Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, defense witness, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, testified that CALE88 Foods Corporation was registered for banana-chip exports on December 9, 2021 and reported starting commercial operations on January 1, 2023. He said its BOI Form S-1 submissions reported direct labor of 115 in 2023, 201 in 2024 and 50 in 2025. BOI had no recorded cancellation of registration or suspension of incentives.
Session digest
November 20, 2026
A concise guide to the day’s testimony, arguments, rulings, evidence, and unresolved matters, with every item linked to the source video.
Source-linked digest
Read and verify
Click any timestamp to cue the embedded source video.
Witnesses and evidence
Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, defense witness and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, explained CALE88 Foods Corporation’s eligibility for an income-tax holiday, special corporate income tax, duty exemption and VAT zero rating. He clarified that the company had used VAT zero rating in 2024 and 2026, covering performance in 2023 and 2025, and had not availed itself of an income-tax holiday. He said losses in its first two operating years made that holiday meaningless.
Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, defense witness and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, said pandemic restrictions led BOI to conduct virtual inspections for applicants in 2021. BOI physically visited CALE88 Foods Corporation in 2026 after its good-standing application and a reported employment decline. He said the figure of 50 workers came from the company’s notarized report, rather than an inspection headcount; he had not personally visited the plant and relied on submitted reports and audited financial statements.
Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, defense witness and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, put CALE88 Foods Corporation’s reported sales for 2023–2025 at P208,748,899. Responding to Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian’s comparison with about P776 million in AMLC inflows, he said the BOI submissions supplied no explanation for receipts exceeding the declared sales. He put bank-certified remittances for the covered years at US$721,283 and said BOI lacked bank certificates covering 2024; the company had reported approximately P150 million in exports that year.
Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, defense witness and Director IV of the FDA Center for Food Regulation and Research, described CALE88 Foods Corporation’s initial registration denial, its revised labeling and the laboratory analysis supporting nutrition information. She said the revised label removed a claim about cardaba bananas and supplied complete nutrition facts supported by the test result. Prosecution counsel Atty. Reynaldo Robles stipulated that the company applied for two product registrations, for local manufacture and export, submitted the appropriate requirements and received the certificates.
Senator-judge interventions
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian asked defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, why CALE88 Foods Corporation’s ₱208 million in audited sales for 2022–2025 differed from roughly ₱776 million in AMLC inward remittances, even adding ₱20 million in shareholder advances, and whether sales were understated. Rodolfo could find no explanation in the operational documents submitted to BOI. On the much smaller bank-certified receipts, Rodolfo totaled $721,283, approximately ₱41.83 million at ₱58 per dollar, and said BOI lacked bank certificates for 2024, when reported export sales reached ₱150 million. Gatchalian questioned why a BOI-registered exporter would forgo VAT zero-rating and other incentives, invoking the importance of VAT relief under CREATE MORE; Rodolfo did not know why the company had not applied and said exporters generally maximize available incentives. Gatchalian also questioned reliance on self-declared applications and operational reports. Rodolfo said these could be checked against audited financial statements and, for VAT zero-rating applications, bank certificates. Asked about bills of lading or other proof that goods actually left the country, Rodolfo acknowledged BOI did not require those customs documents and pointed to Bureau of Customs and Philippine Statistics Authority records. Gatchalian proposed examining customs documentation to verify actual exports.
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero observed that CALE88 Foods Corporation was identified as a possible source of Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte’s funds and asked whether the defense was addressing allegations of a nonfunctioning business and payments without products or consideration; defense counsel Atty. Justin Nicol B. Gular agreed. Later, Escudero said an operating business could still be a source of unexplained or undeclared income, making proper declaration the question; prosecution counsel Atty. Erwin G. Matib maintained that his questioning concerned the company’s capacity to conduct business. During the FDA examination, Escudero asked whether prosecution counsel Atty. Reynaldo Robles conceded the existence of the photographed banana-chip product. Robles stipulated to submission of samples and compliance with registration requirements, followed by issuance of local-manufacture and export product registrations. Escudero distinguished product registration from quantities produced or sold and their cost; Gular agreed those quantities were outside the intended testimony. When Escudero asked for a sample, Gular said proper evidence would be presented through the proper witness. Escudero then requested the remaining product and packaging photographs. FDA witness Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director IV of the Center for Food Regulation and Research, confirmed that one displayed set related to the initially denied application.
Sen. Erwin Tulfo questioned remarks by Vice Presidential spokesperson Atty. Paolo Panelo that he described as discrediting senator-judges, suggested seeking an explanation or summoning him, and moved for a show-cause order. Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero identified Rule 71 on contempt as the applicable authority; the court approved the motion without objection. Turning to CALE88 Foods Corporation, Tulfo asked defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, whether BOI checked incorporators and directors, invoking Article VII, Section 13 and Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte’s connection through her husband. Rodolfo said BOI normally focused on sector restrictions such as foreign-equity limits. Tulfo challenged virtual inspections and warned that fraudulent businesses could use registration and false addresses to appear legitimate. Rodolfo said BOI registered strategic sectors, used virtual methods when necessary, and had resumed some physical inspections; he agreed to look into Tulfo’s concern. Tulfo also asked whether a company with ₱125,000 paid-up capital and two employees could generate over ₱700 million in sales within three to four years while exports were about ₱250 million. Rodolfo said BOI assessed a ₱12 million project plan and its proposed capacity, disclaimed involvement with the ₱700 million figure, and said he could not judge the growth Tulfo described.
Sen. Risa Hontiveros requested copies of the defense documents; Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero directed their provision. She asked defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, whether registration and annual reports assured lawful transactions. Rodolfo described BOI’s reliance on consistent notarized submissions, financial statements and triggered inspections. Asked about more than P770 million in AMLC-flagged inflows, he said BOI had not compared AMLC figures; 2023 bank certificates were slightly below reported exports, while BOI checked the 70% export requirement. He was uncertain whether a legitimate export contract could attract the suspicious-transaction flag she described. On micro/small-enterprise status, he explained delegated approval and a three-day processing target. In her second round, Hontiveros challenged whether CALE88’s facilities and workers could produce the reported 422,722 kilograms of banana chips in 2025, estimating raw-banana needs at 1.6–2 million kilograms and citing a 120-metric-ton annual capacity in the environmental non-coverage certificate. Rodolfo cited a projected capacity of about 1.18 million kilograms, but said he had not seen the factory and could not personally assess it. He suggested a conversion yielding 1.2 million kilograms; Hontiveros challenged that calculation. Returning to inflows, Rodolfo said BOI documents covered about P208 million and could not certify the transactions beyond that amount as above board.
Sen. Joel Villanueva questioned the contrast between CALE88 Foods Corporation’s GIS employment entries and BOI reports, the long gap between inspections, and checks on labor standards, regular employment and outsourced functions. Defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, said the 50-worker figure came from a notarized S1 report checked against the company’s financial statements, without a physical headcount. Rodolfo confirmed that the pre-registration inspection was virtual and there was no intervening inspection before 2026. A request for good-standing certification and a reported employment drop triggered that visit; BOI monitored the direct-labor commitment, which did not establish regular employment, and checked SSS records when enterprises sought income-tax holiday. Rodolfo identified a barangay operating certificate among the documents supporting the 2024 VAT zero-rating application. Villanueva also asked about China National Township Enterprise, which he described as linked to a Chinese state-owned group, and whether such counterparties required additional disclosure. Rodolfo said BOI’s ordinary requirements did not identify state ownership and he would need to check remittance certificates for the counterparty. Villanueva cited the forensic report’s approximately ₱193.95 million in remittances from China, including ₱19.28 million from that enterprise; Rodolfo put three-year S1 sales at ₱208,748,899 and said, if those remittance figures were correct, they would account for most sales. When recognized for a second round, Villanueva said defense counsel Atty. Michael Wesley Poa’s assurance about later witnesses satisfied him to wait until the next hearing.
Sen. Imee Marcos asked defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, about CALE88 Foods Corporation’s business-plan evaluation, commencement of operations and workforce. Rodolfo confirmed BOI evaluated the proposed project, recorded a January 1, 2023 operating start, and received reported employee counts of 115 in 2023, 201 in 2024 and 50 in 2025. Asked whether BOI records indicated fictitious or inflated operations, he said no; he declined to judge the “implausible business model” characterization but cited company reports and an inspection that found operations. Marcos attributed the workforce decline to banana-sector problems. In a later round, she asked why CALE88 had not sought an income-tax holiday. Rodolfo offered first- and second-year losses and third-year net income of ₱375,000 as a possible reason, and confirmed banana disease when Marcos raised Panama disease in Davao. Marcos then asked defense witness Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director IV of the FDA’s Center for Food Regulation and Research, about facility, equipment, sanitation and quality-control checks before licensing. Pagayunan confirmed that licensing involved evaluation and inspection, assigned inspections to the Field Regulatory Operations Office, and cited issuance of the license to operate. She also confirmed a manufacturing location was identified, while saying she had not brought that document.
Sen. Vicente C. Sotto III reviewed BOI incentives with defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head: income-tax holidays, subsequent lower income tax, export VAT zero-rating, import exemptions and local-tax treatment. Rodolfo said local treatment depended on the locality and explained the all-in 5% special corporate income tax option. Sotto challenged what he understood as earlier testimony that CALE88 Foods Corporation continuously benefited from incentives. Rodolfo said the company used VAT zero-rating for two years but had not availed of an income-tax holiday or duty-free importation. He explained that losses in its first two operating years made an income-tax holiday immaterial, and that it still had not availed in profitable 2025. When Sotto pressed whether no incentives had been given, Rodolfo’s answer specifically concerned the income-tax holiday. Asked about owners’ taxes, Rodolfo distinguished their personal income tax from the corporation’s holiday. Sotto also raised differences between General Information Sheets submitted to BOI and the SEC; Rodolfo said he was unaware of differences and that both agencies should receive the same information. Sotto urged stronger BOI diligence and research when granting incentives and challenged reliance on notarized submissions.
Sen. Paolo Benigno “Bam” Aquino asked defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, about CALE88 Foods Corporation’s registration, factory and product photographs, and incentives. Rodolfo affirmed proper registration and the photographs, and clarified that CALE88 had not applied for an income-tax holiday or duty-free importation, was not yet eligible for special corporate income tax, and had used VAT zero rating in 2024 and 2026 for raw-material purchases. Aquino compared roughly P208 million in BOI-reported sales with BIR submissions showing similar sales and losses. For 2025, Rodolfo cited P375,000 positive net income, while Aquino cited a P48,000 loss in the BIR submission; Rodolfo said profitability did not affect BOI status. Aquino questioned how about P700 million in AMLC inflows, including P315 million from China, could coexist with those declared sales. Rodolfo said other companies could have foreign-exchange or interest income, but CALE88 had declared no other income source to BOI; explaining the excess would be guessing. Asked who could explain, Rodolfo pointed to company officers and Dr. Lourdes Lebosada, former part-owner and treasurer who signed submissions, and suggested an operating officer or export-sales manager. Aquino proposed presenting the people involved to explain the money; the chair moved to the next senator without a response to that proposal.
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo asked defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, how BOI physically verified CALE88 Foods Corporation’s exports. Rodolfo said it did not conduct that monitoring and relied on notarized submissions and certifications such as bank remittance records. Tulfo criticized notarized documents’ reliability and proposed checking Bureau of Customs records. He then cited a 2024 operational report showing 423 employees and ₱33,793,135.35 payroll; Rodolfo said BOI’s direct-labor figure was 201 and would check the annual financial statements. Challenged on independent verification, Rodolfo cited the company’s submissions and audited financial statements. Tulfo proposed comparing employee counts against PhilHealth, Pag-IBIG and SSS records. Rodolfo said income-tax-holiday applications required an SSS certificate of good standing and a contribution master list. Tulfo suggested the company might have avoided applying to avoid producing those records, and asked about site inspections. Rodolfo described a mid-2026 visit triggered by a good-standing request that the company had not known would occur, but said he knew of no headcount. He agreed it was possible the company did not have 201 employees.
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson asked defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, how CALE88 Foods Corporation sustained operating expenses despite ₱125,000 paid-up capital and ₱8.05 million in losses over two years. Rodolfo recalled roughly ₱3.5 million in advances in the financial statements, agreeing with Lacson’s clarification that these came from shareholders. Lacson accepted the company’s BOI registration and compliance with registration requirements, but said inward remittances of hundreds of thousands of dollars raised concern that it might have been used for money laundering. He sought waybills, shipping records or comparable proof to address those doubts and rebut the forensic financial analysis. Defense counsel Atty. Michael Wesley Poa responded that the defense had witnesses for those matters and would make the necessary manifestation for the next trial date. Lacson said he was awaiting that evidence.
Prosecution position
Prosecution counsel Atty. Erwin G. Matib questioned the late notarization of CALE88 Foods Corporation’s commercial-start report and amended annual reports, discrepancies in employee figures, and the absence of labor-benefit records at BOI. Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, defense witness and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, said BOI relied on company submissions and had not performed the labor checks tied to an income-tax-holiday application. He also clarified that the ownership correspondence updated BOI records and noted the transfer, rather than approving it.
Prosecution counsel Atty. Reynaldo Robles stipulated that CALE88 Foods Corporation applied for two product registrations, submitted the required supporting material and received the registrations. He sought to question the supporting license to operate and whether FDA monitored business operations after issuance.
Public prosecutor Rep. Terry L. Ridon requested fewer defense presentation days as a consequence of canceled hearings and asked for the number and identities of remaining witnesses.
Defense position
Defense counsel Atty. Justin Nicol B. Gular offered the BOI and FDA witnesses to rebut Article II allegations and prosecution forensic witness Atty. Alexander B. Cabrera’s account of CALE88 Foods Corporation. He identified the disputed characterization as an implausible business model and said the defense also sought to answer the report’s assertion that CALE88 shareholder Atty. Manases R. Carpio received money from the corporation without consideration or products sold.
Defense counsel Atty. Justin Nicol B. Gular ended further direct examination of FDA witness Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director IV of the Center for Food Regulation and Research, in reliance on prosecution stipulations, then requested a transcript backread when the prosecution questioned compliance and supporting documents. He said he would seek to reconduct the direct if the stipulations were narrower than the defense had understood.
Lead defense counsel Atty. Sheila C. Sison dispensed with the planned CITEM witness, said other witnesses would be presented after the break, and requested cancellation of November 26–27 because witnesses and counsel were unavailable. She committed to provide the witness list for December 1–4 with more than five days’ notice.
Court rulings and directions
Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero reminded the parties that AMLC records admitted with the other exhibits were sealed under the court’s November 6 order and available only through supervised access for senator-judges, parties and authorized individuals.
On Sen. Erwin Tulfo’s motion, the court directed the Clerk of Court to issue a show-cause order to Vice Presidential spokesperson Atty. Paolo Panelo concerning his remarks the previous afternoon. Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero invoked the suppletory application of Rule 71 after explaining that Panelo was outside Rule 18 because he was neither counsel of record, a witness nor a party.
Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero allowed the defense to enumerate CALE88 Foods Corporation records for the record and directed that Sen. Risa Hontiveros and other requesting senator-judges receive copies. The parties stipulated to the BOI documents’ authenticity, existence and due execution, with the chair excluding the truth of their stated facts from that stipulation.
Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero allowed defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, to explain the 2021 facility photographs as part of BOI’s official records over the prosecution’s competency and hearsay objections.
Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero sustained the defense’s objection to a prosecution question linking Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte’s tree planting with CALE88 Foods Corporation’s compliance.
Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero sustained an asked-and-answered objection during the FDA cross-examination, stating that FDA witness Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director IV of the Center for Food Regulation and Research, could not testify to actual manufacture, sales or quantities produced or sold. At the defense’s request, the chair later read back the exchange recording the parties’ FDA application-and-compliance stipulations.
Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero canceled the November 26–27 hearings because defense counsel and witnesses were unavailable, set hearings to resume December 1, and asked the defense to arrange at least two sequential witnesses with five-day notice. The trial adjourned until December 1, 2026, at 10 a.m.
After public prosecutor Rep. Terry L. Ridon sought consequences for canceled defense hearing days, Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero took the manifestation under advisement and said the cancellations would not be taken against the respondent at that point.
Chronology
The defense presented Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, for direct examination, prosecution cross-examination, redirect and senator-judge questions before he was excused.
Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director IV of the FDA Center for Food Regulation and Research, followed as a defense witness. After her examination and questions, she was excused. Lead defense counsel Atty. Sheila C. Sison then dispensed with the planned CITEM witness and said other witnesses would be presented after the break.
Still unresolved
Defense counsel Atty. Michael Wesley Poa told Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson that the defense had witnesses to address the questions about CALE88 Foods Corporation’s remittances and shipping records, with a manifestation to follow for the next trial date. The defense presentation continued after the two agency witnesses were excused.