Working DraftImpeachment Trial of Vice President Sara Duterte
← Timed transcript

Session digest

November 19, 2026

A concise guide to the day’s testimony, arguments, rulings, evidence, and unresolved matters, with every item linked to the source video.

Source-linked digest

Read and verify

Click any timestamp to cue the embedded source video.

01

Witnesses and evidence

Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente, a certified public accountant, lawyer and former AMLC financial investigator, testified for the defense on anti-money-laundering standards and financial-analysis methods. Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno and senator-judges challenged the basis of his opinions because he had not reviewed the complete prosecution forensic report or its underlying case records. Dela Fuente cited confidentiality and his lack of authority to access the records, and described his answers as confined to displayed excerpts and hypothetical questions.

Dela Fuente described covered transaction reports (CTRs) and suspicious transaction reports (STRs) as indicators requiring verification, with bank inquiries supplying the underlying transaction records. He distinguished inflows from income, returned capital from earnings, and corporate receipts from shareholder income. On cross-examination, he agreed that a forensic accountant could use corporate-veil analysis in a professional report.

Dela Fuente agreed that the Cale88 patterns described during questioning were red flags warranting investigation. He identified contracts, invoices and shipment records as ways to verify claimed export payments, and said credible information about a foreign criminal investigation could justify enhanced due diligence and suspicious-transaction reporting.

Presiding Officer Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero announced receipt of Davao City Accountant Vingeline A. Bahan's mayoral and DILG travel-authority documents authorizing travel to Beijing and Shanghai from December 2 to 7, 2025, and directed that copies be furnished to the parties and senator-judges.

02

Chronology

03

Prosecution position

Diokno challenged the factual foundation of Dela Fuente's opinions, given his lack of review of Atty. Alexander B. Cabrera's complete report and underlying records. Diokno pressed the court-order exception to confidentiality and elicited agreement that sensitivity analysis is recognized in accounting and that corporate-veil analysis may be used in a professional report.

Diokno challenged treating outside professional earnings as legitimate income despite constitutional restrictions on the Vice President. At the close, Rep. Terry L. Ridon said the defense's divestment arguments belonged in a written memorandum or closing arguments and declined an oral response.

04

Defense position

Vinluan challenged the prosecution's sharing of AMLC material with a private analyst and questioned public disclosure and onward dissemination. He distinguished the House Committee on Justice's earlier receipt of documents from the impeachment court's authority, and sought latitude to test the AMLC material used for Article 2.

Vinluan challenged attribution of corporate revenue, estimated franchise capital and insurance value to Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte, as well as desktop research, receipts and calculations in the forensic report. He defended presenting selected excerpts to Dela Fuente in open court. On redirect, Dela Fuente distinguished analytical corporate-veil work from judicial action.

05

Senator-judge interventions

Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian contrasted ₱2.7 billion in bank transactions during 2009–2013 with the much smaller BIR income figures presented for Duterte, and asked whether the discrepancy warranted investigation, a freeze-order application or a red-flag assessment. He also asked what additional records were needed, raised bank amounts outside the SALNs, and asked whether the discrepancy was an impeachable offense. Defense witness and former AMLC financial investigator Dela Fuente said the figures merited further investigation and the normal freeze-order and bank-inquiry processes. He explained that covered persons flag suspicious activity and that investigators need source bank records to trace the money beyond CTR and STR snapshots; he deferred the question of impeachability to the impeachment court.

Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano urged greater latitude for the defense to answer AMLC and bank-record evidence already presented, arguing that the proceeding's political and reputational consequences made a rebuttal important to public acceptance of the judgment. He accepted that money laundering was not a separate charge, but asked for less technical treatment of the distinction between AMLA violations, predicate crimes and unexplained wealth, while accepting the instruction to make the point and move on. Presiding Officer Escudero reiterated that counsel could challenge the AMLC evidence supporting Article 2 and identified the formal offer, a tender of excluded evidence and closing arguments as later opportunities to address withdrawn articles.

Sen. Erwin Tulfo questioned the relevance of archival impeachment footage; Presiding Officer Escudero agreed and directed counsel to move on. Later, Tulfo challenged the usefulness of testimony without reviewed case records; Vinluan acknowledged his manifestation. Tulfo pressed Dela Fuente about Article VII, Section 13 business restrictions and an SEC/SALN discrepancy he described. Dela Fuente gave his personal interpretation that business ownership was prohibited, urged neutral investigation of the records and left the constitutional-violation question to the court. Finally, Tulfo questioned the witness's short stays in government jobs. Dela Fuente explained his moves through law-school demands, a coterminous appointment and family/private-practice choices, and said he maintained good relations with former colleagues.

Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson questioned the relevance of an archival opinion from an earlier impeachment trial; Presiding Officer Escudero agreed and directed counsel to move on. Later, Lacson asked Dela Fuente about the legislative history of AMLA Section 16 and received the reply that he was not familiar with it. Lacson argued that its political-harassment protection addressed election candidates and contributors, rather than providing a general protection in impeachment proceedings.

In an early manifestation, Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan said challenges to the prior disclosure ruling belonged before the Supreme Court and supported limited further questioning. He tested Dela Fuente’s claimed political nonaffiliation through former partner Atty. Edward Gialogo’s alleged political connections; Dela Fuente disclaimed personal knowledge and could not recall whether he voted in 2016. Pangilinan contrasted the difficulty of preparing a report in two weeks with immediate criticism of excerpts and questioned the value of opinions without the facts; Dela Fuente said he addressed limited hypotheticals and AML standards. Returning to confidentiality, Pangilinan asked how the court could receive evidence through witnesses under the end-user theory. Dela Fuente denied accusing the court of violating the law and agreed that court-authorized or compelled review would be legal, while maintaining AMLC’s processing role.

Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo questioned the relevance of confidentiality testimony given the bank-secrecy exception for impeachment, asked about freeze-order procedures, and said former Chief Justice Renato Corona had still been impeached for not telling the truth in his SALN. Defense witness and former AMLC financial investigator Dela Fuente described investigation followed by an ex parte application with prior AMLC council authority or approval. Tulfo challenged the breadth of Dela Fuente's testimony and his ability to counter prosecution witness Cabrera's report without having studied the full document. Tulfo also questioned the witness's AMLC rank, promotion history, completed cases and role as lead investigator or team signatory, and warned that contrary evidence could expose him to contempt. Dela Fuente said he had declined a promotion as he was leaving, had participated in approximately 80–90 cases and led some investigations, and stood by his account. He distinguished limited answers based on displayed portions and hypothetical questions from a full analysis, which would take time. Presiding Officer Escudero reminded counsel that the witness was not a constitutional-law expert and directed them to wind up that line or move on.

Sen. Pia S. Cayetano clarified that the impeachment exception cited by Raffy Tulfo appears in the bank secrecy law, rather than the Anti-Money Laundering Act. Tulfo replied that the laws were related before returning to his questions about investigative procedure.

In a manifestation, Sen. Risa Hontiveros criticized the fairness of videos whose speakers were deceased or absent and could not be questioned. She later challenged Dela Fuente’s criticism without reading the full report or underlying records; he invoked confidentiality, defended comparing displayed passages with the law and affirmed respect for Cabrera’s qualifications. In her later round, Hontiveros examined Dela Fuente’s Cagayan Economic Zone Authority consultancy, casino-sector training and POGO or online-gambling clients. He described compliance and cooperation with investigations rather than evasion, acknowledged covered-person clients and said he could not determine criminality in the case from private practice. Hontiveros pressed Cale88’s 757 transaction reports totaling about P1.25 billion and comparisons with his past cases; he estimated roughly 30% had more reports and said large corporate volumes can be normal. She cited reported losses, two employees, P208 million sales versus P776 million inflows, P319 million from China and year-end balances below P400,000. He agreed these were red flags warranting scrutiny, while distinguishing them from direct evidence of wrongdoing.

Sen. Joel Villanueva questioned the breadth of Dela Fuente's testimony and his lack of prior review of the forensic report, accepting leeway but opposing unlimited scope. Vinluan said selected excerpts were being presented in court. Villanueva then tested explanations for payments exceeding recorded capital and the verification of export receipts. Dela Fuente said the payments merited scrutiny, offered dividends or compensation as possibilities to test, and identified contracts, invoices and shipment records for verification; he also said an owner could work as an employee. Villanueva's follow-up asking whether the compensation would be income received no separate witness answer before he moved on. On foreign remittances, Villanueva asked what checks banks should perform and whether foreign criminal-investigation information could justify action without a conviction. Dela Fuente called for documentary support, agreed that credible information could justify enhanced due diligence and suspicious-transaction reports, and described risk-based account closure.

Sen. Paolo Benigno “Bam” Aquino asked whether Dela Fuente had received case documents before appearing, including the subpoenaed bank statements, insurance placements and corporate information sheets; he answered that none had been shown to him. Vinluan said the defense was confronting the witness in court with selected portions of the 50-page forensic report and asking about concepts. Aquino called for direct answers about specific matters, rather than repeated replies that a witness did not know or had not read the documents.

Sen. Imee Marcos invoked Lady Justice’s blindfold to argue for equal legal treatment without relying on personalities or requiring every document to be read. In her later round, she asked about financial-intelligence reports, media sources, retrospective suspicious-transaction flags and aggregate bank flows. Dela Fuente said intelligence reports have weight as clues leading to evidence and described news reports as second-hand information. Marcos questioned linking 2019 insurance transactions to later flood-control reporting; he said banks can revisit old records when new information emerges and that a suspicious flag triggers checking rather than automatic freezing or a finding of criminality. Asked whether P4.4 billion in inflows, outflows and repeated rollovers represented accumulated wealth, he said a full financial investigation was needed and agreed that simply adding all money entering and leaving accounts was insufficient.

Sen. Camille Villar urged giving defense witness Dela Fuente time to present his opinions, arguing that universal accounting principles could be discussed without seeing the specific records. She compared his treatment with the hearing of prosecution witness Cabrera, whose report she said included internet research and assertions with limited factual support.

Sen. Vicente C. Sotto III asked when Dela Fuente wrote his AML handbook and what work he was doing in January 2021. Dela Fuente said the handbook was published in July 2025 after work begun in 2024, that he had served in the AMLC from 2015 to 2018, and that he was a private-law-firm partner in January 2021. Sotto pointed out that the law was amended in January 2021, after the witness had left the agency.

06

Court rulings and directions

Presiding Officer Escudero clarified that Article 2 concerned unexplained or ill-gotten wealth rather than a separate AMLA offense, while allowing the defense to challenge the AMLC evidence supporting the charge. He permitted limited confidentiality questions and noted the prosecution's continuing objection. He identified the formal offer, a tender of excluded evidence and closing arguments as opportunities to address withdrawn articles.

Presiding Officer Escudero directed the Clerk of Court Atty. Renato N. Bantug Jr. to have inappropriate flame transitions removed or edited from the court recording and asked PRIB to be more careful with presentation effects.

07

Notable quotations

Dela Fuente: "CTRs and STRs po, they are not the actual proof. They are indicators."

Dela Fuente: "I'm not discounting the entire report, just the portion shown to me."

08

Still unresolved

Presiding Officer Escudero set further defense testimony for November 20, 2026 at 10 a.m. The scheduled witnesses were Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan and CITEM representative Atty. Eva Marie Mariquina, replacing Rowena G. Mendoza. He directed that both parties receive their subpoenaed documents. Responding to Lacson's scheduling question, Sison clarified that these were the last witnesses for that week. Later hearing dates were to be announced at the next sitting.