagad po yun.
Report correctionOkay, thank you. Enough na po yung answer niya kanina. Okay lang po yan. Ngayon, pakitignan yung report na yan, letter C.
Report correctionPakitignan yung notarial details sa baba. Familiar naman po kayo sa mga notarized documents, no? Yung document number, page number, book number, series of... Ano po yung year na nakalagay dun sa series of notarial details?
Report correctionSo most likely, nasubmit po itong document na to 2024 and not in 2023.
Report correctionSo hindi po nila na-comply yung 30-day period to file this report. Yes or no lang po?
Report correctionOkay, thank you. Hindi po kayo inimbita nung grand opening ng Cale88?
Report correctionSo hindi nyo po alam kung nag-start talaga yung operations nito dahil wala kayo doon? Personally?
Report correctionOkay, thank you. Ngayon, tignan natin itong mga Form S1 na sinubmit supposedly ng Cale88. Ito ay letter D ng, still dun sa transmittal letter dated November 18, 2026.
Report correctionSo, importante po na timely din ang pag-submit ng mga S1 forms. At nabanggit niyo po kanina kung calendar year. Yung ending ng kumpanya dapat by April 30 na submit na ito.
Report correctionFollowing, yes. So meron po kayong sinubmit na Form S1 para sa calendar year ending 2023. Ito po ay certified ni Lourdes Lebosada. Pirmado niya po ito noong April 25, 2024. Pakiverify po.
Report correctionSo mukhang timely naman yung pag-submit ng 2023 kasi naihabol yung notarization.
Report correctionTignan po natin yung S-1 form naman for the year ending 2024. By the way, may nakalabel dito na amended. Ito po yung sa letter D. For the calendar year ending 2024 dash amended.
Report correctionKaso ang nasa files ko lang po yung amended. Meron po kayo nung first na filed?
Report correctionSige, it's ticking. Sige, later na lang po. Anyway, meron po kay original pero amended. Okay, hanap niya na.
Report correctionHindi po yan kasama sa transmittal letter ninyo noong November 18?
Report correctionMeron po. Nahanap ko lang. Pero hindi po kasama dun sa transmittal.
Report correctionWala dito. O sige, para lang hindi magtagal, balikan ko na lang po yan mamaya. Sige po. Puntahan muna natin itong amended na 2024. Form S1. Again,
Report correctionOpo. Nasa last page po yung attestation o certification kung sino man pong pumirma.
Report correctionOpo. Tignan po natin tong certification na ito nun attached dun sa amended 2024 S1 form ng Cale88. So sino po yung pumirma dito?
Report correctionAt nabanggit niyo ito po yung isa sa mga bagong directors na at
Report correctionMay 18, 2026. So nasubmit po ito malamang after na ng notarization.
Report correctionTama. Okay. So yung S1 form for 2024, na-submit siya after May 18, on or after May 18, 2026?
Report correctionSince notariado po, na-execute lang yung S1 form noong May 18, 2026, impossible yung na-file ito before that date?
Report correctionOkay. So na-file po ito either on May 18 or after? So hindi po siya timely. Late na po na file itong amended 2024.
Report correctionOkay, sige amendment. Puntahan natin yung last S1 form na naka-attach sa November 18, 2026 letter ninyo.
Report correctionPakicheck nga yung heading, paklarify lang po. Kasi ang nakalagay dito sa S1 form na naka-attach sa transmittal nyo, hindi ko alam kung malitong kopya ang nasa akin, pero nakalagay po kasi dito. Yung sa cover page, BOI Form S1, Annual Report on Actual Operations. Ang accounting period po nito ay para sa 2024. Ang ending date of accounting is December 31, 2024. Pero you claim po na this is for the year 2025.
Report correctionYun pong nung kinarify ko po ito, nagkamali po nung entry. 2025 po talaga yung reference po dito.
Report correctionYung pong kasi po online po yan na inaano nila. Yung kumpanya po inakamanya.
Report correctionOkay. Tignan natin po yung last page nito. Notaryado rin po ito. Tama po ba?
Report correctionMukhang pareho po yung tao. At sabay po na notaryo ka. May 18, 2026. So sabay na notarize yung amended 2024. S1 form and yung 2025 S1 form. So the same na-file po ito after na ng either on May 18 or after itong 2025 S1 form.
Report correctionHindi na po pirmado itong 2024 and 2025, hindi na po pirmado ni Dr. Lourdes Lebosada.
Report correctionSo yung naglagay ng detalye dito, Sa mga S1 forms na to, hindi na po si Lourdes Lebosada.
Report correctionHindi na. Si Leo Sacurom na po. Yung bago na po. Yung bago na. Hindi yung dati.
Report correctionAnd confirm nyo lang po, wala po kayong personal knowledge sa actual operations ng Cale88?
Report correctionHindi ko po alam kung sa grocery nabili ko po or kung saan. Basta...
Report correctionHindi kayo ever nakabisita sa planta nila? Kayo personally?
Report correctionKasi dun po supposedly yung Cale88 daw po sa Davao del Norte.
Report correctionSo dahil hindi po kayo involved sa operations, personally hindi nyo po mapapatutokanan yung mga figures na naka-report sa mga S-1 forms, itong tatlong S-1 forms na naka-attach sa letter ninyo.
Report correctionUmaasa lang po tayo dun sa report nila na notarized at nakabangga po sa kanilang annual financial statement na
Report correctionAlright, thank you. Okay na po yun. Thank you po sa explanation ninyo.
Report correctionMay binasa po na section ng Omnibus Investment Code si Atty. Gular kanina. Importante po na yung mga registered business enterprises na nagkocomply sila sa mga conditions in consideration for the tax incentives na nabibigay sa kanila. And let me just... Flash on the screen, Your Honor, Article 7, No. 8 of the Omnibus Investment Code or Executive Order No. 226. So, binasa po kanina ito ni Atty. Gular. Pero kung pwede niyo po bang basahin itong section na ito? Nababasa niyo po ba?
Report correctionAfter due notice, cancel the registration or suspend the enjoyment of incentives, benefits of any registered enterprise and or require refund of incentives enjoyed by such enterprises including interest and monetary penalties for failure to maintain the qualifications required by this code for registration with the Board of B. For violation of any provision of this code, of the rules and regulations issued under this code, of the terms and conditions of registration, or of laws for the protection of labor or of the consuming public.
Report correctionProvided that the registration of an enterprise whose project timetable as set by the board is delayed by one year shall be considered automatically cancelled unless otherwise Reinstated as a registered enterprise by the board.
Report correctionTech Booth, can you go back to the previous slide? Thank you. So nakalagay po dyan na dapat compliant yung mga registered business entities sa code of provisions ng Omnibus Investment Code sa rules and regulations issued under this code. or by the Board of Investments and of the terms and conditions of the registrations or the laws for the protection of labor or of the consuming public. So nakahighlight po yung protection of labor. So tama po ba na yung mga registered business enterprises ay nagpapasweldo ng tama, nagkocomply sa labor standards?
Report correctionovertime pay, holiday pay, and all these standards. Namomonitor niyo po ba yun kung compliance sila?
Report correctionPagka po sila ay kumuha ng income tax holiday, ang operating event po kasi rito pagka nag-request na sila ng income tax holiday, doon po matitrigger ngayon yung pagtingin po namin including yung kanilang pagkua po ng certificate of Good standing sa SSS for the benefits at lahat po. Nakalagay din po doon kung ano yung mga empleyado nila na kinunan ng benefits yung SSS number. Wala po yung pangalan. Si Cale88 kasi hindi siya nag-avail ng any incentive. No income tax holiday.
Report correctionAnd wala po siya sa special corporate income tax. Yun lang pong VAT exemption and zero rating lang po yung inavail niya for two years. Nung 2024 at saka 2020, 2024 at saka po nung 2026. Ang tinitignan naman po namin doon na compliance is the export to Total sales ratio.
Report correctionFor the VAT zero certification, hindi nyo na tinitignan yung labor aspect?
Report correctionHindi na po. Yung ratio lang po doon. As an exporter po ba siya o hindi. On the rest, doon po namin tinitignan yung compliance with labor standards. Dito po, hindi po siya nag-avail.
Report correctionAlright, thank you. So dahil hindi siya nag-avail, never po kayo nakakita ng mga SSS forms, mga PhilHealth, mga Alphabets?
Report correctionSo, never po kayo nakakita ng pangalan ng empleyado ng Cale88. Tama po ba?
Report correctionAnd wala kong hindi nagkaroon ng compliance check tungkol sa mga supposed employees ng Cale88 kung napapaswelduhan ba sila ng...
Report correctionDahil wala kong sinubmit sa inyo ng mga reports dahil hindi nga sila nag-avail. Thank you.
Report correctionHindi lang po S-1 form ang dapat sinasubmit ng registered business entities. Tama po ba? Kasama po dapat sa sinasubmit nila yung annual incentive report at annual benefits report?
Report correctionYung annual incentive report at annual benefits report, diretso po nilang sinasubmit ito sa sistema po ng FIRB. Bagong sistema na ito under the CREATE. So diretsyo po yun sa kanila. Hindi na po yung dumadaan sa amin.
Report correctionSo tinatawag nating firms yung fiscal incentive reporting system po.
Report correctionOkay. Pero just to confirm po, ang late filing ng S-1 form,
Report correctionPwede pong maging subject to fines, penalties, and or cancellation. Tama po ba?
Report correctionsa employment. So, isa po sa condition para sa registration ng Cale88 ay yung commitment ito na mag-generate ng trabaho. And based po sa
Report correctionapplication documents nila and registration documents, so per
Report correctionyear, meron silang kinukomit na minimum number of direct laborers. So dapat direct hired po ito, hindi pwede yung subcontract?
Report correctionYung direct labor po na sinasabi natin dito, yung mga nasa shop floor. Yung talaga pong directly related dun sa kanilang registered activities. So yung nagma-manufacture, so yung nagluluto siguro, nagsa-chop nung banana, nagluluto, yun po.
Report correctionDoon sa form po natin, ang naalala ko, meron tayong separate na iba po yung...
Report correctionSubcontracting? Okay. Alright. Pero for yung core activities ng isang enterprise, kailangan employee nila mismo yung gumagawa.
Report correctionAng naalala ko po, basta... Pwede pong outsource basta directly na nandun po sa shop floor kung manufacturing po siya.
Report correctionOkay. Yung mga S1 form kasi na sinasubmit ng Cale88, ang nakalagay doon hindi nakadetalya po yung mga pangalan na empleyado.
Report correctionTotal number of employees at labor cost, yun lang po yung nakalagay. Wala pong enumeration ng names ng employees. And since hindi po kayo parte ng operations, never pa po kayo nakapunta sa project site, hindi nyo po na-meet yung mga supposed employees ng Cale88, tama po?
Report correctionAng mga registered enterprises, nagsasubmit din ho ng mga SEC records sa Board of Investments, tama po ba?
Report correctionIpapakita ko po sa inyo yung mga general information sheets ng Cale88 for the years 2022. up to 2025. And your honors, may we be allowed to show to the witness the following exhibits. GIS for the year 2022 exhibit P-2-2-4-4-4-B-2. This is the second amended 2022 GIS. The GIS for 2023 P-2-2-4-4-C. GIS for 2024 P-2-2-4-4-C. 4-D, GIS for the year 2025, P-2-2-4-4-E.
Report correctionYour Honor, before the counsel for the prosecution asks a question, we would just like to object on the grounds of incompetence, Your Honor, only insofar as the GISs which are not part of the transmittal. I note, Your Honor, that in the November 18, 2026 transmittal, There are indeed general information sheets pertaining to the years 2024 to 2025. We have no objections to those to be clarified. But with respect to the other general information sheets that the Council for Prosecution is attempting to confront the witness, we have to object on the ground of incompetency, Ron. He is a representative from the Board of Investments.
Report correctionIt's the second amended GIS for 2022, 2023, 2024, and 2025. The witness just confirmed that SEC records are periodically submitted.
Report correctionFor 2024 and 2025. If he knows, I'd have to allow it, Atty. Justin. If he knows. Kung hindi niyo po alam, Dr. Perry, sabihin niyo po. Hindi niyo alam kung wala kayong record. Witness may answer? If he knows.
Report correctionYung sinubmit po sa aming GIS, yung in relation po dun sa change in ownership. Kaya yun po yung meron kaming GIS.
Report correctionIn that case, Your Honor, I will reiterate my objection with respect to the other GISs.
Report correctionNow, Attorney Erwin, I would have to ask, you're confronting him with exhibits not identified by the witness but previously offered and identified, correct? Attorney Erwin?
Report correctionSo these are not the documents attached to the form submitted to BOI?
Report correctionIf you're familiar with it, you may say so. If you're not familiar with it, Attorney Dr. Perry, you may say so.
Report correctionOkay. That's for what year? 2023? Attorney Aaron?
Report correctionSo you're being shown four GIS forms, Dr. Perry.
Report correctionAng aware po ako yung pong sinubmit namin na 20... GIS sheet for 2024 and 2025 po.
Report correctionOkay. That's his answer, counsel. Your witness?
Report correctionThey are flashing what appears to be the 2022 amended GIS. The witness already answered that he is not aware of these documents. We just ask that this be, with all due respect, taken down.
Report correctionOkay, we'll proceed to 2024. So, 2024, familiar po kayo, no?
Report correctionWell, actually, I'd like you to focus on the page about employees since that's what we're talking about.
Report correctionCan you confirm kung ilan po yung nakalagay dyan na number of rank and file employees?
Report correctionPero yung sa number of rank employees, wala pong figure. Tama po ba?
Report correctionTotal rank and file employee, two po yung nakikita ko.
Report correctionNapanood niyo po ba yung interjection dati ni Sen. Dr. Judge Joel Villanueva tungkol sa zero rank and file employees na nakareport sa GIS for the years 2022, 2023, and 2024? And dahil dito humingi siya ng alpha list of employees from the BIR witness?
Report correctionGusto niyo pong malaman kung ano yung nag-i-response ng BIR tungkol dun sa request ni Sen. Villanueva na mag-submit ng alpha list of employees.
Report correctionObjection, Your Honor. This is improper, Your Honor. The witness is incompetent.
Report correctionThe witness is interested to know, Your Honor. He nodded his head.
Report correctionWhat's the relevance of his interest to that? You can reform, counsel.
Report correctionAlam niyo po ba na hindi nagsasubmit ng alpha list of employees? Itong Cale88 sa BIR, based pa sa certification.
Report correctionSame objection, Your Honor. The witness would be incompetent. He is from the Board of Investments. They had their time to present that witness. They failed to do so. It's moot.
Report correctionConsidering that they're supposed to know if the business enterprises are not yet done, Your Honor. May I finish?
Report correctionSo, as we read earlier, the BOI is supposed to to enforce compliance of labor standards over these registered business enterprises. In connection with that, Your Honor.
Report correctionAtty. Justin, just to get over this hump, I guess you'll move on from this, Atty. Erwin. Witness may answer if he knows. Would you be aware?
Report correctionAnd hindi po nilerequire ng BOI na mag-submit Ang mga registered business enterprises ng SSS forms detailing the names of the employees of the business enterprises and detailing yung SSS deductions or contributions. Wala pong ganun na sinasubmit sa inyo.
Report correctionAng pangbanggaho kasi namin yung incentives eh. Gaya po ng nasabi ko kanina. Pag nag-avail po sila ng incentive, kihingin po namin yun.
Report correctionDahil ito po, hindi naman siya nag-avail ng incentives so wala po kaming pambanga doon.
Report correctionAnd how about the PhilHealth reports listing the names of employees na members ng PhilHealth?
Report correctionNo, I asked about the SSS forms. I'm asking about the PhilHealth forms, Your Honor.
Report correctionThank you. Okay. Puntahan natin yung... Transfers of shares to Tekemo.
Report correctionNakalagay po sa number 7F ng general terms and conditions and actually nakalagay din po sa BOI primer ninyo na the enterprise must seek prior permission of the BOI before doing any of the following acts.
Report correctionMay we flash the primer? On the screen and the following acts are, number one, transfer ownership and or control of the enterprise engaged in an undertaking other than the preferred project covered by its registration. Expand its capacity with or without incentives, which is consistent dito po sa number 7F ng general terms and conditions na inimposed ng BOI. Sa Cale88. So consistent po yung wording and may we show on the screen number 7F of the general terms and conditions. 7F.
Report correctionSo ando na po kayo sa 7F ng general terms and conditions. So yes or no lang po. Confirm nyo po na dapat before transferring ownership or control, dapat magpaalam sa BOI. Thank you. And dinidiscuss niyo po kanina, kinocompare niyo yung 2024 GIS ng Cale88 and yung 2025 GIS. Kinoconfirm niyo po na nagkaroon ng changes dun sa list of stockholders. So hindi ko na po ipapakita sa inyo dahil kinonfirm niyo na rin naman po yun.
Report correctionBasically, yung 95% combined shareholding ni Dr. Lebosada at Atty. Manases Carpio, na nakalista sa 2024 GIS. Sa 2025 GIS, nawala na ko yung names nila at pumalit po itong Pikimong Pikimong Philippines Corporation.
Report correctionOwning 95% as well. Tingnan nga po natin yung July 8, 2026 letter na naka-attach sa November
Report correctionIt's labeled kasi as a letter request. Pero I've read the letter. Pakilinaw nga lang po, ano ko ba talagang nire-request dito sa letter na ito? Are they requesting for a congratulations dahil nalipat na yung kumpanya? Are they requesting for approval? Pero pagkabasa po kasi natin, it's prior. I mean, they should ask. For that before. Pero ito po nangyari na after, tama po ba? July 8. Natapos na po yung supposed transfer. Tama po ba yun?
Report correctionAnd July 8, third day na po ito nung impeachment trial natin sa court. So, confirm ko lang po. Wala akong nababasa na request po sa letter. Kayo po ba meron?
Report correctionWala po. Updating po ito nang ini-inform po tayo to update their records na iba na po yung may-ari.
Report correctionSo hindi po siya talaga request? Kung baga FYI lang pala sa BOI?
Report correctionOkay lang. Alright. Thank you. Okay lang po yan. And then tignan naman natin tong response ng BOI dated October 9, 2026.
Report correctionna ito ay letter of approval of the request for change in ownership. And I'm reading the letter po. Wala po akong nababasa na salitang approved eh. Narinig ko po kayo kanina, kinorrect nyo pa nga po. I believe you said the word note.
Report correctionWala pong approval dito. Wala pong approval. Note po. We are noting.
Report correctionOkay, so hindi po in-approve. Wala pong approval. Yes or no lang po ha? Wala pong approval dun sa change in ownership?
Report correctionSir, alam niyo po ba na mahiling magtanim ng mga puno si Vice President Sara Duterte?
Report correctionAndito po yung pitch. I have a point, Your Honor. I promise. Put me on a short leash. Your Honor,
Report correctionunless there is relevance, Your Honor, we ask that this be taken down.
Report correctionThank you, Your Honor. Tama po ba na itong pagtatanim ng mga punin ni Vice President Saro Duterte ay connected sa pag-comply ng Cale88 Foods sa tree planting activities na requirement ng Board of Investment. In fact, ang requirement mo ng Board of Investments ay magtanim dapat ang mga enterprises ng at least 100 forest trees. May ganong requirement? Tama po ba?
Report correctionObjection, Your Honor. Misleading. There is no prior testimony coming from the witness wherein he testified that the Vice President participated in the compliance requirement of tree planting. The insinuation being made by the prosecution that the pictures being shown or that was displayed of the Vice President planting trees had any relation to the Cale88 Foods Corporation's registration is misleading, malicious, and callous, Your Honor.
Report correctionI will have to sustain the objection on your question, Attorney Erwin. Move on.
Report correctionOkay, Your Honor. So, may compliance po ba itong Cale88 Foods sa tree planting activities?
Report correctionI'll have to check po dun sa specific terms and conditions kung nakalagay po yung sa tree planting. Pero sa pagkakaalam ko po... Kasama po ito sa mga nire-require ng BOI. Pero may time period po for them to, sa pagkakaalala ko po, may time period for them to also comply. I -check ko lang po.
Report correctionYes, i-lead ko po kayo sa requirement. It's actually in 7D of the general terms and conditions.
Report correctionComply with the tree planting program of the board requiring a minimum of 100 forest trees to be planted pursuant to memorandum circular number one not later than one year from date of registration. Proof of compliance must be submitted within one year from date of registration. Otherwise, application for availment of any incentive by the enterprise shall not be accepted by the board.
Report correctionWala po kayo sa mga tree planting activities ng Cale88 Foods? Kung may nangyari man po na ganun? Wala po kayo na -witness na ganun?
Report correctionSo personally, hindi nyo po masabi kung nakapag-comply itong Cale88 dun sa required tree planting of 100, at least 100 forest trees?
Report correctionPersonally po, wala. Pero pwede ko pong i-check kung nag-submit po sila ng notarized na statement na nag-comply po sila. Sa compliance po namin.
Report correctionWala po ako nakikita sa files niyo na gano'n eh. Wala pong nakasama.
Report correctionKasi din po, hindi sila nag-avail ng income tax holiday prior to availment of ITH. Doon po yan na check-check talaga. Nababangga po pagka nag-avail sila ng ITH, ng duty exemption, at saka po ng SCIT.
Report correctionAlright. Sige, tignan natin yung application process nitong Cale88.
Report correctionNabasa ko po sa primer ninyo na pag may mga applications po, ang inoobserve nyo po ay first in, first out basis in processing the applications for registration.
Report correctionOkay. And nakalagay po sa primer ninyo na due to the volume of applications, firms shall receive a notification of the board's action on their ITH applications approximately within one year from the date of official acceptance. So pwedeng maging ganun po yung period up to one year based dito sa primer ninyo.
Report correctionI thought I heard you, Dr. Perry, that Cale88 did not apply for ITH.
Report correctionHe did not apply for ITH. He was not given ITH. So what's the connection of this provision?
Report correctionWith regard to the... I just want the witness to confirm that there are a lot of applications with the BOI. And it takes time for them to process. These documents, Your Honor, these applications.
Report correctionBut this refers to ITH. The witness already said they did not apply for ITH. They were not given ITH.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. And when it comes to applications in general and not just ITH, Your Honor, inclusive of registration, Your Honor,
Report correctionas to the length of time that it may take time in... Processing the applications for registrations, Your Honor.
Report correctionObjection, Your Honor. May we ask now the relevance of this line of questioning?
Report correctionYes, that's exactly what I'm asking, Atty. Erwin. What's the relevance of this too?
Report correctionThen I'll go directly to the point and not dwell on this ITH application, Your Honor.
Report correctionSa ITH application kasi first in, first out basis. How about in any other application, like application for business... Registration. Same po ba?
Report correctionAs much as possible po, we are following kung sino po yung nauna. Para fair lang naman po.
Report correctionOkay. Kung sino po yung nauna. At in your experience, gaano po kakahaba usually yung period?
Report correctionMeron po kaming citizens charter na required po kami pagka po upon submission of sa registration po. Upon submission of complete documents, pag tinanggap na po namin siya for checklisting, we are required to process within 20 days from the time of application for registration.
Report correctionPagkatapos po, doon naman po pag MSME, required po kami to process within 3 days po. Sa registration po yan, magkakaiba ko kasi yung registration sa Of course, ITH Availment.
Report correctionPero realistically speaking, nasusunod po ba yung 20 days?
Report correctionAs much as possible po, we try to keep to kung ano po yung nasa citizen's charter po natin.
Report correctionOkay. Let me just go into yung documents na nakatouch sa November 20 letter ninyo.
Report correctionPakonfirm nga po na merong application for registration dated December 6, 2021.
Report correctionBased po yun sa November 20, ano? Oo. Na sinubmit sa... December 7 pala po ito.
Report correctionApplication for registration, December 6, using yung BOI form po for small enterprise projects.
Report correctionYes, December 6 po, ano? Kanina po, pinakita sa inyo yung online notice of publication.
Report correctionAt pinost po, sabi niya po, hindi na kailangan mag-publish in a newspaper of general circulation para hindi na gumastos. So online po yung naging posting dito.
Report correctionAnd you confirm po na, pinakita po kasi sa inyo kanina, nakita ko po yung date na finlash sa screen when Attorney Gular was doing his direct examination, December 6. 2021 na post yung notice na ito. And then based on notice na ito, binigyan po yung public ng three days to file their opposition or objection. Tama po ba? Pero kung titignan po natin, mayroon ng by December 7, may approval ang Davao
Report correctionoffice ng BOI. Ito po yung third document. dun sa November 20, 2026. Sorry, it's the second document. It's the final compliance.
Report correctionIt's the final compliance with prerequisites for issuance of certificate of registration. Nakalagay po na may date of approval by the division chief ng December 7, 2021. Tama po. Can you verbalize your answer po? Tama po ba? December 7, may approval na ang Davao City Division Chief.
Report correctionIn fact, may letter na rin po na sinend ang Division Chief ng Davao, si Mr. Gil M. Dureza, dated December 7, 2021, kay Dr. Lourdes Lebosada. Based po sa document...
Report correctionSo nakalagay po dito sa letter, you can read it with me. Dear Dr. Lebosada, we are pleased to inform you that the Board, through the Board of Investments, Davao Extension Office, has approved your company's project on December 7, 2021. So this was a day after po nung... application form na December 6, 2021. So, when yung notice of, yung publication notice po, dated December 6. So, kung ako po, nag-oppose po ako by December 8, ano pong sasabihin ng BOI Davao sa akin na late na po ako dahil may lumalabas po na may approval na. Late po ba yung opposition ko? Am I on time or maaga pa po?
Report correctionPara po kasi maging operational talaga yan, kailangan po siyang makareceive nung final approval from the board mismo. Yun po yung certificate of registration na tinatransmit po natin. So hindi pa po... Yun po, approved at the level ng ating BEO, yung Division Chief. Pero pagka po meron pang, ang importante po, hindi pa namin i-issue po yung Certificate of Registration po natin.
Report correctionAt kailangan po yun ng action ng Board of Investment mismo?
Report correctionUna-una po, pagka po kasi ginawa yun ng Division Chief, ini- Kagaya po nasabi ko kanina, iniipon po lahat ng mga MSME application tapos sinasabay-sabay sila para inote ng board every first meeting of the month.
Report correctionDo you remember po kung kailan yung first meeting of the month nung December 2021?
Report correctionPwede ko pong tignan yung records po kung kailan siya.
Report correctionKasi pwede pong tumama yun ng ibang araw. Halimbawa walang quorum during the, naiiba-iba ho yung, although we try as much as possible na.
Report correctionPero na-notice ko po na December 9, meron na pong DOI na from ano.
Report correctionSo, December 9, 2021 is Thursday po. December 9, 2021. Thursday po yun.
Report correctionAnyway, hindi pa rin po tapos yung 3-day period for the public to oppose. Kasi
Report correctionDecember 6 po na-publish. 6 po ba nakalagay po yung naka-post? 6, 7, 8, 9 po nilabas.
Report correctionHindi nyo masabi. Anyway, just to ask, sino po yung mayor ng Davao City noong 2021? Alam nyo po ba?
Report correctionHindi... Hindi ko po alam. Kung sino ang mayor ng Davao City noong 2021.
Report correctionOkay. Kailangan po mag-submit ang registered business enterprises ng kanilang Articles of Incorporation sa BOI. Tama po ba?
Report correctionKasama po dun sa... Opo. Kasama po. Na-incorporate na po siya.
Report correctionIpakita ko po sa inyo yung Articles of Incorporation ng Cale88.
Report correctionAh, by the way, before this. Okay. Nabanggit niyo po yung board kanina. So minsan hindi natutuloy yung meeting ng board kasi walang quorum. 7 po ang members ng BOI. So ilan po dapat ang members para magka-quorum?
Report correctionSo dapat may 4 members na mag-attend para may quorum para mag-conduct ng business. Anong effect po pag walang quorum ang Board of Investments?
Report correctionSo at least four, okay. Pakitingnan po yung Articles of Incorporation ng Cale88.
Report correctionYung portion po na, yung number of Board of Directors, pakibasa po kung ilan ng Board of Directors dapat ng Cale88 Foods.
Report correctionThat the number of directors of the corporation shall be six, and the names, nationalities, and residences of the first directors of the corporation are as follows.
Report correctionSo, kung ang BOI kailangan ng 4 out of 7 for quorum, ilan naman po sa Cale88 para magkaroon ng quorum? Kung 6 ang kanilang board members.
Report correctionYour Honor, we will have to object on the ground of incompetence, Your Honor. I do not know why the prosecution is asking with all due respect. The internal processes of Cale88 Foods Corporation from a Board of Investments witness, Your Honor, on the basis of the requirement of quorum of the BOI. With all due respect, we think that's a stretch. We think it's outright irrelevant.
Report correctionAttorney Erwin, you have to... With your indulgence... Before this witness testified, the Chair already said that your articles of impeachment merely make mention of Cale88 as one of the possible sources of monies of the Vice President. So whether it is actually engaged in business or not is of no moment. In fact, it proves your case, if at all, that
Report correctionit is a regular business as a source of possible
Report correctionrevenue. Number two, your witness, Alex Cabrera, described it as a... What was the word, Attorney Justin?
Report correctionThen you can prove that too, but whether you prove that or not, I find that a surplusage on the part, quite frankly, of Attorney Cabrera because he seeks to prove unexplained, undeclared income. And if this is an ongoing business, then the question is, dineclare ba o hindi nang tama? So, why are we nitpicking on... The BOI's official documents on file with their office.
Report correctionYour Honor, I'm wrapping up and the relevance of this line of questioning goes into the capacity of this entity to conduct business. I will show later on how it's going to be relevant but I'd like to hear the answer. I have a point, Your Honor. I promise that it's going to be relevant, Your Honor.
Report correctionThen in that case, Attorney Justin, I think the key word is he's about to wrap up. On that assumption and premise, with your indulgence, Atty. Justin, I'll allow it. Yes.
Report correctionHindi ko po alam kung ano yung majority na required nila. Normally po, divided by 2 plus 1 yung alam ko po.
Report correctionSo, apply po natin yung formula nyo. Divided by 2 plus 1 is what?
Report correctionOkay. Gusto ko sanang ipakita sa inyong 2022 GIS pero object kan. So, diretso tayo sa 2024 GIS.
Report correctionSo, less than four. And are you aware po na sa second amended pa lang ng 2022 GIS nitong kumpanyang to, tatlo rin yung directors nila? Aware po kayo doon? Aware po kayo na as early as dung filing nila ng 2022 amended GIS, tatlo lang din po yung nakalagay na board of directors.
Report correctionYes, dalawa na lang. So lalong mababa pa sa 4. So kanina nabanggit nyo, hindi makakapag-conduct ng business ang BOI kung walang quorum. Is it the same for companies?
Report correctionObjection, Your Honor. Misleading. But number two, Your Honor, if I may. I thought he was winding up, Your Honor.
Report correctionHe already withdrew the question, counsel. Again, it is misleading because they vote based on their shareholdings in the company and the law already allows an OPC. Anyway, Attorney Erwin.
Report correctionJust last few questions. Balikan po natin yung mga affidavits na inattach ni Lourdes Lebosada. For example, itong... May mga affidavits naka-attach sa application nila for... VAT zero rating.
Report correctionPuntahan natin tong Annex A dun sa VAT zero rating certificate dated 2024. Affidavit po ni Dr. Lourdes Lebosada.
Report correctionThat I have been authorized by the company's board of directors to transact business with BOI relative to our application for BOI certification for VAT zero rating including submission of documents forming part of the firm's application.
Report correctionOkay, so this is a sworn statement. Pero mukhang maliho yung statement niya na authorized siya by the board kasi by this time wala na pong quorum dahil tatatlo lang yung directors. So how could they authorize her? Tama po ba?
Report correctionHindi ko po alam. Basta ito po yung pinagbasihan namin itong sworn.
Report correctionSo nag-rely lang po kayo kung ano man yung sinabi niya? Whether totoo o hindi.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. Kanina po, Sir Perry, tinanong kayo about yung virtual site inspection noong 2021.
Report correctionBasically, tinanong niya Atty. Erwin at kinumpirman niyo naman na walang tao doon. Could you please explain why the site inspection conducted in 2021 over Cale88 Foods Corporation? Was done virtually, sir.
Report correctionPandemic po kasi nun eh. So may mga quarantine health restrictions. Yun po, pandemic po.
Report correctionAnd just I'll be direct to the point, yung virtual site inspection, how was this applied to all BOI applicants? Was this only for Cale88 Foods Corporation?
Report correctionHindi po. Sa lahat po, talagang wala po kaming choice but to go for virtual inspection.
Report correctionAt ulitin ko po, bakit po walang choice yung Board of Investments?
Report correctionAt paano po sinigawa yung site inspection noong 2026?
Report correctionAt kanina sinabi niyo po from Manila office. Bakit po physical yung pagpunta? Kumpara noong sa una na virtual lang.
Report correctionNow... Tinanong din ni Atty. Erwin kanina na paano nyo daw malalaman kung nag-ooperate talaga yung kumpanya kung hindi nyo naman talagang physically pinupuntahan ng Board of Investments. Now, para lang po malaman ng prosecution, pati ng publiko, paano ba nga kinukumpirma ng ating Board of Investments, isang malaking institution ng ating gobyerno na talagang nag-ooperate yung mga export enterprise nila?
Report correctionTinitignan po natin kung meron silang revenue na from exports po. So kagaya po halimbawa yung sinabi ko po kanina na doon po sa report nila sa S1, meron pong nakalagay na export revenue. Tapos po may revenue din po sila doon sa kanilang annual financial statement. Tapos po for certain years, noong 2024,
Report correctionSaka nung 2025, nag-apply po sila ng VAT zero rating where for those two years, meron po silang nai-attach na certification ng mga bangko po dun sa inward remittances po nila.
Report correctionThank you, Sir Perry. Puntahan na naman natin yung mga tanong at mga concerns ng prosecution at pati na po siguro ng ibang tao. Yung mga number of employees ng Cale88 Foods Corporation. Now, I recall, dun sa direct examination natin, may site inspection nung 2026. Ano nga yung discussion with respect to the employees, if you recall, in that site inspection?
Report correctionThat question is vague. Actually, I don't understand what the... What
Report correctionwas stated in the report, Your Honor? I don't know how that's vague.
Report correctionIt was what was stated in the report only. Atty. Erwin, you asked for that same table. I believe the one that reflected 51?
Report correctionI'm referring to the report on site inspection dated May 18, 2026, Your Honor. There is a finding with respect to the employees. Yes.
Report correctionI'm asking the witness. Based on the finding during the ocular, Dr. Perry.
Report correctionYes, that is correct. Ang sinabi po dito ay based on 2025, during the inspection, the firm's compliance with its terms and conditions has been discussed, particularly its direct labor commitment. For 2025, year 3, the firm had to maintain, so ito po yung commitment nila, direct labor of 39. Based on the 2025 BOI Form S1, the firm had an actual labor of 50, while in 2024, they reported 2,001. So sa record soon namin, may 50 siya, but nagtataka lang ho kami bakit bumaba from 201 to 50.
Report correctionYung tanong ko po kasi sinabi niyo po na may mga tauhan talaga. In fact, I noticed earlier these were high-ranking officials from the Board of Investments who physically went and conducted the ocular inspection. Mayroon po bang finding dun sa ocular inspection na sinabi tatlo lang yung empleyado ng Cale88 Foods Corporation? Kung mayroon man.
Report correctionNow, diniscuss din ni Atty. Erwin kanina. Yung sa Board of Investment Form S1, naalala niyo po. Specifically, sinabi niya, wala daw listahan ng empleyado. May requirement na baga na ganyan na dapat ilista lahat ng mga empleyado ng isang export enterprise or any enterprise registered under the Board of Investment under this BOI S1 form? Mayroong requirement?
Report correctionOkay. Now, last question. Last question po. Sir, para malaman niyo na nandyan talaga yung export enterprise at nandyan talaga yung produkto, kailangan ba tikman ng Board of Investments ang produkto mismo ng lahat ng enterprise?
Report correctionInterjection from Senator Judges. Chair recognizes Senator Judge Villanueva. You have two minutes, sir. You may proceed when you're ready.
Report correctionSen. Villanueva will be followed by Sen. Marcos, thereafter Sen. Hontiveros, thereafter Sen. Sotto, Sen. Erwin Tulfo, and Sen. Bam Aquino. And the Senate President.
Report correctionYes, Mr. Presiding Officer, thank you, Mr. Senate President. Mr. Witness, gusto ko lang pong maintindihan ng gusto, doon sa binabanggit po na GIS, walang nakalagay na empleyado, pero doon sa in-inspect po at Sinumitin na dokumento sa inyo May 115 at nung huli sa site inspection ng May 20, May 2026 ay merong 50. Anong dahilan? Bakit magkaiba po?
Report correctionAng masasagot ko lang po yung dun sa form namin. Yung pong binabanggit na 50 doon po sa site inspection ay base rin po yun dun sa Form S1 na sinubmit din po nung kumpanya. Notarized. Yun po yung basehan dun sa 50. Hindi po nagbilang yung mga tao namin kung meron talagang 50 na physically na nandun po ng mga tao. Ang basehan po yung kanilang notarized na submission.
Report correctionTapos po, binabangga din po natin yung direct labor na yun dun sa annual financial statement din po na sinasubmit nung kumpanya. Tinitignan ko may mga notes to the financial statement din puro na nakalagay yung direct labor po nila.
Report correctionTinitignan ko po, January 1, ah, 2021, nagkaroon ng virtual inspection. And then ang next ay May 2026 na.
Report correctionNormally naman po hindi naman po talaga kailangan inspectin dahil meron po kaming nagre-rely po tayo sa mga dokumento na sinasubmit nila. Except dito lang din po nung humingi, ang trigger po nung humingi sila ng Certificate of Good Standing in relation to their BOC registration. Kaya po nung humingi sila nun, nung tinignan po, oh bumaba yung kanyang Labor from 200 to 50. Puntahan natin. Tatignan natin kung ano yung nangyayari sa kanya.
Report correctionWhen you inspect, hindi ba tine-check nyo rin kung bakit nung time na binigyan nyo sila ng incentives, part po ng kanilang plano ay mag-employ and siguro hindi na nakalagay doon kung endo or contractual yung magiging part of the employment or seasonal workers. Would that be correct to say?
Report correctionAng tinitignan po yung actual operation tapos kung may mga tao po, hindi ko alam kung na -check pa.
Report correctionJust for you to understand where I'm coming from, siyempre yung incentives bibigay mo pero wala ka ng pakialam whether they are submitting to our labor laws. Contractual ba sila? Because I'm just confused, no? A bit confused because zero rank and file yung nakalagay sa GIS. And yet, you have this amount of sales, revenues. I can't believe na lahat ay contractual. Sino mag-handle ng accounting? Treasury, HR, production heads are also outsourced. I don't think yung key positions cannot be... can be outsourced.
Report correctionMeron naman po silang nakareflect din ng mga administrative staff po. Pero kasi ang commitment po nila sa amin ay yung direct labor. So kaya po yun yung tinitignan natin.
Report correctionBut the direct labor definition doesn't mean you're regular.
Report correctionTama po. At saka po, again po, maikita po namin yung kanilang Yung SSS, ulitin ko lang po, pag nag-apply po sila ng income tax holiday, pero ito hindi nag-a-apply talaga ng, kumbaga po, wala siyang inavail na incentive niya except for the VAT zero rating application for two years.
Report correctionSir, last na lang po, I'll go to the second round. Bago o pagkatapos bigyan ng BOI registration ang Cale88. Nagkaroon po ba kayo ng actual inspection, yung before? O ito lang, itong virtual inspection lang po?
Report correctionSo again, dun sa 2021 to 2026, wala pong nangyaring inspection, walang mabe-verify na operation yung kumpanya,
Report correctionNoon pong nag-apply sila ng VAT zero rating noong 2024. Part po kasi na ng documentary requirement po namin yung pag-submit ng, at that time po, ng barangay certificate. Barangay certificate po na may nag-ooperate po doon sa lugar na yun noong na ganong kumpanya. Yun lang po yung meron kami.
Report correctionAre you aware, Dr. Rodolfo, yung China National Township Enterprise na isa sa mga kumpanyang nagpapadala ng pera dito sa Kalye 88 ay wholly owned subsidiary ng China National Agricultural Development Group na isang Chinese state... Owned Enterprise. Mayroon po bang records o disclosures din sa ang BOI na nagpapakita kung ang naturang Chinese company ay isa sa mga investors, buyers, partners ng KL88?
Report correctionPwede ko pong tignan yan doon po sa VAT zero rating application po nung kumpanya. Check ko lang po ngayon.
Report correctionAnong taon po kaya siya nagpadala? 2023, 2024, o 2025?
Report correctionKasi po, 2024 po, butas kami. Wala po siyang application for VAT zero rating. Kaya po wala kaming, ang pinagbabasayan lang po namin ng export sales niya ay yun pong dineclare niya dun sa S1.
Report correctionSiguro, attorney, ang ano ko na lang po is that kung meron po, kung may state-owned enterprise na Nakikipag-transaksyon sa isang Philippine Corporation. Meron po bang additional disclosures o documentation na hinihingi ang BOI depending on the nature of the transaction?
Report correctionBase po sa documentary requirements namin dito sa kumpanyang ito at saka sa similarly situated, wala po kaming, hindi po namin malalaman kung state-owned o hindi state-owned. Kailangan pong mag-extra. Google ho siguro or tatanong ho namin sa aming post.
Report correctionSo there would be no record whatsoever from DTI or BOI ng anumang official business engagement. If that's the case. With a state-owned enterprise. Between the Cale88 and the representatives of this Chinese firm.
Report correctionKung ano lang po, kung nasama po siya doon sa, pag nag-a-apply po kasi ng VAT zero rating, sinasama po doon yung Bank Certificate ng mga remittances. Doon po sa Certificate ng remittances, may mga bangko po na nagsasabi kung kanino galing exactly yung remittance kung napumasok, sino yung nagpasok, tsaka dito po sa accounts na to. Doon po, mati-check po namin kung naka-declare po doon.
Report correctionAnd last na po ito, Mr. Presiding Officer, yung Cale88, receive. Approximately 193.95 million in international remittances from China during the period examined in the forensic report na diniscuss po dito. And one of the identified remitters was China National Township Enterprise with remittances of approximately 19.28 million pesos.
Report correctionKasi po, ang total sales po, Okay lang po ba na sumagot ako? Yun
Report correctionsa S1 na submissions po ng kumpanya. Kung tototalin ko po yung tatlong taon na 2023, 2024, 2025, aabot po ng 208 million pesos. Thereabouts, 208,748,899. Kung ang sinasabi niyo po, Honorable... Judge ay 190 million.
Report correctionIt's actually in the forensic report. It's not actually. Did not come from me.
Report correctionBasta kung ganun po. Kung sakaling totoo man lang po yun ay ibig sabihin ho halos siya lang po yung kliyente dahil ang sales po nitong ng ating Kali 88 ay 208 or 209 million pesos. I-round off ko na. Over the... 3 years as declared sa amin ng Kompanya sa S-1 Reports na notarized.
Report correctionOpo. Sila yun. Salamat po. Salamat sa witness. Thank you.
Report correctionSenator Judge Marcos, you may proceed, ma’am. You have two minutes.
Report correctionYes, maraming salamat sa ating presiding judge. At pagod na si Usec. Perry. Akala ko Pax Silica ang pag-uusapan natin eh. Biglang na-impeachment testigo ka pala. In any case, before approving an application for registration, sinabi po ninyo at binasa yung mahabang listahan na yung BOI ini-evaluate yung applicant's proposed investment. Ika nga yung business plan, business operations, production capacity, financial projections. Tama po ba bago...
Report correctionSo, klaro sa inyo kaagad na yung business plan, posible. Otherwise, hindi naman ninyo papayagan at ia-approve. And does the BOI require the registered enterprises to report the commencement of actual commercial operations? Kasi nabanggit ninyo kanina, yung start of commercial operations, sinabmit din.
Report correctionApo, yun po yung start of commercial operation, yun po yung actual start, actual commercial operation.
Report correctionTapos, did Cale88 submit this report, yung January 2023? So... It commenced according to BOI records yung 2023, start of the year talaga. Tapos, based on your records din sa BOI, ilan ba talaga yung employees ng Cale88? Kanina pa natin pinag-uusapan yung tatlo sa GIS, pero sinasabi ninyo more than 100, 110 pa yung nabanggit. So, it's not true na dalawa o tatlo lang empleyado? Ano ba talagang pagkaintindi natin? Para i-clarify lang po.
Report correctionDito po sa submission niya po sa BOI Form S1. Nung 2023 po, 115. Nung 2024, 201. Tapos nung 2025 po ay 50.
Report correction50. Nag-wind down na. Doon na yung mga problema sa saging sa buong Davao region. Kaya't nag-wind down na. So hindi totoo yung 2 or 3 na empleyado. Claro yun sa BOI.
Report correctionSa dokumento po namin, iba ho. Ito po yung mga figures na sinaito.
Report correctionThat's right. Okay, so based din sa records ninyo, is there any indication that Cale88 Registered Manufacturing and Export Project was fictitious or that the company inflated its commercial operations, its exports? Meron ba kayong basihan na peke to?
Report correctionWala. Wala talagang hint. At therefore, masasabi natin, at least in terms of the BOI at yung dokumentong hawak ninyo, it is not an implausible business model. Tama po ba?
Report correctionHindi ko po masagot yung implausible business model, pero ang masasagot ko lang po, may kumpanya po na nagre-report sa amin ng ganitong mga figures. Yun po. O notarized.
Report correctionSo, hindi siya fictitious at wala namang basehan na sabihin na walang ganong kumpanya. Sa pagkaalam ng BOI, kumpleto naman ang papel at existing naman.
Report correctionSa papel na hawak namin at saka po dun sa pagpunta, yung 2020, early, mga middle part of 2026, meron naman pong nakita.
Report correctionNung nakapunta na kayo na... Patunayan naman ninyo na talagang nag-ooperate siya bilang kumpanya.
Report correctionMaraming salamat yun lang po. Thank you very much, Presiding Judge.
Report correctionThank you, Senator Judge Marcos. Senator Judge Risa is recognized. You may proceed, ma'am. You have two minutes.
Report correctionKapag po ba rehistradong isang kumpanya gaya ng Cale88 at nagsasubmit ng annual reports, Sigurado na ba yung BOI na above board lahat ng transaction ng ganung kumpanya?
Report correctionAng assumption po namin, basta po tama yung pagkakasubmit, notarized, tapos na ibabangga namin sa mga ibang submission din po niya, kagaya ng audited financial statement, tapos nagtutugma naman po ay opo.
Report correctionSo kung baga dun lang sa loob ng apat na kanto ng mga dokumento, basta't consistent sa isa't isa, pwede niyong i-presume na above board yung mga operasyon?
Report correctionOpo. Tsaka po kung every now and then, kung halimbawa nga po kamukha nung may nag-request ng Certificate of Good Standing tapos binisita, ganun po.
Report correctionYun yung iba kapag binisita. So kapag may actual na inspection on the ground.
Report correctionNakumpirman niyo po ba kung yung export sales at yung inward remittances sa mga reports ng Cale88 sa BOI ay eksaktong tumutugma dun sa lampas 770 million pesos na finlag na inflows ng AMLC?
Report correctionWala po akong alam dun sa AMLC kung ano man po yung figures niya. Ang alam ko po yung figures po na reported sa atin. At yung ito po ay galing sa kumpanya. So submitted, as I said po, notarized. And in two years ay backed up po ng bank certification ng inward remittances.
Report correctionMay mga hindi po sakto. Halimbawa po nung 2023, meron po siyang sinayit na export figures. Pag binangga po namin sa bank certification, mas mababa po ng konti. Pero pag tinitignan naman po kasi namin, papasok pa rin ba siya dun sa 70% na export requirement natin? Kasi po yun po yung talagang binabantayan namin sa... Bank VAT zero rating application. 2024 po wala kaming basihan kundi po yung sinubmit niya. Tapos po 2025 meron po.
Report correctionMeron pong bank certification na na-receive po kami dahil nag-apply po siya ng VAT zero rating.
Report correction2026, nung nag-apply po siya, covering the 2025 po yung mga nire-review namin. New owners na po yun sa 2026. Doon po kay Dr. Lebozada, doon lang po siya sa 2024 application, covering yung 2023.
Report correctionKahit pag-usapan lang natin yung 2023 hanggang 2025, at least sa simula, meron kayong nakitang kaunting discrepancies sa pagitan ng submissions ng Cale88 sa inyo at yung bank certificates. Pero wala pa po kayong pagbangga ng mga findings sa AMLC or mga flag transactions ng AMLC dun sa sinumite ng Cale88.
Report correctionOkay po. Sa karanasan po ninyo, kung may lehitimong export contract ang isang transaksyon, likely po ba na ma-flag yan as suspicious due to no underlying legal or trade obligations, purpose, or economic justification?
Report correctionYes. Likely po ba na ma-flag as suspicious Due to no underlying legal or trade obligations, purpose, or economic justification, kung may lehitimong export contract ang isang transaksyon.
Report correctionKung may kahit sino mang ibang agency na mag-flag. In this case, for example, AMLC.
Report correctionOrdinarily po, kung legit, yung makikita lang po namin na mga transactions, ordinarily, parang wala po.
Report correctionHindi kayo sigurado. Kaya babalikan ko po sa round 2. Pero huling tanong, Mr. Presiding Officer, dito sa round 1, tama po ba na registered as micro and small enterprise ang Cale88?
Report correctionOkay po. Eh, hanggang ngayon po ba ay... Registrado pa rin ang Cale88 bilang micro and small enterprise at nakakakuha ng mga benepisyon noon? Halimbawa yung hindi pagbayad ng tax or walang VAT?
Report correctionYung relevance po kasi nung kanyang pagiging micro and small enterprise ay with respect po dun sa napabilis po yung kanyang application process dahil pumasok po siya dun sa
Report correctionDelegated na po yung pag-approve sa kanya dun po sa Davao BEO po namin. So mas mabilis po tsaka yung 3 days na under our citizens charter dapat po ma-approve from the time na mag-provide ng complete documentary requirements.
Report correctionItutuloy ko sa round 2, lampas dun sa pag-apply ng Cale88 bilang small and micro enterprise. Salamat po. Salamat, Mr. Presiding Officer.
Report correctionThank you, Senator Judge Sotto. The former Senate President is recognized. Thereafter, Senator Judge Erwin.
Report correctionThank you, Mr. Presiding Officer. Thank you, kind sir. I was not intending to ask any questions anymore. Pretty much black and white originally mga narinig ko. So okay na sana. But you see here in the Senate, aside from the 20 senators, maraming mga legal stuff eh. Easily, Tigalawa. Eh mayroon pang open source na mga media at kung saan saan. So there are many questions that arise. So help me out. I am somehow suffering from a conundrum. Doon sa mga nabagit mo kanina before lunch and ngayong after lunch.
Report correctionLinawin ko muna. Ito yung mga binibigay niyong fiscal incentives to everyone. Income tax holiday.
Report correctionDepende po sa... Sa locality po, dun sa LGU. At saka po kung nandun po sila sa, kung ang pinili po nila, kung for export po sila, tas pinili po nila ay yung special corporate income tax, then yung pong 5% na special corporate income tax ay all in na po yun, tapos ibibigay na lang po yung share ng local government po dun.
Report correctionOkay. Now, this is my confusion. Before lunch, sabi niyo, Cale88 is continuously, just records natin, benefiting from tax incentives. It's a direct quote nung binanggit niyo kanina during your direct examination eh. So ano-ano itong tax incentives na binibigay sa Kali 88?
Report correctionAh, Honorable Senate, Honorable Judge, hindi ko maalala kung binanggit ko po yun. Pero po, hindi, ang naalala ko pong sinabi ko, hindi siya nag-avail ng tax incentive. Hindi po siya nag-avail ng income tax holiday. Hindi po siya nag-avail ng duty-free importation. Ang inavail lang po niya ay yung pong VAT zero rating. Yun lang po. And for two years.
Report correctionEh kasi marami kami dito, ganun na intindi namin sa sinabi mo kanina, pero yan ang sinabi mo after lunch. Well, we can check on the records of the journal. So, you're saying na, okay, you're saying that Cale88, wala kayong binigay tax incentives.
Report correctionKasi po, dun sa first year niya po, lugi po siya. So meaningless po sa kanya yung income tax holiday. Sa second year po niya, nung 2024, lugi pa rin po siya. So hindi pa rin po siya nag-avail ng income tax holiday dahil wala din naman po siya talagang kailangan bayaran. Nung 2025 po, meron po siyang income na. Pero hindi po siya nag-avail ng income tax holiday po. So wala po kaming naibigay na income tax holiday sa Cali.
Report correctionSo as of now, from 2021 hanggang 2025, iba yung 2026, iba na may ari, iba na binenta eh. Pinag-uusapan dito yung 2021-2025. Sinasabi nyo, wala. Hindi sila nag-avail ng kahit anong tax incentives from BOI.
Report correction2023 po siya nag-start ng commercial operation, hindi po siya nag-avail. 2024 hindi po. 2025 hindi rin po.
Report correctionEh bakit ganun ang intindi namin kanina sa sinabi nyo na mayroong tax incentives?
Report correctionPasensya na po, pero ito po yung ganito po. Talagang hindi po siya nag-avail.
Report correctionAlright. Ngayon, just to... Clarify issues on income tax. Yung mga corporate income tax, pagka yung mga ganito, hindi nagbabayad ano?
Report correctionAs individuals po, meron po silang personal income tax.
Report correctionMerong mga pagkakaiba yung GIS na sinubmit sa inyo at sinubmit sa SEC. Are you aware of that?
Report correctionHindi po. Yung pong dinasubmit sa amin kung yung tungkol o halimbawa dun sa 2024 and 2025 sa change in ownership, kung ano po yung sinubmit nila sa SEC, yun din po dapat yung isubmit nila sa amin.
Report correctionPero sa records, iba eh. Isinubmit sa inyo saka sinubmit sa SEC.
Report correctionAnyway, ayun yung point kanina ng Senator Villanueva also. But nevertheless, sige, I just suggest that siguro BOI dapat you should be more diligent and more research on giving out incentives to everybody. Tsaka yung binabanggit niyo yung notarized, medyo nangingiti po ako eh. Kasi sinubmit, eh notarized naman. Dito po may mga nagsasabit ng notarized eh. Napalpak. Remember?
Report correctionSenator Judge Erwin Tulfo is recognized. You have two minutes, sir, when you're ready. Next would be the Senate President. Thereafter, Senator Judge Bam Aquino.
Report correctionThank you very much, Mr. Presiding Officer. Ginoong testigo, sir, hindi po ba ninyo chine-check ang mga incorporators or board of directors na mga kumpanya na magkaparehistro sa inyo? Ito po ang Cale88 po.
Report correctionAlam niyo naman siguro itong nasa Article 7, Section 13 ng ating Constitution na ang Vice Presidente bawal po ma-affiliate sa mga negosyo. I mean, well, through her husband, di po ba? Community property po yun yung negosyo. Hindi ninyo chinecheck?
Report correctionNormally po, hindi na po eh. Ang mas concerned po kami limbawa kung mayroong restriction dun sa sector. Kagaya po alimbawa bawal ang foreigner or dapat to merong limitation lang doon sa foreign equity ownership.
Report correctionAlright. Isa pa akong katanungan. Nabanggit nyo kanina virtual lang pag inspect ninyo ng mga kumpanya. Hindi o talaga ninyo physically chinecheck kapag may nagparehistro sa inyo? I mean, wala? I mean, kung saan lang, gino-google lang ninyo?
Report correctionSimula po ng pandemic, pero kung... May mga na-inspect din naman po kami. Ngayon na po. Nung pandemic po talagang walang physical inspection. Pero ngayon na po may mga na-inspect naman po kami yung physical.
Report correctionNo wonder. Kaya hindi po ako nagtataka. Napakadami mga kumpanya na mga scammer. Napakadami mga Pilipino ang naluloko sa online. na nagbabayad ng pera. Pag hinabol na nila, pupuntahan lang kumpanya. E isang lupa na mga puno ng saging lang ang laman, o damuhan, o lumang bahay, pero wala talaga doon yung kumpanya. Ito yung, I think that the problem there is, nagpaparehistro sila para magamit lang legit. May mga bibigyan nyo sila ng mga permit, pero illegitimate. I mean, ibig ka nga eh, fly by night. Ginagamit lang po kayo para manloko ng tao, para legitimate. Hindi niyo ba ako alam yan na marami pong na-scam ngayon?
Report correctionHonorable Judge, very specific lang po yung mga sectors na nire-register po namin. Ito po yung mga strategic sectors. So kung halimbawa po hindi po namin kayang physically puntahan, meron naman po kaming ibang mga paraan kagaya po halimbawa virtual, titignan po namin. Pero po yung mga binabanggit po ng halimbawa ng mga nag-scam, hindi naman po nare-register din po?
Report correctionSiyempre sir, hindi naman nila sasabihin mga scammer sila, di ba ba? Magpaparehistro, for example ako, magre-rehistro ako ng kumpanya, eh talagang target ko naman local na ng tao, pupunta ako sa inyo, sa BOI, i-rehistro ko yung kumpanya ko, tapos maglalagay ako ng isang lugar doon, maglalakad-lakad, ah ito, number 1, 2, 3, ilang-ilang, or whatever street. Tapos ire-rehistro ko na. Eh hindi ko naman kumpanya yun. Kaya marami yung tayo sa office ko, marami yung nagre-reklamo na gano'n. Na naloloko sila pag sisingilin nila o kukuha sila ng refund. Eh wala ho, wala silang madatnan dahil peke-dos, peke yung nirehistro sa inyo na address. Siguro, sir, sa susunod kailangan ninyong tignan. Ano po?
Report correctionAlright, my last question po, Mr. Presiding Officer, if you would please. Posible po ba ang kumpanya kagaya po ng Cali 88 na 125,000 pesos lang ang paid up capital at may dalawang empleyado na sinasabing la would rack up over 700 million pesos sales in 3 to 4 years. Pero yung kanilang export worth, exported na goods ay worth 250 million lang. Only on the same period din. Posible po ba yun? 125,000 pero ang kanilang sales, 700 million. Parang maganda ho mag-invest dito.
Report correctionNung tinignan po namin yung kanilang business plan, ang tinignan po namin dun sa kanilang project cost na umaabot ng 12 million, yun ho yung posible. Yun pong kaya po. Based doon sa kanilang mga sinabing i-invest nila, kaya po nila yung capacity that will deliver yung ganitong amount po. Doon po namin siya tinignan.
Report correction700 million. Wala po kaming kinalaman doon sa 700 million. Na
Report correctionnga may question is, posibleng ho kaya ito? May mga nakita na ba kayong company na less than 1 million, less than half a million, tapos would rack up, would make sales in 3 to 4 years, eh times 1,000, 10,000 percent po. Ika nga yung kikitain.
Report correctionI have no capacity to make that judgment, Honorable Senator.
Report correctionAlright. Maraming salamat po, Mr. Witness. Thank you, Presiding Officer.
Report correctionThank you, Senator Judge Erwin. The Senate Presidents are recognized.
Report correctionThank you, Mr. Presiding Officer. Ganang hapon, Yusef Perry. Sundan ko lang po yung mga tanong ni Senator Riza kanina.
Report correctionNarinig ko ho sa inyo, tsaka tinitignan ko yung mga sidamit niyo, mga dokumento, na from 2022 to 2025, ng audited sales ng Cali 8.8 is 208 million. Tama po ba?
Report correctionnung tinitignan ko rin yung pinakita ng AMLC, I'll flash it, na ang inward remittance is about P776 million. Yung inward remittance niya.
Report correctionSa inyong karanasan, dahil alam ko expert kayo pagdating sa incentives, matagal na rin kayo sa BOI, anong possible reason dito dahil ang laki ng discrepancy?
Report correctionAnong meron bang undervaluing of sales, hindi nagde-declare ng tama? Base sa inyong analysis, dahil matagal na
Report correctionkayo sa... DTI, at kabisado nyo yung mga ganito nag-a-apply ng incentives. Anong possible reason ang layo ng numbers? At kahit na tinitignan ko yung balance sheet, may 20 million na advances from shareholders. Kahit na idagdag yung advances, dahil in-flow rin yan, hindi aabot ng 776.
Report correctionIn relation po, honorable judge, dun sa operations po nung kumpanya at saka po dun sa mga sinabit nila sa aming dokumento, wala akong makitang rason para tumaas po sila ng more than dito po sa declared sales revenue po nila na sinabit sa amin. So, yun po.
Report correctionAt tinitignan ko rin yung... Yung documento niya sinabit niyo sa amin, yung kanilang bank certification, yung mga sinertify ng bank ko na pumasok, is about 43 million. Tama po ba?
Report correctionYung sa record ko po, yung bank certification po kasi in dollars. So ang nasa record po namin, base po dun sa kanilang
Report correctionVAT zero rating application, $352,000 noong 2023. Ito po yung related sa sales po nila. Tapos po sa 2025 ay $368,000. Kung ito total ko po, $368,000.
Report correctionSo $721,283. dollars po. Yun po. Yung covered ng bank certificate.
Report correctionmalayo pa rin from 41 million ang sinertify ng banko na pumasok versus sinasabi ng AMLC na 700 million ang inflows. Malayo pa rin. Mas malayo.
Report correctionAnong mga possible reasons based on your experience?
Report correctionDoon lang po sa reporting sa mga dokumentong hawak po kasi namin. Hindi po kasi sila nag-file ng VAT zero rating for 2020, for 2025.
Report correctionSo kaya po wala po tayong bank certificates covering the 2024 period. Yung 2024 period po kung titignan natin yung kanilang sinasabit na export sales, yung po yung may pinakamataas sila dapat na export sales na umabot po ng 150 million. So wala po kaming kopya ng bank certificates.
Report correctionyun ang next na tanong ko dahil nga Ang isang kumpanya nag-a-apply sa BOI for the incentives, di ba ho? Lalo na yung VAT zero rating para hindi ka magbayad ng VAT. Pag export-oriented enterprise ka. Pero why go all through the trouble tapos hindi ka rin mag-a-apply ng VAT zero rating? Sabi nga kanina ni former Senate President Tito Sotto, pati other incentives like ITH, yung duty, customs duty exemptions. Bakit hindi sila nag-apply base sa iyong analysis and observation? The whole point kaya nga mag-BOI register ka is for the incentives. Kung hindi, di wag ka na mag-BOI register anymore. Pwede ka naman maging normal corporation at mag-export ka. Lalo na in 2024 dahil malaki yung sales nila. 150 million. Sa tingin mo, anong analysis? Bakit ganun?
Report correctionLalo na po dahil export-oriented siya, alam tayo po dito pagka meron tayong mga panukala kayo po at kami po sa BOI, pinag-uusapan yung mga bagay na importante sa mga exporter. Kung maalala niyo po, VAT zero rating yung isa sa mga talagang pinag-aawayan. It has to be very facilitative.
Report correctionKasi alam mo naman, alam ni Senate, ni presiding officer to, yung Create More Law na pinasa natin. Isa sa pinakamainit na topic doon, yung VAT. Kaya yan talaga ang hinahabol ng mga investors natin, lalo na export enterprise. Kaya nagtataka ko. Bakit hindi nila inavail? Dahil BOI registered naman sila.
Report correctionKadamihan po ng mga exporter, kung meron po silang ganyang incentive, would avail of it, would maximize it po.
Report correctionLastly, Mr. Presiding Officer, last question na ito. Nakita ko rin dito sa mga application, these are all self-declaration. Itong... Itong S-1 application ninyo, yung annual report on actual operations, even yung application ng VAT zero rating, based on good faith to.
Report correctionYung, Honorable Judge, yung VAT zero rating po, yes, pero may mga nakakadikit po na bank certificate.
Report correctionYes, oo, galing sa bank ko. Pero yung S-1 form, yung annual report on actual operations, based on good faith to. Kung anong dineclare ko sa inyo, Yun na ang gagamitin yung basis.
Report correctionMababangga naman po, again, dun sa annual audited financial statement na galing po sa kanila. At saka po, to the extent na nag-apply sila ng VAT zero rating, dun po sa bank certificate po nung inflows nila ng export sales.
Report correctionAng hindi ko nakikita dito ay yung customs documentation.
Report correctionPaano natin malalaman kung mayroon talagang export na nangyari?
Report correctionOpo, makukuha po yun sa Bureau of Customs, tapos po nire-report po nila yun for compilation ng data sa PSA, sa Philippine Statistics Authority. Doon po sa kanila makukuha po yun.
Report correctionPero sa inyo, sa pagbibigay nyo ng incentives at reportorial ng mga corporation, hindi... Nakita ko hindi kasama dito yung customs documents para malaman kung talagang mayroong lumabas na goods.
Report correctionbase nyo lang yung inordinate test ng bangko at yung invoice na galing rin sa kanila.
Report correctionyung actual customs, let's say, bill of lading or any supporting documents na mayroong lumabas na goods, wala.
Report correctionBaka yan ang dapat natin tignan, Yusek, dahil of course
Report correctionalam natin. Nagbibigay tayong incentives to attract exporter but talagang dapat may export na nangyayari. Lalo na ngayon kasi ang konteksto mas malaki nga yung inflows versus the actual sales and the actual bank remittance. Thank you, Mr. Presiding Officer.
Report correctionMarami salamat, Mr. Presiding Officer. Actually, karamihan po ng mga tanong ko natanong na rin ni Senate President Sherwin. Maybe I can just clarify a few points. So sa inyo pong palagay, Yusec Perry, this is a real business, correct no?
Report correctionCorrect. Okay. May pictures kayo nung factory?
Report correctionHindi sila nag-avail ng tax-free status? Is that correct to say?
Report correctionApat yan, di ba? VAT, tax holiday, corporate income. You
Report correctionmeaning hindi sila nag-apply or wala sila nakuha?
Report correctionHindi po sila nag-apply. Doon po sa SEIT, hindi po sila eligible kasi wala pa doon sa period. Doon po sa duty-free importation, wala po silang in-import. Wala po hindi sila nag-apply.
Report correctionSo pagating sa tax, dun lang sila sa VAT zero rating nakakuha ng incentive?
Report correctionKasi po yun yung binanga sa 2023 performance po nila and then 2026 binanga naman po sa 2025 performance.
Report correctionTama ba na yung VAT zero rating pertains to the purchase of raw materials?
Report correctionOkay. Tama rin ba na sa inyong dokumento 208 million yung total sales nila?
Report correctionwe have the BIR submission. It's also the same number. So tumutugma itong total sales, 208 million. Dito rin sa BIR, 8.1 million yung loss. You also
Report correctionNegative 42,255. In 2023, negative 1.88 million. In 2024, negative 6.1 million. And in 2025, negative 48,000.
Report correctionWell, sa BIR submission to this court, it was negative 48,000. But in any case, lugi yung kumpanya.
Report correctionYung BOI status ba? Has any connection kung lugi ka o kumikita ka?
Report correctionHindi naman, no? Hindi siya affected? So, lahat na napag-usapan ko, more or less, this is part of the course of a regular business. Is that your estimation?
Report correctionOkay. Ang hindi ko nalang talaga maintindihan, yung AMLA inflow na nabanggit ni Senator Sherwin kanina at nabanggit ni Senator Risa, 700 million yung pumasok. Of which 315 million ay galing sa China. Napag-uusapan yan. Pero 208 million lang yung declared na kinita. Okay. And you cannot hazard a guess kung paano nangyari yan.
Report correctionSo ang alam ko lang po yung operation nila, it should be 208 million pesos yung papasok.
Report correctionSo dapat 208 million yung papasok kasi 208 million yung nakadeklara nakita.
Report correctionUnless may investor ka galing sa ibang bansa or may... You're an expert here Yuseg Perry. Yung ibang perang papasok sa bank account mo... Kung hindi ito sales, kasi ang sales na deklarado ay 208 million, posibleng ano ito? Maybe hypothetically, posibleng ano po ito? Kasi that's about
Report correctionAng masasabi ko lang po, Honorable Judge, is dun po sa pagkakaalam namin ng operation nila, tsaka sa mga declaration nila sa amin, wala silang ibang source of income, kundi itong operation lang po na ito. Kaya po kung tatanungin niyo ako kung ano dapat yung pumapasok sa kanila, ito lang pong amount na to. As to the other sources, I would be purely guessing kung magsasalita ko.
Report correctionOkay, since pinag-uusapan dito kung expert ka ba o hindi, but you've been in the DTI for more than a decade already. Huwag muna tong Cali 88, pero pag may nakita kang gantong transaction report na may deklaradong a certain amount, pwede rin pumasok na pera, almost times 3. Posibleng ano yun?
Report correctionNa kapareho ng ganito po. Yung iba po kasi meron silang, for example,
Report correctionforeign exchange earnings. Yung iba po halimbawa may interest na pumasok, interest income, some other. Pero yun din po kasi dinideclare din po dapat sa amin yun kung meron silang other sources of income. Dito po walang nakadeclare po sa amin other sources.
Report correctionKung ibabangga mo po dun sa sinasabi na iba na pumasok sa kanila, may difference po. Pero wala akong alam ko dun. Ito lang yung alam ko.
Report correctionOkay. So ito po, last question, Mr. Presiding Officer. So Yusek Perry, wala ka naman kinalaman talaga sa Kali 88, di ba?
Report correctionHindi ka naman officer doon. Sino ba talaga yung makakapag-explain kung ganito karaming pera yung pumasok, ganito karaming diniklara? Who can really explain this? It's not you.
Report correctionAng tingin ko po yung si President, si Treasurer, yun po nagpa-file sa amin ng mga apidabit na nakapirma po siya si...
Report correctionPart one owner po siya and I think Treasurer yung... Designation niya and siya po yung nakapirma dun sa mga submissions niya po sa amin nung sila pa po yung may-ari.
Report correctionCan you name nga, sino yung mga posibleng makakapag-explain nito? Hindi po kayo eh. It's the owners, the general manager, the president, the treasurer, the auditor.
Report correctionOperating officer. Operating officer. Yung kung meron silang export sales manager, mga ganun po.
Report correctionOkay. And siguro po, Mr. Presiding Officer, para malaman talaga natin kung ano ba talaga yung totoo dito po sa perang ito, maganda kung ma-present rin yung mga taong yan para lang ma-explain kung ano. Because I think we will continue asking Yusek Rodolfo na hindi naman talaga niya alam yung mga sagot po dito. Thank you po, Mr. Presiding Officer.
Report correctionyou. Senator Judge Raffi is recognized. You have two minutes, sir. You may proceed when you're ready.
Report correctionMr. Witness, Paano po nalalaman kung talagang merong ine-export ang Kale 88 na produkto?
Report correctionHonorable Judge, dun po sa bank certificate po na may pumasok na remittance.
Report correctionBank certificate na pumasok sa remittance. But that's not my question. My question is Paano nalaman physically meron talagang ine-export na produkto ang Kale 88?
Report correctionNagre-rely po kami dun sa mga notarized na mga submission at saka po dito sa mga certified certifications po ng ibang entities kamukha po ng bank.
Report correctionNotarized. Alam mo naman, Mr. Witness, na isa sa pinaka-unreliable na dokumento ay itong notarized na documents. In fact, pumunta ka dyan sa Recto, pumunta ka dyan sa labas ng City Hall, nagpila-pila yung mga malilit na mesa at Tinataas yung kamay, notary, notary public.
Report correctionDapat ang the best way to determine kung talaga merong ine-export ang isang kumpanya ninyo is to go to the Bureau of Customs. Yun lang yun, as simple as that. Rather than relying on documents submitted by the exporter by way of notary public.
Report correctionSo alam mo na next time, siguro gagawin nyo. Now, second, sa annual report ng Cali 88 noong 2024, sinasabi nila na meron silang 423 employees.
Report correctionYeah, annual report on actual operations calendar year ending 2024, payroll 33,793,135.35. Number of employees, 423. So paano nyo po na nalalaman, na mamonitor kung talagang merong 423 employees na nag-work doon?
Report correctionYung 2024 po na nasa amin, yung sa direct labor niya po is 201.
Report correctionDi kita ko muna kontrahin dyan. Sige. So paano nyo manalaman na talagang 201 ang mga empleyado nila?
Report correctionAgain, notarized. Nakabangga po dun sa audited financial statement dahil po dun sa notes to the financial statement meron po siyang...
Report correctionbakit hindi kayo mismo ang gumagawa ng monitoring, gumagawa ng checking? Example, o kanina banggit niya ng prosecution. PhilHealth,
Report correctionPag-IBIG, PhilHealth Pag-IBIG. Yung mga benefits ng mga empleyado na pwede mong kunin sa kanila at pagbabanggain mo sa number of employees. SSS, you know? Diba?
Report correctionNatitignan po namin yan pagka nag-avail po sila ng income tax holiday dahil po merong requirement doon na Certificate of Good Standing coming from SSS. Kasama po sa sinasubmit ng SSS ay yung master list ng mga pinagbabayad po nila ng contribution.
Report correctionKaya siguro sila hindi nag-avail ang tax holiday para hindi nila mabigay mga dokumento ang sinasabi mo natin ngayon. So therefore, maaaring wala silang ganun kalaki kalami empleyado. Wala ba kayong ginagawang actual na site inspection to make sure na talagang pag sinabi ng 201 employees, meron talagang 201 employees?
Report correctionYun lang pong pagbisita lang po namin noong 2026, noong mid of this year po.
Report correctionAh, sorry. Nag-request po sila ng Certificate of Good Standing. Pero di po nila alam na bibisitahin po namin sila para as part of the process for the Certificate of Goods.
Report correctionSo, posibleng na wala silang 201 employees. Kasi wala po akong ginagawang headcount.
Report correctionSenator Judge Lacson is recognized. You may proceed, sir. You have two minutes. When you're ready.
Report correctionMaraming salamat po, Mr. Presiding Officer. Good afternoon, Usec Perry.
Report correctionSundan ko lang po yung mga tanong na aking mga kasamahan dito. Una-una yung sinabi ni Sen. Judge Tulpo, Erwin. Ang paid-up capital, 125,000 pesos. Ang record sa BIR, net loss nila sa loob ng dalawang taon, 2022 to 2023, 2023 hanggang 2024, 8.05 million. Ang gusto ko pa nang malaman, yung explanation, Bakit magpapatuloy ang operation ng isang kumpanya ay consistent yung loss? Kung gusto nyo lang pong, kasi nandyan naman kayo sa BOI, sa DTI, kung gusto nyo lang pong sagutin saan ang gagaling yung kanilang OPEX,
Report correctionkanilang pang-sustain sa kanilang operation. Kasi malaki yun, 8.05 million in two years.
Report correctionHonorable Judge, may nabasa po ako sa financial statement nila na merong advances from officials na parang 3.5 million. So may ganun po akong nabasa dun
Report correctionSo alam nyo, wala naman pong question na yung Kale 88 ay legitimately registered sa BOI. Nor will I question na nag-compliance sila sa mga requirements. Ang myth of the issue here is from the defense or from the prosecution. Kasi may mga agam-agam na pwedeng ginamit na pang money laundering kasi may pumasok na inward remittances in hundreds of thousands of dollars. Hindi lang masabi kanina siguro ni Senator Ban pero parang ganun ang tumbok niya eh.
Report correctionAng gusto namin makita yung proof, at least yung records, yung waybill, yung shipping records. Alam ko sabi nyo kanina sa consumption. Pero lahat kami nagtataka, at least sa defense, para ma-repute sana yung forensic financial analysis, sana kung meron kayo, para lang mawala sa aming duda na baka nagamit lang yung KALI 88, baka pwedeng I-enlighten nyo kami tungkol sa mga bagay na mga dokumento.
Report correctionJust to respond, Your Honor. Thank you po, Your Honor. We appreciate that. At alam naman namin kung ano hinahanap nyo. As nabanggit din, Senator Bam, we have witnesses for that, Your Honor. We will make the necessary...
Report correctionNo, no, it's okay, Your Honor, but we understand why these questions are being asked. We understand, Your Honor.
Report correctionAnd yun lang po, Yosef Perry, maraming salamat sa inyong panahon sa araw na ito. Thank you po.
Report correctionyou, Senator Judge Luxon. Senator Judge Villanueva, to avail of his second round.
Report correctionanswer of Attorney Poa satisfied this representation to just Ask and wake next time, Mr. Presiding Officer. Thank you very much. Thank
Report correctionSenator Judge Riza then, finally, to avail for interjection.
Report correctionSalamat, Mr. Presiding Officer. Magandang hapon muli, USEC.
Report correctionkanina po sa first round natin, sinabi niyo sa akin na registered pa rin bilang micro and small enterprise ang Kale 88.
Report correctionNoong 2025 po ang reported production nila ng Kale 88 ay 422,722 kilograms na banana chips. Sa mga tansya po, aabot sa 1.6 hanggang 2 milyong kilong saging o mga 1,900 metric tons kada taon ang kailangang iproseso para Ah, gumawa nung ganyang 422,000 plus kilograms ng banana chips. Eh, base po sa nakita at ni-report ng inyong team na nag-inspect yung laki po nung factory, yung dami po ng tauha nila, kaya ba talaga yung ganyang kadambuhalang scale of operations?
Report correctionHonorable Senator, dun po sa sinubmit po nila na business model, dun sa projection plan po nila, ang total capacity po nila actually ay humugit-kumulang po na 1.18 million kilograms of banana.
Report correctionyun po yung dapat po more or less maglalaro po dun sa 1.18 million
Report correctionactually, one-fourth lang yung 422,000 plus kilograms na production nila noong 2025.
Report correctionAnd yet, kahit po yung 422,000 plus kilograms na yun na reported production noong 2025, I mean, parang micro and small, no? So, small-scale na enterprise. Large-scale imagination. Actually, Yusek, it sounds bananas.
Report correctionHindi na natin kailangan gamitin yung salitang plausible, implausible. Talaga bang sa laki ng kumpanya, sa dami ng
Report correctionmga taon, laki ng factory, kaya ba talaga yung ganitong kalaking production?
Report correctionHindi ko kasi nakita yung factory, kaya ako mismo hindi ko masagot.
Report correctionTo start to wrap up po, dun din po kasi sa certificate of non-coverage na galing naman sa DNR, iba pa pong department, ang nakasulat na production capacity ng factory, yung parehong factory na in-inspect, nakasulat ng DNR na production capacity ng factory ng Kale 88 ay 120 metric tons lamang po per year. Less than one-tenth yung 1,900 metric tons na masasuggest nung reported production nila nung 2020. Kumbaga, hindi nagsaswak. Hindi nagmamatch.
Report correctionKung 120 times 10,000, aabot po siya sa 1.2 million kilograms din po siya.
Report correctionWala nga pong times 10 or 1000. Ibig sabihin, kasi nga supposedly small or micro enterprise ito. Pero ang
Report correctionng ambison, ang laki ng inireport. Lastly po, balik po ako sa BOI, sa annual reports po ng inyong bureau. Required rin po na i-report ang updated production and performance data ng kumpanya kasama po yung sales, kasama din po yung foreign remittances nito. Base po sa business standing ng Kale 88 sa mga dokumentong ito, di po ba nakakagulat na may pumapasok pa lang at least P770M mula sa ibang bansa na finlag ng AMLC?
Report correctionHindi po magmamatch dun sa kung ano yung sa records namin na dapat po mapasok.
Report correctionHindi magmamatch mathematically. So, nakakagulat emotionally.
Report correctionPero sa ngayon, at the very least, hindi nyo nga po ma-certify na above board ang lahat ng operasyon ng Kale 88.
Report correctionUp to 208 po, nakikita po namin na covered ng dokumento. Up to 208.
Report correctionboard. Over the past cumulative, over the past three years.
Report correctionSo beyond that po, dun sa kalahating milyong piso, hindi niyo masi-certify sa ngayon na above board ang mga transaksyong iyon. Sir?
Report correctionThank you, Dr. Perry. Maraming salamat po sa inyong panahon, oras, pasensya at pagsagot sa mga katanungan.
Report correctionApologies. We still have one interjection. Senator Judge Imee is recognized.
Report correctionquickly lang. Isang tanong lang. Ika-clarify ko lang yung nabanggit ninyo kanina. Yung bakit hindi nakapag-avail ng income tax holiday yung Kale 88? What is the reason sa palagay po ninyo?
Report correctionAng isa pong possible na reason ay dahil losses naman po siya dun sa year 1, year 2 losses po siya. Tapos po ang net income niya na nasa record po namin nung third year ay P375,000.
Report correctionPaliba sa lugi, hindi na nag-apply nung dalawang taon na yun. Nag-umpisa na ulit noong 2025. Kasi maraming tayong kilala na talaga nagkalugi-lugi sa banana exports dahil nagkasakit nga lahat ng saging sa Davao region noong Panama disease. Tama po ba yun?
Report correctionnagugulat yung iba bakit hininto na lamang yung pag-a-apply ng income tax. Okay. Maraming salamat yun lang po, Presiding Judge.
Report correctionThank you, Senator Judge Imee. Take two tayo. Dr. Perry, salamat sa inyong panahon, oras at pasensya sa pagsagot sa mga katanungan mula sa magkabilang panig at ganyan din sa mga miyembro ng hukumang ito. You are excused, sir. And thank you for your time.
Report correctionKindly call your next witness, Attorney Justin.
Report correctionFor our next witness, Your Honor, may we call to the witness stand Ms. Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, MBA.
Report correctionKindly situate the witness to the witness stand.
Report correctionThe clerk is directed to administer the oath to
Report correctionOn the part of the prosecution, who will be standing in your behalf?
Report correctionGood afternoon, Attorney. Good afternoon, Attorney Robles.
Report correctionYou, Pilar, Marilyn, Pagayunan, do swear that the evidence you shall give in the case now pending between the Philippines and Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte shall be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. So help you God.
Report correctionMa'am, ano po ang tawag sa inyo? Pilar o Marilyn?
Report correctionOkay. Ma'am Marilyn, naunawaan niyo po ba ang inyong pinanumpaan kaugnay sa pagbibigay niyo ng inyong testimonya sa hapong ito?
Report correctionOpo. Your Honor, based on the subpoena that I received, I will have to testify dun po sa product registration documents that were submitted by the Cali 8 Food Corporation to FDA.
Report correctionAnd the certificate of product registration issued under the company, the Cali...
Report correctionWe are offering the testimony of Madam Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, MBA, sorry, for the following purposes, Your Honor. Number one, that she is a Director IV of the Center for Food Regulation and Research under the Food and Drug Administration or the FDA. Number two, By authority of the Director General of the FDA, she issued and signed the Certificate of Product Registration of Cali 88 Foods Corporation for Sweetened Banana Chips with FDA Registration Number FR4-0000009768567 on August 17, 2022 and valid until August 16, 2027. Number 3 Cali 88 Foods Corporation was engaged in lawful legitimate export business of sweetened banana chips and had the requisite license to operate and the certificate of product registration issued by the FDA. Number four, to disprove the material allegations under Article 2 of the Articles of Impeachment and the supposed forensic report of Attorney Alexander B. Cabrera to identify documents and of course to testify. on matters related to the foregoing.
Report correctionYour Honor, for the purpose of expediting the proceedings, we are willing to stipulate on the first and second purposes. And for the third and fourth purposes, we are going to cross-examine the witness in that regard.
Report correctionAlso, to abbreviate the proceedings, Attorney Ray, are you willing to stipulate as to the... You've been given a copy of the documents the witness will be testifying to? And they are all certified true copies?
Report correctionAre you willing to stipulate as to the authenticity, due execution, existence, and the fact that these are on record?
Report correctionAnd that the witness will be able to identify them?
Report correctionYour Honor, again, briefly, not as long as the prior witness, just please allow me to manifest the marking so I could continuously... conduct my direct examination.
Report correctionOf course. Given that manifestation and stipulation, you may do so, counsel, for purposes of marking and for purposes of spreading into the records the documents that the witness would be able to identify whether you present it to her directly in the course of your direct or not. At least it will be part of the records.
Report correctionThank you, Your Honor. Given the stipulation of the prosecution, we would just like to request the marking. of the following documents that were produced directly by the Food and Drug Administration. Number 1, FDA letter of denial dated February 24, 2022. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-43-CALI-88. Number 2, Intertech test report for CALI-88 Food Corporation with attached photos of products and packaging material dated March 29, 2022. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-44-CALE88 Next is CALE88 Foods Corporation's Letter with attached photos of products and packaging dated April 30, 2022 We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-45-CALE88 Next would be the Order of Payment dated May 4, 2022 We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-46-CALE88 Next would be certificate of product registration in close parenthesis low-risk food product with FDA registration number FR-400009004164 in favor of Cali 88 Foods Corporation issued on June 15, 2022 valid until June 15, 2027. And next we request that that be marked. The aforesaid document as defense exhibit D-2-47-CALI-88. Next document would be the license to operate number 3000009127981 for FR ending with 8567. We request that it be marked as defense exhibit D-2-48-CALI-88. The second set of documents provided by the witness covered by FR-8567. We also request that the following documents be marked. Cali 88 Food Corporation's letter dated July 2, 2022. We request that it be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-49-Cali 88. Order of payment dated July 14, 2022. We request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-50-Cali 88. Next is Certificate of Product Registration. In close parenthesis, raw material with FDA registration number FR4-0000-0976-8567 in favor of Cali 88 Foods Corporation issued on August 17, 2022, valid until August 17, 2027.
Report correctionWe request that this be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-51-Cali 88. Next will be photos of a generic box for Calis. which is a brand name. We request that this be marked as a defense exhibit D-2-52-CALI-88 and license to operate number 3000009127981 which is the same as the one previously marked but it is with the set of documents for FR-ending 8567. We request that the same license to operate number License to operate, rather, be marked as Defense Exhibit D-2-53-Cali 88, Your Honor. That would be all, Your Honor.
Report correctionThank you, Your Honor. May I proceed to my direct examination, Your Honor?
Report correctionMa'am, for the record po, magandang hapon. Can you please state your name and your position?
Report correctionI am Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director for the Center for Food Regulation and Research of the Food and Drug Administration.
Report correctionSince I am the director for the Center for Food and Drug Administration, the responsibility of the Center for Food Regulatory is to in charge of the regulation of food products processed within the mandate of FDA and this would include the registration, processing of applications and evaluation of the product registration.
Report correctionIn accordance to the applicable rules and regulations of the FDA issuances.
Report correctionMa'am, maraming salamat po. Palapit lang po yung dalawang mic, ma'am, para mas clear yung... Okay lang po. Maraming salamat, ma'am. Ma'am, how long have you been with the Food and Drug Administration?
Report correctionMy first government employment is since 1990. That was in National Food Authority, the Food Development Center. And I was transferred to the Nutrition Service of the Department of Health. And because of the reorganization with the Department of Health, I was transferred also to the BFAD then, before FDA, in December 2000.
Report correctionUntil now, so I was in the Food and Drug Administration.
Report correctionMaraming salamat po ma'am. At para maintindihan po naming lahat ma'am, ano po itong FDA? Just a general description.
Report correctionFDA is a food agency, the Food and Drug Administration under the Department of Health which has the mission or which has the
Report correctionJurisdiction among health products to ensure the safety, efficacy, and quality of health products that would include drugs, medical device, cosmetics, and then preferred processed food.
Report correctionOkay, ma'am. Earlier, ma'am, stipulate po ng ating prosecution na ikaw po ay Director IV ng FDA, particularly Center for Food and Regulation Research. Ano po itong... Center for Food and Regulation Research po.
Report correctionYung Center for Food Regulation and Research is one of the center under the Food and Drug Administration which has the responsibility to regulate processed food. At isa dun po sa
Report correctionTrabaho namin is to evaluate and process application for product registration in accordance to the applicable rules and regulations and FDA issuances po.
Report correctionThank you po. Now, as Director IV of the Center of Food and Regulation Research, what are your duties and responsibilities?
Report correctionI would like to... This specific is specific po dito sa product registration. So yung process po kasi ng product registration as of now, it's an electronic process which the applicant has to apply online and then the process would There will be online application of the applicant then it will have to be pre-assessed in accordance to the completeness of the requirements that was submitted by the applicant company and then it will be after the pre-assessment then there will be payment then payment it will be posted by the cashier by the other department and then it will be evaluated. and then check. And then that's the
Report correctiontime that I will be the final approving authority. So that's my involvement.
Report correctionMa'am, kinonfirm po kanina na may mga documents po kayong isinumute dito sa impeachment court. Kaugnay na po sa sapina na in-issue para sa inyo. Unahin ko na po. Pero bago tayo pumunta sa mga document to, if you know ma'am, what... Set of FDA guidelines applies to manufacturers, traders, and distributors such as exporters of processed food. Ano po yung current guidelines natin dyan?
Report correctionKasi sir, I was asked to testify with regards to the product registration rights. So, we have an issuance, the AO 2014-0029 that would cover the licensing. of the establishment and the registration of prepackaged food products.
Report correctionOkay. Ma'am, one of the documents that you submitted is in relation to... You confirm, ma'am, that there were two sets of documents. Tama po ba? Yung isa is FR ending 4164 and the other one would be FR ending... 6
Report correctionPuntaan po natin yung unang set of documents po, ma'am. In the first set of documents, one of the documents you brought is an FDA letter of denial dated February 24, 2022. Do you have that document with you now, ma'am?
Report correctionCan you please explain to us what that letter is, ma'am?
Report correctionApplication was received and evaluated by the FDA, which is submitted by Jessica Tequillo as the representative of the company that I think applied for the product registration of the sweetened banana chips. It's for local distribution. So when it was evaluated, there was deficiencies that were found. And so, if you apply for the product registration, the result can be denied and approved. So, if there's a denial, the company will comply with the grounds for the denial, the reason why.
Report correctionOpportunity for the company to reapply within 6 months from the date the initial denial was sent to the email of the representative of the company.
Report correctionOkay. Thank you, ma'am. In that letter of denial from the FDA, who is the company involved there, ma'am? Just for transparency and for the record.
Report correctionBased on the letter of denial, the company is Cali88 Foods Corporation because it was addressed. To that company.
Report correctionOkay. And for transparency, ma'am, can you please read and explain the grounds stated in that letter kung bakit po na-deny ang application ng Cali88?
Report correctionOkay, so it was denied because the documents, there are inconsistency, Your Honor. In the process of the application, the online application, the company should There's a provision there that you have to specify the list of ingredients and in that particular information we have to validate in the label that was submitted as part also of the requirements for the product registration so that in the particular item there is inconsistent declaration because we have to be consistent what you And what you put in the online application, it should be the same.
Report correctionThank you, ma'am. Now, I've followed the chronology of the documents that you submitted. And the next document is actually, that you submitted before this impeachment court, is actually a Cali 88 Foods Corporation's letter with attached photos of products and packaging dated April 30, 2022. May we also request the tech to please flash this document. Can we scroll down please to the contents of the letter first?
Report correctionMa'am, my question is, what is the relation of that letter from Cali 88 Foods Corporation to the earlier letter of the FDA letter of denial dated February 24, 2022, if any, ma'am?
Report correctionThe relation of this letter to the letter of denial, the company is informing the Food and Drug Administration, Your Honor, that they are now applying for the reapplication and they are addressing the deficiencies that were identified in the letter of denial and they will be filing a reapplication.
Report correctionOkay. Now, in that application, ma'am, there's actually an attachment. If you look at the document, the last pages of, it states in the letter that there are attachments. Can we please scroll down to the attachments as well? We ask that it be shown. Para lang po makita. Can you zoom out para makita yung buong banana chips?
Report correctionNow, these appear to be packagings, ma'am, of Calis banana chips. Tapos may, I would assume, dried banana chips. Ano po ito, ma'am? How is this related to the letter? upon which these are attached to.
Report correctionThis is the packaging that was submitted in the initial application and it was evaluated in accordance to the regulations on labeling based on the FDA, FDA Philippines regulation and food labeling. So this was evaluated, so that, that’s why there was a denial as a result of that evaluation in the initial, because that was the one submitted initially. So based on the...
Report correctionPara lang po klaro ma'am, let's look at the screen right now and it appears to be a plastic packaging with the label banana I could, can we request the...
Report correctionBanana goodness in every bite. And there is nutritional facts below. Now, you said earlier that this is in response to the earlier denial. How is the submission of these Photos of packagings, a response to the earlier denial. Para po sa amin na hindi pamilyar sa mga requirements sa FDA.
Report correctionSir, these are the documents as part of the documents that was submitted in the earlier application na it was denied because the FDA evaluator finds the non-compliant to the labeling regulations of FDA. So as declared in the Denial letter, so non-declaration of the complete nutrition facts.
Report correctionAnd then there is the claims initially regarding the banana because this is considered as nutrient content claims or health claim because cardaba is the highest content of nutrients because it is the deepest roots among other banana plants.
Report correctionMa'am, can we go back to the letter? Just the last paragraph of the letter dated April 30, 2022. Can we zoom in on that? Please check on
Report correctionhave that document, ma'am? Can you counter left, please? It states there, based on the aforementioned grounds of denial, we already reflected and amended the deficiencies made in our last application for a registration. Attach in this letter as Annex A is the former and the revised label of our product in accordance with the labeling guidelines provided by Administrative Order No. 2014-0030. Again, it's stated we already rectified and amended. Ma'am, sa mga dokumento na sinumiti niyo, ano po yung mga na-rectify at na-amend na mga packaging?
Report correctionAs far as I remember, it was deleted. Deleted po yung claims. And then there's a complete nutrition information declaration and it is being supported by the certificate of analysis that was I think submitted, that was marked earlier because it's the product that has been applied is for the local distribution.
Report correctionOkay. Now you referred to an analysis. What relation does the I am showing you now the inter-tech test report for Cali 88 Food Corporation with attached photos of products and packaging dated March 29, 2022. Ano po yan na document ma'am? Sa amin po na hindi alam kung ano po yung relevance ng document na yan.
Report correctionSo because sa prepackaged food product, your honor, kailangan po natin maglagay ng nutrition information. So you cannot just put, hindi pwede pong manghula na ito ang protein content, ito yung total fat, ito yung carbohydrates, ito. So it has to be... are justified through a certificate of analysis. So this is the proximate, this is what you call proximate analysis to support the declaration of the nutrition facts na sinasabi pong nire-rectify na ng applicant company as a response to the letter of denial that was issued a while ago.
Report correctionBaba pa. Or meron. Yan. Can we zoom out just? So ito ma'am, these are based on that Intertech test report. There are boxes and labeling ma'am. How is that relevant to the rectification that you referred to earlier ma'am?
Report correctionI think sir, you have to flash this one. Because that's the secondary packaging.
Report correctionthat's the primary. Sorry, ma'am. Hindi ako familiar sa packaging. And thank you for helping. And thank you for helping. Can we zoom on that banana chips and the packaging itself, ma'am? Can we rotate if it's possible?
Report correctionOkay. Now, ma'am, same question. What is the relevance of this? It states there, Kales Banana Chips. And then it's a front and meron din pong back. Ano pong relevance nito sa sinabi niyo kanina na compliance of the letter of denial?
Report correctionYeah, so this shows the labeling that was attached to the reapplication, Your Honor, yung letter. Okay. So it means na tinanggal na yung claim that Cardaba has, and then... It's already compliant when it comes to nutrition facts because the declaration of the nutrition facts is already complete and it was supported by the laboratory test result.
Report correctionMa'am, balik pa rin tayo sa Intertech Test Report. Sino po yung kumuha ng test report na yan? Base sa dokumento po.
Report correctionSino po yung kumuha po? Sinong korporasyon? Kumuha. Oo. Or nagpa-test report? Bakit may test report na ganyan?
Report correctionThe Cali Food Corporation because that's the company that submitted the application for...
Report correctionMa'am, para makakuha po ng test report na ganyan, ano po yung mga ginagamit ng kumpanya para sa mga out results na nakikita natin?
Report correctionKasi this is not being done by the FDA, right? So it is only submitted as part of the documentary requirements relative to your reapplication.
Report correctionjust ask the question directly, ma'am. Kailangan po ba nilang itest yung banana chips mismo sa report na yun?
Report correctionAtty. Justin, with your permission, with your indulgence, yes, what is it, Atty. Ray?
Report correctionYour Honor, to abbreviate the proceedings, I don't think there's a need to go into all of these details, Your Honor. It was already stipulated that the Caglia 88 was duly issued a certificate of registration. And to go through the denial, the packaging, and everything would be an utter waste of the time of the Honorable Court.
Report correctionDo you concede, Atty. Ray, that there is indeed a product as shown in the picture earlier?
Report correctionThat these documents were submitted and the application was processed and a CPR was issued.
Report correctionThat's not my question, Atty. Ray. Do you concede that there is such a product as shown
Report correctionin the picture earlier and in the attachment submitted?
Report correctionThe pictures were submitted and a sample of the product was given and analyzed.
Report correctionWala ba kayong dala, Atty. Justin, na banana chip dyan?
Report correctionUnfortunately, Your Honor, in due time, hindi pa po namin natikmat. We will present the proper evidence through the proper witness.
Report correctionclarify, Your Honor, maybe we could expedite the proceedings. The extent of the prosecution's stipulation. Are they now stipulating that Cali 88 Foods Corporation has indeed a banana chip product, Your Honor?
Report correctionNo, Your Honor. We are stipulating that Cali 88 applied for A certificate of product registration. They submitted appropriate requirements including a sample of the product and that the Food and Drug Administration through the Center for Food Registration and Research issued the certificate of product registration after processing the application.
Report correctionI will have to continue, Your Honor. I hope you understand. Unless they stipulate that there is indeed a product.
Report correctionYour Honor, you already stipulated that they submitted samples of the product. And that is the only extent, I mean, unless they can print the product here, Your Honor. So, that is the, even the witness cannot say that there is a product, only that samples were submitted to them, Your Honor.
Report correctionthat's a conclusion. We're splitting hairs here, counsel.
Report correctionWhether or not X amount of the product were produced or sold is different. But what all that the witness will testify to is there is indeed a product.
Report correctionThere is a product that was sought to be registered and
Report correctionduly registered. As to the quantities of the product sold as to its cost, that is a totally different matter.
Report correctionThat is correct, Your Honor. That is not our intention in presenting it.
Report correctionintention is that there is such a product that was applied for registration before the FDA. The FDA saw the product, the product was submitted, it was approved by the FDA, and duly registered by the FDA as a product purportedly selling Banana chips with a nutritional value at the back of the packaging.
Report correctionthe requirements for the registration of the products were duly submitted and after processing, the Food and Drug Administration through the Office of the Gentle Lady approved the certificate of product registration.
Report correctionAtty. Ray, I guess it's best that you summarize. Para lang po hindi ako ma...
Report correctionI will really summarize, Your Honor. That if allowed to testify, Your Honor, the witness will attest to the fact that Cali 88 applied for registration. In fact, applied for two certificate of product registration. One for local manufacturer, one for export. And that this application were supported by the appropriate requirements, and they were eventually approved by the Food and Drug Administration, and they were issued the proper certificate of product registration.
Report correctionYour Honor, given the stipulations of the prosecution, we will dispense with the further presentation. of the witness. And we just ask that the testimony thus far be admitted.
Report correctionthe record, are there any other pictures of the product, counsel?
Report correctionrequest the tech to please show all the photos. We refer to Intertech Test Report, Cali 88 Food.
Report correctionShort of a sample, at least show us the pictures of the supposed product applied for registration.
Report correctionWhat other pictures do you have to be identified by the witness? This is the actual packaging and the package?
Report correctionOf the product, Your Honor, according to the witness.
Report correctionTek, kahon yung pinapakita mo naman eh. Karol, tulungan mo ko.
Report correctionI'll specify the documents with the photos, Your Honor. The first would be Kale 88 Food Corporation's letter with attached photos of products and packaging dated April 30, 2022 as testified by the witness.
Report correctionYes, these were the ones initially denied. Tama po ba?
Report correctionNext are the... Intertech test report for Cali 88 Food Corporation with attached photos of products and packaging dated March 29, 2022, which eventually led to the issuance of the certificate of product registration, Your Honor.
Report correctionPertaining to the second product registration of raw material, these
Report correctionare the photos of generic box for Cali, Your Honor.
Report correctionThey are part of the second set of documents under FR-976856.
Report correctionI think we're satisfied. Short of a sample being brought at the appropriate time, should you decide to do so?
Report correctionI think the pictures satisfies this court. Any senator or judge who wish to make interjections? If there are none, we will excuse this witness.
Report correctionForgive me, Tony Ray. Sorry, I assumed. Are you done with your direct, Atty. Justin?
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. Just a few points, Your Honor. Please. Ma'am, para lang po magka-idea kami, based on our open source research, kayo po ay career official ng FDA, di po ba? 23 years na po yata kayo.
Report correctionActually, in the government service, I'm 36 years already. But the FDA started in 2000.
Report correctionSalamat po sa servisyo niyo. I hope you understand. I have to ask you some questions as part of my job. Kung pwede pong answerable by yes or no, sagutin niyo po ng yes or no. Ngayon kung may kailangang ipaliwanag, I'm sure bibigyan po kayo ng opportunity ng counsel for the respondents. Ngayon kung hindi nyo alam yung sagot o hindi nyo kayang ipaliwanag, pakisabi na lang po para hindi natin i-extend pa po yung discussion. So ang unap ko pong tanong, yung pong proseso ng pag-a-apply ng Certificate of Product Registration, di po ba... Parang lumalabas na two-stage process po yan, di po ba? Kailangan muna meron kang license to operate, tama po ba?
Report correctionOpo, your honor, because the license to operate is one of the requirements for product
Report correctionNgayon po, so, Kaya po napansin ko ang sinubmit yung dokumento, dalawang set po ito. Tapos dalawa yung certificate of product registration. Isa po yung for export, isa po yung for local. Tama po ba?
Report correctionAt kasama po dun sa ano, can we request the tech to project the two certificate of product registration?
Report correctionSo ito po yung dalawang certificate of product registration.
Report correctionMedyo... Maliit po yung sulat. Pero babasahin ko na lang po. Yung una, ito po yung Certificate of Product Registration, Calies Sweetened Banana Chips with FDR Registration Number FR-0000-900-4164. Ito po yata yung para sa lokal. Tama po ba?
Report correctionNgayon, yung pangalawa, ito po yung Certificate of Product Registration na nakalagay raw material, Calles Sweetened Banana Chips for Export Market Only. Ito po yung FR-4000-9768-567. Tama po?
Report correctionAng tanong ko po, assuming na merong license to operate yung isang company at mag-apply sila ng Certificate of Product Registration for Process Foods, gaano po katagal normally tumatagal yung pag-proseso ng opisina niyo bago mag-issue ng ano? On the average po.
Report correctionYes, your honor. So our objective or our target is we have to follow the ease of doing business timeline. So it should be like for us, our target is 20 days.
Report correctionCenter for Food Regulation and Research, the timeline now starts at when the payment was posted and it will be, kasi may payment pa po yun sir, your honor. The process is online. So it will not be forwarded to the Center for Food for evaluation if this application has not been, the payment has not been posted. So that's the existing process.
Report correctionko po ma'am, kasi sinasabi niyo payment, ibig sabihin that was pre-cleared already.
Report correctionPero ang normal po is, let's say bago po akong kumpanya na meron akong license to operate. Nag-apply po ako ng Certificate of Product Registration. On the average, from the time I file my application, up to the time ma-issue yung Certificate of Product Registration. Ano po yung common experience? Normally, gaano po katagal?
Report correctionalways target on 20 days but because there is an influx of... Application, then we have some backlog.
Report correctionMga ganun po. Anyway, so ito po yung Certificate of Product Registration.
Report correctionNapansin ko po may inattach din po kayo dito sa parehong set ng documents. Meron pong license to operate na inattach kayo.
Report correctionWe attach even if it's not submitted by the company because what was testified is all the documents that was submitted because it's already in the system of FDA, the license to operate.
Report correctionSo, in effect, can we go to the next slide please? Ito pong license to operate na ito, kaya niyo inattach. Sinasabi niyo na ito yung license to operate ng kumpanya in support of the requirements of the application. Tama po ba?
Report correctionYes, because the license to operate that was attached, it means na valid, it was renewed.
Report correctionHindi, at tinatanong ko po, ito po ba yung license to operate in support of the application?
Report correctionDuring the time that the CPR was applied, ang LTO po nilang na nakalagay doon sa, naka-indicate po sa CPR is yung iba po yung LTO number.
Report correctionBakit po itong inattach niyo eh? Yun yung supposedly kasama ng application?
Report correctionsir kasi expired na siya because the validity ng LTO is until October 9, 2022.
Report correctionSo ang tanong ko po, ito po ba o hindi ang LTO na in support of the application?
Report correctionHindi po siya yung LTO in support ng application during the time the application was filed because the license to operate number there is 855-7334 and the expiry date is until October 9, 2022. So the company has filed for the renewal.
Report correctionContrary to what you're saying, ang nakalagay po dito, October 9, 2027.
Report correctionBefore you answer, Ma'am Marlene, Attorney Justin?
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. We are just objecting, Your Honor, because we're just confused since the prosecution has already stipulated that Cali 88 Foods Corporation is already compliant in relation to its application for a certificate. or food registration. The line of questioning appears to be on the question. Secondly, Your Honor, we're pertaining to a renewal, Your Honor. So, we do not see. It appears to be inconsistent, Your Honor. On one hand, they were stipulating. On the other hand, they are now questioning the compliance and the assessment made by the FDA.
Report correctionWhat we stipulated on is that they submitted the requirements and the CPR was issued.
Report correctionYour Honor, what we are asking the witness is regarding the supporting documents. We would just like to know if the proper supporting documents were submitted because as the witness said, before a CPR is issued, a valid license to operate must exist.
Report correctionWe are looking at this license to operate, Your Honor, and it does not have a date of issuance.
Report correctioncan we just be allowed to ask the witness regarding this so that she can explain?
Report correctionI’ll allow it, and then move to your next point, Attorney Ray.
Report correctionBut given the statement of Atty. Ray of the extent of his stipulation, we request a back-read of the transcript right now to confront him. with the exact stipulations he made. Because otherwise, if that is his position, we have been misled in giving up our direct examination and will ask that we be allowed to reconduct the same, Your Honor. This is all fairness, Your Honor. We ask a back-read of the transcript of stenographic notes and the exact wording that were uttered from the mouth of Atty. Ray just for fairness, Your Honor.
Report correctionCali 88 complied with all the requirements of the FDA and that the permits and licenses were duly issued in accordance with law.
Report correctionI remember my exact words. Submitted all of the requirements and they were issued.
Report correctionNo, Your Honor. I'm just trying to clarify from the witness because the document does not state when the LTO was issued.
Report correctionThen, we can, the court would be informed if the requirements were properly complied with.
Report correctionPrecisely, counsel, you stipulated that... They
Report correctionAnd that they complied, I think Attorney Justin asked for it, that they complied. with the requirements of the FDA and that therefore the license was issued.
Report correctionWell, we're just trying to clarify this particular document, Your Honor. This is my only other point, Your Honor. After this, I'll move on, Your Honor.
Report correctionI'd rather that you move on, counsel. Move on to your next point.
Report correctionNgayon, ang isa pong, Ma'am Pilar, ang isa pong punto na sinasabi po ng prosecution, kaya kayo pinasinta, kasi daw po, Kayo ay tetestigo na ang Kalye 88 Food Corporation ay engaged sa lawful, legitimate export business of sweetened banana chips. Ang tanong ko po, after po ma-issue itong Certificate of Product Registration, minonitor niyo po ba yung negosyo ng Kalye 88?
Report correctionYour Honor, that’s not part of our job because Yan po, safety quality yung aming proseso sa pag-evaluate po ng application.
Report correctionSo, hindi nyo po matestiguhan na lawful, legitimate ang negosyo ng Cali 88 at hindi nyo rin po mapapasinungalingan yun, di po ba? Kasi hindi nyo naman binantayan ang operations nila.
Report correctionKindly answer through the mic, ma'am. Don't just shake your head.
Report correctionHindi. Ulitin ko po, Your Honor, na hindi po kasama yun sa trabaho namin. So hindi po ako makasag—
Report correctionYour Honor, I am just asking the witness because the purpose said that she will testify that the Cali 88 is engaged in lawful export. I'm trying to clarify if she can. Now the other ano, hindi nyo rin po masasabi kung Totoong nagmanufacture ng banana chips for export ang Kali 88.
Report correctionWe are now really confused, Your Honor, and it is at this point that we will respectfully insist a back-read and production of the transcript of stenographic notes because the direction of Attorney Ray’s cross-examination is diametrically opposed to his previous Stipulations, Your Honor.
Report correctionWe have to be able to be clarified of the extent of the stipulations. This has nothing to do with the certificate of examination, Your Honor.
Report correctionThis is not a debate. Kindly allow Attorney Justin to finish and then I'll allow
Report correctionWe are just asking, Your Honor, that the extent and the words uttered by Atty. Ray be produced through a back read of stenographic notes, which I'm sure Atty. Ray understands is normal. In court proceedings and in courts of record for us to exactly know the extent of the stipulations. And his response to our request of clarification. The reason being, Your Honor, is because we withdrew our direct examination precisely of the extent of the stipulations. Otherwise, we already expressed our intent to continue with our direct examination, Your Honor. Our objection right now, and I hope Atty. Ray would allow me to finish, is that the track of his cross-examination is diametrically opposed to the previous stipulations he already made.
Report correctionMy questions now had nothing to do with the stipulation. I am asking the witness... After the issuance of the certificate of product registration, did she keep track of the business?
Report correctionYour Honor, I think that's even part of the stipulations that the
Report correctionof production which was offered by the presiding officer, the tonnage, is outside.
Report correctionground that it has already been asked and answered specifically by the presiding officer that the witness would not be qualified to testify as to whether or not These were actually manufactured and or sold and as to the quantities produced and or quantities sold locally or internationally. So the witness will not be able to answer.
Report correctionNone, Your Honor, but we just request at the appropriate time for the back read.
Report correctionset. We will do that before we direct examination.
Report correctionIf there are no interjections, Senator Judge Imee, none.
Report correctionSenator Judge Aimee is recognized. You may proceed when you're ready, ma'am. You have two minutes.
Report correctionMaraming salamat. Para umabot tayo ng pitong oras tungkol sa banana chips, Presiding Officer po. Does the FDA ordinarily evaluate the manufacturing facilities, equipment, sanitation standards, quality control of an applicant seeking a manufacturer's license? Kasi sinabi ninyo kanina nage-evaluate talaga kayo bago magrehistro.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor, but I was asked to appear for the product registration. I mean, I mean...
Report correctionYes, but that's part and parcel of the FDA's due diligence, ika nga, bago magbigay ng registry, di ba?
Report correctionTapos in CALE 88's case, what evaluation or inspection did you undertake before issuing its license to operate?
Report correctionThe license, Your Honor, the license to operate is there are other offices in the FDA. It's not only the Center for Food Regulation and Research. The one handling the inspection is the Field Regulatory Operations Office.
Report correctionBut to the best of your knowledge, pumasa naman to sa FDA. Evaluation and Inspection.
Report correctionThat's right. Oo. So you were able to act on it rapidly upon approval of the inspecting group.
Report correctionAnd based on the FDA records, did Cali 88 identify a manufacturing facility where its products would be produced, in fact? Nag-identify sila ng address at lugar?
Report correctiontrabaho ninyo. Pero meron namang ganun. So, klaro kung saan sila magpaproduce ng banana chips na mahiwaga at iba pa. Okay, maraming salamat yun lang po.
Report correctionThank you, Senator Judge Aimee. There'll be another Senator Judge who registered to make interjections.
Report correctionMarilyn. Miss Marilyn, maraming salamat po sa inyong oras, panahon at pagsagot sa katanungan. Maswerte po kayo at maikli lang kayo.
Report correctionI will do the back read as soon as I get it, Attorney Justin.
Report correctioncalled, may I just ask that the lead defense counsel be recognized.
Report correctionSalamat po. Gayun din sa pagsagot sa tanong ng Senator Judge, kaugnay ng paglilitis na ito. Your excuse, ma'am.
Report correctionthe record, in response to the request of Attorney Justin, Mr.
Report correctionRobles, I already summarized, Your Honor. If allowed to testify, Your Honor, the witness will attest to the fact that Cali 88 applied for registration, in fact, applied for two certificates of registration, one for local manufacture, one for export. And that the application was supported by the appropriate requirements and they were eventually approved by the Food and Drug Administration. And they were issued the proper certificate of product registration. Atty. Mr. Gular. And that Cali88 complied with the requirements. Mr. Robles, the requirements. Yes.
Report correctionAnd then we proceed with the proceeding officer asking that the pictures be shown.
Report correctionYung bago nun ng manufacturing yun ang wala pa ako.
Report correctionThank you, Your Honor. That is all that we ask, Your Honor. Thank you. And we thank the court.
Report correctionThank you. Your next witness, Counsel or Attorney Sheila?
Report correctionBefore we call the next witness, we just ask that the lead...
Report correctionYes, Attorney Sheila, what is your pleasure, ma'am?
Report correctionThank you. Good afternoon, Your Honors. Before the court calls our next witness, Ms.
Report correctionYes, in lieu of Ms. Mendoza from CITEM. We'd like to inform the court that we will be dispensing with the presentation of this witness considering also the lateness of the hour and in the interest of time. And having heard what the court and
Report correctionThe senators and judges have expressed earlier on the information that they would rather see and hear from the witnesses of the defense. We will be presenting other witnesses when the hearings resume after the break.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. The witness from the FDA is our last witness.
Report correctionwon't hear any objection from me for sure or anyone from us, Attorney Sheila. Before we call it a day, I was informed, I'd like to inform the body of the successful, succeeding hearings rather. Given the adjustments that are being made in connection with the budget, subject to notice being given a day before if we will cancel. Again, because the budget deliberations are a moving target. And as you know, it is one of the most important pieces of legislation we should pass. But nevertheless, we are multitasking. And upon prior consultation with the Senate President, this will be our schedule for the next... For the next couple of weeks, hopefully until we adjourn. Again, unless notified a day before that we will be canceling it to give way to the budget, and unless we notify the parties a day before if we will be conducting a whole day hearing, we will revert to the original schedule of 10 to 3 p.m.
Report correctionAnd our next scheduled date will be November 26, 27, and then 1, 2, 3, 4, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, and until we adjourn on the 18th, depending on whether or not we still need it. Depending on how the trial will progress, meaning to say when the defendant, when the respondent will rest, if there will be any rebuttal evidence, if there will be any rebuttal evidence, and time to be given. For the formal offer, comment thereto and ruling of the impeachment court. So to repeat, we revert to the original schedule of 10 a.m. to 3 p.m.
Report correctionWe will adjourn and our next trial date will be on November 26 and 27. The following week, December 1, 2, 3, 4. Because November 30 is a holiday. December 7, 8, 9, 10, 11. 14, 15, 16, 17 as may be necessary. Again, without prejudice to notice being given a day before if you will cancel the trial to give way to the budget and if you will have a whole day session. Otherwise, it will only be from 10 to 3 or 10 to 2 as the case may be because we still have to rearrange the plenary. For the information and guidance of the parties concerned.
Report correctionDecember 2 is Pasay Day but we usually do not follow the local holiday but we follow the November 30 holiday so there will be no trial nor session on November 30. Yes, comment? Attorney Sheila?
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. We would like to be candid to the court and say that our next witnesses are not available on 26th and 27th also given that we were only informed today that there will be hearings for next week and as you know your honor this is not our only commitment so we have also already made some commitments in our other engagements but nonetheless we assure this court that we will not And in fact, we are not interested in a protracted, prolonged trial of this case. And as this court had seen, the defense has been prudent with the time of this court, has not abused this court, and has not wasted three months of time for presenting witnesses that will eventually be withdrawn.
Report correctionWell, it is not a conclusion. It is a fact. It's part of the record.
Report correctionHonorable Ridon, it's not a debate. Let Attorney Sheila finish and the court will give you the corresponding opportunity and make the corresponding ruling as well.
Report correctionWell, if... The Congressman Ridon would like again a readback of the day when they withdrew the witnesses. Would he prefer that I'm stating a fact? It was a factual statement. At any rate, to continue, our witnesses are not available on the 26th and 27th, but we are ready to resume on December 1, 2, 3, and 4. And we heard also this Court say that it’s reserving a hearing date on...
Report correctionAs may be necessary 16th and 17th, I think we will make sure that we will not again abuse the time of this court and finish the presentation of defense even prior to the additional date set by this court, Your Honor. But on the 26th and 27th, we ask for the indulgence of this court to allow us. Two just cancelled. Anyway, as per the pre-trial order, we ask for 30 days for the presentation of our witnesses. And the court can just deduct these two days from our time, Your Honor. Thank you.
Report correctionJust to note, counsel, the 30 days is for four articles. But just to clarify, the 30 days was for the four articles.
Report correctioncancel the 26th and the 27th given the fact that counsel, correspondent, and their witnesses are not, might not be, might not, are you already sure, Attorney Sheila?
Report correctionOkay. So we shall resume hearing where your witness will be available on December 1.
Report correctionAnd we shall have four trial dates in that week. One, two, three, and four.
Report correctionAnd as may be necessary, five trial dates on the following week.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. One, two, three, and four. But I just heard the presiding officer state earlier that it would be adding 14th, 16th, and 17th.
Report correctionThat may be for the court already, actually, Attorney Sheila.
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. At this point, we assure this court and the public, we will not be wasting any time.
Report correctionAnd I also make known before this court what I stated in an interview, that it is my hope that we can decide one way or the other on this matter, on this case before we adjourn as a Congress and before the year is over. Again, one way or the other. So that both as a country and a people, we can move forward accordingly, whatever the outcome of this trial may be, without impinging on, of course, the rights of the respondent. That's why we are allocating enough time. For the respondent as well as the prosecution, if ever they will still go to the process of rebuttal or surrebuttal evidence as the case may be. On the motion earlier made by the Honorable Ridon, with your indulgence, Attorney Sheila, let's just replace it with spent a lot of time in lieu of the word waste in the course of the past months.
Report correctionYour Honor. I'm sorry, December 8 is also a holiday, I was told just now, so that is the bill of our former Senate President, Senator Judge, former Senate President Sotto.
Report correctionthink it needs to be stated that the defense has already canceled the day previously, and they will cancel two more days. So I think a consequence needs to be placed on the defense. particularly lessening the days of presentation that they have. And as stated by the presiding officer, the 30 days that they're mentioning relates to four articles of impeachment. So I think it needs to be settled at this point what exactly are the specific number of days that they have to basically present their defense on unexplained wealth.
Report correctionI think Attorney Sheila already answered that in the previous hearing, counsel,
Report correctionShe gave a number of 8 to 10 and I think barring any unforeseen, the dates from the 1st to the 4th might be enough depending on how long the cross and the direct will be. And if you're looking at a tentative timeline for the information again of the parties, if that is finished on the week of the 4th, ending in the 4th, then the following week will be for offer. And the following week would be for preparation by the senator judges and or arguments of the parties before the court schedules a vote on the matter. If, again, there are no unforeseen circumstances such as rebuttals or rebuttal and similar procedures that are part of the rules of court.
Report correctionAs a final point, Your Honor, they mentioned that they wanted to cancel the Next two hearing dates and that presumes that they have information already as to who the witnesses will be who are basically unavailable for the next two hearing dates. Is it possible at this point for us to actually know who these specific witnesses are and how many actually are remaining witnesses for the defense at this point?
Report correctionBefore I respond to that last question, let me, if the court will allow me to respond to the 30-day comment or statement.
Report correctionAllow me, Attorney Sheila, so it's not to belabor the point. The court simply notes the manifestation of the Honorable Ridon on the dates and on the cancelled trial dates. It will take it in advisement and will not take it against any party. As this has been done also in the past by the prosecution and will not take it against the
Report correctionHonor, thank you. All I'm going to say is that I think for purposes of this entire trial and before this honorable court, both the prosecution and defense stand on equal footing. And so if under the law and under the rules, the prosecution... Retains the prerogative to direct the way that they will go with their presentation, then the same prerogative should be allowed the defense. And if we find it sufficient to just allot. One day for an article before the three other articles were withdrawn by the prosecution, then that is our prerogative. So I don't see how that 30-day comment matters here. But at any rate, Your Honor, with respect to the disclosure of the witnesses, yes, but we will comply with the five-day period before we disclose. The witnesses that we will present starting December 1, Your Honor. This is also consistent with what the prosecution had done and had extended to the defense in the past during their time of presentation.
Report correctionAttorney Sheila, to save on the court's time as well, can you submit for December 1 and sequentially at least two, depending on how long you think it will take, but at least two witnesses for sure. So that should be finished with one witness, we can proceed with the next. As long as you comply with the five-day notice rule sequentially for the December 1, 2, 3, and 4 hearings.
Report correctionfact, Your Honor, we plan to submit before December 1 the witnesses that we will be presenting for the week of December 1 to 4. So that would be more than five days.
Report correctionThere being no other matters to be taken up and given the manifestation of the lead counsel for the respondent that the witnesses are not available on November 26 and 27.
Report correctionAnd given the commitment of the lead counsel for the respondent that in compliance with the five-day notice rule and even more than that, in fact, they will submit. Their list of witnesses for the coming week of December 1 to 4. To afford the opportunity to the prosecution on the other side to prepare for these witnesses as well. And as the rule suggests too, any subpoena documents submitted to the court will automatically be reproduced by the court and furnished to the parties. Would that be okay?
Report correctionYes, Your Honor. Also, Your Honor, just one more matter. I forgot. We will also be asking for a schedule of the marking of the documents that were requested to be marked since yesterday.
Report correctionOf course, we will also ask the availability of the process.
Report correctionNext week. Anytime next week. I think we will have time.
Report correctionOkay. There being no other matters to be taken up, trial is adjourned. until December 1, 2026. That's a Tuesday at 10 o'clock in the morning.
Report correction