# Audio overview — November 20, 2026

BOI and FDA officials testify on CALE88 Foods Corporation as senator-judges press financial, export and staffing questions; the trial resumes December 1.

## Introduction

This is Working Draft's audio overview of the Impeachment Trial of Vice President Sara Duterte for November 20, 2026. This is a working reference, not an official Senate record.

## Agency records and financial questions

The defense called two regulatory officials about CALE88 Foods Corporation and its banana-chip business. Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, Department of Trade and Industry Undersecretary and Board of Investments Vice Chairman and Managing Head, described registration, incentives and company reports. Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director IV of the Food and Drug Administration's Center for Food Regulation and Research, explained product approvals. Senator-judges pressed the gap between reported sales and bank inflows, disputed staffing figures, and proof of exports. Defense counsel Attorney Michael Wesley Poa said further witnesses would address financial and shipping questions. Both agency witnesses were excused, and the defense presentation continued.

- [00:19:31 · S00063](../?t=1171.98#S00063)
- [03:29:16 · S00634](../?t=12556.7#S00634)
- [03:29:18 · S00635](../?t=12558.880000000001#S00635)
- [04:29:19 · S01102](../?t=16159.3#S01102)
- [04:35:32 · S01142](../?t=16532.18#S01142)
- [05:40:54 · S01546](../?t=20454.03#S01546)
- [05:42:11 · S01560](../?t=20531.67#S01560)
- [05:42:25 · S01561](../?t=20545.79#S01561)
- [06:33:38 · S04135](../?t=23618.7#S04135)
- [06:35:28 · S01882](../?t=23728.07#S01882)
- [06:35:46 · S01883](../?t=23746.73#S01883)
- [04:45:03 · S01185](../?t=17103.63#S01185)
- [05:08:39 · S01320](../?t=18519.19#S01320)
- [05:10:01 · S01327](../?t=18601.32#S01327)
- [05:11:32 · S01331](../?t=18692.82#S01331)
- [05:12:33 · S01339](../?t=18753.26#S01339)
- [05:31:43 · S04509](../?t=19903.99#S04509)
- [05:32:24 · S01483](../?t=19944.61#S01483)
- [05:33:01 · S01485](../?t=19981.34#S01485)
- [05:33:17 · S01492](../?t=19997.4#S01492)

## What the defense sought to answer

Defense counsel Attorney Justin Nicol B. Gular offered the regulatory evidence to answer Article Two allegations and prosecution forensic witness Attorney Alexander B. Cabrera's characterization of CALE88 Foods Corporation as an implausible business model. He also sought to answer the assertion that shareholder Attorney Manases R. Carpio received company money without consideration or products sold. Presiding Officer Senator Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero later observed that an operating company could still supply unexplained or undeclared income; proper declaration remained the question. Prosecution counsel Attorney Erwin G. Matib said his examination concerned the company's capacity to conduct business.

- [00:19:31 · S00063](../?t=1171.98#S00063)
- [00:51:21 · S02119](../?t=3081.73#S02119)
- [00:51:45 · S02121](../?t=3105.6099999999997#S02121)
- [00:51:59 · S02122](../?t=3119.1#S02122)
- [00:52:02 · S02123](../?t=3122.3199999999997#S02123)
- [05:43:20 · S01577](../?t=20600.0#S01577)
- [00:50:12 · S00162](../?t=3012.119#S00162)
- [00:50:56 · S00163](../?t=3056.38#S00163)
- [04:24:13 · S01050](../?t=15853.34#S01050)
- [04:24:51 · S01054](../?t=15891.24#S01054)
- [04:25:22 · S01058](../?t=15922.130000000001#S01058)
- [06:07:27 · S04091](../?t=22047.52#S04091)
- [06:07:54 · S01678](../?t=22074.74#S01678)
- [06:08:04 · S01680](../?t=22084.66#S01680)
- [06:08:32 · S01683](../?t=22112.41#S01683)
- [06:09:42 · S01695](../?t=22182.2#S01695)
- [06:10:09 · S01700](../?t=22209.95#S01700)
- [06:11:04 · S01708](../?t=22264.81#S01708)
- [06:12:00 · S01711](../?t=22320.66#S01711)
- [06:13:25 · S04103](../?t=22405.18#S04103)
- [06:13:30 · S01731](../?t=22410.06#S01731)

## Registration and incentives

Defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, said CALE88 Foods Corporation registered for banana-chip exports in December twenty twenty-one and reported starting commercial operations in January twenty twenty-three. Its reports listed direct labor of one hundred fifteen, two hundred one, and fifty across twenty twenty-three through twenty twenty-five. BOI had no recorded cancellation of registration or suspension of incentives. Senator Imee Marcos asked whether agency records indicated fictitious or inflated operations. Rodolfo said no, citing reports and an inspection that found operations. He described VAT zero rating used in twenty twenty-four and twenty twenty-six, covering performance in twenty twenty-three and twenty twenty-five. The company had not used an income-tax holiday. In a later round, Marcos raised banana-sector problems and Panama disease. Rodolfo confirmed the disease and offered early losses and third-year net income of three hundred seventy-five thousand pesos as a possible explanation for not seeking the holiday.

- [01:07:18 · S00227](../?t=4038.57#S00227)
- [01:27:03 · S00325](../?t=5223.73#S00325)
- [04:48:04 · S01199](../?t=17284.03#S01199)
- [03:28:46 · S00631](../?t=12526.89#S00631)
- [03:29:10 · S00633](../?t=12550.380000000001#S00633)
- [00:55:38 · S00186](../?t=3338.2799999999997#S00186)
- [03:48:32 · S00769](../?t=13712.18#S00769)
- [04:59:13 · S01273](../?t=17953.03#S01273)
- [05:00:04 · S01278](../?t=18004.58#S01278)
- [05:19:26 · S01385](../?t=19166.86#S01385)
- [04:46:04 · S03066](../?t=17164.26#S03066)
- [04:46:08 · S01190](../?t=17168.84#S01190)
- [04:46:41 · S01191](../?t=17201.83#S01191)
- [04:47:16 · S01195](../?t=17236.61#S01195)
- [04:48:18 · S01200](../?t=17298.89#S01200)
- [04:48:39 · S01202](../?t=17319.63#S01202)
- [04:48:58 · S01204](../?t=17338.69#S01204)
- [04:49:13 · S01206](../?t=17353.33#S01206)
- [04:49:40 · S01210](../?t=17380.13#S01210)
- [04:50:00 · S01212](../?t=17400.27#S01212)
- [05:39:44 · S01538](../?t=20384.55#S01538)
- [05:39:52 · S01539](../?t=20392.49#S01539)
- [05:40:06 · S01540](../?t=20406.81#S01540)
- [05:40:23 · S04068](../?t=20423.85#S04068)
- [05:40:42 · S04069](../?t=20442.75#S04069)
- [06:31:01 · S01844](../?t=23461.59#S01844)
- [06:31:05 · S01845](../?t=23465.15#S01845)
- [06:31:44 · S01848](../?t=23504.05#S01848)
- [06:31:55 · S01850](../?t=23515.19#S01850)
- [06:32:15 · S01852](../?t=23535.81#S01852)
- [06:32:27 · S04131](../?t=23547.11#S04131)
- [06:32:40 · S01854](../?t=23560.72#S01854)

## Checks behind the paperwork

Prosecution counsel Attorney Erwin G. Matib challenged late notarization, amended reports, conflicting employment figures and missing labor-benefit records. Defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, said BOI relied on company submissions and had not conducted the labor checks associated with an income-tax-holiday application. He clarified that ownership correspondence noted a transfer and updated records, rather than approving it. Senator Erwin Tulfo questioned checks on incorporators and directors, invoking constitutional restrictions and Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte's connection through her husband. Tulfo also challenged virtual inspections and the business growth he described. Rodolfo said pandemic restrictions required virtual inspections in twenty twenty-one and BOI had resumed physical visits. He said BOI evaluated a twelve-million-peso project plan and its proposed capacity; he could not judge the growth Tulfo outlined.

- [03:35:34 · S00681](../?t=12934.32#S00681)
- [03:35:57 · S00687](../?t=12957.75#S00687)
- [03:40:09 · S00719](../?t=13209.78#S00719)
- [03:40:53 · S03005](../?t=13253.73#S03005)
- [03:41:03 · S00726](../?t=13263.7#S00726)
- [03:58:15 · S00860](../?t=14295.93#S00860)
- [03:47:40 · S00768](../?t=13660.85#S00768)
- [03:49:08 · S00773](../?t=13748.54#S00773)
- [03:49:27 · S03014](../?t=13767.34#S03014)
- [04:05:07 · S00905](../?t=14707.93#S00905)
- [04:05:52 · S00911](../?t=14752.7#S00911)
- [00:15:44 · S00042](../?t=944.17#S00042)
- [00:16:06 · S00044](../?t=966.14#S00044)
- [00:17:02 · S00048](../?t=1022.62#S00048)
- [00:17:48 · S00049](../?t=1068.9#S00049)
- [00:18:46 · S00053](../?t=1126.89#S00053)
- [00:19:00 · S00058](../?t=1140.67#S00058)
- [00:19:07 · S00059](../?t=1147.03#S00059)
- [05:02:38 · S01297](../?t=18158.96#S01297)
- [05:02:47 · S01298](../?t=18167.77#S01298)
- [05:03:05 · S01299](../?t=18185.6#S01299)
- [05:03:26 · S01300](../?t=18206.6#S01300)
- [05:03:41 · S01301](../?t=18221.1#S01301)
- [05:03:59 · S01302](../?t=18239.02#S01302)
- [05:04:13 · S01303](../?t=18253.48#S01303)
- [05:05:01 · S01304](../?t=18301.82#S01304)
- [05:05:26 · S01305](../?t=18326.66#S01305)
- [05:06:13 · S01306](../?t=18373.79#S01306)
- [05:06:14 · S01307](../?t=18374.37#S01307)
- [05:06:55 · S01308](../?t=18415.56#S01308)
- [05:07:27 · S01310](../?t=18447.77#S01310)
- [05:07:56 · S01314](../?t=18476.18#S01314)
- [04:29:56 · S01106](../?t=16196.35#S01106)
- [04:30:14 · S03061](../?t=16214.46#S03061)
- [04:30:40 · S01110](../?t=16240.6#S01110)
- [04:37:36 · S01149](../?t=16656.09#S01149)
- [04:36:30 · S01146](../?t=16590.53#S01146)
- [03:43:54 · S00746](../?t=13434.49#S00746)
- [03:44:24 · S00752](../?t=13464.69#S00752)
- [03:44:36 · S00754](../?t=13476.59#S00754)

## Workers and physical verification

Senator Joel Villanueva questioned CALE88 Foods Corporation's inconsistent employment entries, labor standards and inspection gap. Defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, said the fifty-worker figure came from a notarized report checked against financial statements, without a physical headcount. The pre-registration inspection was virtual; a good-standing request and reported employment decline triggered the next inspection in twenty twenty-six. Villanueva also asked about Chinese counterparties and remittances; Rodolfo said BOI's ordinary requirements did not identify state ownership. Villanueva cited approximately one hundred ninety-four million pesos in Chinese remittances. Rodolfo said that, if correct, those receipts represented most of the roughly two hundred nine million pesos in three-year sales reported to BOI. Senator Raffy T. Tulfo separately cited a report listing four hundred twenty-three employees against BOI's direct-labor figure of two hundred one. He also asked how BOI verified exports. Rodolfo said it had no such monitoring and relied on notarized submissions and bank certifications. Tulfo proposed checking Bureau of Customs records. He proposed checking PhilHealth, Pag-IBIG and SSS records. Rodolfo said income-tax-holiday applications required SSS documentation and agreed it was possible the company did not have two hundred one employees.

- [04:35:32 · S01142](../?t=16532.18#S01142)
- [04:35:55 · S01145](../?t=16555.22#S01145)
- [04:36:30 · S01146](../?t=16590.53#S01146)
- [04:37:00 · S01147](../?t=16620.39#S01147)
- [04:37:36 · S01149](../?t=16656.09#S01149)
- [04:38:10 · S01150](../?t=16690.62#S01150)
- [04:38:46 · S01154](../?t=16726.05#S01154)
- [04:39:31 · S01155](../?t=16771.8#S01155)
- [04:39:46 · S03049](../?t=16786.49#S03049)
- [04:39:50 · S03050](../?t=16790.01#S03050)
- [04:40:15 · S01156](../?t=16815.26#S01156)
- [04:40:36 · S01157](../?t=16836.0#S01157)
- [04:40:38 · S03051](../?t=16838.56#S03051)
- [04:40:49 · S03063](../?t=16849.96#S03063)
- [04:40:50 · S03064](../?t=16850.48#S03064)
- [04:40:54 · S01158](../?t=16854.09#S01158)
- [04:40:57 · S01159](../?t=16857.29#S01159)
- [04:41:22 · S01160](../?t=16882.81#S01160)
- [04:42:55 · S01173](../?t=16975.77#S01173)
- [04:43:15 · S01174](../?t=16995.94#S01174)
- [04:43:48 · S01176](../?t=17028.55#S01176)
- [04:44:21 · S01179](../?t=17061.78#S01179)
- [04:44:23 · S01180](../?t=17063.92#S01180)
- [04:45:03 · S01185](../?t=17103.63#S01185)
- [04:45:35 · S01189](../?t=17135.63#S01189)
- [05:25:18 · S01424](../?t=19518.79#S01424)
- [05:25:38 · S01425](../?t=19538.92#S01425)
- [05:26:06 · S01429](../?t=19566.98#S01429)
- [05:26:12 · S01434](../?t=19572.4#S01434)
- [05:26:22 · S01435](../?t=19582.38#S01435)
- [05:26:41 · S01436](../?t=19601.09#S01436)
- [05:27:26 · S01439](../?t=19646.28#S01439)
- [05:27:45 · S01440](../?t=19665.81#S01440)
- [05:27:53 · S04052](../?t=19673.17#S04052)
- [05:28:06 · S04054](../?t=19686.52#S04054)
- [05:28:20 · S01453](../?t=19700.46#S01453)
- [05:28:24 · S01458](../?t=19704.94#S01458)
- [05:28:36 · S01459](../?t=19716.59#S01459)
- [05:28:50 · S01460](../?t=19730.91#S01460)
- [05:29:10 · S01461](../?t=19750.27#S01461)
- [05:29:30 · S01462](../?t=19770.83#S01462)
- [05:29:44 · S01466](../?t=19784.72#S01466)
- [05:30:00 · S04056](../?t=19800.84#S04056)
- [05:30:00 · S01469](../?t=19800.98#S01469)
- [05:30:05 · S01472](../?t=19805.1#S01472)
- [05:30:12 · S01473](../?t=19812.07#S01473)
- [05:33:01 · S01485](../?t=19981.34#S01485)
- [05:33:17 · S01492](../?t=19997.4#S01492)
- [05:33:33 · S01497](../?t=20013.92#S01497)
- [05:33:41 · S01499](../?t=20021.65#S01499)

## Sales, bank receipts and export proof

Senator Sherwin T. Gatchalian compared roughly seven hundred seventy-six million pesos in Anti-Money Laundering Council inflows with about two hundred eight million pesos in reported sales, asking whether sales were understated. Defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, found no explanation in the operational documents submitted to BOI. Bank-certified remittances totaled about seven hundred twenty-one thousand US dollars. BOI lacked bank certificates for twenty twenty-four, when reported exports were approximately one hundred fifty million pesos. Gatchalian questioned why an exporter would forgo incentives and how BOI checked self-declarations. Rodolfo cited financial statements and bank certificates, but said BOI did not require bills of lading. Gatchalian proposed customs records to verify actual exports.

- [05:08:04 · S04001](../?t=18484.44#S04001)
- [05:08:20 · S01318](../?t=18500.34#S01318)
- [05:09:36 · S01326](../?t=18576.01#S01326)
- [05:10:01 · S01327](../?t=18601.32#S01327)
- [05:10:28 · S01328](../?t=18628.21#S01328)
- [05:11:32 · S01331](../?t=18692.82#S01331)
- [05:11:51 · S01335](../?t=18711.9#S01335)
- [05:12:33 · S01339](../?t=18753.26#S01339)
- [05:12:59 · S01340](../?t=18779.34#S01340)
- [05:14:37 · S01344](../?t=18877.11#S01344)
- [05:14:39 · S01345](../?t=18879.63#S01345)
- [05:15:05 · S01346](../?t=18905.88#S01346)
- [05:15:15 · S01347](../?t=18915.9#S01347)
- [05:16:03 · S01350](../?t=18963.9#S01350)
- [05:16:24 · S01352](../?t=18984.72#S01352)
- [05:16:32 · S01354](../?t=18992.45#S01354)
- [05:16:48 · S01355](../?t=19008.15#S01355)
- [05:17:03 · S01356](../?t=19023.25#S01356)
- [05:17:18 · S01361](../?t=19038.37#S01361)
- [04:45:03 · S01185](../?t=17103.63#S01185)
- [05:08:39 · S01320](../?t=18519.19#S01320)

## Capacity and unexplained inflows

Senator Risa Hontiveros asked whether CALE88 Foods Corporation's registration and reports assured lawful transactions. Defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, described checks using notarized submissions, financial statements and triggered inspections. He said BOI had not compared the AMLC inflows. In a second round, Hontiveros questioned whether facilities and workers could produce the reported four hundred twenty-two thousand seven hundred twenty-two kilograms of banana chips in twenty twenty-five, citing a much smaller capacity in an environmental certificate. Rodolfo cited a larger projected capacity, but had not personally seen the factory. Hontiveros challenged his conversion calculation. Returning to the money, Rodolfo said BOI documents covered about two hundred eight million pesos; he could not certify transactions beyond that amount as above board.

- [00:49:51 · S00159](../?t=2991.45#S00159)
- [00:49:57 · S00160](../?t=2997.7200000000003#S00160)
- [00:50:12 · S00162](../?t=3012.119#S00162)
- [04:50:04 · S01214](../?t=17404.41#S01214)
- [04:50:23 · S01218](../?t=17423.86#S01218)
- [04:50:38 · S01219](../?t=17438.07#S01219)
- [04:51:06 · S01221](../?t=17466.81#S01221)
- [04:51:31 · S01229](../?t=17491.51#S01229)
- [04:51:57 · S01230](../?t=17517.2#S01230)
- [04:52:26 · S01231](../?t=17546.54#S01231)
- [04:54:04 · S01238](../?t=17644.97#S01238)
- [04:54:30 · S01241](../?t=17670.4#S01241)
- [04:55:08 · S01246](../?t=17708.07#S01246)
- [04:55:26 · S03053](../?t=17726.43#S03053)
- [04:55:44 · S01248](../?t=17744.04#S01248)
- [04:56:01 · S01249](../?t=17761.42#S01249)
- [05:33:53 · S01501](../?t=20033.75#S01501)
- [05:34:19 · S01505](../?t=20059.79#S01505)
- [05:35:17 · S01506](../?t=20117.2#S01506)
- [05:35:48 · S01510](../?t=20148.67#S01510)
- [05:36:36 · S01514](../?t=20196.58#S01514)
- [05:36:43 · S01515](../?t=20203.2#S01515)
- [05:37:29 · S01518](../?t=20249.48#S01518)
- [05:37:39 · S01519](../?t=20259.87#S01519)
- [05:38:25 · S01522](../?t=20305.73#S01522)
- [05:38:39 · S01524](../?t=20319.63#S01524)
- [05:39:03 · S01528](../?t=20343.88#S01528)
- [05:39:33 · S01535](../?t=20373.17#S01535)

## Tax treatment and competing accounts

Senator Vicente C. Sotto III questioned whether CALE88 Foods Corporation had continuously benefited from incentives. Defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, distinguished its two years of VAT zero rating from the unused income-tax holiday and duty-free importation. Losses made an income-tax holiday immaterial in the first two operating years. Sotto urged stronger diligence and questioned differing General Information Sheets submitted to BOI and the SEC. Rodolfo said he was unaware of differences and both agencies should receive the same information. Senator Paolo Benigno "Bam" Aquino compared BOI and BIR sales and losses, including differing twenty twenty-five profit figures. Rodolfo said profitability did not affect BOI status. Asked about inflows far exceeding sales, he said CALE88 had declared no other income source to BOI and explaining the excess would be guessing. He pointed to company officers and former part-owner and treasurer Dr. Lourdes Lebosada as possible sources of explanation. Aquino proposed calling the people involved; the chair moved to the next senator.

- [04:56:31 · S01251](../?t=17791.63#S01251)
- [04:57:31 · S01256](../?t=17851.72#S01256)
- [04:58:18 · S01271](../?t=17898.48#S01271)
- [04:58:46 · S01272](../?t=17926.14#S01272)
- [04:59:13 · S01273](../?t=17953.03#S01273)
- [05:00:04 · S01278](../?t=18004.58#S01278)
- [05:00:40 · S01279](../?t=18040.08#S01279)
- [05:01:06 · S01282](../?t=18066.87#S01282)
- [05:01:17 · S01287](../?t=18077.52#S01287)
- [05:01:34 · S01290](../?t=18094.25#S01290)
- [05:01:40 · S01292](../?t=18100.01#S01292)
- [05:01:47 · S01293](../?t=18107.54#S01293)
- [05:02:08 · S01295](../?t=18128.2#S01295)
- [03:48:32 · S00769](../?t=13712.18#S00769)
- [05:17:42 · S01365](../?t=19062.16#S01365)
- [05:17:52 · S01366](../?t=19072.34#S01366)
- [05:18:10 · S01367](../?t=19090.53#S01367)
- [05:18:13 · S04010](../?t=19093.81#S04010)
- [05:18:15 · S04011](../?t=19095.31#S04011)
- [05:18:15 · S04012](../?t=19095.79#S04012)
- [05:18:19 · S04013](../?t=19099.13#S04013)
- [05:18:19 · S04014](../?t=19099.61#S04014)
- [05:18:21 · S04015](../?t=19101.91#S04015)
- [05:18:45 · S04020](../?t=19125.44#S04020)
- [05:19:08 · S01382](../?t=19148.9#S01382)
- [05:19:26 · S01385](../?t=19166.86#S01385)
- [05:19:36 · S01386](../?t=19176.98#S01386)
- [05:19:42 · S01387](../?t=19182.58#S01387)
- [05:19:43 · S04027](../?t=19183.82#S04027)
- [05:19:52 · S01389](../?t=19192.7#S01389)
- [05:20:15 · S01392](../?t=19215.48#S01392)
- [05:20:27 · S01393](../?t=19227.7#S01393)
- [05:20:33 · S01394](../?t=19233.59#S01394)
- [05:20:48 · S04030](../?t=19248.46#S04030)
- [05:20:58 · S04033](../?t=19258.74#S04033)
- [05:22:15 · S04035](../?t=19335.09#S04035)
- [05:23:09 · S01406](../?t=19389.97#S01406)
- [05:23:33 · S01411](../?t=19413.58#S01411)
- [05:24:05 · S04042](../?t=19445.44#S04042)
- [05:24:18 · S04045](../?t=19458.72#S04045)
- [05:24:20 · S04046](../?t=19460.56#S04046)
- [05:24:23 · S04047](../?t=19463.34#S04047)
- [05:24:44 · S01421](../?t=19484.48#S01421)
- [05:24:55 · S04051](../?t=19495.09#S04051)
- [05:25:18 · S01424](../?t=19518.79#S01424)

## The defense promises more evidence

Senator Panfilo "Ping" M. Lacson asked how CALE88 Foods Corporation sustained expenses despite one hundred twenty-five thousand pesos in paid-up capital and eight point zero five million pesos in losses over two years. Defense witness Dr. Ceferino S. Rodolfo, DTI Undersecretary and BOI Vice Chairman and Managing Head, recalled about three and a half million pesos in shareholder advances. Lacson accepted BOI registration and compliance with registration requirements, but raised concern that the company might have been used for money laundering. He sought shipping records or similar proof to address those doubts. Defense counsel Attorney Michael Wesley Poa said witnesses would address those matters, with a manifestation for the next trial date. Lacson awaited that evidence. Senator Joel Villanueva said that assurance satisfied him to wait until the next hearing.

- [05:30:17 · S01476](../?t=19817.37#S01476)
- [05:30:29 · S01478](../?t=19829.66#S01478)
- [05:31:18 · S01480](../?t=19878.05#S01480)
- [05:31:29 · S01481](../?t=19889.35#S01481)
- [05:31:40 · S04057](../?t=19900.41#S04057)
- [05:31:42 · S04508](../?t=19902.41#S04508)
- [05:31:43 · S04509](../?t=19903.99#S04509)
- [05:32:24 · S01483](../?t=19944.61#S01483)
- [05:33:01 · S01485](../?t=19981.34#S01485)
- [05:33:17 · S01492](../?t=19997.4#S01492)
- [05:33:25 · S01495](../?t=20005.7#S01495)
- [05:33:28 · S04059](../?t=20008.2#S04059)
- [04:35:32 · S01142](../?t=16532.18#S01142)
- [04:35:55 · S01145](../?t=16555.22#S01145)
- [04:36:30 · S01146](../?t=16590.53#S01146)
- [04:37:00 · S01147](../?t=16620.39#S01147)
- [04:37:36 · S01149](../?t=16656.09#S01149)
- [04:38:10 · S01150](../?t=16690.62#S01150)
- [04:38:46 · S01154](../?t=16726.05#S01154)
- [04:39:31 · S01155](../?t=16771.8#S01155)
- [04:39:46 · S03049](../?t=16786.49#S03049)
- [04:39:50 · S03050](../?t=16790.01#S03050)
- [04:40:15 · S01156](../?t=16815.26#S01156)
- [04:40:36 · S01157](../?t=16836.0#S01157)
- [04:40:38 · S03051](../?t=16838.56#S03051)
- [04:40:49 · S03063](../?t=16849.96#S03063)
- [04:40:50 · S03064](../?t=16850.48#S03064)
- [04:40:54 · S01158](../?t=16854.09#S01158)
- [04:40:57 · S01159](../?t=16857.29#S01159)
- [04:41:22 · S01160](../?t=16882.81#S01160)
- [04:42:55 · S01173](../?t=16975.77#S01173)
- [04:43:15 · S01174](../?t=16995.94#S01174)
- [04:43:48 · S01176](../?t=17028.55#S01176)
- [04:44:21 · S01179](../?t=17061.78#S01179)
- [04:44:23 · S01180](../?t=17063.92#S01180)
- [04:45:03 · S01185](../?t=17103.63#S01185)
- [04:45:35 · S01189](../?t=17135.63#S01189)
- [05:33:33 · S01497](../?t=20013.92#S01497)
- [05:33:41 · S01499](../?t=20021.65#S01499)

## What the FDA witness described

Defense witness Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director IV of the FDA Center for Food Regulation and Research, described an initial registration denial and revised banana-chip labeling. The revision removed a cardaba-banana claim and added complete nutrition facts supported by laboratory analysis. Prosecution counsel Attorney Reynaldo Robles stipulated that CALE88 Foods Corporation applied for two product registrations, submitted the appropriate requirements and received certificates for local manufacture and export. Senator Imee Marcos asked about facility, equipment, sanitation and quality-control checks. Pagayunan said licensing involved evaluation and inspection through the Field Regulatory Operations Office and confirmed that a manufacturing location was identified, although she had not brought that document.

- [05:49:44 · S01591](../?t=20984.31#S01591)
- [05:55:28 · S01620](../?t=21328.37#S01620)
- [06:02:42 · S01644](../?t=21762.01#S01644)
- [06:03:34 · S01646](../?t=21814.11#S01646)
- [06:05:36 · S01658](../?t=21936.71#S01658)
- [06:11:04 · S01708](../?t=22264.81#S01708)
- [06:11:38 · S04517](../?t=22298.74#S04517)
- [06:11:44 · S04518](../?t=22304.4#S04518)
- [04:46:04 · S03066](../?t=17164.26#S03066)
- [04:46:08 · S01190](../?t=17168.84#S01190)
- [04:46:41 · S01191](../?t=17201.83#S01191)
- [04:47:16 · S01195](../?t=17236.61#S01195)
- [04:48:04 · S01199](../?t=17284.03#S01199)
- [04:48:18 · S01200](../?t=17298.89#S01200)
- [04:48:39 · S01202](../?t=17319.63#S01202)
- [04:48:58 · S01204](../?t=17338.69#S01204)
- [04:49:13 · S01206](../?t=17353.33#S01206)
- [04:49:40 · S01210](../?t=17380.13#S01210)
- [04:50:00 · S01212](../?t=17400.27#S01212)
- [05:39:44 · S01538](../?t=20384.55#S01538)
- [05:39:52 · S01539](../?t=20392.49#S01539)
- [05:40:06 · S01540](../?t=20406.81#S01540)
- [05:40:23 · S04068](../?t=20423.85#S04068)
- [05:40:42 · S04069](../?t=20442.75#S04069)
- [06:31:01 · S01844](../?t=23461.59#S01844)
- [06:31:05 · S01845](../?t=23465.15#S01845)
- [06:31:44 · S01848](../?t=23504.05#S01848)
- [06:31:55 · S01850](../?t=23515.19#S01850)
- [06:32:15 · S01852](../?t=23535.81#S01852)
- [06:32:27 · S04131](../?t=23547.11#S04131)
- [06:32:40 · S01854](../?t=23560.72#S01854)

## The court defines the FDA examination

Defense counsel Attorney Justin Nicol B. Gular ended further direct examination in reliance on prosecution stipulations. Prosecution counsel Attorney Reynaldo Robles then sought to question the supporting license and monitoring after issuance. Gular requested a backread of the stipulations. Presiding Officer Senator Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero sustained an asked-and-answered objection: FDA witness Pilar Marilyn M. Pagayunan, Director IV of the Center for Food Regulation and Research, could not testify to actual manufacturing, sales or quantities. After the witness was excused, Escudero read the stipulation exchange into the record. Earlier, Escudero had distinguished registration from quantities and costs, and requested remaining product and packaging photographs. Gular said proper evidence would come through the proper witness.

- [00:50:12 · S00162](../?t=3012.119#S00162)
- [00:50:56 · S00163](../?t=3056.38#S00163)
- [00:51:21 · S02119](../?t=3081.73#S02119)
- [00:51:45 · S02121](../?t=3105.6099999999997#S02121)
- [00:51:59 · S02122](../?t=3119.1#S02122)
- [00:52:02 · S02123](../?t=3122.3199999999997#S02123)
- [04:24:13 · S01050](../?t=15853.34#S01050)
- [04:24:51 · S01054](../?t=15891.24#S01054)
- [04:25:22 · S01058](../?t=15922.130000000001#S01058)
- [06:07:27 · S04091](../?t=22047.52#S04091)
- [06:07:54 · S01678](../?t=22074.74#S01678)
- [06:08:04 · S01680](../?t=22084.66#S01680)
- [06:08:32 · S01683](../?t=22112.41#S01683)
- [06:09:42 · S01695](../?t=22182.2#S01695)
- [06:10:09 · S01700](../?t=22209.95#S01700)
- [06:11:04 · S01708](../?t=22264.81#S01708)
- [06:11:38 · S04517](../?t=22298.74#S04517)
- [06:11:44 · S04518](../?t=22304.4#S04518)
- [06:11:45 · S01709](../?t=22305.7#S01709)
- [06:12:00 · S01711](../?t=22320.66#S01711)
- [06:13:25 · S04103](../?t=22405.18#S04103)
- [06:13:30 · S01731](../?t=22410.06#S01731)
- [06:23:49 · S01793](../?t=23029.46#S01793)
- [06:24:08 · S01794](../?t=23048.84#S01794)
- [06:24:27 · S04523](../?t=23067.74#S04523)
- [06:26:22 · S01808](../?t=23182.77#S01808)
- [06:28:42 · S01822](../?t=23322.86#S01822)
- [06:29:39 · S01827](../?t=23379.22#S01827)
- [06:30:01 · S01831](../?t=23401.74#S01831)
- [06:30:09 · S01833](../?t=23409.48#S01833)
- [06:33:38 · S04135](../?t=23618.7#S04135)
- [06:34:09 · S01870](../?t=23649.44#S01870)

## Other court action and the next sitting

On Senator Erwin Tulfo's motion, the court directed a show-cause order to Vice Presidential spokesperson Attorney Paolo Panelo over remarks the previous afternoon. Presiding Officer Senator Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero invoked Rule seventy-one on contempt. He also reminded parties that AMLC exhibits remained sealed under supervised-access rules. At the close, lead defense counsel Attorney Sheila C. Sison dispensed with the planned CITEM witness and requested cancellation of November twenty-six and twenty-seven because counsel and witnesses were unavailable. Public prosecutor Representative Terry L. Ridon sought fewer defense presentation days as a consequence. Escudero took that request under advisement and said the cancellations would not be taken against the respondent at that point. The court canceled those sittings, asked for at least two sequential witnesses with five-day notice, and adjourned until December first, twenty twenty-six, at ten in the morning.

- [00:14:01 · S00028](../?t=841.29#S00028)
- [00:17:02 · S00048](../?t=1022.62#S00048)
- [00:18:19 · S00051](../?t=1099.67#S00051)
- [00:18:46 · S00053](../?t=1126.89#S00053)
- [00:19:00 · S00058](../?t=1140.67#S00058)
- [00:19:07 · S00059](../?t=1147.03#S00059)
- [06:42:17 · S01908](../?t=24137.39#S01908)
- [06:42:29 · S01911](../?t=24149.79#S01911)
- [06:42:33 · S01914](../?t=24153.11#S01914)
- [06:42:36 · S01915](../?t=24156.49#S01915)
- [06:42:43 · S01917](../?t=24163.94#S01917)
- [06:48:34 · S01940](../?t=24514.27#S01940)
- [06:49:34 · S01950](../?t=24574.99#S01950)
- [06:50:37 · S01956](../?t=24637.23#S01956)
- [06:44:44 · S01930](../?t=24284.0#S01930)
- [06:46:56 · S01936](../?t=24416.64#S01936)
- [06:47:20 · S01937](../?t=24440.5#S01937)
- [06:35:28 · S01882](../?t=23728.07#S01882)
- [06:35:46 · S01883](../?t=23746.73#S01883)
- [06:39:26 · S01891](../?t=23966.5#S01891)
- [06:40:53 · S01902](../?t=24053.26#S01902)
- [06:41:28 · S01904](../?t=24088.99#S01904)
- [06:47:22 · S01939](../?t=24442.96#S01939)
- [06:48:57 · S01941](../?t=24537.64#S01941)

## Closing

Each substantive point in this overview links to the reviewed transcript and the official Senate video. This has been the November 20, 2026 audio overview.
