1
00:09:01,440 --> 00:09:03,220
Atty. Renato N. Bantug Jr.: ...the impeachment court.

2
00:10:01,160 --> 00:10:03,960
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: The Sergeant-at-Arms is directed to make a proclamation.

3
00:10:03,960 --> 00:10:15,490
Alfredo Sotto Corpuz: All persons are commanded to keep silent under pain of penalty while the impeachment court is in session for the trial of Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte.

4
00:10:15,630 --> 00:10:23,650
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: The impeachment trial of Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte is hereby called to order. We shall be led in prayer by Senator Judge Alan Peter Cayetano.

5
00:10:25,450 --> 00:13:37,620
Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano: A reading from the book of Chronicles 2, 7, 14. If my people, who you are called by my name, will humble themselves and pray and seek my face and turn from their wicked ways, then I will hear from heaven and will forgive their sins and heal their land. Lord Father God, as we come to you here today, We acknowledge that before we are members of the prosecution or the defense, or before we are senator judges, or before we are those who are advocating the impeachment or the acquittal of the vice president, we are Filipinos. And even before we can say we are Filipinos, we are your children. So when you say, if your people, we ask Lord God that we be part of This verse, because you never lie, who says that if my people. We know, Lord God, that we call on your name. We know that we are humbling ourselves. We know that we pray. Yet, Lord, as a nation, have we really turned our back on our wicked ways? Even today, as we are nearing the wrapping up of this impeachment proceeding, Lord, nearing the conclusion. So many big cases, major cases of corruption remain silent. Cover-ups are happening left and right and corruption that has stopped may also be restarted. Next Monday, we will start looking at the national budget which could be a source of huge blessing to the Filipino people, a source of relief, a source of some medicine or cure for the economic woes of the country. But it could also be poison, Lord God, depending on what the deliberation, what the product of the deliberation will be. Lord, so as we humble ourselves to you today, we ask that we learn to look at ourselves first, our institutions, our intentions. Lord, again we ask that you make the evidence so, so, so clear, one way or the other. Very, very clear, Lord, and we ask that the objectivity Hit every single Filipino. Not only the senator judges but every Filipino. Make it very very clear whether conviction is in order or an acquittal. We pray for the integrity of the court, Lord God. The court has been through many trials, many debates, many Issues, Lord God. We leave this to your hands and to the judgment of history. But as we go on today, we pray, Lord God, that you will give us the strength, the wisdom, the patience, our Senate President, our leaders, the leaders of the House. Because even as we speak today, abortion is being discussed. And other great sins. So how can we ask you to heal our land unless we turn from our evil ways? Lord, teach us to turn from our evil ways. We lift this up to you in Jesus' mighty name. Amen.

6
00:13:37,840 --> 00:13:40,780
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Amen. The Clerk of Court will now call the roll.

7
00:13:41,280 --> 00:13:57,140
Atty. Renato N. Bantug Jr.: Roll call of members. Senator Judge Aquino. Senator Judge Cayetano, Alan. Senator Judge Cayetano, Pia. Senator Judge dela Rosa. Senator Judge Ejercito. Senator Judge Estrada. Senator Judge Go. Senator Judge Hontiveros.

8
00:13:57,340 --> 00:14:26,060
Atty. Renato N. Bantug Jr.: Senator Judge Lacson. Senator Judge Lapid. Senator Judge Legarda. Senator Judge Marcoleta. Senator Judge Marcos. Senator Judge Padilla. Senator Judge Pangilinan. Senator Judge Sotto III. Senator Judge Tulfo, Erwin. Senator Judge Tulfo, Raffy. Senator Judge Villanueva. Senator Judge Villar, Camille. Senator Judge Villar, Mark. Senator Judge Zubiri. The Presiding Officer, Senator Judge Escudero. The Senate President, Senator Judge Gatchalian.

9
00:14:26,410 --> 00:14:41,530
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: With 16 senator judges present, the chair declares the presence of a quorum. In accordance with the rules of procedure on impeachment trials, the chair now recognizes the duly elected presiding officer to preside over the proceedings of the impeachment court.

10
00:14:43,310 --> 00:14:53,990
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you, Mr. Senate President. If there are no objections, we shall dispense with the reading of the journal, Journal No. 40 of November 11 and 12 of the Senate, sitting as an impeachment court, and consider it the same as approved.

11
00:14:57,580 --> 00:15:01,640
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: The Clerk will please call the case before the Impeachment Court.

12
00:15:01,940 --> 00:15:08,400
Atty. Renato N. Bantug Jr.: Case number 004-2026, in the matter of Impeachment Trial, Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte.

13
00:15:09,180 --> 00:16:25,580
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Before asking for the appearances of the parties, the Chair would like to inform the parties that on the basis of the manifestation of the Counsel of Respondent regarding the witnesses they will present, the Court issued a subpoena. For the following witnesses, Attorney Rainer Dela Fuente, Dr. Ceferino Rodolfo, Pilar Marilyn Pagayunan, and Ms. Rowena Mendoza, all of which have been duly served through electronic mail. Also, Chair would like to inform the Senator Judges and the parties that in compliance with the request of Senator Judge Hontiveros during the trial of November 10, 2026, The Court on November 16, 2026 received a letter of City Accountant Vingeline Bahan with the following documents through electronic mail. Number 1, authority to travel dated November 13, 2025, issued by the City Mayor of Davao City authorizing her to travel to Beijing and Shanghai, China from December 2 to 7, 2025. And number 2, travel authority issued by the Department of Interior and Local Government in relation to that travel. The Clerk of Court is directed to furnish the Senator Judges and the parties with a copy of City Accountant Bahan's submission.

14
00:16:53,500 --> 00:17:18,940
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: With respect to witness Rowena Mendoza of the Center for International Trade Expositions and Missions, she acknowledged receipt of the subpoena but stated that she is presently in Frankfurt, Germany on an approved official mission on the Sabina Duces Tecum, CITEM is currently collating and gathering all relevant documents in relation to Cale88 Foods Corporation.

15
00:17:22,080 --> 00:17:28,100
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: She does request for time to submit the required documents and to move the date of her appearance to a later date.

16
00:17:34,040 --> 00:17:54,740
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: The chair shall act accordingly on her request before the end of today's trial, before we adjourn rather. or even before lunch so that she can act accordingly with respect not only to the subpoena at testificandum but also to the subpoena duces tecum. So ordered. Appearances of the parties.

17
00:17:56,520 --> 00:17:59,620
Rep. Terry L. Ridon: Good morning, Your Honors. For the prosecution, we are ready.

18
00:18:03,450 --> 00:18:04,630
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: For the respondent.

19
00:18:04,750 --> 00:18:08,170
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Good morning, Your Honor. Same appearance for the respondent accused.

20
00:18:08,530 --> 00:18:11,050
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Who will handle Atty. Dela Fuente, Atty. Sheila?

21
00:18:11,310 --> 00:18:17,080
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: We ask that Atty. Mark Vinluan be recognized, Your Honor. Atty. Mark Vinluan.

22
00:18:17,800 --> 00:18:26,770
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Atty. Mark, for the prosecution who will handle the witness, Atty. Dela Fuente, Honorable Ridon.

23
00:18:26,850 --> 00:18:28,310
Rep. Terry L. Ridon: It will be Honorable Diokno, Your Honor.

24
00:18:33,640 --> 00:18:38,080
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Good morning, Honorable Chel. Call your

25
00:18:38,080 --> 00:18:38,980
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: witness, Atty. Mark.

26
00:18:39,160 --> 00:18:50,790
Rep. Terry L. Ridon: Your Honor, but before calling the witness, the prosecution would like to get copies of all the documents which the four witnesses will be submitting. So that it can guide the cross-examination.

27
00:18:50,910 --> 00:18:56,730
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Have you provided them with a copy, Atty. Mark? Not yet?

28
00:18:56,770 --> 00:19:03,110
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We were given one set of documents earlier by the Senate staff, Your Honor. But at the proper time, we will furnish them with copies.

29
00:19:04,370 --> 00:19:11,610
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, kindly furnish them accordingly so that we will not delay with the cross-examination of the witness. You may call your witness, Atty. Mark.

30
00:19:11,850 --> 00:19:12,550
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Morning, Your Honor.

31
00:19:13,860 --> 00:19:18,320
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: For the next witness, we call to the witness stand, Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente.

32
00:19:19,070 --> 00:19:21,330
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly situate attorney Rainer to the witness stand.

33
00:19:37,250 --> 00:19:40,990
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: The clerk is directed to place the witness on the road.

34
00:19:41,840 --> 00:19:43,240
Atty. Renato N. Bantug Jr.: Sir, kindly raise your right hand.

35
00:19:45,310 --> 00:19:56,650
Atty. Renato N. Bantug Jr.: You, Rainer Dela Fuente, do swear that the evidence you shall give in the case now pending between the Philippines and Vice President Sara Zimmerman Duterte shall be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. So help you God.

36
00:19:56,930 --> 00:19:57,490
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

37
00:20:04,350 --> 00:20:09,370
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Atty. Dela Fuente, did you understand? Naunawaan niyo po ba yung inyong sinumpaan, kaugnay ng

38
00:20:09,370 --> 00:20:12,350
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: inyong testimonya o pagbibigay na inyong testimonya sa umagang ito?

39
00:20:12,530 --> 00:20:13,190
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

40
00:20:14,070 --> 00:20:16,750
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Can we address you as Atty. Rainer?

41
00:20:17,190 --> 00:20:18,410
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Sir. Yes, Your Honor.

42
00:20:19,410 --> 00:20:22,070
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Okay, good morning, Atty. Rainer. Offer, Atty. Mark.

43
00:20:22,730 --> 00:20:23,490
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Offer, Your Honor.

44
00:20:28,800 --> 00:21:10,780
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Number one, Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente is a certified public accountant, lawyer, and anti-money laundering compliance practitioner. Number two, his knowledge and experience will enlighten this honorable court of fundamental legal concepts related to the anti-money laundering law, thereby demonstrating that the findings of alleged unexplained wealth on the part of the Vice President, as well as the methodologies used therefore, are erroneous, malicious, and without merit. And number three, He will also testify on other relevant matters and identify documents. That would be all, Your Honor.

45
00:21:10,880 --> 00:21:28,880
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: We reserve the right to cross-examine, if Your Honor, please. Your Honor, I understand that the witness will be testifying on a curriculum vitae or resume. May we have a copy of that so that we can catch and follow while that's happening?

46
00:21:29,740 --> 00:21:36,050
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We will ask him about it, Your Honor, and we will... Provide the prosecution copies thereof.

47
00:21:36,070 --> 00:21:38,230
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: But I understand you only have one copy, counsel.

48
00:21:39,150 --> 00:21:41,130
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We asked... I think...

49
00:21:41,130 --> 00:21:42,790
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You have a copy. He has his own copy too.

50
00:21:43,150 --> 00:21:44,890
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: He has multiple copies, I believe.

51
00:21:45,440 --> 00:21:48,500
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You have multiple copies, Attorney Rainer, of the documents you will be presenting?

52
00:21:48,880 --> 00:21:51,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. It's in my USB. The electronic copies.

53
00:21:54,740 --> 00:21:56,740
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly submit it to the court.

54
00:21:58,760 --> 00:22:10,010
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: The OSAA is directed to get a copy of the USB so that we can print it and we shall... Make it available to the witness, Attorney Mark, in the course of his testimony. Pakikuha yung USB, please.

55
00:22:12,530 --> 00:22:20,440
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly give it to the secretary so they can print necessary copies.

56
00:22:27,290 --> 00:22:39,690
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: May we know, Your Honor, if there are other documents aside from the resume that were produced by the witness?

57
00:22:39,850 --> 00:22:51,710
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We will ask him if he provided or brought other documents. Can

58
00:22:57,020 --> 00:22:58,440
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: we proceed now, Your Honor?

59
00:23:04,830 --> 00:23:09,330
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: What copies do you have, Honorable Chel? The CV?

60
00:23:09,850 --> 00:23:13,130
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I don't have... I thought

61
00:23:13,130 --> 00:23:18,050
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: you were given copies already. What copies were given to them? Clerk of Court or Attorney Diokno?

62
00:23:18,250 --> 00:23:18,830
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I have three

63
00:23:18,830 --> 00:23:51,860
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: documents, Your Honor, please. One is the profile of the witness. Second is an FATF report entitled Operational Issues. Financial Investigations Guidance dated June 2012 and the third is a paper authored by the witness among others entitled Financial Investigation and Anti-Money Laundering Guidelines to Tackle Wildlife and Environmental Crime in the Philippines dated July 2025.

64
00:23:52,580 --> 00:23:57,470
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We confirm that we also have the same set of documents.

65
00:23:57,590 --> 00:24:08,200
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Okay. Let's see how far we'll go. Kindly just bring it out, Honorable Diokno, whenever you want a copy and if the copy has not been given to you. You may proceed, Atty. Mark, with your direct examination of the witness.

66
00:24:08,660 --> 00:24:09,460
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you, Your Honor.

67
00:24:10,910 --> 00:24:12,930
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Good morning, Atty. Dela Fuente. Good

68
00:24:12,930 --> 00:24:13,950
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: morning, Your Honors.

69
00:24:14,710 --> 00:24:15,530
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Kamusta po kayo?

70
00:24:16,070 --> 00:24:16,770
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay naman, Sir.

71
00:24:16,950 --> 00:24:24,630
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay naman. Alright, dumiretsyo na po tayo. The court issued a subpoena in relation to your appearance in today's proceeding. Naalala niyo po?

72
00:24:25,430 --> 00:24:26,130
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

73
00:24:26,310 --> 00:24:31,920
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And then, we were just talking about it, but you brought Documents in relation to that subpoena, correct?

74
00:24:32,260 --> 00:24:32,960
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, your honor.

75
00:24:33,160 --> 00:24:36,040
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Ilang sets of documents po yung dinalo nyo?

76
00:24:36,360 --> 00:24:40,020
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Three sets po, your honor. Electronic form.

77
00:24:41,120 --> 00:24:44,500
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. So, I'll just go through those documents.

78
00:24:46,910 --> 00:25:04,900
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: So, you brought a copy of your CV and then a copy of a publication entitled Financial Investigation and Anti-Money Laundering Guidelines. As well as a report, operational issues, financial investigations guidance.

79
00:25:06,860 --> 00:25:08,100
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Do you confirm this?

80
00:25:08,360 --> 00:25:10,180
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. I confirm those documents.

81
00:25:11,390 --> 00:25:16,310
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And may we confirm from the prosecution if those are the same set of documents that they have?

82
00:25:16,670 --> 00:25:23,130
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I have not seen the documents that he has. All I can say is that those were the documents provided to us by the court.

83
00:25:27,390 --> 00:25:31,870
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: If copies of those documents are shown you, printed copies, you will be able to identify them.

84
00:25:32,030 --> 00:25:32,750
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

85
00:25:34,560 --> 00:25:42,120
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: At this point, I'm showing you a copy. Can we use the court's copy, by the way, Your Honor, of the documents that he brought? I'm

86
00:25:42,120 --> 00:25:42,700
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: sorry, Attorney Mark.

87
00:25:42,780 --> 00:25:44,260
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Can we use the court's copy

88
00:25:44,260 --> 00:25:48,860
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: of the documents? Can he be provided with copies of those at this point?

89
00:25:51,160 --> 00:25:57,810
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: As well as any electronic form in a USB that was provided to the court.

90
00:26:12,270 --> 00:26:15,590
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Are you referring to the CV and the first two attachments, Attorney Mark?

91
00:26:16,030 --> 00:26:16,730
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Yes, Your Honor.

92
00:26:16,850 --> 00:26:17,570
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You have a copy, right?

93
00:26:17,810 --> 00:26:18,290
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Yes, Your Honor.

94
00:26:18,390 --> 00:26:19,810
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You have a copy, Honorable Chela?

95
00:26:20,090 --> 00:26:20,730
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Yes, Your Honor.

96
00:26:21,010 --> 00:26:21,890
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You may proceed, Attorney Mark.

97
00:26:22,010 --> 00:26:36,090
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: At this point, Your Honor, may we request, Your Honor, upon proper identification of witness of those documents that they be marked as our exhibits D-2-AML-1 and so on at the proper time, Your Honor.

98
00:26:37,240 --> 00:26:37,840
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: So ordered.

99
00:26:38,560 --> 00:26:50,850
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. We are aware... And we also see in your CV that you are a certified public accountant. Can you share with all of us how or when you obtained your degree in accountancy?

100
00:26:51,600 --> 00:27:08,140
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I obtained my degree in accountancy from De La Salle University. So I have double degrees, Bachelor of Science in Applied Economics and Accountancy. I graduated October 2005, took the board exam 2006, passed the board 2006.

101
00:27:09,330 --> 00:27:12,490
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, and what school organizations were you part of, if any?

102
00:27:13,420 --> 00:27:30,950
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: During those times, the usual, I think, as far as I can remember, Junior Philippine Institute for Accountants and also Economics Organization for the school.

103
00:27:31,420 --> 00:27:37,860
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Very well. Now, after passing the board exam, what was your first experience as a certified public accountant?

104
00:27:38,930 --> 00:27:48,850
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: After passing the board exam, your honor, I went to law school. Same year, 2006, I entered San Beda College of Law.

105
00:27:51,320 --> 00:27:54,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: During that time, I'm a full-time student.

106
00:27:55,940 --> 00:28:06,620
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Until my third year, I applied with the Bureau of Internal Revenue as a revenue officer in Manila. I was a working student on my third year.

107
00:28:08,290 --> 00:28:09,510
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: That's around 2009.

108
00:28:11,110 --> 00:28:23,170
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2010. So that's my experience as a revenue officer. I was able to apply my knowledge on accountancy as a government employee.

109
00:28:24,910 --> 00:28:31,350
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Punta naman po tayo dun sa pagiging abogado ninyo. Kindly share with all of us when you obtained your law degree.

110
00:28:31,750 --> 00:29:06,010
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: So I graduated 2011, took the 2012 bar exams, passed it. 2011, and then I took my oath 2012. And while waiting for the results of the bar exam, I applied with Punong Bayan and Aurelio as a senior tax associate. Then after the results of the bar exam, I went back to government service, was part of the pioneer batch for the governance commission for government-owned and controlled corporations, GCG. So,

111
00:29:06,010 --> 00:29:07,750
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Your Honor, please, I'm very sorry to

112
00:29:07,750 --> 00:29:09,550
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: interrupt the witness and the

113
00:29:09,550 --> 00:29:22,010
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: defense counsel. But may I see clarification from the defense? Are they attempting to qualify this witness as an expert? Because there is nothing in the offer of testimony to that effect.

114
00:29:22,390 --> 00:29:23,470
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We will get there, Your Honor.

115
00:29:23,910 --> 00:29:27,550
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Then I will have to make an objection, Your Honor, because it's not part of the offer.

116
00:29:28,350 --> 00:29:34,210
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: It's part of the offer, Your Honor. It's just couched in different terms, but we will talk.

117
00:29:34,820 --> 00:29:38,020
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: we'll talk about uh his expertise and his knowledge role

118
00:29:38,260 --> 00:29:42,540
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: May I request a

119
00:29:42,820 --> 00:29:51,840
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: ruling of the Honorable Court, Your Honor, please. I did not hear the word expert or being offered or qualified as an expert in the offer of testimony.

120
00:29:52,300 --> 00:29:59,960
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: While it was not specifically mentioned, Honorable Diokno, you can infer it from Offers 1 and 2. And it is also my understanding, given the...

121
00:30:01,900 --> 00:30:14,320
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Description of this witness when they requested for a subpoena that he is being presented as an expert in the particular field that he will be testifying to particularly, I guess, on AMLC matters.

122
00:30:16,140 --> 00:30:18,960
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Did you make an objection or made an observation, Honorable Diokno?

123
00:30:19,400 --> 00:30:21,100
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I made an objection, Your Honor, please.

124
00:30:21,640 --> 00:30:25,520
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: At this time, Honorable Diokno, I would have to overrule the objection. You may proceed, Attorney Mark.

125
00:30:25,680 --> 00:30:27,120
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Just a manifestation. Thank

126
00:30:27,120 --> 00:30:27,320
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: you, Your Honor.

127
00:30:27,480 --> 00:30:28,540
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, Attorney Diokno.

128
00:30:28,600 --> 00:30:28,860
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I'm very sorry, Your Honor.

129
00:30:28,860 --> 00:30:30,320
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Honorable Diokno, manifestation.

130
00:30:30,340 --> 00:30:39,440
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Just a manifestation that we are not admitting the credentials or qualifications of this witness and will include it in our cross-examination.

131
00:30:39,760 --> 00:30:40,960
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Duly noted. Subject to cross.

132
00:30:43,800 --> 00:30:48,540
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Pagkatapos ng law school and after passing the bar, what was your first experience as a law practitioner?

133
00:30:48,560 --> 00:31:10,780
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, again, as part of GCG, I started there as an Analyst for GOCCs. So there's an application, combined application of my knowledge in accountancy and also law. So that's under GCG.

134
00:31:10,900 --> 00:31:20,460
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: So you mentioned that you have experience in government service. I understand that you are a former AMLC official. Please tell us about that experience.

135
00:31:21,290 --> 00:31:22,570
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sorry sir, what's the last part?

136
00:31:22,710 --> 00:31:26,310
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Former AMLC. Former AMLC official, please tell us about that experience.

137
00:31:26,770 --> 00:31:42,130
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Objection, Your Honor. There's no basis yet. The witness has not testified that he was ever connected with the Anti-Money Laundering Council. We see that in the CV. But the witness has not identified the CV or attested to its truth, Your Honor.

138
00:31:42,390 --> 00:31:43,730
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly reform, Attorney Mark.

139
00:31:45,110 --> 00:31:59,310
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. We'll show you a copy of your own CV. Just so you can refer. It says in your CV that you are a former AMLC official. Can you please tell us more about that experience?

140
00:31:59,950 --> 00:32:13,490
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay, I entered the AMLC in 2015 as a financial investigator, proper designation bank officer 2. So I was assigned with the compliance and investigation group during that time.

141
00:32:13,500 --> 00:32:16,380
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2015 july 2015.

142
00:32:16,940 --> 00:32:21,220
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: All right. And what are your—what were your duties and responsibilities in relation to that role?

143
00:32:22,420 --> 00:32:43,940
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: uh well it's financial investigation we handle compliance matters financial investigation matters so any case referred to the council as part of the team that look into scrutinize check the data and produce reports that may be used by other

144
00:32:43,940 --> 00:32:49,310
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: agencies, law enforcement agencies and other agencies with investigative powers.

145
00:32:49,830 --> 00:32:58,810
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: You mentioned the term financial investigation. Can you describe your duties as far as you can and responsibilities as such as a financial investigator?

146
00:32:59,390 --> 00:33:29,010
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: We start first, Your Honor, with investigative sparks, investigative triggers. There are cases referred to us and these cases are then assigned. Ina-assign ito sa iba't ibang grupo within AMLC Secretariat. At kami yung gumagawa from scratch up until case build up until makapag-produce ng report, investigation or report that may be used.

147
00:33:30,530 --> 00:34:08,600
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Number one, tulungan ang ating mga law enforcement agencies sa pag-iimbestiga sa predicate crime. And number two, if meron ng predicate crime, mag-proceed yun sa pag-file ng kaso for money laundering. So, in a nutshell, doon humiikot yung aking duty previously with the AMLC and during that time kasi magkasama ang compliance and investigation. So, other than pag-iimbestiga, yung routine compliance checks sa mga ating covered persons ginagawa rin doon base sa aking function dati-dati sa sekretaryat.

148
00:34:09,820 --> 00:34:14,500
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: How would you describe or how extensive is your experience in financial investigation?

149
00:34:15,060 --> 00:34:30,660
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, from 2015 to 2018, during that time, very small pa lang ho ang sekretariat so we really multitask. Lahat ho ng pwedeng iba tong trabaho, hindi ho namin pwedeng hindian yan. So ginagawa ho namin lahat.

150
00:34:31,920 --> 00:34:37,460
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Matanong ko lang po very quickly, kaya po ba gawin in two weeks ang isang extensive financial investigation?

151
00:34:38,310 --> 00:34:49,090
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Two weeks? Kaya, pero mahirap po. If we would be very realistic, kaya, pero sobrang hirap po yan.

152
00:34:49,330 --> 00:35:06,890
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay. We'll leave it at that, no? Kasi yung ibang so-called expert, two weeks lang. Now, let's move on. By the way, dito po sa profile nyo, napansin ko rin po na there's this term AML, CFT, and CPF compliance. Can you explain to us what these are?

153
00:35:07,210 --> 00:35:44,630
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay. Ang anti-money laundering kasi ngayon hindi lang sa isa. Tatlo na sila. Mayroon ng terrorist financing at saka financing, rather, proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. So tatlo na yan. You cannot discuss money laundering without touching upon the topic on terrorism financing and proliferation of weapons of mass destruction. So magkakasama na yung tatlo na yan. Paggamit ng ating financial system, in order to mask yung illicit sources of money. So yan ho ang mundo. So it concerns financial crimes.

154
00:35:45,400 --> 00:35:52,320
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. How about this, you have also a role on regulatory advisory. Can you share your experience in this?

155
00:35:52,940 --> 00:37:30,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay. When I left the public service po, ako ay pumunta sa private sector. I started a law firm with a friend and then later on, I branched out and started my own. 2021. That is AML Consulting PH. So aside from the private sector clients, I was also tapped by other government agencies as their AML consultant. Based on my competence and experience, tinulungan natin sila how to draft their own supervisory framework, how they will be governing their covered persons. So maganda ho kasi meron ang aking eksperyensya sa gobyerno dati na mix ko ho with my first-hand experience sa mga covered persons, private sector. So nakita ko ho kung saan nahihirapan ang ating private sector at napapaintindi ho natin sa kanila kung saan ang gagaling yung sa gobyerno. Bakit naghihigpit ang gobyerno? So sabi ko we have to be sa middle. We comply with the international standards but also we don't, for lack of better term, pahirapan itong ating private sector. So yung aking naging role, advisory lamang po, recommendatory. The ultimate decision maker are still kung sino yung head of the agency. So yan yung aking regulatory compliance work. We advise government agencies how to craft properly yung kanilang AML policy so that it is realistic. Hindi lang siya theoretical.

156
00:37:31,320 --> 00:37:31,980
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: All right.

157
00:37:32,100 --> 00:37:47,320
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: With the permission of Attorney Mark and Attorney Rainer, continuing authority is given to assisting counsels to approach the witness at any point in time. And no further authorization need be given by the court nor the presiding officer. You may continue, Attorney Mark.

158
00:37:47,320 --> 00:37:54,280
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you, Your Honor. You also have experience as an accredited trainer for the AMLC. Please tell us more about that.

159
00:37:54,280 --> 00:39:02,420
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, I left the service in 2018. I had a one-year self-imposed bar na hindi ako nag-practice ng anything related to AML. So 2019, after one year, I applied for accreditation. I was one of the first three accredited trainers. So diyan ko sinimulan yung aking firm, training lamang. Hindi ko nga alam kung ito ay magpaprosper o hindi. So from time, yung aking mga nagiging estudyante, na niwala naman sila sa akin. So unti-unti dun ko na-build. Yung aking client base. They tapped me as their consultant. Kung ano yung tinuturo mo, sabi nila, tulungan mo kami how to craft our AML policies. So doon ho nag-expand yung aking practice. So dati-dati ho, mag-isa lang ako sa opisina. Ngayon ho, kahit papaano, meron na ho tayong mga team of lawyers, paralegals that do assist me in this kind of work. So from training, 2019, yan ho, hanggang ngayon ay tuloy-tuloy ko ho yung ginagawa. So covered persons, bangko, Real Estate, lahat ng tinatawag nating covered persons, we do provide training sa kanila.

160
00:39:03,370 --> 00:39:21,510
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, you also mentioned that you have your own consulting firm and according to your profile, you are the founder and lead counsel of AML Consulting PH. Can you tell us when this was organized and can you tell us your duties and responsibilities for this organization?

161
00:39:22,070 --> 00:40:27,990
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay, yung AML Consulting PH, again, I started this 2021. Again, the focus po nito ay more, again, training, compliance work, and research. Our core, ano po namin sa training, again, later on, those that attended my sessions, they do tap yung ating hong opisina para kanila maging consultant kasi ito ay medyo technical. So they need assistance. Tinutulungan natin sila to craft their own MTPP, yung kanilang money laundering and terrorist financing prevention program, institutional risk assessment, post-registration compliance work. So ito, again, on the side lang kami, advisory. The ultimate decision maker remains the covered person. So ito ang ginagawa namin day in and day out. Sa dami ng ating covered persons, in my own way, nasa private sector, Masaya rin ako kasi natutulungan ko rin yung aking mga dating kasamahan sa AMLC. Tinuturuan natin ng tama, hindi tinuturuan ng mali yung mga covered persons.

162
00:40:28,650 --> 00:40:37,730
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. You mentioned that you also work for the BIR or the Bureau of Internal Revenue. Can you share with us that experience as well?

163
00:40:38,030 --> 00:41:14,500
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay. Your Honor, noong 2009 to 2010, For at least one year, I worked with Revenue Region 6, BIR Manila, as a revenue officer. So, I was part of the assessment group. So, we review tax dockets na inaakyat po sa Revenue Region 6, Manila. So, pagre-review ng mga assessments, lahat po ng taxes, business taxes, income taxes, before... I-close yung case or pag may kulang pa, binabalik ko namin sa mga revenue district offices or sa RDOs.

164
00:41:15,690 --> 00:41:25,070
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, you also mentioned governance commission for government-owned and controlled corporations. This is under the office of the President, correct?

165
00:41:25,330 --> 00:41:25,890
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

166
00:41:26,110 --> 00:41:33,770
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And can you tell us your experience on this? What were your duties and experience, your responsibilities, as well as knowledge and trainings that you gained?

167
00:41:34,250 --> 00:41:35,890
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay, so for this one, Your Honor,

168
00:41:37,820 --> 00:41:58,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2012. I entered this commission as a financial analyst and then later on I was transferred to the transportation and infrastructure sector. So lahat ito, mga GOCCs na nandoon sa sector na iyon, in-evaluate po namin ang kanyang financials. Kailangan bang itong i-rationalize?

169
00:41:58,500 --> 00:42:19,180
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: i-close, i-dissolve yung mga korporasyon na ito? Kami yung gumagawa ng analysis and we give recommendations sa aming commissioners as to what are our findings and ano yung mga recommendations para matulungan yung ating gobyerno, lalo na sa mga GOCCs na hindi na based on their mandate.

170
00:42:19,420 --> 00:42:29,160
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: You were also an accredited trainer for the Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation or PAGCOR. Can you please tell us more about that?

171
00:42:29,600 --> 00:42:53,810
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: After getting my 2019 accreditation from the AMLC, nagkaroon ko ng accreditation process ang PAGCOR for the casino sector. So I was fortunate enough to be the first accredited AML trainer for the casino sector. So as far as I can remember, around 2022 or 2023.

172
00:42:54,500 --> 00:42:56,280
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And what were your duties and responsibilities?

173
00:42:56,900 --> 00:43:21,920
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yung ating mga PAGCOR covered entities, casinos, land-based and internet-based casinos, they are required to undergo training. Again, we expect them to have these AML measures in place for the board and the frontliners to, again, properly implement it. They need proper training. So ito ang ating nagiging role. During that time, I think,

174
00:43:23,790 --> 00:43:38,330
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Marami ho kasi sila. So, in a way, it is being outsourced by PAGCOR to us through an accreditation process. So, I took the chance po of having this to complement my AMLC accreditation.

175
00:43:38,730 --> 00:43:50,830
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. You also have experience as an independent consultant at the AML Research Center Asia Pacific or RCAP Incorporated. Please tell us more about your role in that organization.

176
00:43:51,470 --> 00:44:54,000
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ito ang AML Research Center Asia-Pacific. This is an independent research firm. We registered this here in the Philippines. Hindi ako technically kasama sa grupo na ito. Ang purpose nito, kasi lumalaki na ang practice, is to detach it from AML consulting and have it dito sa research center na ito. More on collaborating. With other international bodies. Kasi over the years, I noticed na nare-recognize na rin ang Pilipinas pagdating sa AML matters. So nakakatawa nga po, mayroon na mga US-based fintech companies that do contact us asking for independent AML. Compliance Testing. So to delineate yung role domestic sa international, ito yung research center for this one and I am also designated here as a senior technical official po.

177
00:44:54,680 --> 00:45:04,520
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, you mentioned yung independent consultant. Matanong ko lang sir, kapag sinabi po bang independent, do you weigh both sides or just focus on one side?

178
00:45:05,740 --> 00:45:26,340
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I think you don't take sides po. That will destroy your independence. So your findings might go against the institution that engage you. So you're only answerable dun sa standards that you apply as a consultant.

179
00:45:26,720 --> 00:45:31,160
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Bakit po? Pag-focus po ba kayo sa one side, ano po bang effect dun sa independence niyo?

180
00:45:31,340 --> 00:45:33,540
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, again, there are biases.

181
00:45:33,540 --> 00:45:45,160
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: It obscures your overview from the start. So again, it derails your work. There is a bias.

182
00:45:45,360 --> 00:45:56,040
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: You also have experience as a former consultant for CEZA. Para lang po alam ng lahat ano po ba tong CEZA and what were your duties and responsibilities dito?

183
00:45:56,280 --> 00:46:02,540
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yung CEZA po, Cagayan Economic Zone Authority. If I may correct your honor, consultant pa rin po ako nila.

184
00:46:04,170 --> 00:46:05,050
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Up to now.

185
00:46:05,290 --> 00:46:06,390
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Sorry for that.

186
00:46:07,030 --> 00:46:32,630
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes. So ang CEZA po kasi one of our supervising agencies and so far as AML matters. So again, as their advisor pagdating mo sa AML matters in crafting their supervisory framework, they are considered a supervisor po sa AML matters for their covered persons.

187
00:46:34,670 --> 00:46:47,200
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: CEZA covered persons that are under the AML regime. So doon sa aspeto na iyon, sa segment na iyon, doon tayo tumutulong. Crafty, the framework.

188
00:46:47,760 --> 00:47:24,800
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I'm very sorry to interrupt the defense and the witness. But may I know the relevance of this line of questioning? The witness apparently is delivering his credentials on anti-money laundering. But the respondent in this case is not being charged with any money laundering crimes. The issue before this court are all centered on unexplained wealth, non-declaration of SALN, and participation in business. And I haven't heard anything from this witness that would qualify him on those matters.

189
00:47:26,480 --> 00:47:27,840
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Attorney Mark, what do you say?

190
00:47:28,040 --> 00:47:46,870
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: I have to correct the good counsel. Under the articles of impeachment, there are actually allegations pertaining to money laundering and other related matters. So, we will tackle that issue later on, Your Honor. But in the meantime, Your Honor, can we just proceed with qualifying this?

191
00:47:47,130 --> 00:47:47,970
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: At any rate,

192
00:47:47,970 --> 00:47:51,290
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Your Honor, they presented an AML...

193
00:47:51,290 --> 00:47:52,970
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: If I may be allowed to finish...

194
00:47:52,970 --> 00:47:56,470
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: In fact,

195
00:47:56,510 --> 00:48:15,870
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Your Honor, they presented an AMLC witness. and they made interpretations on the data as well. They also presented their own witness, Your Honor. So, it is our position that, Your Honor, that we also have the prerogative to present our own expert on the witness.

196
00:48:16,630 --> 00:48:18,390
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: May I speak, Your Honor?

197
00:48:18,390 --> 00:48:19,630
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, Honorable Diokno.

198
00:48:19,990 --> 00:48:28,450
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Well, I would have to most respectfully disagree with the attempt by the Defense Council to correct this representation.

199
00:48:30,490 --> 00:48:51,490
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I have seen and read the articles of impeachment a number of times. I have not seen any single word that refers to the respondent committing any crime under money laundering. So may I know where in the articles that is contained, if any? Because an

200
00:48:51,490 --> 00:48:54,670
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: allegation like that is too serious to let pass.

201
00:48:55,560 --> 00:49:00,020
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: i hope that i will count you to it the council that you will show it at the

202
00:49:00,490 --> 00:49:01,630
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: The point you decide to.

203
00:49:02,290 --> 00:49:03,750
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Very well, Your Honor. Can

204
00:49:03,750 --> 00:49:04,490
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: we just move on?

205
00:49:06,490 --> 00:49:31,110
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: To abbreviate the proceedings, Honorable Chel, that Attorney Rainer is qualified as an expert by the counsel for respondent, Attorney Mark, only means that he can give his opinion. Not that it's gospel truth, not that it's the truth, not that it's accurate, not that it's correct, but only to allow the witness to give his opinion if he's qualified as an expert.

206
00:49:33,500 --> 00:50:13,110
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: He will be testifying to giving his opinion on documents identified, AMLC documents identified, presented, offered, and allowed by this court. So, in the interest of abbreviating the proceedings, again, subject to cross, of course, as regards the depth of his expertise. It will only, qualifying attorney Rainer as an expert will merely Enable him to give his opinion. Not that it's correct, again, not that we agree with it, not that it's legal, not that it's accurate, but only to give his opinion. As opposed to an ordinary witness that's not allowed to give his opinion.

207
00:50:14,780 --> 00:50:30,320
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: So, we can skip with this if you will stipulate that he is an expert that can give his opinion with respect to AMLC documents identified by the prosecution and by the defense. Correct, Attorney Mark?

208
00:50:30,380 --> 00:50:31,140
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: By the defense also.

209
00:50:31,510 --> 00:50:32,330
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: That's correct, Your Honor.

210
00:50:33,090 --> 00:50:42,990
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Or if you don't want to concede it, you're also free to do so, Honorable Diokno. And we can proceed with... I think we're about to go to the seminars he has attended.

211
00:50:43,830 --> 00:50:45,010
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We're going to that.

212
00:50:45,350 --> 00:50:46,150
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: If Your Honor, please.

213
00:50:46,830 --> 00:50:48,230
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, Honorable Diokno.

214
00:50:48,330 --> 00:51:21,660
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I was questioning the relevance of the line of questioning of the Good Counsel. He responded by saying that it is relevant, but said that... The reason being that money laundering is included in the articles of impeachment, particularly Article 2. Since that is his contention, Your Honor, please may we hold him to that now and may we ask him to show the relevance of this line of questioning by pointing to the allegations of the Article 2 that according to him pertain to money laundering.

215
00:51:21,840 --> 00:51:30,310
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Yes, Your Honor, we will cite the exact page later on but it will preempt our line of questions, Your Honor. We ask for some leave with your honor. And besides,

216
00:51:31,530 --> 00:51:53,690
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Honorable Diokno, again, you have common exhibits coming from AMLC by both the defendant and the prosecution, which is the proper subject matter of this witness to testify on. Again, if he is going to be qualified as an expert. May the court ask again, are you willing to stipulate as to his...

217
00:51:56,010 --> 00:52:03,950
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Expertise on the subject matter. Again, Honorable Diokno, without conceding that what he will say will be the truth and is accurate and is legal and correct. Subject to cross.

218
00:52:04,790 --> 00:52:12,270
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Inasmuch as I would like to facilitate the proceedings, Your Honor, I am not in a position to make any such stipulation at this point.

219
00:52:12,330 --> 00:52:14,270
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Then we will listen to the seminars he attended.

220
00:52:14,750 --> 00:52:15,550
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Very well, Your Honor.

221
00:52:16,870 --> 00:52:18,150
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Attorney Mark, you may proceed.

222
00:52:18,430 --> 00:52:31,650
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Let's move on. Sorry for that interruption, Attorney Dela Fuente. You also worked for APECO. Can you tell us more about APECO and your duties and responsibilities with this organization?

223
00:52:32,050 --> 00:53:02,680
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: For APECO, your honor, Aurora Pacific Economic Zone Authority, same with CEZA. They have the same requirement during that time, crafting their supervisory framework, helping them how to perform their function, forming their own AML department. So, yan ang aking naging role sa kanila, setting up their AML group. So, I think it's for only one year or one and a half year lang po.

224
00:53:02,860 --> 00:53:14,580
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. By the way, what other accountancy associations or institutions are you affiliated with? And what are your roles and positions in these associations or institutions, if any?

225
00:53:16,010 --> 00:53:42,690
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: As a CPA, we're part of the Philippine Institute of Certified Public Accountants. And from time to time, when I ventured into AML practice, they do invite me as their resource speaker or subject matter expert for AML. Kasi ang profession ng CPAs ngayon, covered na rin ng AMLA. So pagdating sa ganitong mga sessions, ako ang nagpa-facilitate.

226
00:53:43,290 --> 00:53:53,790
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. What other law-related associations or institutions are you affiliated with and what are your roles and positions in such associations or institutions, if any?

227
00:53:54,090 --> 00:54:38,730
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Currently, Your Honor, sa IBP. I have yet to be invited by IBP for AML-related trainings. But other associations, yung ating mga covered persons. Sa mga banko, RBAP, Rural Bankers Association of the Philippines, they have invited me to speak before them for AML matters. Association po ng mga non-bank financial institutions, yung PAFERA, Philippine Association for Foreign Exchange Dealers and Remittance Agents. Sa real estate din ho, yung SHDA, Subdivision in Housing Development Association. So they do top me as their resource speaker pagdating sa mga ganitong AML matters.

228
00:54:39,330 --> 00:54:49,270
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Marami na po tayong na-discuss na roles niyo sa education and professional experience as well. But what awards and citations can you share with us, if any?

229
00:54:49,810 --> 00:55:20,990
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, individual awards, Your Honor. Wala ho. Kasi nung ako ay nasa gobyerno na Agency-based awards. But when I ventured into private sector, again, ito kung when they do invite me as their resource speaker, Arbap, Seda, local and international, those recognitions ang binavalyo ko po the most. So it's not the trophies but the recognition about my competence and experience that what matters to me po.

230
00:55:21,250 --> 00:55:29,750
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you for that. Meron pa po ba kayong any significant role or na hindi pa natin natalakay? Or any organization that you are part of?

231
00:55:29,890 --> 00:55:31,390
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: More or less, yun na po yun.

232
00:55:31,470 --> 00:56:26,790
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: More or less, Your Honor, yun na po. Lately, dun 2025 po, I was invited by an international organization, a non-profit organization, Traffic International, to help them in coming up with a paper. Using financial investigation in tackling illegal wildlife trade or environmental crimes. So it started with a research paper and then later on that research paper, naging libro po and we use it to train law enforcement agencies here in the Philippines and also the private sector to combat illegal wildlife trade. So nung hung nag-start siya 2024, 2025, we did a trading caravan and this year po. Meron kami noong April and next week meron kami noong November. So it will involve the public and private sector.

233
00:56:27,170 --> 00:56:48,250
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. So you mentioned that you are an author. Can you tell us about your participation in the publication of this book that you brought, Anti-Money Laundering Handbook? Can you please, very briefly, can you please tell us what this book is all about? And also ask my assisting counsel to make him identify it.

234
00:56:54,540 --> 00:57:13,460
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay. So, Your Honor, last July of 2025, we were able to come up with this practical handbook entitled Financial Investigation and Anti-Money Laundering Guidelines to Tackle Wildlife and Environmental Crime in the Philippines. So I am—I was the lead author, with me Mr. Ben Brock and Mr. Serene Chng.

235
00:57:13,710 --> 00:57:49,640
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: This book is supported by the US Department of State and Bureau of International Narcotics and The purpose is to give a practical handbook sa ating hong Philippine law enforcement agencies so far as doing their financial investigations. So I use my experience in crafting this. The purpose is to adopt follow the money principles in conducting investigations. Hindi ko kasi matitigil ang ganito mga krimen kung hindi natin

236
00:57:51,680 --> 00:58:20,880
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Pipigilan yung pera. Yun ang source ng motivation why these crimes still proliferate and we hit the criminals where it hurts them the most. Dito ay sa kanilang financial aspect. Ang purpose nito is not to compel or force law enforcement agencies to adopt whatever is on this book but to give them an insight. Ano ba ang best practices na ginagawa?

237
00:58:22,340 --> 00:58:30,560
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: ng ating financial intelligence unit, ng ating financial investigator, which is the AMLC, pagdating po sa mga ganitong krimen.

238
00:58:30,650 --> 00:58:42,090
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: At this point, Your Honor, may we request that the court's copy of this document be marked as our exhibit accordingly, considering that he already identified the same in open court at the proper time.

239
00:58:42,280 --> 00:58:42,620
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: So marked.

240
00:58:44,240 --> 00:58:51,860
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: All right. There is another publication here entitled Operational Issues, Financial Investigations Guidance. Can you tell us what

241
00:58:52,280 --> 00:58:55,120
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Your role is or how you use this in your practice?

242
00:58:57,140 --> 00:59:49,420
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay. Your Honor, ito pong FATF report dated June of 2012 entitled Operational Issues on Financial Investigations Guidance. Ito yung aming ginagamit insofar nung ako ay ginagawa ang libro na ito. Ito ang aking naging basis in aligning. Itong libro na ito, with the internationally accepted standards, which is again promulgated by the Financial Action Task Force, FATF. Again, hindi ho ito yung strict rules, but these are merely recommendations, guidance, from the international bodies setting the standards to combat money laundering. So we aligned the book with this FATF report.

243
00:59:54,570 --> 01:00:02,560
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: It's entitled Regulatory Issues No. 2. Can you share us more about this? and so far as your goal that you discussed.

244
01:00:03,700 --> 01:00:54,280
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay, ito kong makapal na dokumento composed of 200 pages. We call this the GoTRACS. Ito ho ay ang Guidelines on Transaction Reporting and Compliance Submission. It was, again, Regulations No. 2 Series of 2024. Ito ho yung mga regulasyon. Sa pagre-report, pagsasubmit ng mga covered and suspicious transaction reports sa ating AMLC. Akin lamang po itong sinama sa aking submission kasi ito yung ating magiging basis later on kung ang tanong ay mapunta sa pag-interpret ko ng mga CTRs and STRs. Ito yung governing rule right now.

245
01:00:55,480 --> 01:01:15,820
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: At this point, Your Honor, we also request that the documents identified by the witness also be marked accordingly at the proper time. All right. Maraming salamat, Atty. Dela Fuente. You've already shared a lot about your educational and professional background. But please tell us, what is your passion with regard to your accountancy and law practice?

246
01:01:17,020 --> 01:01:22,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, nung hong ako ay nasa accountancy practice talaga, tax. Huwag na talaga ang aking

247
01:01:23,160 --> 01:01:38,720
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Focus. That's the reason why I applied with the Bureau of Internal Revenue to gain knowledge, apply my tax, gain real world tax experience, how to audit. Pagdating naman sa aking law practice, again, hindi ko hupilano kung saan ako dadalhin.

248
01:01:40,900 --> 01:01:51,800
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Nakapunta ako sa AMLC Secretariat and yung aking trabaho doon lumapit na sa aking puso. Yun na ang naging advocacy ko.

249
01:01:52,100 --> 01:01:58,000
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi ko rin inakala na dito ako dadalhin sa ganitong klaseng practice. Dito kasi sa

250
01:01:58,430 --> 01:02:06,670
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ito ang AML practice. So I tried to focus on this one.

251
01:02:06,910 --> 01:02:11,810
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you. What is your hope in terms of uplifting the accountancy and legal profession?

252
01:02:12,700 --> 01:02:22,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, number one po ano, ito hung AML practice again. Ngayon ho, just sharing, sa

253
01:02:23,040 --> 01:02:43,260
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa aming opisina, meron na rin mga eskwelahan, ating mga top schools and state universities and colleges na nagbibigay ng partner kami sa kanila to give internship program. So we expose them na meron another opportunity and that is AML practice. So

254
01:02:43,260 --> 01:03:04,930
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: by sharing this with students, future lawyers, future accountants, we are giving them Opening to them new opportunities for practice that they can apply here or even gain employment abroad. And while doing that, we also instill to them integrity and independence.

255
01:03:05,570 --> 01:03:14,090
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you po for generously sharing your background, Atty. Dela Fuente. Now, please allow us to ask, what political affiliations do you have, if any?

256
01:03:15,190 --> 01:03:18,530
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: None, Your Honor. Unfortunately, starting

257
01:03:18,530 --> 01:03:21,010
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2019, hindi na ako nakaboto.

258
01:03:21,380 --> 01:03:32,880
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And to obviate the need of any cross-examination on this point, let me just ask you a more pointed question. What is your personal or professional affiliation with the Vice President, if any?

259
01:03:33,520 --> 01:03:34,280
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: None, Your Honor.

260
01:03:34,540 --> 01:03:47,320
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: All right. Considering the discussion, Your Honor, the lengthy discussion on the experience and expertise of the witness, may we be now allowed to proceed with propounding questions in relation to this case, Your Honor?

261
01:03:47,740 --> 01:03:50,060
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You may proceed, Counsel. Again, subject to cross.

262
01:03:51,930 --> 01:05:07,950
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. So, to set forth the framework, Attorney Dela Fuente, let me direct your attention to Section 2 of the Anti-Money Laundering Act of 2001 as amended. Let me read. It is hereby declaration of policy. It is hereby declared the policy of the state to protect and preserve the integrity and confidentiality of bank accounts and to ensure that the Philippines shall not be used as a money laundering site. for the proceeds of any unlawful activity. Consistent with its foreign policy, the State shall extend cooperation in transnational investigations and prosecutions of persons involved in money laundering activities wherever committed, as well as in the implementation of targeted financial sanctions related to the financing of the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction terrorism and financing of terrorism pursuant to the resolution of the United Nations Security Council. My question is this. As a financial investigator, how important is it to protect and preserve the integrity and confidentiality of bank accounts?

263
01:05:08,790 --> 01:05:39,660
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Napakahalaga po, Your Honor. Ang banko ang ating gateway sa ating financial system. The system only works if the accounts Maintain their integrity. Paano pong i-maintain ng integrity? Number one, ensure that only those accounts funded by clean sources should be opened and maintained. Number two, these accounts are also protected from arbitrary state intrusion. So, again, this is based on those principles. Kaya ho, kapaka-importante.

264
01:05:39,840 --> 01:05:52,640
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: At the same time, ayaw naman po natin i-promote yung unlawful activity. So, where do you strike the balance between Preserving confidentiality on one hand and investigating unlawful activity on the other.

265
01:05:53,170 --> 01:06:09,590
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, under the AMLA, Your Honor, there are safeguards provided by the law to ensure na we run after the criminals without sacrificing the individual rights ng account holder. So there are safeguards, Your Honor.

266
01:06:09,810 --> 01:06:14,850
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now the law also mentions the term unlawful activity very briefly.

267
01:06:15,080 --> 01:06:17,140
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Kindly explain this concept of unlawful activity

268
01:06:17,390 --> 01:06:19,990
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Unlawful activity as provided under the law.

269
01:06:20,070 --> 01:06:48,550
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Under the AMLA, Your Honor, these unlawful activities, ito ay meron lamang tayong 36 na unlawful activities provided under Section 3 of the AMLA. So these are, well, crimes that has possible linkage po. Again, may financial aspect po. May linkage to A monetary instrument or property that can be used.

270
01:06:49,540 --> 01:06:57,620
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, talking about confidentiality, let me direct your attention to exhibits D-2-2 and D-2-1.

271
01:06:59,430 --> 01:08:21,330
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, in the interest of time, I'll just read the title and some highlighted portions. It says here, BSP AMLC deny releasing alleged Duterte bank account documents. And there's a highlighted portion there that says Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas or BSP and the Anti-Money Laundering Council are not the source of the documents and information being cited by a vice presidential candidate. And the D-2-1 says here AMLC official statement. Let me read that highlighted portion. We have categorically stated before That the Anti-Money Laundering Council is not the source of the documents and information attached by Senator Antonio F. Trillanes IV in his complaint regarding the alleged bank accounts of President Rodrigo Duterte. It has neither provided the Office of the Ombudsman with any report as a consequence of any investigation of subject accounts for any purpose. Now, by the way, Atty. Dela Fuente, you can answer based on the factual milieu of this case or in general. But my question is this, what is the propriety or impropriety for that matter of a third person requesting data and information from the AMLC?

272
01:08:23,950 --> 01:08:35,730
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: A third person, Your Honor? Again, under Section 8-A, on information security and dissemination, only authorized government...

273
01:08:37,000 --> 01:08:40,440
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: or even the courts can have access over this information.

274
01:08:41,460 --> 01:08:53,150
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Wala hong mention nun of any other person or any other institution that should have access over this confidential information.

275
01:08:53,690 --> 01:09:14,820
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: If your honor please, again I am very sorry to interrupt but I would have to object to the testimony and have it stricken off the record based on its irrelevance. Senator Trillanes was not a witness before this court and we have not presented any evidence emanating from him before this impeachment court.

276
01:09:15,460 --> 01:09:34,060
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I'll allow it, counsel. Subject to cross later on should you desire to do so because it was placed on record that there was an intention to so present him only that the schedules did not permit it and later on it was withdrawn. Let it remain in the record. Objection overruled. Attorney Mark, you may proceed.

277
01:09:34,550 --> 01:10:54,790
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you for that, Your Honor. Now, let me direct your attention to Exhibit P-2-9-2 pertaining to an alleged forensic examination report of a certain attorney Cabrera, a so-called forensic expert. I'll read the second paragraph of the introduction. It says here, The work performed involved analyzing documents that were made available to the undersigned. Pursuant to the subpoenas issued by the Senate Impeachment Court, such as the VP SALN for the years 2022 to 2025, reports from AMLC, the income tax returns filed by the VP and her spouse, the bank statements and bank records, investments they made, the financial statements of corporations they have an interest, and documents filed by the corporations with the SEC. Aside from this statement, this so-called expert also admitted in open court that it was the prosecution, not the Senate Impeachment Court, that gave him access to AMLC reports, among other documents. My question is this. What is the propriety of a third person, such as this so-called expert, accessing and analyzing reports from the AMLC?

278
01:10:58,430 --> 01:11:23,010
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Under the AMLA, Section 8-A on Information Security and Confidentiality, this role of doing financial investigation in relation to Section 7 is expressly reserved to our AMLC, the Anti-Money Laundering Council.

279
01:11:27,390 --> 01:11:55,110
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: AMLC. Among those, again, relevant to the question, it is our central AMLC-FT authority, our only financial intelligence unit, and sila lang ho ang investigador pagdating sa money laundering and terrorist financing cases. So, other than those three enumerated, I have no other information kung pwede ba itong i-allow sa iba outside the AMLC.

280
01:11:55,370 --> 01:13:36,310
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you for that. Now, para lang po maliwanag kung bakit natin pinapag-usapan yung AMLC, money laundering, unlawful activity, at iba pa, let me direct your attention to page 14 of the Articles of Impeachment and I'll read the relevant portion. Relevantly, the investigation reports from the AMLC on respondent and her spouse indicate that the bank transactions involving their bank accounts may have been involved in predicate offenses of money laundering. Particularly, A, drug trafficking and related offenses, B, graft and corrupt practices, and C, malversation of public funds. Ulitin ko lang po yung charges. Ito rin po kasi yung response ko sa query ni Representative Diokno kanina. So, in fairness to the prosecution, they used the term, and I quote, may have been involved in predicate offenses of money laundering. Okay. So, Atty. Dela Fuente, the Filipino people want to know the truth. The prosecution is now accusing VP Sara over 800 plus million in unexplained wealth based on the findings of a so-called forensic analyst who, according to him, has a room full of awards and citations. However, the articles of impeachment merely indicates, and I quote, may have been involved. In predicate offenses. My question is this. Based on your knowledge and experience as a financial investigator, how important is it to be certain with accusations of unlawful activity and or money laundering?

281
01:13:36,650 --> 01:14:15,810
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Objection, Your Honor. The question is misleading. The quoted portion may have been involved in predicate offenses. It's not part of the substantive charges that are pending before this court. The main issues that are before this court are number one, whether there is unexplained wealth on the part of the respondent. Number two, whether she did not declare certain assets and net worth in her SALNs. And number three, whether or not she participated in business. And I believe that is very clear to everyone. The question is an attempt to mislead not only this court but to the public as well.

282
01:14:18,230 --> 01:14:18,950
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Attorney Mark?

283
01:14:19,090 --> 01:14:25,010
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: No further comment. If the court will already rule, we can move on. Anyway, Your Honor, it's in the court's record in the articles of impeachment.

284
01:14:25,470 --> 01:15:10,310
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, Honorable Chel, the prosecution took pains at presenting an AMLC witness and also various, numerous AMLC documents to support their allegation under Article 2. I think it's too late in the day to say that it is... Irrelevant to comment on or for a witness to testify on AMLC documents. I just don't know to what extent Attorney Rainer can testify given his statement that in his opinion, citing 8A, third parties including him, I guess, cannot actually look at it himself as well. So, let's see where this will go. Let's see where this will go, Attorney, Honorable Chel. You may proceed, Attorney Mark. Do you want

285
01:15:10,310 --> 01:15:11,070
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: to repeat the question?

286
01:15:11,510 --> 01:15:25,050
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: There's a hanging question. My only question is, based on your knowledge and experience as a financial investigator, how important is it to be certain with the accusations of unlawful activity and or money laundering?

287
01:15:25,710 --> 01:16:04,170
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Very important, Your Honor. The predicate offense or the unlawful activity, yan ho ay isa sa mga elemento ng money laundering under Section 4 ng batas. Hindi ho mag-proceed sa money laundering if the predicate offense Something unlawful, something illegal that happened first. It's very critical. We have to remember money laundering is a derivative offense. It cannot happen on its own. It has to depend on a prior or previous unlawful activity. Isa ko nga dapat yun sa 1 out of the 36 enumerated sa Section 3 ng batas.

288
01:16:05,000 --> 01:16:34,100
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Let's see kung ano ba yung money laundering accusation against VP Sara. Let me direct your attention to section 4 and you already mentioned this just for the sake of helping our senator judges and the public understand this matter. Section 4, money laundering offense. Money laundering is committed by any person who, knowing that any monetary instrument or property represents, involves, or relates to the proceeds of any unlawful activity, transacts said money

289
01:16:34,980 --> 01:17:59,920
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: monetary instrument or property letter B converts transfers disposes of moves acquires possesses or uses said monetary instrument or property C conceals or disguises the true nature source location disposition movement or ownership of or rights with respect to said monetary instrument or property D. attempts or conspires to commit money laundering offenses referred to in paragraphs A, B, or C. E. Aids, abets, assists in or counsels the commission of the money laundering offenses referred to in paragraphs A, B, or C above. And F. Performs or fails to perform any act as a result of which he facilitates the offense of money laundering referred to in paragraphs A, B, or C above. Money laundering is also committed by Any covered person who, knowing that a covered or suspicious transaction is required under this act to be reported to the Anti-Money Laundering Council fails to do so. So just like the prosecution, we are also guessing kung alin ba dito sa list na ito yung specific charge against VP Sara. So I'll just ask this question. In layman's terms, Attorney Dela Fuente, based on the provision that we just read, please distinguish unlawful activity on one hand. From money laundering offense on the other hand. I know you already alluded to this earlier.

290
01:18:00,400 --> 01:18:07,960
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: So again, the predicate crime or the unlawful activity is the triggering event. It

291
01:18:07,960 --> 01:18:23,400
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: will trigger if the investigation would proceed to money laundering. Again, derivative offense ko kasi ang money laundering. If there's no unlawful activity, no predicate crime that happened, then money laundering has no leg to stand on.

292
01:18:24,220 --> 01:18:46,960
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, let's move on. Let me direct your attention to section 6 of the AMLA. It says your prosecution of money laundering. A. Any person may be charged with and convicted of both the offense of money laundering and the unlawful activity as herein defined. And B. The prosecution of any offense or violation under this act shall proceed independently.

293
01:18:48,060 --> 01:19:02,580
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: any proceeding relating to the unlawful activity. So let's talk about the details later on, Attorney Dela Fuente. But generally, how does the prosecution of the unlawful activity aspect relate to the prosecution of the money

294
01:19:02,900 --> 01:19:13,780
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor, it can proceed independently. Maaari siyang magtuloy-tuloy hanggat they are independent from one another.

295
01:19:14,800 --> 01:19:36,560
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: So, para lang po malinaw sa lahat, dalawang aspeto po kasi ito. Yung unlawful activity aspect, yung pinapaliwanag nyo kanina sa isang banda, at yung money laundering aspect naman po sa kabilang banda. And yung unlawful activity, you also may already mentioned na ito po yung may 36 na halimbawa under sa batas. Tama po?

296
01:19:36,740 --> 01:19:37,280
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, sir.

297
01:19:37,320 --> 01:20:14,860
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: 36. And then, based on what we read earlier, The alleged unlawful activity or predicate crime being charged against VP are, and I quote maybe, number one, drugs, number two, graft and corruption, and number three, malversation of public funds. Yung alleged drugs, wala namang witness. Yung alleged graft and corruption and malversation of public funds, withdrawn na. My only question is this. Again, you can answer based on the factual milieu po of this case or in general. How do you characterize the strength of allegations that have already been withdrawn?

298
01:20:17,090 --> 01:20:20,690
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Objection, Your Honor. The witness would not be competent to answer that question.

299
01:20:21,210 --> 01:20:21,230
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: If he knows, Your Honor.

300
01:20:21,290 --> 01:20:22,010
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: If he knows.

301
01:20:23,180 --> 01:20:24,220
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Attorney Rainer, if he knows.

302
01:20:24,560 --> 01:20:29,660
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: How would you characterize yung strength po o yung lakas ng allegation kapag winithdraw na po?

303
01:20:30,570 --> 01:20:42,650
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, I leave it to the sound wisdom, sound discretion of the Honorable Impeachment Court. How would they assess the strength or the weakness? or the fact that it was withdrawn. So I leave it to the wisdom po.

304
01:20:42,810 --> 01:20:49,630
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you. Now let me show you a video and then ask you thereafter. Your Honor, this video is unmarked but

305
01:20:49,630 --> 01:20:58,060
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: we reserve the right to mark it at the proper time. This is around 7 minutes, Your Honor, so we beg the court's indulgence. If we

306
01:20:58,060 --> 01:20:59,680
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: may be allowed to play, Your Honor.

307
01:20:59,940 --> 01:21:01,960
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Before the video is played, Honorable Chell?

308
01:21:02,300 --> 01:21:14,250
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Yes, I see from the caption that the video pertains to statements made by the late... Sen. Miriam Defensor-Santiago. I believe that would pertain to the corona impeachment trial.

309
01:21:14,690 --> 01:21:15,390
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: That's correct.

310
01:21:15,750 --> 01:21:25,850
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Yes, then I would have to object, Your Honor, because the circumstances pertaining to that trial are different in terms of the withdrawal to this trial and the situation here.

311
01:21:26,110 --> 01:21:27,150
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: I have no question yet.

312
01:21:27,150 --> 01:21:28,990
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We are aware of that, counsel.

313
01:21:30,850 --> 01:21:42,880
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Again, subject to cross insofar as pointing that out is concerned. Is there a shorter version of this, Attorney Mark? I distinctly remember actually what Senator Miriam said.

314
01:21:43,060 --> 01:21:48,500
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Well, we will ask a certain portion of that material, Your Honor, if you may be allowed to.

315
01:21:48,660 --> 01:21:53,920
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, when you get to that point, you can pause it already.

316
01:21:54,160 --> 01:21:54,740
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you, Your Honor.

317
01:21:55,620 --> 01:21:57,240
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Tech is instructed to play the video.

318
01:22:02,870 --> 01:22:52,620
Video Playback Narration: ...factor that prevents you from presenting your evidence that you already said to us in January you were going to present. Letter C, is merely corroborative or cumulative. This does not apply because when you file an impeachment complaint, you have different articles of impeachment which are separate from and independent of each other. So none of these articles of impeachment, just like causes of action in a civil case, are said to be cumulative or corroborative. Cumulative means you already produced evidence in the form of one witness and you just want to add, let's say, ten more witnesses to completely repeat what that other witness said. That is corroborative. Kaya, Kung corroborative lang ito mismo, pwedeng hindi mo na ipresenta. Eto naman, hindi corroborative eh. Because they are separate and distinct articles of impeachment. And letter D, the Supreme Court.

319
01:24:38,400 --> 01:24:45,660
Video Playback Narration: Maaga pa, what are you, conducting trial by publicity? Is that what you're trying to do? We will not be swayed.

320
01:24:47,380 --> 01:25:10,340
Video Playback Narration: The entire capacity for tsunami waves by Manila Bay can fall over this impeachment court and will not be affected. by what you say in the public or what your chosen public brings back to you, particularly if they've been paid to do so. Please, do not try these little dirty tricks on us. We're all old people here.

321
01:25:11,990 --> 01:25:14,770
Video Playback Narration: Tumanda na tayo lahat sa politika. Huwag nyo kaming ginaganyan, ha?

322
01:25:18,080 --> 01:25:35,630
Video Playback Narration: Kamukha ng survey, just as I predicted. Aba, may balita kanina sa isang dyaryo ng survey daw sa UP. Five hundred ang respondents. Like, 75% of them said, no, we no longer trust the Chief Justice. Kayong mga UP kayo, dapat kayo i-kick out immediately.

323
01:25:37,330 --> 01:26:16,970
Video Playback Narration: If you are true, actual person, you should be kicked out immediately. Because you do not deserve to be in UP, and the people who machinated the publication of that press release should likewise be kicked out of UP. If they're enrolled in the roles of the university as alumni, They should be permanently erased from the rolls as a perpetual shame on the university. Pero mo, may survey daw sila na 500 katao sa UP nagsabi ng Chief Justice so far because of the prosecution evidence can no longer be trusted. Ang

324
01:26:18,510 --> 01:26:52,720
Video Playback Narration: taas-taas naman ang pagtingin ng tao sa UP, pagkatapos 500 lang out of let us say 50 million all over the Philippines and it's not even conducted on scientific basis. It's not conducted by any of those. Reliable survey firms that have already been proven in their forecast for election results. Kanya-kanya lang sila. Grabe! My goodness me! If I were, the symbol of UP is standing there, naked, called the Oblation, I would immediately throw away my fig leaf.

325
01:26:56,080 --> 01:27:00,880
Video Playback Narration: Wag na tayong magtago-tago pa. Eh kagaguhan lang naman palang pinapag-aralan sa UP kung ganyan.

326
01:27:01,220 --> 01:27:23,620
Video Playback Narration: I cannot imagine a survey where 500 High IQ people will say we have already lost trust in the Chief Justice because we have already heard the evidence from the prosecution although we admit that the defense has not yet presented its case. Grabe naman, sino namang PR firm nag-isip nito? Sabihin lang ninyo, [unclear].

327
01:27:25,240 --> 01:27:27,660
Video Playback Narration: You are playing games. I

328
01:27:28,080 --> 01:27:41,660
Video Playback Narration: was not born yesterday. I was born a long time ago and I'm about to die. I want to leave a legacy that at least When presented with this anomaly in trial technique, I rose to condemn it.

329
01:27:42,260 --> 01:27:43,480
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly pause the video.

330
01:27:46,020 --> 01:27:48,700
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Kindly pause the video. We can pause there, Your Honor.

331
01:27:49,040 --> 01:27:51,840
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Thank you. Mr. Presiding Officer, we'd just like to ask...

332
01:27:51,840 --> 01:27:54,180
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: What is the pleasure of the Honorable Tulfo Erwin?

333
01:27:54,260 --> 01:27:59,720
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: I have a question. What is the relevance of all this, Mr. Presiding Officer?

334
01:27:59,780 --> 01:28:01,720
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I was about, before you...

335
01:28:01,720 --> 01:28:22,300
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: I mean, and then we're like watching a movie. And then another thing. Pagpahingahin na po natin yung namayapa. That is a different case. This is a different case. This is a different set of senators. Diba rin po yung sinaunang panahon. I really do not understand. Why are we watching this?

336
01:28:22,680 --> 01:28:46,530
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I was about to pause it as well when you raised your hand, Honorable Tulfo. I would have to agree, Attorney Mark. And I think you also said you can pause already at this juncture. I think we've heard enough with respect to the video you wanted to present. Move on to that point or to your next point. But before that, the Honorable Lacson is recognized.

337
01:28:48,350 --> 01:29:05,170
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson: In support of the observation of Senator Judge Tulfo, hindi ko po makita yung significance ng opinion ng one of the 24 senator judges in the 2011 impeachment trial of the... Late Justice Corona.

338
01:29:06,540 --> 01:29:10,080
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We note the manifestation of V. Lacson as well and the

339
01:29:10,080 --> 01:29:16,160
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Chair agrees. As the Chair earlier ruled, move on to your next point, Atty. Mark.

340
01:29:16,320 --> 01:29:26,080
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: I'll just move on to my next point, Your Honor. Similar to the previous impeachment, the prosecution withdrew charges against respondent accused, including

341
01:29:26,080 --> 01:29:43,230
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: those on alleged malversation of confidential funds and bribery, as mentioned. My question is this. In relation to investigating the money laundering aspect, what is the effect if the charges for the predicate crime or unlawful activity have already been withdrawn?

342
01:29:44,410 --> 01:29:50,990
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Objection, Your Honor. Again, the question is misleading. The respondent is not being charged with money laundering in this case.

343
01:29:51,430 --> 01:29:54,490
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: If he knows, Your Honor. Anyway, it's there in the articles of impeachment.

344
01:29:55,600 --> 01:30:00,180
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Attorney Mark, the Chair has given you enough

345
01:30:00,180 --> 01:30:49,440
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: leeway already on this aspect. But I have to cite and state that the Honorable Diokno is correct. AMLC or violation of the AMLC is not per se part of the charge in Article 2. Although it is mentioned in pages 12 and 14 of the Articles of Impeachment, as the Chair stated earlier, it was merely being cited as the basis, as evidence. of the supposed unexplained or ill-gotten wealth. But there is no specific charge. Neither is there any issue that this court will rule upon in regard to any purported violation of the anti-money laundering law. But if you will proceed to attack it on the basis of AMLC records being used as evidence, then perhaps you can...

346
01:30:50,160 --> 01:31:16,500
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Do so. But allow the Chair to be clear. The Honorable Diokno is correct. There is no charge, neither will the court vote on any purported violation of the anti-money laundering law committed by the Vice President. It was only being cited to prove Article 2 on ill-gotten and unexplained wealth. Before I recognize Attorney Mark, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Alan?

347
01:31:17,140 --> 01:31:19,340
Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano: May I interject on this topic?

348
01:31:19,340 --> 01:31:19,840
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You may do so,

349
01:31:20,100 --> 01:31:20,720
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Your Honor. You may proceed.

350
01:31:20,740 --> 01:31:47,400
Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano: Mr. Presiding Officer, dear colleagues, Mr. Senate President, in general, I agree with the ruling and observation of the Presiding Officer. I don’t think there’s a disagreement there, but I’d ask for some latitude for the defense for a simple reason. The prosecution was given so much time presenting grave threats, presenting

351
01:31:49,260 --> 01:33:32,450
Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano: You know, the different articles. As I said last time, to clarify, di ba? I remember nung bata kami, meron yung ano, yung one-inch punch. Yung sabihin kung sinong mas malakas. Tapos pag ikaw unang sumuntok, suntukin mo ng malakas, hindi one-inch malakas. Tapos sabihin, ay, talo ako. So hindi na pwedeng sumuntok yung kabila. So, you know, the prosecution basically presented all their witnesses, evidence. They did it in a... Very professional manner. We don't agree with everything, but they did it. And then they withdrew it. And if you look at the case of Duterte v. H.O.R., and even the previous cases, that's why they said that's a difference between a purely judicial case. It's also a political case. The reputation of a high-ranking official na pwedeng ma-impeach, maging COA yan, maging... Justice ng Supreme Court, maging Chief Justice, maging Presidente and Vice President. May value yan sa ating mga kababayan. So, we can't just, you know, allow the prosecution to present anything they want. Then, pag konting latitude lang sa defense, I don't even think this will take an hour or two. So, hindi na natin sila pinayagan or at least hindi na sila humingi na isa-isa i-rebat yung... Articles na hindi pinakita sa atin. So I fully respect and I think tama naman yung sinabi mo, Mr. Presiding Officer, in a purely legal, di ba, na ito pwede mo i-prove at hindi. Pero this is also a political proceeding. You know, it's not only a matter of what's the judgment, conviction or...

352
01:33:34,020 --> 01:34:24,420
Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano: It's also whether the people will accept the judgment. And then if the defense is not given a chance to somehow even collaterally to address the issues that were brought up before. So if this is something that was brought up sa media only. I agree with everyone here. Sa media nyo nasagutin, sa defense. But we all know na meron witnesses dito na dinala from AMLC. Alam natin na diniscuss yung bank records, credit card records, etc. So, I submit to you, Mr. Presiding Officer, but I just appeal for a little bit of leeway for them to be able to serve their client well by being able to present their defense. Thank you, Mr. President.

353
01:34:24,420 --> 01:34:51,240
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Noted, Honorable Alan Cayetano. We are not stopping or preventing Attorney Mark from doing so, but only establishing the guideline that he does not need to defend his client against a charge of violation of the AMLC. There is no such charge. Although AMLC was used as basis to prove or supposedly to prove ill-gotten and or unexplained wealth, he can go to that at any point in time.

354
01:34:53,970 --> 01:35:06,590
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: But to clarify, they are not defending their client against a charge for violating the anti-money laundering law. No such allegation is contained in the articles of impeachment.

355
01:35:06,950 --> 01:35:08,310
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, Senator Judge Alan?

356
01:35:09,170 --> 01:35:10,510
Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano: Mr. President, that's what

357
01:35:10,510 --> 01:36:49,040
Sen. Alan Peter Cayetano: I'm saying, Mr. Presiding Officer. That's very technical. Hindi naman technical ang ating mga kababayan. So, when we have the anti-money laundering representative here, He presented evidence na kaya nga kinuha yung mga ibang documents kasi yung mga bangko naglagay kung bakit nila flinag yung ibang mga account. Tapos pag tinignan mo naman yung report ng mga bangko, ito ay mga newspaper clippings. So what I'm saying is that as far as people are concerned, whether it's a charge against the anti-money laundering law, whether it's the predicate crime, whether it's ill-gotten wealth, Sa atin mga abogado, that's a fine line that we understand. But to the public, katulad ko po, hindi naman ako nag-practice ng law in that regard, napaka-importante na may konting latitude naman yung defense na ipakita. Kasi for me, if they fail to show, then I'll still consider the evidence, even if winidraw nyo na yung... Yung articles na yun. Kasi it's still part of this article now eh. Whether nga may ill-gotten wealth or not. But if they present their evidence well and then it shows na mukhang napolitika lang yung pati yung AMLC. So, I'm not disagreeing with you, Mr. President, per se. I'm just saying na if we can be less technical. But I go with your ruling that Make the point, then move on. We shouldn't dwell on it, but we should also give them a little bit of latitude, Mr. President.

358
01:36:49,140 --> 01:37:33,130
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We have been, Senator Judge Alan, and it's not, the court is not trying to prevent counsel, simply trying to guide him to go directly to the point, so as also not to waste the court's time on defending the Vice President on charges that are not there. And thirdly, insofar as the article's withdrawn, There is a proper time and procedure for that as well which the presiding officer intimated to the respondents already which is either during their formal offer they can make a tender of excluded evidence for if at all those articles that were withdrawn which I will allow and or number two during the closing argument. So that time would be available for the respondent at the appropriate opportunity. You may proceed, Attorney Mark.

359
01:37:33,330 --> 01:37:33,690
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Yes, Your Honor.

360
01:37:33,750 --> 01:37:36,730
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We are willing to proceed at this point, but just a short manifestation.

361
01:37:37,210 --> 01:37:38,190
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, of course, Attorney Mark.

362
01:37:38,490 --> 01:37:52,550
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Your Honor, we are not actually talking about withdrawn charges. The paragraph that I read actually pertains to Article 2 of the impeachment, so it's there. So I don't understand why we cannot confront this issue head-on.

363
01:37:53,560 --> 01:37:55,820
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: With the way that we deem fit, Your Honor. But

364
01:37:56,400 --> 01:38:28,440
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We're allowing it, Attorney Mark, as I said, only that to clarify, there is no charge and you need not defend your client against a charge for violating the anti-money laundering. But that, as I said, money laundering documents, AMLC documents were presented to prove the Article 2 allegation of the prosecution. And we will allow you to do that and to utilize the expertise of this witness in order to Prove or disprove any of the points raised by the previous AMLC witness. You may proceed, counsel.

365
01:38:28,640 --> 01:39:24,120
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you, Your Honor. I'll just move on to a new point. Let me direct your attention to the first paragraph under Section 7 of the AMLA, Attorney Dela Fuente. You already mentioned or alluded to this a while ago. It says here, to investigate suspicious transactions and covert transactions deemed suspicious after determination by AMLC. Money laundering activities and or violations of this act. Now, Atty. Dela Fuente, we learned from the presentation of the prosecution that AMLC investigated VP Sara and her husband, Atty. Mans Carpio. May mga report na ipinasas si Executive Director Buenaventura. Again, let's talk about the details later on, but my only question for now is, based on your knowledge and experience as a financial investigator, how active or passive, as the case may be, is the AMLC's role in investigating money laundering activities.

366
01:39:25,020 --> 01:40:03,440
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay, Your Honor. We have to delineate ang role ng AMLC. Under Section 7, they have that role as a financial intelligence unit and financial investigator. Magkaiba ho yung dalawa na iyon. So number one, financial intelligence, they gather, they compile information. which will be shared with other agencies. If meron ng predicate crime, saka lang ho mag-a-activate yung role as, when we say predicate crime, one of the 36, saka lang ho ma-a-activate yung second role, which is financial investigator.

367
01:40:04,180 --> 01:40:13,260
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. One more question on this. Ano po bang nature ng reports na ito, ng mga MLC reports, in terms of confidentiality?

368
01:40:13,530 --> 01:40:35,850
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, these are highly confidential information po ito. The purpose for which it will be used ay nakasulat po doon sa report and also directed doon sa adresi as to the end user of the report. The confidentiality of the report po, it travels with the document, with the information.

369
01:40:36,500 --> 01:41:13,050
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, very well. Now let me direct your attention to section 8 of the AMLA. It says here, creation of a secretariat. The AMLC is hereby authorized to establish a secretariat to be headed by an executive director who shall be appointed by the council for a term of five years. And then it goes on with the rest of the qualifications about the AMLC secretariat. Ulitin ko lang po yung tanong no, but with a slight variation. Based on your knowledge of the law and your experience as a financial investigator naman po, how active or passive is the secretariat's role in investigating money laundering activities?

370
01:41:14,000 --> 01:41:47,620
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Under Section 7, Your Honor, and in relation to Section 8, the AMLC and its relationship with the Secretariat, yung ginagawang pag-iinvestiga, it's part of the day-to-day operations ni AMLC Secretariat. They are expected to receive, analyze, and disseminate financial intelligence. And if there is now a predicate crime, they are mandated to investigate it. Pursue investigation.

371
01:41:48,670 --> 01:42:06,130
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now I just want to highlight this portion of the rules and get your comments. Chapter 2, Rule 5 of the revised Implementing Rules and Regulations of the AMLA as amended. Section 2.4, it says, Unity in all actions. The Council shall act unanimously.

372
01:42:07,180 --> 01:42:11,700
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: in the discharge of its functions. Now, based on your knowledge and experience in

373
01:42:11,700 --> 01:42:18,700
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: AMLC, how does this requirement of unanimity apply in pursuing financial investigations, if at all?

374
01:42:19,410 --> 01:42:30,230
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yung hung mga official resolutions, official documents emanating from the Council should bear all the signatures of the Council members. Dapat ako unanimous ang approval.

375
01:42:30,570 --> 01:43:18,990
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now, just to give context to my next question, We learned from the presentation of the prosecution that C.E.D. Buenaventura appeared before the House Committee on Justice on April 22, 2026 and he disclosed the following. Yung una po, yung summary of covered transaction reports and suspicious transaction reports po ni VP Sara and her husband, Atty. Mans Carpio, for the period of 2006 to 2025. Yung pangalaw po, yung financial intelligence reports on VP Sara. Pangatlo, Investigation Reports on VP Sara and Attorney Manz. So lahat po ito galing sa AMLC. May simple question is this. Generally, what is the nature of the information contained in these documents in terms of confidentiality?

376
01:43:19,230 --> 01:43:24,570
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor, these are confidential information. Items 1, 2, and 3.

377
01:43:25,480 --> 01:43:53,190
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, and let's be more specific po. Yung documents disclosed kasi... Included summary of covered transaction reports or CTRs and suspicious transaction reports for the years 2006 to 2025. So around 19 years for both VP Sara and attorney Manz. Just for clarity, what is the nature of the data and information contained in CTRs and STRs in terms of confidentiality?

378
01:43:53,230 --> 01:44:20,450
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: If your honor, please, I would have to object to this line of questioning. I think it's very clear that this court has... Rejected the claims of confidentiality of the AMLA documents. This court has accepted the documents presented by the Executive Director. And the questions, in fact, pertain to proceedings that took place before the Committee on Justice, not before this court. Therefore, I would have to object to these questions, Your Honor.

379
01:44:20,720 --> 01:44:21,840
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: What is the ground, Your Honor?

380
01:44:21,970 --> 01:44:24,050
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Irrelevant and immaterial, Your Honor, please.

381
01:44:24,470 --> 01:44:25,510
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Comment, Attorney Mark?

382
01:44:25,730 --> 01:44:34,290
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: No further comment, Your Honor. If he knows, Your Honor. Anyway, we're pertaining to a different proceeding, the proceeding of the House Committee on Justice.

383
01:44:35,150 --> 01:44:46,550
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: In the meantime, Attorney, Honorable Chell, I'll allow it. You're on a short leash, Attorney Mark, on the ground cited by the Honorable Chell. Kindly go to your point.

384
01:44:46,750 --> 01:44:48,030
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: One last point on this, Your Honor.

385
01:44:48,250 --> 01:44:52,010
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: What is the pleasure, with your indulgence, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Kiko?

386
01:44:52,630 --> 01:44:57,190
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Yes, Mr. Presiding Officer, just a manifestation that we already

387
01:44:58,400 --> 01:45:08,760
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: this point previously. If they wish to question the ruling of this court, bring it to the Supreme Court. Do not bring it here. So we agree with the Presiding

388
01:45:09,010 --> 01:45:18,300
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: We will not object to his questions but they are on a very short leash, Mr. President.

389
01:45:18,340 --> 01:45:22,640
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you. Duly noted. Attorney Mark, you may proceed.

390
01:45:23,600 --> 01:45:25,200
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: All right. I’ll just move on to a new point.

391
01:45:25,690 --> 01:45:28,960
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I thought you had one more.

392
01:45:28,960 --> 01:45:32,230
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: One more point on this. Of course, we don't want to antagonize also his relationship with the council.

393
01:45:32,250 --> 01:45:37,370
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Short leash means you can still ask one or two questions, counsel. We're not stopping you.

394
01:45:37,450 --> 01:45:52,790
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Because, Your Honor, just to give a context, Your Honor, we are clarifying not just the findings, Your Honor, of unexplained wealth, but also the methodology used. So, in other words, Your Honor, We hope for the court's leeway and indulgence regarding this matter.

395
01:45:52,930 --> 01:46:16,310
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I see your point, Attorney Mark. Without saying it, you're trying to show where the AMLC is coming from and that in what they have done, they might not only have violated the law, but actually may be showing bias in a certain way for or against one side. So again, you're in a short leash, but you're free to ask a couple more questions along this line. Please proceed, Attorney Mark.

396
01:46:16,700 --> 01:46:51,860
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: I will not abuse that leash. I will just move on to a new point. Now, there was a letter from Executive Director Buenaventura to Representative Luistro dated October 1, 2026, where he attached tabular summaries containing confidential data and information on VP Sara and attorney Manz. And these tabular summaries use aggregate amounts, yung total amounts po. My question is this, what is the propriety of aggregating Confidential data from the CTRs and STRs and disclosing them to the public as aggregate amounts.

397
01:46:52,180 --> 01:46:59,860
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Again, Your Honor, I'm sorry to interrupt but I would have to enter a continuing objection to the questions being propounded by the counsel.

398
01:46:59,880 --> 01:47:06,740
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Continuing objection is duly noted for the last few questions of Attorney Mark on this topic. You may proceed.

399
01:47:06,800 --> 01:47:18,800
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: I think I made that clarification that he can answer based on the factual milieu of this case or in general. So if he's not comfortable answering based on the factual milieu, he can just answer in general.

400
01:47:18,920 --> 01:47:23,640
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Court already ruled. We will allow it. Continuing objection is duly noted. Witness may answer.

401
01:47:25,660 --> 01:47:36,460
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: What is the propriety of aggregating amounts, i-process po yung amounts from the CTRs and STRs and then presenting it, disclosing it to the public as aggregate amounts?

402
01:47:38,000 --> 01:48:13,470
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: As I see it, Your Honor, there are two questions. The first one, the propriety of submitting tabulated or summarized CTRs and STRs. So that is still part... Of the AMLC's role as a financial intelligence unit, they have to process raw data so that it will add value to any ongoing investigation. So that's my response to the first question. Second question, Your Honor, the propriety of disclosing

403
01:48:13,470 --> 01:48:18,010
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: them as aggregate amounts without the proper court order.

404
01:48:18,450 --> 01:48:45,960
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay, again, under Section 8-A, there is a second paragraph. Meron hong way, what we call authorized disclosure. But again, it's not an absolute. Under that second paragraph, the AMLC shall formulate rules concerning information exchange and dissemination, including handling, protection, access, and storage of such information.

405
01:48:46,000 --> 01:48:59,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: uh as to how the information should be used and for what purpose

406
01:49:00,230 --> 01:49:04,230
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: With the indulgence of Atty. Mark, what is the pleasure of Sen. Judge Raffy Tulfo?

407
01:49:05,640 --> 01:49:13,340
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Mr. Presiding Officer, we’ve been listening to this witness testimony for the past one and a half hours already, or two hours, as a matter of fact, I believe.

408
01:49:15,450 --> 01:50:21,640
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: And yung purpose na nandito siya is to give his testimony about yung prohibition sa pag-divulge ng mga information, banking information, dahil yun po ay nasa batas natin. At napag-usapan na po natin ito before, RA 1405, in cases of impeachment, kaya exempted ang impeachment court na maghingi ng mga information, whether that would be confidential or whatever it is that you called, Any bank account for that matter ng sino man dito sa impeachment court. So bakit pa natin kailangan itong taon to? I'm sorry, Mr. Witness, I don't have anything against you. I don't have any personal thing about you or against you. Pero hindi ka kailangan dito kung tutusin. Kasi nga po, Mr. Presiding Officer, ilang beses na natin na pag-usapan to na exempted ang impeachment court. So why do we still need his expertise, if that's what you call it? Wait, wait, let me finish. Huwag mo ako interrupt. Huwag mong gayahin ako sa prosecution, okay?

409
01:50:21,840 --> 01:50:22,300
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Please,

410
01:50:22,880 --> 01:51:16,330
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: thank you, thank you, attorney. Kasi nga po, we've spent so much time already. In fact, marami siya mga sinasabi kanina. Sino-showcase yung kanyang background, yung kanyang credentials, etc. And later on, tulad namang nangyari sa mga dating witnesses na, I don't know, nagiging evasive. So I just want to warn this witness kung mamaya pagdating sa interjections, siguraduhin mo lang na the reason why you were called here is to give some opinions or expertise tungkol sa AMLC and money laundering, dapat masagot mo. Dapat hindi ka maging tulad sa mga dating mga witnesses na kung saan palagi naging evasive at umiiwas. Yun lang. And then lastly, alam mo yung ano no, Section 1405? You are aware of that, right? You are a lawyer. An

411
01:51:16,330 --> 01:51:23,810
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: act prohibiting disclosure of or inquiry into deposits with any bank institution and providing penalty thereof. Alam mo yan?

412
01:51:24,180 --> 01:51:24,700
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

413
01:51:24,830 --> 01:51:38,350
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: At alam mo, doon sa provision na yun, nakalagay doon, bawal nga talaga ang mag-disclose ng mga accounts ng banko except in cases of impeachment. Alam mo

414
01:51:38,350 --> 01:51:41,570
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: yan? Thank you. Thank you, Mr. President and Officer.

415
01:51:42,190 --> 01:51:59,720
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you. Note the remarks of Senator Judge Raffy are duly noted. Again, the Counsel for Respondent is winding up. And so far as this topic is concerned, I ask for the indulgence and patience of our colleagues. What is the pleasure of Senator Judge Pia?

416
01:52:00,300 --> 01:52:25,990
Sen. Pia S. Cayetano: Mr. President, just to clarify because... We should be citing the proper laws. What his honor, Senator Tulfo, is citing is the bank secrecy law, not the AMLA. So for the record lang, kasi baka hanapin ng law students, hanapin ng nanonood, wala ho yan sa AMLA. The exception is specifically in the bank secrecy law. Yan lang.

417
01:52:26,920 --> 01:52:29,930
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Note, Senator Judge Raffy is recognized.

418
01:52:33,950 --> 01:52:39,210
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Yes, Mr. President, pero related yan eh. Saka isa pa, quickly.

419
01:52:40,780 --> 01:52:46,520
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Mr. Witness, ikaw ba'y nakapagbuna ng investigation against somebody na may kaso ng money laundering?

420
01:52:47,000 --> 01:52:47,800
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

421
01:52:47,980 --> 01:52:49,580
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Correct. So, alam mo yung procedure?

422
01:52:50,060 --> 01:52:50,880
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

423
01:52:51,180 --> 01:52:56,100
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Na pupunta ka ngayon sa CA para ipa-freeze yung account?

424
01:52:57,000 --> 01:52:58,640
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Pag may investigation po, doon lang.

425
01:52:58,640 --> 01:53:03,660
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Exactly. And then what would you do pag pupunta ka sa CA para mag-present ng...

426
01:53:03,660 --> 01:53:08,920
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: It's an ex parte. There should be first a council authority, council approval.

427
01:53:09,660 --> 01:53:18,000
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Correct. Pero you will be presenting pieces of evidence to justify the reason why you are asking for freezing the account.

428
01:53:18,280 --> 01:53:18,760
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

429
01:53:18,820 --> 01:53:23,420
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you. Duly noted and well taken. Attorney Mark, you may proceed.

430
01:53:25,260 --> 01:53:37,440
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Also, just for the guidance of the Senator, we will try to demonstrate, Your Honor, the relevance as we go along. Yes. We're just setting the precedence for...

431
01:53:38,680 --> 01:53:40,480
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I take this as part of the

432
01:53:40,480 --> 01:53:49,260
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: preliminary, yes, but kindly also take note of the time, Atty. Mark, so that you can pause at the appropriate time of your direct examination for lunch.

433
01:53:49,460 --> 01:53:50,360
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We will do that, Your Honor.

434
01:53:50,440 --> 01:53:51,280
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you. You may proceed, counsel.

435
01:53:51,860 --> 01:54:05,300
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Your Honor, I have another video, Your Honor. Can we just show this video? This is an unmarked exhibit, Your Honor. We just request leeway, Your Honor, considering also that, again, the prosecution spent time.

436
01:54:05,340 --> 01:54:11,300
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: around three months presenting their evidence. We just need several minutes, Your Honor, for the presentation.

437
01:54:11,420 --> 01:54:12,560
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: No, of course, counsel, we're not limiting you.

438
01:54:12,720 --> 01:54:27,140
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: All right. There's this video. We beg the court's indulgence. We are exhibit, this is an unmarked exhibit, but we reserve the right to mark it at the proper time. Can we just play this video? And then we have a relevant question thereafter. Thank you.

439
01:54:30,220 --> 01:54:43,890
Video Playback Narration: Pagpapatalsik ng miyembro ng Korte Suprema. Let alone the Chief Justice. May chilling effect po yan sa Korte Suprema. Kasi mga

440
01:54:45,430 --> 01:55:35,340
Video Playback Narration: tao lang rin po naman kami. At one point po, lalo na po nakita naman ng aking mga kasama sa Korte Suprema kung ano ang ginawa sa akin at yung aking pamilya. Hindi lang po ginamit yung makinarya. Buong makinarya at lakas at poder ng gobyerno laban sa amin. BIR, LRA, AMLC, Ombudsman. Kung ano-ano po. Sabay-sabay po kaming inimbistiga ng BIR. Pati po yung mga anak namin, pati yung mga balain namin na wala naman pong pakialam dito sa impeachment na ito. Wala naman pong kasalanan. Ay pinapuntahan ng BIR.

441
01:55:38,680 --> 01:56:02,700
Video Playback Narration: Yan lang po, isang bahagi lang po yan. Yung pangalawang bahagi po ay at probably mas matindi po. Yung araw-araw na 24-7 magbuhat umaga hanggang gabi, wala na kaming nadinig kundi pang lalait, pang iinsulto, pang alipusta sa aming honor, sa aming pagkatao, sa aming reputasyon. Kung

442
01:56:05,520 --> 01:56:13,170
Video Playback Narration: nalalaman lang po na sana ng mga taong gumawa nito. Yung sakit ng loob na dinulot nila sa amin.

443
01:56:25,100 --> 01:56:26,560
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Counsel? Just

444
01:56:28,060 --> 01:56:28,880
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: a few more minutes, sir.

445
01:56:30,550 --> 01:56:34,730
Video Playback Narration: Chief Justice, are you alright? I thought

446
01:56:34,730 --> 01:56:38,790
Video Playback Narration: it was done. Hindi po.

447
01:56:46,410 --> 01:56:53,550
Video Playback Narration: Yung pangalan ko pong pinangalagaan po all my life. Tapos

448
01:56:58,160 --> 01:57:02,540
Video Playback Narration: tawag-tawagin kayong masamang tao, magnanakaw, mandrugas.

449
01:57:06,320 --> 01:57:08,780
Video Playback Narration: Hindi lang po akong...

450
01:57:10,440 --> 01:57:34,260
Video Playback Narration: Nag-suffer po dito. Pati po yung mga anak ko. Pati po yung mga apo ko. Gusto ko lang po maikwento sa inyo yung isang araw yung aking panganay na apo. Anak po nung anak ko si Carla. He is 9 years old and studying in Xavier School. Napaka-talino po nung batang yun eh.

451
01:57:40,600 --> 01:57:57,750
Video Playback Narration: Isang araw po na nag-uusap-usap kami sa pamilya tungkol dito sa impeachment na ito. Nakita ko si Franco, yung aking apo po, nandun po sa isang sulok. Wala po siyang, usually po playful yung batang yun, pero that

452
01:57:59,740 --> 01:58:10,110
Video Playback Narration: particular instance, he was very quiet, alone in a corner. So, I approached him, I said, Franco, what's wrong? He

453
01:58:10,110 --> 01:58:21,880
Video Playback Narration: said, nothing, nothing, grandpa, nothing. No, I know you, you're not your usual self. What is wrong? Tell grandpa.

454
01:58:26,900 --> 01:58:28,880
Video Playback Narration: Kapipilit, kapipilit ko po.

455
01:58:31,710 --> 01:58:33,510
Video Playback Narration: Sabi ko po, do

456
01:58:36,100 --> 01:58:43,580
Video Playback Narration: you know what they're talking about in the newspapers about Grandpa? Do you know what they're saying about Grandpa? And

457
01:58:45,020 --> 01:58:45,680
Video Playback Narration: he said yes.

458
01:58:47,240 --> 01:58:48,940
Video Playback Narration: What do you think? He

459
01:58:51,920 --> 01:59:01,530
Video Playback Narration: kept quiet for a very, very long time and I said, tell Grandpa, I want to know what you think about what they're saying about Grandpa.

460
01:59:03,540 --> 01:59:06,820
Video Playback Narration: Ngayon ko lang po nakita yung aking apo.

461
01:59:14,450 --> 01:59:22,720
Video Playback Narration: Nung ko lang po nakakita yung aking apo, he clenched his fist and he said, I am very, very angry.

462
01:59:24,250 --> 01:59:27,810
Video Playback Narration: Nagulat po ako kasi for a 9-year-old to say that.

463
01:59:29,470 --> 01:59:48,490
Video Playback Narration: Yun po ang nararamdaman at pinagdaanan ng aming pamilya. Pinagbintangan kami 45 properties daw. Alam naman po ni Administrator Eulalio Diaz na hindi totoo yung sinasabi niya. Ili-leak niya doon sa media.

464
01:59:50,250 --> 01:59:56,910
Video Playback Narration: Tapos meron namang mga member ng kabilang panig na pinapangandakan na

465
01:59:56,910 --> 01:59:58,810
Video Playback Narration: lang yung 45 properties.

466
02:00:03,580 --> 02:00:07,060
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly pause the video. What is the pleasure of Senator Judge Raffy?

467
02:00:07,220 --> 02:00:24,920
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Last na lamang po na manifestation. Mr. Presiding Officer, maraming salamat po sa defense sa pagpapakita ng video ni dating CJ Corona, the late CJ Corona. Thank you. But let me remind you, na-impeach pa rin si CJ Corona dahil sa hindi niya pagsasabi ng totoo sa kanyang SALN. Tama?

468
02:00:25,080 --> 02:00:30,180
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you. How many more seconds or minutes, Attorney Mark?

469
02:00:32,280 --> 02:00:32,920
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: If you know.

470
02:00:33,000 --> 02:00:35,040
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Maybe around 12 is a good

471
02:00:35,040 --> 02:00:35,960
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: time to pause your honor.

472
02:00:37,750 --> 02:00:39,790
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: 12? No, how many more minutes would this video be?

473
02:00:41,460 --> 02:00:47,980
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Well, we can, there's a portion there that we wanted to ask questions on your own, but we can pause there for now.

474
02:00:47,980 --> 02:00:52,540
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: No, but how many more minutes so that we know how long, we just know how long the video.

475
02:00:52,740 --> 02:00:54,180
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Around 4 more minutes.

476
02:00:54,340 --> 02:00:56,320
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Okay. Okay. Tech, kindly play the video.

477
02:00:56,600 --> 02:00:57,240
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: At that point

478
02:00:57,240 --> 02:00:58,520
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: na lang, please resume the playing.

479
02:00:58,830 --> 02:01:01,190
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: If Your Honor, please, before the video is resumed.

480
02:01:01,190 --> 02:01:02,810
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, Honorable Chell.

481
02:01:03,090 --> 02:01:12,270
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Just several manifestations, Your Honor. Number one, I do not see the relevance of the alleged persecution experienced by the former Chief Justice.

482
02:01:12,270 --> 02:01:13,270
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: No question yet, Your Honor.

483
02:01:13,570 --> 02:01:20,570
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I'm simply making a statement, Your Honor. I'm not yet making an objection. And again, I'm being interrupted by the good counsel.

484
02:01:20,990 --> 02:01:25,150
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: It's okay, counsel. Take it easy. Without interruption, please. Go ahead.

485
02:01:25,550 --> 02:02:01,040
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Thank you. Your Honor, I do not see the relevance of the statements made by the Chief Justice Corona about his alleged persecution, except that it is an appeal to emotion that I believe has no place in this impeachment trial. Whatever question is asked, it would be immaterial, it would be irrelevant, it would constitute hearsay because we cannot even cross-examine the late Chief Justice Corona on his statements, and it would be misleading. Because there is no such evidence of persecution in this case before the court.

486
02:02:01,440 --> 02:02:04,680
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We note the manifestation of the Honorable Diokno.

487
02:02:06,000 --> 02:02:07,480
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Just a quick response, Your Honor.

488
02:02:07,600 --> 02:02:08,620
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Quick response, Attorney Mark.

489
02:02:09,920 --> 02:02:34,860
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We've already learned at this point that impeachment is not a purely legal proceeding. There's a political aspect to it. And I think, Your Honor, we've been prudent in laying the basis for our questions. So again, Your Honor, we just ask for a little leeway. For the defense, Your Honor, the prosecution have had this time, and in fact, we don't have any question yet. So, just a little leeway for the defense, Your Honor.

490
02:02:35,040 --> 02:02:59,630
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Again, we'll allow it, and as pointed out by Senator Judge Raffy, at their peril as well, because we know what happened with respect to that case, the testimony being shown notwithstanding. So, we'll allow it at this juncture. Tech will kindly play the video. Continue to play the video. And then perhaps if it's 4 minutes, ask your question and then we can pause. Atty. Mark, please proceed.

491
02:03:02,120 --> 02:03:15,620
Video Playback Narration: Pinagbintangan kami 45 properties daw. Alam naman po ni Administrator Eulalio Diaz na hindi totoo yung sinasabi niya. Yet, ili-leak niya doon sa media.

492
02:03:17,440 --> 02:03:27,420
Video Playback Narration: Tapos meron namang mga member ng kabilang panig na pinapangandakan na lang yung aming 45 properties na hindi naman po totoo.

493
02:03:27,860 --> 02:03:59,640
Video Playback Narration: I'm very very sorry to interrupt but your answer has not been responsive. My question is what is the effect on the members of the Supreme Court led of course by the Chief Justice with respect to the following principles. Number one, the principle of checks and balances. How do you view this principle as impacted by the present impeachment trial? Number two, the so-called principle of the independence of the judiciary. And number three, the doctrine of subjudice. I only have two minutes, that's why I had to interrupt. Thank you.

494
02:03:59,780 --> 02:04:17,100
Video Playback Narration: I'm sorry, I'm sorry, Your Honor. I just got carried away emotionally. I think this whole impeachment proceeding has had a very chilling effect on the Supreme Court, if I may say so.

495
02:04:19,050 --> 02:04:31,360
Video Playback Narration: Wala pong kahit na sinong miyembro ng Korte Suprema ang gustong magdaan dito sa pinagdaanan ko ito. Yung checks and balances po. Ang

496
02:04:32,160 --> 02:04:46,690
Video Playback Narration: checks and balances po ay ang pagkapantay-pantay ng executive, legislative, at saka judiciary. At nasabi ko po nung Martes, yung

497
02:04:49,190 --> 02:05:18,030
Video Playback Narration: pagwawasak po niyang checks and balances na yan, Ay probably, ay siguro po ay ang pinakamasamang epekto nitong impeachment complaint na ito. Kasi po, yung po ang, yung prinsipyo po ng checks and balances, madam, ay ang nagagarentiya po ng ating demokrasya. Pagka sinira ninyo yung checks and balances na yan, yan po ay siguradong

498
02:05:19,570 --> 02:05:29,560
Video Playback Narration: diktatura na ang susunod. Yan nga po ang binanggit ko nung Martes. Ngayon, sa ating

499
02:05:35,130 --> 02:06:57,990
Video Playback Narration: subjudice rule po ay alam na po nating mga abogado na hindi na po dapat payagan niyang patuloy-tuloy na komentaryo ng mga tao dyan sa labas. Nagbibigay nilang kuro-kuro. Ang problema po ay parang they're already crossing the boundary of propriety and impropriety. So ang epekto po niyan ay nalalaso ng kaunti, ng unti-unti ang pag-iisip ng ating taong-bayan kung sino po ang may kwarta na may magpapairal ng media campaign. Siya ang nagahawak ng power to influence the mind. and the opinion of the public. Mabuti po tayong mga member po nitong Senado. Kaya kayo naman po ang mga tayong may experience at saka sanay dito sa mga bagay na ganito at hindi kayo nasisway. Pero yung mga taong bayan po, paano naman po yun? You have an impeachment court yung hindi po maipresentang ebidensya dito doon ho inilalahad sa labas. So,

500
02:06:57,990 --> 02:06:59,310
Video Playback Narration: nasisira po yung...

501
02:06:59,310 --> 02:07:01,830
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly pause the video.

502
02:07:02,070 --> 02:07:36,420
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: My question is in line with section 16 of the AMLA, prohibitions against political harassment. So, in the video, Chief Justice Renato Corona mentioned that BIR, LRA, AMLC, Ombudsman, among others were used against him. My only question is... Again, you can answer based on the video or in general, but what is the effect of weaponizing the AMLC against any individual or his or her family in terms of financial investigations?

503
02:07:36,760 --> 02:07:40,560
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Objection, Your Honor. The question is irrelevant, immaterial, and misleading.

504
02:07:41,500 --> 02:07:42,240
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: If he knows,

505
02:07:42,240 --> 02:07:50,220
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: counsel, if you know, Attorney Rainer, you may also say that you do not know or would not comment. You're called.

506
02:07:50,770 --> 02:08:17,870
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, under Section 16 of the AMLA, Your Honor, there is a prohibition on the use of AMLC-derived information for political persecution, aside from political persecution, also to hamper commerce and trade. So, the law discourages the use of information, well, the legal use of this information in relation to political persecution.

507
02:08:18,410 --> 02:08:36,890
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you. By the way, since we used their videos, we just extend our commemoration to the Santiago and Corona families. We honor their contributions and legacies. Let's move on. Let me direct your attention to one last video. This is just a one-minute video, Your Honor. Again, an unmarked video, but we reserve our right to mark it at the proper time. If we may be allowed, Your Honor.

508
02:08:38,350 --> 02:08:42,310
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Counsel may proceed. I guess you will wind up after you ask a question based on this video?

509
02:08:42,430 --> 02:08:43,490
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Correct, Your Honor. Thank you.

510
02:08:43,710 --> 02:08:45,010
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Would that be a good time to stop?

511
02:08:45,250 --> 02:08:45,950
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: That would be a

512
02:08:45,950 --> 02:08:47,250
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: perfect time to stop, Your Honor.

513
02:08:47,300 --> 02:08:53,060
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Kindly play the video, tech.

514
02:08:53,500 --> 02:08:56,000
Video Playback Narration: Do you think

515
02:08:56,000 --> 02:08:58,960
Video Playback Narration: sir may basehan po para ma-impeach nga po siya? What are your thoughts po?

516
02:08:59,320 --> 02:09:19,980
Video Playback Narration: You know, we just had an election. Guys, lay off. Stop it. Can do other things, but do not tinker with the structure of government. I will not countenance it. Elected iyong tao eh. So why do you have to? Is

517
02:09:19,980 --> 02:09:22,660
Video Playback Narration: it because, just because, it keeps on harping on me?

518
02:09:22,860 --> 02:09:24,300
Video Playback Narration: Hayaan mo. This is a democracy.

519
02:09:24,970 --> 02:09:32,780
Video Playback Narration: It's freedom of speech. Wala naman, there are, there is no, or there are no overt acts committed.

520
02:09:34,470 --> 02:09:35,750
Video Playback Narration: Kakatapos lang ng eleksyon,

521
02:09:35,750 --> 02:09:38,910
Video Playback Narration: Bakit mo sirain ang bayan?

522
02:09:41,270 --> 02:09:50,390
Video Playback Narration: Okay, ako, malay mo ako, baka hindi na ako magising bukas sa bangungot, okay na. Siya naman, you know, you create trouble.

523
02:09:53,980 --> 02:10:02,420
Video Playback Narration: Ayaw niyang military kasi ayaw niyang mag... Hindi naman tamad to. Bakit naman dagdagan yung problema nila? Pati pulis.

524
02:10:03,020 --> 02:10:06,220
Video Playback Narration: Who will keep order in this country, kung di sila?

525
02:10:06,260 --> 02:10:07,920
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We can pause the video there.

526
02:10:08,550 --> 02:10:28,220
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, so, Atty. Benaventura, in the video, FPRRD talked about not impeaching then Vice President Leni Robredo. But let me ask you, in what way can data from The AMLC, for example, based on your experience, be used as a political weapon in an impeachment proceeding, if at all.

527
02:10:29,510 --> 02:10:44,310
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Your Honor, please, the witness would not have any competence to answer that. He was only a financial investigator for two years or less than two years, and there's been no basis established for him to make a decent answer to that question.

528
02:10:44,790 --> 02:10:47,230
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: If he knows, Your Honor, just based on his opinion. The

529
02:10:47,230 --> 02:10:49,290
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Chair will allow it. If you know, Atty. Rainer?

530
02:10:49,880 --> 02:10:51,320
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor, what's the question again?

531
02:10:52,060 --> 02:10:59,300
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Being used as a political weapon point data from AMLC in an impeachment proceeding.

532
02:11:02,470 --> 02:11:10,850
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: But let me ask you, in what way can data from the AMLC be used as a political weapon in an impeachment proceeding, if at all?

533
02:11:12,150 --> 02:11:15,570
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: It can. The possibility is still there. It can be used.

534
02:11:16,170 --> 02:11:17,290
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We can pause there.

535
02:11:18,410 --> 02:11:20,210
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We shall pause for lunch.

536
02:11:22,340 --> 02:11:29,910
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We shall resume at 1pm. What is the pleasure of Senator Judge Risa before we call a recess?

537
02:11:34,970 --> 02:12:20,700
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Salamat, Mr. Presiding Officer. Just a brief manifestation bago nga po tayo mag-pause for recess. Yung dalawa po na ipinakita, patay na po sila. Yung pangatlo naman po ay wala rito. Kaya hindi rin po naming mga senator judges lahat silang tatlo na makakausap. I think just to express Mr. Presiding Officer na hindi po fair yung ganitong sitwasyon. Hindi po fair either sa tatlong taong ipinakita ang video nila. Hindi rin po fair sa Senate Impeachment Court po na ito. For the record, Mr. Presiding Officer, salamat po.

538
02:12:20,940 --> 02:12:27,280
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Noted. We shall pause for lunch recess and we shall resume at 1pm.

539
03:13:36,780 --> 03:14:55,990
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Before, kindly situate Attorney Rainer to the witness stand. Before Attorney Mark continues with his direct examination, court would like to state on the manifestation and request by witness from CITEM, Ms. Rowena Mendoza, the chair was already prepared to deny the request considering that the November 15th subpoena was issued by this court to Ms. Mendoza, quote, and or any representative from CITEM. However, this Court was in receipt of an email communication from Ms. Rowena Mendoza sent to the Clerk of Court at 11.02 a.m. today, stating that, number one, the subpoena documents will be submitted to the Court today, and number two, Attorney Eva Marie Mariquina, Q-U-I-N-A, shall be the one to testify in Ms. Mendoza's stead given that the subpoena is not only for Ms. Mendoza but any representative from CITEM. Would that be alright with the counsel for respondent? For the record, the counsel for respondent is nodding. So we shall proceed with the testimony of the CITEM representative who will now be Attorney Eva Marie Mariquina tomorrow, November 20, 2026. It's ordered.

540
03:14:56,830 --> 03:14:57,830
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you, Your Honor.

541
03:14:57,910 --> 03:15:34,540
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Before proceeding again, Chair would like to instruct the Clerk To clerk of court, to kindly instruct the PRIB to be more mindful and careful with respect to, I don't know what you call it, the transition effects from a scene. The flames are not well taken and are inappropriate to these proceedings. So kindly be mindful. And the clerk is directed to kindly remove and edit it from the records of the impeachment court. As it is deemed inappropriate. So ordered.

542
03:15:36,050 --> 03:15:45,610
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Atty. Mark, your turn. You may proceed with your direct examination or rather continue with your direct examination of Atty. Rainer.

543
03:15:49,050 --> 03:15:49,950
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you, Your Honor.

544
03:15:52,950 --> 03:16:37,780
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Atty. Dela Fuente, let me direct your attention to Section 8A of the AMLA. You already mentioned this a while ago but I'll read it for the benefit of the Senator, Judges, and the public. Information security and confidentiality states that, and I quote, the AMLC and its secretariat shall securely protect information received or processed and shall not reveal in any manner any information known to them by reason of their office. This prohibition shall apply even after their separation from the AMLC. You were part of the AMLC Secretariat. Please describe the powers and limitations of this office in terms of revealing confidential information.

545
03:16:38,460 --> 03:17:20,980
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, Your Honor, this is one of the, there are three rules on confidentiality and this is the third rule found on the first paragraph of 8-A. Now, it admits of an exemption on the second paragraph that is for authorized disclosure if this pursuant to information exchange. and if it is pursuant to an order of a court of competent jurisdiction. Now, again, the rule is that there is confidentiality should be the followed exception, again, if it is pursuant to information exchange and also pursuant to an order of a lawful court.

546
03:17:21,670 --> 03:17:28,420
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. What types of data? and information are considered confidential information under this provision.

547
03:17:28,880 --> 03:17:42,160
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: So confidential information here would cover the transaction reports, CTRs and STRs, derivatives of these CTRs and STRs. So that would be the intelligence reports and the investigation reports.

548
03:17:42,720 --> 03:17:47,840
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And to be sure, how strict must the AMLC be with the rule on confidentiality?

549
03:17:48,080 --> 03:17:52,600
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: So again, under the same section, second paragraph,

550
03:17:56,230 --> 03:18:18,110
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Paragraph allowing for the disclosure. It says there that the AMLC shall formulate rules concerning information security, confidentiality, procedures for the proper handling, protection, storage of the information. So there are still safeguards. It is authorized but controlled disclosure.

551
03:18:20,030 --> 03:18:50,260
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Pertinent AMLC reports in this case contain a portion indicating general principles of information exchange with regard to the end user of confidential information from the AMLC. We don't want to flash the document on the screen, so I'll just go through the points one by one. We'll just get your comments thereon. Number one is, what does it mean? that the end user must first verify the information provided.

552
03:18:51,640 --> 03:19:17,290
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay, again, this is... Again, this is still subject to the verification of the end user. So, again, the report does not contain conclusions but rather intelligence information. So, again, it is up to the end user as to how they will appreciate the information.

553
03:19:17,720 --> 03:19:25,500
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, so in your experience po as a financial investigator, paano po ba ginagawa yung tamang pag-verify ng information contained in these reports?

554
03:19:26,180 --> 03:20:04,300
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well again, the end user of the report, normally it's a law enforcement agency or an agency with investigative powers. There are things that are outside the... The view of AMLC. Again, money laundering lang sila. But dun sa unlawful activity, it's within the powers of the investigating unit, the law enforcement agencies. So again, some information might not have been disclosed sa AMLC. So it's up to the end user to verify if this information is useful or not.

555
03:20:05,320 --> 03:20:10,620
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Number two, what does it mean that the end user must protect the confidentiality of the information?

556
03:20:11,540 --> 03:20:39,390
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, since this information are, again, subject to verification, if it falls in the hands of, again, an unauthorized individual or organization, it might be used. It may deviate from its intended use or purpose. So we have to protect its confidentiality. It's subject, again, to verification. Subject to further checking by the end user.

557
03:20:39,850 --> 03:20:46,650
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Ano po ba yung tamang measures para masiguradong mapoprotektahan yung confidentiality ng mga impormasyon?

558
03:20:47,620 --> 03:21:08,050
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Number one po, ano? Depende po yan sa ilalagay ni AMLA. Kasi there are, again, different information that should be handled. Wala pong isang rule lang for every information. So normally, It should be restricted to the end user. The use should only be confined to the intended use indicated in the report.

559
03:21:08,470 --> 03:21:16,650
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, and proceed po tayo sa number 3. What does it mean that the end user must use the information for intelligence purposes only?

560
03:21:17,610 --> 03:21:23,890
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay, when we say for intelligence purpose only, it is for analytical purpose. Not

561
03:21:23,890 --> 03:21:35,410
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: for evidence gathering or leading to coercive measures. For case build-up, for information gathering.

562
03:21:36,100 --> 03:21:42,360
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. How proper po na i-disclose yung mga datos sa publiko kung wala naman pong court order?

563
03:21:43,950 --> 03:21:54,810
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Very dangerous po ito if we let this out in the public. Why? Because we are in fact compromising the safety and security of the concerned account holder, the

564
03:21:54,970 --> 03:22:00,250
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: covered person, and also the one who processed the information.

565
03:22:00,810 --> 03:22:10,010
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you. Number four, last two na lang po. What does it mean that the end user must not use information as evidence in formal proceedings?

566
03:22:10,630 --> 03:22:11,970
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: For number four,

567
03:22:12,050 --> 03:22:13,870
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor, again,

568
03:22:14,450 --> 03:22:36,720
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: it is not the evidence. It is not the... Evidence itself. Yan ho ay for intelligence use only. Para ho siyang nagbibigay ng clues, investigative leads. It doesn't give you the exact evidence but it leads you. Tinuturo niya kung saan ang mga ebidensya. Leads

569
03:22:36,720 --> 03:22:39,040
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: lang ho ito. Parang clues. Nagbibigay ho ng clues.

570
03:22:39,780 --> 03:22:43,300
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Ano po ba yung mga formal proceedings contemplated under this rule?

571
03:22:43,940 --> 03:23:04,830
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: When we say my own appreciation po of formal proceedings, that would These are coercive proceedings, court proceedings, one that would involve appreciation of the facts and also a ruling, an order from a court of competent jurisdiction.

572
03:23:05,390 --> 03:23:17,590
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, and finally, what does it mean that the end-user must refrain from reproducing, copying, extracting, printing, or distributing material to any third party without the written consent of the council members?

573
03:23:18,950 --> 03:23:42,340
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: So I think your honor, it's self-explanatory. No forward dissemination. No re-dissemination from its intended user cannot go beyond those who are originally the intended end user. So it cannot be re-forwarded, it cannot be re-disseminated.

574
03:23:42,560 --> 03:24:00,570
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now, my next question is this. What is the legal effect? Confidential data and information on VP Sara and Attorney Manz being disclosed in a public proceeding similar to what happened in the House Committee on Justice on April 22, 2026.

575
03:24:01,150 --> 03:24:12,070
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Your Honor, objection. The question is misleading. The documents produced by the AMLA before the Committee on Justice were based on a subpoena issued by the Committee. That should be clear.

576
03:24:13,410 --> 03:24:15,930
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Subject to that qualification. Witness may answer.

577
03:24:18,130 --> 03:24:42,910
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: I'll repeat, ano pong legal effect kapag ang confidential data or information po ni VP Sara and Attorney Mans were disclosed in a public proceeding similar to what happened in the House Committee on Justice on April 22, 2026, subject po dun sa qualification na sinabi ni Representative Diokno, na sinabi na po yun, but with the added qualification na hindi po sila court.

578
03:24:43,500 --> 03:24:56,230
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, Your Honor, I have no personal knowledge as to the matter surrounding that scenario. But what I can relay, Your Honor, nasa Section 14D, if

579
03:24:56,230 --> 03:25:04,570
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: there is a violation of confidentiality, there is a corresponding criminal liability to those who violated that.

580
03:25:04,770 --> 03:25:16,830
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now, just to ask another point on this, who will you consider po as end users? Of confidential information kapag ginawa na pong public yung hearing, for example.

581
03:25:18,750 --> 03:25:20,190
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kapag ginawa ng public.

582
03:25:20,190 --> 03:25:28,810
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Kanyari, public na po yung hearing, since public po yung hearing and televised, who will you consider as the end users ng mga confidential information kapag gano'n?

583
03:25:29,560 --> 03:25:42,960
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, it doesn't convert the information from being confidential to now a unclassified information or a freely available information.

584
03:25:44,510 --> 03:25:51,050
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The confidentiality nature of the information still remains with that data.

585
03:25:51,370 --> 03:26:08,090
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now, based on your knowledge also as a financial investigator, ano po ba yung mga measures na can be used or observed when end-users receive confidential information in a public hearing, for example, like the one before the House Committee on Justice?

586
03:26:09,090 --> 03:26:32,420
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor, like the one flashed on the screen. A while ago, those are just some of the measures na nilalagay ko dun sa mga reports emanating from our AMLC. So that would restrict use of the information to only the intended users and will serve as a caution, as a reminder to those who might be accessing it without proper authority.

587
03:26:34,880 --> 03:26:56,800
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Let me direct your attention to section 14. You mentioned this, but I will no longer read. I will be more circumspect this time. But it talks about breach of information, security, and confidentiality. Itanong ko lang po sa inyo, as an expert on this matter, who are the responsible persons in case of breach of information, security, and confidentiality?

588
03:26:57,000 --> 03:27:02,200
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Objection, Your Honor. There's been no finding that this witness is an expert and that the subject of dispute.

589
03:27:02,600 --> 03:27:03,360
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: If he knows, Your Honor.

590
03:27:03,850 --> 03:27:10,730
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I object to the qualification of the witness or the statement describing him as an expert. I move to strike that portion.

591
03:27:11,690 --> 03:27:21,210
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: If he knows, counsel, in regard to the qualification or description as an expert, let it stay on the record, subject to cross with respect to his qualifications. Witness, may answer?

592
03:27:21,960 --> 03:28:03,900
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor, under Section 14D, as to who will be liable, again, the one, I think, the one here, po, no? Who access without authority The confidential information. So that's the first one. Second, if the offender is a public officer or employee, there is a corresponding accessory penalty. And third, if it is disseminated or disclosed by the mass media, and then it will also include the reporter, publisher, editor-in-chief, and as indicated under Section 14D.

593
03:28:03,900 --> 03:28:31,090
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: All right. Tuloy lang po natin sa paragraph F. Nakalagay doon imposition of administrative sanctions. Again, I won't read the entire provision but based on this provision po and based on your experience with AMLA also, what are the natures of the penalties involved po sa batas? Aside from those that you already mentioned.

594
03:28:32,540 --> 03:28:51,180
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa administrative sanctions mo under section 14, normally it includes monetary and non-monetary penalties. So it can range from a simple reprimand up to imposition of monetary penalties as high as 500,000 Philippine pesos per violation.

595
03:28:51,560 --> 03:29:06,890
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, so you mentioned media. So it will be a teaching moment for all of us as well. Based on your knowledge and experience as a financial investigator, how should the media handle confidential information as end users?

596
03:29:07,960 --> 03:29:28,650
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: As much as possible, it must be again in line with AMLA and our law on data privacy. Sensitive personal information should be redacted, removed, or blocked. So that it cannot reveal this information. It can be used weaponized against the account holder.

597
03:29:29,190 --> 03:29:55,500
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Let's go back to Section 7.1 of the AMLA. And I'll read, To investigate suspicious transactions and covert transactions deemed suspicious after determination by AMLC, money laundering activities, and other violations of this Act. So based on this provision, please describe to us. The process how the AMLC must conduct financial investigation based on CTRs and STRs. I-detail yun na

598
03:29:55,500 --> 03:29:57,660
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: po natin. Where does the investigation process begin?

599
03:29:58,400 --> 03:30:20,880
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay. When we say investigation, that’s already stage two. Prior to investigation, we have what we call financial intelligence. That’s stage one. So day-to-day, the AMLC receives, analyzes, and disseminates this financial intelligence information. So it can be again forwarded to law enforcement or its own financial investigation group.

600
03:30:21,340 --> 03:31:04,400
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: If there is already a predicate crime, saka na po siya pupunta sa second stage, financial investigation. The first one, stage one, financial intelligence is more on the analytical part. Analysis lang ho yan. Second part, that is the more coercive evidence gathering phase. That is the financial investigation stage. Now before mag-proceed ho sa ating mga coercive processes, there must be an AMLC, well, council authority. So that would pave the way for filing for a petition, for freeze order, bank inquiry. Civil Forfeiture. So, provided po siya ng Section 10, 11, and 12 ng ating AMLA.

601
03:31:04,580 --> 03:31:16,430
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. You mentioned yung referral to law enforcement agencies. Ano po ba yung mga measures that the AMLC observes in relation to this stage of the process?

602
03:31:18,280 --> 03:31:26,580
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, when the information, financial intelligence report is forwarded to law enforcement agencies, whether local or abroad,

603
03:31:28,780 --> 03:31:54,900
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: It's only used for intelligence purpose. Intelligence gathering or case build up. So normally po, it acts as a precaution or as a reminder dun sa end user that they have to verify, still verify, the information and if it will be helpful in their investigation. Kung makakatulong sa kanilang investigation at relevant pa yung information.

604
03:31:55,610 --> 03:31:58,970
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you po. What documents ang ini-issue diyan po? Kung meron man.

605
03:32:00,240 --> 03:32:08,060
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Normally, your honor, again, the financial intelligence report or sometimes po, ano, na pag may financial investigation report ka.

606
03:32:08,220 --> 03:32:18,650
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: How about in relation to the law enforcement agency and the AMLA, meron po bang mga ini-execute the documents doon to protect the confidentiality?

607
03:32:18,850 --> 03:32:32,600
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Nandun na po yung mismo sa report itself. Naka-embed na siya. Naka-incorporate na po yung measures na yun sa dokumento para hindi na po sila magtingin-tingin pa or mag-refer sa iba pang dokumento.

608
03:32:33,620 --> 03:32:42,230
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Matanong ko lang po, kasama po ba yung sensitivity analysis sa methodology ninyo? Kung alam nyo lang po yung term. Sensitivity

609
03:32:42,230 --> 03:32:58,430
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: analysis? Well, wala po siya sa batas, wala po siya sa AMLA. It's an invest... Investigation technique. But it's not reflected po sa ating batas.

610
03:32:59,030 --> 03:33:23,150
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Sige po. Ako rin po hindi ko alam yung term na yun to be honest. First time ko po marinig yun dun sa so-called expert ng prosecution. And when asked about it, tungkol to yata sa mga bangkay na mainit-init pa. Yun yung explanation. Anyway, the court can just check the records if warranted. Pero dun po sa binanggit nyo na very detailed process. On the average, how long po yung proseso na to?

611
03:33:24,280 --> 03:33:46,600
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor, depende ho yan sa kaso. The number of subjects, the number of accounts, the periods with an S covered. Kasi marami ho yan, kukunin sa mga bangko, maraming records. So far as the timeline, duration of how far, how long will the investigation?

612
03:33:49,040 --> 03:33:55,520
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Mahaba ho. We have simple up to complex cases. So we don't have a specific timeline for that.

613
03:33:55,520 --> 03:34:16,720
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: All right, so mahirap pala pag two weeks lang. Anyway, let me direct your attention to paragraphs three, four and six of the same section. Let me read paragraph three: to institute civil forfeiture proceedings and all other remedial proceedings through the Office of the Solicitor General. Number four, to cause the filing of complaints with the

614
03:34:16,890 --> 03:34:50,130
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Department of Justice or the Ombudsman for the prosecution of money laundering offenses. And I'll jump to paragraph 6 to apply before the Court of Appeals. Ex parte for the freezing of any monetary instrument or property alleged to be laundered, proceeds from, or instrumentalities used in or intended for use in any unlawful activity as defined in Section 3I hereof. In line po dun sa... Pinaliwanag niyong pong proseso kanina. And kung hindi niyo lang po nadaanan pa, please explain to us the process involved under these paragraphs.

615
03:34:50,490 --> 03:35:06,480
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, in relation to Section 7, ibig sabihin lang po niyan, before we proceed to these coercive processes, there must be counsel, ng AMLC Council approval, resolution. So there must be authority po bago umabot sa ganyan mga proseso.

616
03:35:06,640 --> 03:35:28,690
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now, yung CTRs po and STRs ni VP Sara and Attorney Mans, that were examined and processed were from 2006 to 2025. So merong doon na 20 years ago pa yung records. Itanong ko lang po, how does the concept of prescription apply sa mga ganong records, if at all po?

617
03:35:30,810 --> 03:35:59,190
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: In this case, Your Honor, wala kong prescription. As long as merong ongoing case, it can go as far back as 20 years ago. Ito ay nakakabuti rin, hindi lang sa pag-prosecute. Makakatulong din ito para maintindihan natin yung behavior ng account. Minsan nakakatulong ito para ma-explain yung unexplained, malaman ang mga unknown. So it can go both ways po.

618
03:35:59,430 --> 03:36:06,070
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you po for that answer. Now, let me just ask, what is the burden of proof in money laundering cases?

619
03:36:08,040 --> 03:36:12,160
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Since it is criminal in nature, burden of proof is proof beyond reasonable doubt.

620
03:36:12,380 --> 03:36:13,440
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And who has that burden?

621
03:36:14,580 --> 03:36:17,240
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Pagdating ho dyan ang ating prosecutors.

622
03:36:17,860 --> 03:36:34,360
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, very well. Now let's talk about the predicate crime or unlawful activity aspect real quick. How does the AMLC handle the predicate crime or unlawful activity aspect related to the CTRs and STRs reported to it?

623
03:36:35,360 --> 03:36:57,440
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yung sa unlawful activity, Hindi yan obligation or responsibility ng AMLC. Yan ay nasa mga law enforcement agencies. Again, money laundering is a derivative offense. Doon lang siya sa stage 2, money laundering side. But unlawful activity, we leave it to the normal law enforcement and those that are into investigation.

624
03:36:58,160 --> 03:37:10,340
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Isang tanong na lang po regarding dito. How active or passive is the AMLC? In terms of prosecuting the predicate crime or unlawful activity aspect before the appropriate courts?

625
03:37:10,940 --> 03:37:21,620
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, pagdating mo sa predicate crime, it's outside the authority of the AMLC. They leave it to the law enforcement agency's prosecution side po.

626
03:37:21,820 --> 03:37:37,770
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay, thank you po. Dito po kasi sa impeachment, maraming mga prinesenta na CTRs and STRs. But let me ask you, what is the value? CTRs and STRs in terms of actually proving criminal activity?

627
03:37:39,730 --> 03:38:48,080
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: CTRs and STRs po, they are not the actual proof. They are indicators. It would invite scrutiny. In fact, marami ho minsan mga STRs, false positives. Ang purpose po nito, you're just giving AMLC a signal. Para ang nagbibigay kayo ng notice. So AMLC, ito sa mga covered persons na nagsasabit ng STRs and CTRs. Can you take a closer look at this specific STR? So they have to verify it. And then itong CTRs and STRs na ito, a single suspicious transaction report. Mahirap pong mapatunayan. You have to compile everything. Multiple CTRs, multiple STRs, multiple years. For you to have a clear picture. Para huyan nagbubuo kayo ng jigsaw puzzle. Isang puzzle ho, doesn't give you a clear picture or an idea about the entire picture. So you have to put all of these pieces together in order for you to have a clear understanding of what transpired and properly prosecute.

628
03:38:48,260 --> 03:39:03,200
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Thank you po. You mentioned the process of bank inquiries kanina. My question is, If further verification is necessary, what is the proper procedure of coordinating with banks or other covered persons?

629
03:39:04,240 --> 03:39:22,040
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yan po, yung bank inquiry. It will open na yung mga debits, credits, the statement of accounts, the actual bank records. So it is, again, a compulsive process and before we can get that, it must be applied with the Court of Appeals, ex parte.

630
03:39:22,810 --> 03:39:39,240
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. And one last question on this, or at least two more. Portions po kasi of STRs were flashed on the screen. What is the propriety po of disclosing portions of STRs in a televised proceedings?

631
03:39:40,200 --> 03:39:53,910
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, Your Honor, as to the actual flashing, unfortunately, I have no personal knowledge how it was flashed or the circumstances surrounding it. I can only comment on what is reflected sa batas. Again, that would fall under the prohibition.

632
03:39:54,720 --> 03:40:02,140
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: So, just a teaching moment again, what alternative measures can be done so as not to compromise confidentiality in such a situation?

633
03:40:03,630 --> 03:40:15,910
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, so as not to compromise confidentiality, the rule, yun pong pamantayan na nakalagay dun sa report must be strictly observed. Yun lang po yun talaga, no?

634
03:40:16,010 --> 03:40:24,760
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, sige. Thank you po. Now, let's... Now give the so-called expert some airtime and go to page 2 of his report. I'll read.

635
03:40:26,740 --> 03:42:39,740
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Fourthly, her unexplained wealth also comes from corporations that the spouses have ownership or business interests in. Substantial undeclared income of these corporations amount to fraud, which allows for the piercing of the veil of corporate fiction. Thus, the undeclared income of these corporations is attributable as direct income of the stockholders, which include the VP and her spouse. The declaration of her business interests in her SALN and information appearing in the General Information Sheet or GIS reflect the respondent's participation in various businesses. Now, two things I want to discuss with you. Atty. Dela Fuente. Number one, piercing the veil of corporate fiction and participation in business as per the SALN. Let's first talk about participation in business as per the SALN. Let me direct your attention to Article 7, Section 13 of the 1987 Constitution. Section 13. The President, Vice President, the members of the Cabinet, and their deputies or assistants shall not, unless otherwise provided in the Constitution, hold any other office or employment during their tenure. They shall not, during said tenure, directly or indirectly practice any other profession, participate in any business, or be financially interested in any contract with, or in any franchise or special privilege granted by the government, or any subdivision, agency, or instrumentality thereof. including government-owned or controlled corporations or their subsidiaries. They shall strictly avoid conflict of interest in the conduct of their office. So, Atty. Dela Fuente, marami po kasing public officer na may financial or business interests. Again, you may answer this based on the provision that we just read or in general. But what is your understanding po of conflict of interest?

636
03:42:40,510 --> 03:42:53,770
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, the performance... ng kanyang public office should not have any, whether, the business interest that he or she is holding should not benefit from it.

637
03:42:54,530 --> 03:43:42,520
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now let me direct your attention to the salient portions of Volume 2 of the Record of Constitutional Commission, pages 402 to 403. This is according to Mr. Regalado. In the first place, we have stated that the purpose here is not only conflict of interest, but to enable them to give full-time attention to their duties. And then I'll skip to the next part. In other words, they can engage in any other revenue-producing, income-producing activity, legitimate in nature, provided it does not conflict with the objective sought in this section. So based on this portion of the deliberations, kindly explain legitimate income-producing activity by a public officer. If you know.

638
03:43:44,140 --> 03:43:47,000
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Income producing activity by a public officer.

639
03:43:47,240 --> 03:44:01,000
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, those that are derived from, again, from profession and from businesses that are, again, I think declared by that specific official. Ito po yung mga lehitimo na kanyang kinita.

640
03:44:01,160 --> 03:44:20,280
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now, based on your knowledge po and experience as a financial investigator, let's just delve on this po. If the concerned individual Being investigated po by the AMLC, kunyari nag-invest up po kayo tapos public officer siya, what is the importance of studying that person sal and carefully?

641
03:44:21,290 --> 03:44:37,830
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: It gives our AMLC, the investigators, proper profiling of the concerned official. So they will be able to identify if this is within his or her business or financial capacity or profile.

642
03:44:38,270 --> 03:45:05,170
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you po. Now let me direct your attention to the SALNs of the following public officials. These are unmarked but we will mark accordingly at the proper time, Your Honor. Can you flash that? Okay, can you zoom in please? So this is a SALN of our President Ferdinand Jr. Marcos. This is for the year 2022 filed in 2023. I'll just focus on two things.

643
03:45:07,370 --> 03:45:11,190
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: The financial and business interests. Can we go there?

644
03:45:15,400 --> 03:45:44,610
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: So there's a portion po doon na business interests and financial connection. So si PBBM listed two. One is Araka Resources Corporation. And then the other one is El Paraizo Farms Incorporated. And then may pre-provide siya na other details on that. As a financial investigator, what comments do you have on the financial and business interest portion? This portion po of PBBM SALN.

645
03:45:44,810 --> 03:45:45,350
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: If

646
03:45:45,350 --> 03:45:45,570
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: any.

647
03:45:46,110 --> 03:46:06,360
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Your Honor, I would have to, I'm sorry to interrupt, but I would have to object to the question on the grounds of irrelevance and immateriality. The respondent who is on trial in this case and whatever may be in the SALN of another official. Really has nothing to do with any of the issues here.

648
03:46:07,010 --> 03:46:11,710
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: If he knows, Your Honor. Anyway, it's in light with the earlier provision, Section 13, in the President.

649
03:46:11,870 --> 03:47:00,940
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I think this was discussed before, Honorable Chel, and as pointed out too by one of the Senator judges, if not the Presiding Officer himself, on the phrase, participating in business, as opposed to merely having a conflict of interest. That the court took of record, took of note, that previous presidents, in fact not only President BBM, previous presidents wrote business interests in their salon without similar microscopic investigations being conducted against them, beginning for that matter. From former President Corazon Aquino, who I believe listed the most number of corporations that she was a part of at that time. So the court will allow it.

650
03:47:02,470 --> 03:47:11,670
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: If you know, Attorney Rainer, when you conduct your financial investigations, any comment on this portion, business interests and financial interests?

651
03:47:11,670 --> 03:47:43,180
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, in this case, Your Honor, as a financial investigator, I will only take note of this business interest. There's nothing adverse. With this disclosure. We'll take note of this information and if later on we stumbled upon another data that might elicit linking with these entities, business interests, then we'll use that. But as far as I can remember, this is a harmless information.

652
03:47:44,660 --> 03:47:50,260
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you. One more aspect on the SALN. Let us go through

653
03:47:51,780 --> 03:47:55,500
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Towards the last portion, yung total net worth.

654
03:47:57,560 --> 03:48:22,050
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Dami kasi dyan. I don't know if you can see, but the total net worth of PBBM as of 2023 is 960,700,422.23. I'll just let you take note of that and then I'll ask a question later. Let's move on to the next SALN that we have.

655
03:48:25,860 --> 03:48:55,040
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: So this is also for our President Ferdinand Jr. Marcos. This is for the year 2023 and filed in 2024. Let's go to the financial and business interests portion again. So, nandun pa rin, no? So, Araka Resources Corporation and El Paraiso Farms Incorporated. Pagkaganyan, two straight SALNs na. Any comments? Does it trigger anything in your financial investigation?

656
03:48:55,670 --> 03:48:58,910
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: In this case, your honor, none. Again, this is harmless information.

657
03:48:59,630 --> 03:49:06,350
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, and let's go to the last portion pertaining to

658
03:49:08,080 --> 03:49:22,050
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: the total net worth. So, in just one year, Lumake, nagkaroon ng 200 million increase from 900,000, naging 1 billion, 157 million.

659
03:49:26,010 --> 03:49:52,700
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: 867,589.20. Again, I'll let you take note of that. I'll show you one last SALN for the following year. For the year 2023, ah, 2024, filed in April 30, 2025, again for our President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. Let's go to those two portions, yung business and financial interests. It's still there. Araka Resources Corporation and El Paraíso Farms.

660
03:49:54,450 --> 03:50:21,870
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Incorporated, and then I'll go to the last portion, which is the total net worth. So, from 960,000 in a year, naging 1.1 billion, and then after another year, nag-200 million increase na naman, naging 1.3 billion pesos. Do you know how much the salary of the President is? If you know?

661
03:50:22,450 --> 03:50:23,590
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: No idea, Your Honor.

662
03:50:23,710 --> 03:50:30,580
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: No idea. Can you comment on that? Almost yearly, 200 million increase in the SALN.

663
03:50:30,900 --> 03:50:47,120
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, as a financial investigator, Your Honor, I cannot make a conclusion out of this information. Again, it should be subjected. Kailangan hong mabusising imbistigahan muna yan before we can make a conclusion based on this SALN alone.

664
03:50:48,290 --> 03:51:13,550
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, kasi yung pinag-uusapan natin dito, wala pa sa kalahati ng increase. But let me ask you about one more public official. Just to complete the picture, this is a SALN of then Vice President Lenny Robredo. Can you show the name? Maria Leonor Robredo. Can you go to that one portion lang? On the financial and business interests. Let's just see kung meron.

665
03:51:15,310 --> 03:51:16,730
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Meron din siya, Meralco.

666
03:51:18,900 --> 03:51:26,990
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Any comment on this? If you know lang, how you use these types of information in your financial investigation?

667
03:51:27,450 --> 03:51:40,250
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, a typical financial investigator would just take note of this information. It's harmless as it is. So later na lang po, if they stumble upon information regarding that, and then they will correlate it.

668
03:51:40,920 --> 03:52:36,500
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you. Let's move on. Let me direct your attention to page 21 of the so-called expert report. Paragraph 4. VP Sara and spouse have undeclared income from their business interests. It says here, and I read, can you flash that? It says there, a vice president is not allowed to have business interests. This prohibition is not only provided by ordinary law or government policy. The 1987 Constitution itself strictly prohibits the VP. From directly or indirectly participating in any business. Now, without assuming po that this so-called expert's interpretation is correct, how similar or different does the prohibition against the vice president to the prohibition against the president, members of the cabinet, and their deputies or assistants?

669
03:52:37,830 --> 03:52:42,670
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: May limited knowledge po of our constitutional law. It is uniformly applied.

670
03:52:43,070 --> 03:52:55,690
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Uniformly applied. And what special treatment po does the law have? In favor of the President, members of the Cabinet, and their deputies or assistants in relation to this provision. Kung meron man po.

671
03:52:56,890 --> 03:53:02,830
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, Your Honor, my personal appreciation of our constitutional law, it applies equally to all.

672
03:53:03,070 --> 03:53:13,990
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now, one last point on SALN. Since we don't want to disclose any confidential information, Attorney De La Fuente, I'll give you a scenario and ask you several questions thereafter.

673
03:53:16,750 --> 03:53:42,350
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: I'll use a visual. So, there's a public official wife and he's married to a private citizen husband. And the public official wife has been in public office since 2007 up to the present, save for three years. Now, the public official wife filed SALNs for those 19 years, save for the three years. Parang ganito po yung finial na SALN.

674
03:53:44,950 --> 03:53:58,590
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: So, noong 2007, meron po siyang finial na 7 million. Around 7 million pesos. And then ang combined net worth nila, 19 years later, almost 20 years later, is 94 million.

675
03:54:01,170 --> 03:54:47,280
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Nakakasunod po kayo dun sa senaryo ko. So 94 million na po sila. So ang growth po in 19 years is around nandun. 86.9 million pesos. Now if you look at the pertinent ITRs of this couple, the grand total of combined income for which proper taxes were paid, was also around 86 million, 86.7. So ang difference po nila after 20 years is a measly 150,000 pesos. Kaya po, based sa senaryo po na ito as a financial investigator, what does it mean po that the lawful income for which proper taxes were paid matches or is proportionate with what is indicated in the SALN?

676
03:54:48,660 --> 03:55:22,570
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Given this hypothetical scenario, Your Honor, It weakens the argument that there is unexplained income, unexplained figures. Since the materiality of the difference. But again, ito ay base lamang dito sa hypothetical scenario na ito. But I would suggest a further inquiry, a further assessment in order for us exhaust everything. This will be a full-blown investigation.

677
03:55:23,050 --> 03:55:33,030
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you po for that answer. Now let me direct your attention to the so-called expert's conclusion about unexplained wealth as contained in Table 39.

678
03:55:35,970 --> 03:56:13,640
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Meron pong ano dito, seven columns. Year. And then doon po sa fifth and sixth column, nakalagay po doon, and I'll read. Total computed undeclared income from Cali88 and Metro City. And yung sixth column po, total computed undeclared income from GenCorp. So huwag niyo na po masyadong pansinin yung mga figures to kasi conjectures lang naman yan. But let me first ask you, how should the personality of corporations be distinguished from the personality of the individuals affiliated with them?

679
03:56:14,120 --> 03:56:25,840
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Your Honor, I move to strike that portion of the question that refers to conjectures. That is an opinion on the part of the defense counsel and has no place in a direct examination question.

680
03:56:26,520 --> 03:56:43,440
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Let's just replace the opinion of the supposed expert with conjecture. Let that be reflected in the record. Witness may answer.

681
03:56:44,600 --> 03:56:59,200
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Ang question ko naman, Atty. Dela Fuente, in terms of the personality. So, how should the personality of corporations, kasi may binanggit dito na corporations, be distinguished from the personality of the individuals affiliated with them, if at all?

682
03:57:00,650 --> 03:57:08,750
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Under our revised corporation code, Your Honor, I think it's basic principle that there is a separate and distinct personality of the corporation over the shareholders.

683
03:57:09,450 --> 03:57:17,080
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And how should the income of corporations be distinguished from the income of individuals affiliated to them, if at all?

684
03:57:17,080 --> 03:57:26,880
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: As a rule, Your Honor, we abide with the doctrine of separate juridical personalities, separate personalities. So it's separate from the individuals composing the corporation.

685
03:57:27,410 --> 03:57:59,330
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay, thank you. Let's go to another point, yung piercing the veil of corporate fiction po. Dito po kasi sa ginawang ng so-called expert ng prosecution, And I hope this is not become the gospel truth. But he imputed fraud and pierced the veil of corporate fiction. So my question is this, based on your knowledge as a financial investigation, who has the authority to pierce the veil of corporate fiction? If you know.

686
03:58:00,040 --> 03:58:22,480
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Under our revised corporation code, Your Honor, piercing the veil of corporate fiction lies with the court. There should be a judicial declaration first, judicial determination, and it should be made after due process. So there must be proper notice and hearing.

687
03:58:22,480 --> 03:58:43,410
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: All right. So court pala hindi yung so-called expert ang gumagawa ng piercing the corporate veil. Pero paano po kung yung so-called forensic expert lang yung gumawa and based on this alleged piercing the veil. He came up with figures in his report. My question is, what is the reliability of that kind of methodology?

688
03:58:44,850 --> 03:58:56,860
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, Your Honor, I did not read entirely the report as to its reliability. I cannot testify on that.

689
03:58:57,680 --> 03:58:59,000
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: In general?

690
03:58:59,240 --> 03:59:15,470
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: In general, well, it has an adverse effect on the... Reliability. It questions the assumptions made. It puts, na ano yan, nagkakaroon ng duda doon sa mga assumptions at computations made.

691
03:59:15,850 --> 03:59:27,510
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay, thank you po. Sorry, medyo tinetest ko na po yung corporate law knowledge nyo but naalala nyo po ba what are the proper grounds for very briefly lang po, grounds for piercing the corporate veil?

692
03:59:28,010 --> 03:59:43,920
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Normally, Your Honor, if it is to defeat public purpose, commission of fraud, Alter ego. The corporation is used as an alter ego or business conduit. So, those three are the grounds to pierce the veil.

693
03:59:44,160 --> 03:59:53,560
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And one more question on this. How precise po ba should the determination be in terms of the grounds before you pierce the corporate veil?

694
03:59:54,100 --> 03:59:56,960
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kailangan ho may court judicial determination.

695
03:59:57,760 --> 04:00:19,890
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you po. Now, as a final... As a financial investigator, kung di naman pala tama yung piercing the corporate veil, and that is the premise of my question, what is the propriety of attributing gross revenue of a corporation or percentage thereof to any individual affiliated to it based on percentage of ownership, for example?

696
04:00:21,480 --> 04:00:25,600
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, gross revenues, Your Honor.

697
04:00:25,740 --> 04:00:30,730
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: or percentage thereof i-attribute dun sa individual affiliated to it kung wala namang proper piercing.

698
04:00:31,070 --> 04:00:36,720
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: It should be separated. Dapat po magkahiwalay pa rin yan. At hindi nilalump together.

699
04:00:37,100 --> 04:00:49,220
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. So sa madaling salita po, kung wala pong proper piercing of the corporate veil, ano po yung dapat i-attribute na kita ng corporation doon sa affiliated na individual kung meron man?

700
04:00:50,320 --> 04:00:52,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Dapat po. Ito ay magkahiwalay pa rin.

701
04:00:52,590 --> 04:01:08,870
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay, thank you po. Now to be more vivid lang po, no? Kung wala pong proper piercing of the corporate veil ng Cale88, ano po yung dapat i-attribute na kita sa affiliated na individual tulad nila VP Sara at Atty. Mans?

702
04:01:09,640 --> 04:01:14,260
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yung dividendo kung maaari nilang matanggap, yun lamang po.

703
04:01:14,480 --> 04:01:19,430
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Kung walang proper piercing po ng Metro City, ganun din po?

704
04:01:20,520 --> 04:01:25,460
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ganoon din po. Hindi po dapat i-attribute yun sa mga individuals. Separate pa rin po dapat siya.

705
04:01:25,500 --> 04:01:35,480
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And then kung wala pong proper piercing of the corporate veil ng GenCorp, ano po yung mga dapat i-attribute na kita sa affiliated na individual na sina VP Sara at Atty. Mans? Kung meron man.

706
04:01:35,960 --> 04:01:39,340
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kung meron man sila matanggap na dividendo o sweldo, yun lamang po.

707
04:01:39,520 --> 04:01:52,220
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Now, dito sa last column po ng so-called expert report. Which is quite inaccurate. May column and we will demonstrate that through this question. May total undeclared daw.

708
04:01:53,880 --> 04:02:23,810
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Pero kung mapapansin nyo, in-add lang naman. In-add lang naman yung assumed undeclaration per year from 2022 to 2025. Kaya po umabot ng 800 plus million. Now, my only question is this. Kung yung figures po kanina, kasi ito sabi niyo kanina eh, hindi naman attributable yan. If the figures used are inaccurate or not based on actual data, how reliable are the findings? Kung ganun po yung methodology na ginamit.

709
04:02:24,290 --> 04:02:35,590
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Objection, Your Honor, to the use of the phrase quite inaccurate. That's the lawyer testifying, not the witness. The witness has not said anything about any inaccuracies in the report of Atty. Cabrera.

710
04:02:36,210 --> 04:02:42,650
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Anyway, Your Honor, the question may be answered in general terms. My only question is how reliable are the findings?

711
04:02:42,970 --> 04:02:48,990
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly reform, let that stay on the record. How reliable would the findings be if that is the methodology?

712
04:02:49,990 --> 04:02:52,050
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: For this, Your Honor, it would,

713
04:02:52,150 --> 04:02:52,730
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: again,

714
04:02:52,890 --> 04:03:04,450
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: depend on the discretion, the wisdom, application of wisdom ng ating Senate Impeachment Court. As to how, if this is reliable or not, I really leave it to the wisdom.

715
04:03:08,910 --> 04:03:17,190
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: I'll reform the question. If the figures are not based on actual data and then totaled, how reliable is the total?

716
04:03:18,730 --> 04:03:21,070
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, it weakens the reliability, Your Honor.

717
04:03:21,840 --> 04:04:22,640
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you. Let's proceed. Let me direct your attention to page 10 of the so-called expert report. Let me read that for you. To arrive at the calculated... Capital contribution of GenCorp. We confirm through inspection of official receipts the existence of five Jollibee branches in Centerpoint, Davao, Abriza Mall, Bolton, Davao, Gaysano Mall, and Times Square Plaza Corner, all bearing the name of GenCorp Industries, Inc. Refer to Annex C for the inspected receipts. I'll ask about the methodology used, attorney. It appears kasi na itong so-called expert na ito wanted to prove that certain branches of Jollibee belong to a corporation named GenCorp. So naisip niyang paraan ay kumain sa Jollibee branches at tingnan yung mga resibo. I'm not making this up. Let me illustrate. Kindly take a look at page 43 of the so-called expert report. Can you zoom in?

718
04:04:26,860 --> 04:04:38,240
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Sa resibo, nakalagay GenCorp Industries, tapos nakalagay yung branch. This was in Centerpoint. Centerpoint Plaza. Let's go to page 44 of the report.

719
04:04:40,320 --> 04:04:52,350
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Ito. So, yun ulit. GenCorp Industries, and then nilagay niyo yung branch. Bolton. Bolton Street. Okay. Page 45.

720
04:04:54,920 --> 04:05:04,910
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Yan. So, nakalagay ulit doon GenCorp. And then, nakalagay naman Abrizamol. Ito namang receipt na ito, walang duda galing Jollibee ito talaga. Kasi may

721
04:05:04,910 --> 04:05:07,730
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: marka pa ng gravy yung isang resibo.

722
04:05:07,910 --> 04:05:15,350
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Ayan. So, ito lang yata yung expert report na may gravy. But let's move on to page 46.

723
04:05:18,630 --> 04:05:29,200
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Davao City, yan. So, GenCorp ulit, Jollibee Corporation, Gaisano Mall. And then finally, for the fifth receipt, 47.

724
04:05:31,390 --> 04:05:51,260
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Jollibee, under GenCorp ulit, tapos ibang branch naman, Times Square. So, again, between this type of methodology, this is my only question from this so-called expert, and simply verifying information with the duly authorized representative of the corporation itself, which is, in this case, GenCorp, which is more reliable.

725
04:05:52,090 --> 04:06:37,870
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: If your honor, please. I'm sorry to interrupt the good counsel and the witness. But it would appear that this line of questioning is going beyond the offer of testimony of this witness. He was presented and his testimony was offered to prove fundamental anti-money laundering concepts. But now he is talking about a financial investigation into not money laundering but unexplained wealth. And he has no expertise insofar as that subject matter is concerned. He has neither been offered nor has he testified to having any credentials insofar as investigating unexplained wealth, salary and non-declarations, and participation in business interests are concerned.

726
04:06:38,610 --> 04:07:00,870
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: The chair will grant some latitude, counsel, and this can fall under in his general offer, the third or fourth offer if I'm not mistaken. And we'll allow the question. This, I guess... would be their part of their counter to your expert witness, Honorable Chel, and we'll allow it.

727
04:07:00,970 --> 04:07:01,490
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you, Your Honor.

728
04:07:01,690 --> 04:07:02,770
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Attorney Mark, you may proceed.

729
04:07:03,010 --> 04:07:14,670
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Yung methodology lang po na ganun eh, between doing that, what I demonstrated, and verifying information with the corporations involved, which is more reliable in financial investigations?

730
04:07:15,850 --> 04:07:28,640
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Actually, Your Honor, napapakunot ako ng noo kanina dun sa placebo. I don't see the... Again, we don't do this sa financial investigation. It can be verified by official SEC documents.

731
04:07:30,470 --> 04:07:59,200
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: It is more in terms of reliability. It is more official. Again, right now, very ano na ho ang AI. Madaling mabago yung mga ganon. I'm not talking about that specific piece of, yung ating hong na-flash sa screen. But we have this reality, so the best evidence to obtain are those documents emanating from a government agency, certified true copies, etc.

732
04:07:59,680 --> 04:08:03,980
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Sorry, hindi ko lang po narinig yung unang part napapa... ano'ng sabi niyo, napapakunot?

733
04:08:06,200 --> 04:08:07,580
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

734
04:08:07,740 --> 04:09:57,240
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay. Let me direct your attention to pages 10 to 11 of the so-called expert report. Let me read. Desktop research from Jollibee's official website show an initial franchise cost to be at least 35 million to 55 billion per store. Conservatively, assigning a 35 million value to each of the five different branches, a total of at least 175 million capital should be invested. To operate these five branches, rent for the store venue, and working capital requirements for salaries of the manager and crew, as well as initial inventory costs should be, among others, be added. Nonetheless, for purposes of attributing the 20% capital of the respondent, we simply use the absolute minimum amount of 35 million. The equivalent of one of five stores. The capital investments should discuss above constitute equity investments that should form part of the couple's personal properties and should have been disclosed in the SALN. However, a review of the SALNs revealed no corresponding declarations of their equity in these assets. My question is this, we learned from GenCorp representative na hindi naman nagbayad ng 35 million each for each franchise kasi renewal of old franchises lang naman ang ginawa ng GenCorp. So in that case, what is the propriety of attributing 20% of an unverified value of 35 million and declaring it as unexplained wealth?

735
04:09:58,330 --> 04:10:28,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, Your Honor, I have no personal knowledge as to the methodology, how they Applied the techniques dito sa forensic examination report. But looking at this, it should have been complemented by other, not just desktop work or off-site work. There should be what natawag nating on-site. Meron hung iba pang investigation techniques that should have complemented this report nung ito pong naka-flash ngayon sa ating screen.

736
04:10:29,380 --> 04:10:35,540
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you po. I'm glad you mentioned the term desktop research. What do you understand of the term desktop research?

737
04:10:36,120 --> 04:10:58,390
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: We also term it as off-site desk review lang po. Paper review. So, different po siya sa field work. Meron kayong on-site. Meron kayong walkthroughs. You interview, nakikita din nyo, nakakausap din nyo ang mga witnesses. You verify kung ano yung nakita nyo sa inyong desktop review with that on-site review.

738
04:10:58,800 --> 04:11:04,040
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, what trainings or seminars po ba does one need to become an expert in desktop research?

739
04:11:05,230 --> 04:11:29,900
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, yan ho ay nabibigay naman ng mga financial investigation trainings, forensic accounting trainings. Ang kaibahan lang siguro nito ay yung pag-implement. Kasi you need to go out in the field to really observe the people and have a... Full experience how this investigation is being conducted.

740
04:11:30,160 --> 04:13:22,370
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay, thank you po. Move on na po tayo sa ibang part. Let me direct your attention to pages 19 and 7 of the so-called expert report. I'll read paragraph 3 for security bank account and then we just redacted it based on the ruling of the Honorable Court. We performed a fund flow analysis. and identified 5.3 million in fund transfers from, and let me highlight this, Deo Zambrano and Adam Anthony Cabe III, and 5 million representing proceeds from the maturity of an investment. Further, tracing indicated that the 5 million investment had initially been funded through cash deposits consisting of approximately 5,000 pieces of 1,000 banknotes. We have identified that these funds were used to purchase the 10.6 million insurance from FWD. I'll stop there. But in this scenario po kasi, just to give you a background, itong so-called expert identified two other individuals, si Zambrano at si Kabe, to have contributed to the purchase of an FWD insurance in the amount po of 10.6 million. And yet, on page 7, can we go there? We can see na yung whole amount po ng 10.6 million, tech please, was attributed by the so-called expert. Ayan po, let me direct your attention. Yung FWD insurance, inattribute po nung so-called expert, yung buo, sa mag-asawa kay VP Sara at Atty. Mans. So in relation to this scenario po, let me just first ask you muna. Who owns a property if several individuals contribute to its acquisition? If you can just recall po from civil law lang.

741
04:13:22,690 --> 04:13:25,010
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The registered owner, your honor.

742
04:13:26,750 --> 04:13:38,360
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Kapag kamarami sila nag-contribute dun, what is the propriety po of attributing full ownership po dun sa isa lang na tao instead of all the co-owners?

743
04:13:38,860 --> 04:13:43,940
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: They are equally considered co-owners depending on their contribution.

744
04:13:45,180 --> 04:13:51,520
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, so thank you po. So ano pong propriety pag isang co-owner lang kinonsider mo?

745
04:13:52,820 --> 04:13:53,540
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Mali po yan.

746
04:13:53,660 --> 04:14:27,820
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you po. On page 17 po of the report of the so-called expert, so we have here a table, table 23. And I just like to focus on, again, two things. Huwag niyo na pong pansinin yung figures. Nakalagay lang po dyan bank inflows and then income. I ask you this kasi meron po kayong background sa accounting. Pero let me just ask you first, how different po ba yung technical term na income dun sa term na bank inflows?

747
04:14:28,520 --> 04:14:39,440
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Magkaiba po yun, Your Honor. All, well, not all inflows are income but all income are considered inflows.

748
04:14:39,980 --> 04:14:55,490
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay, very clear po. But in the course of this trial, we also encountered the term return of capital. Return of capital. So how proper po or improper is it to consider po yung return of capital as income?

749
04:14:56,610 --> 04:15:01,890
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Magkaiba po yun, Your Honor. Balik lang po ito ng puhunan ng kapital. Hindi po siya kita.

750
04:15:03,500 --> 04:16:27,050
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Maraming salamat po. Now let's go back to page 37 of the so-called report. Again, hopefully, hindi naman ito paniwalaan as gospel truth ng marami. But again, we see here huge amounts attributed to VP Sara and her spouse Atty. Mans. And I won't go through these figures one by one, but just to highlight one last column. Dito po sa total computed amount, meron po ditong tatlong figures, 55 million, 74 million. 82 million. Hindi na po ako maglalabas ng calculator. Pero ang total amount po niyan is around 212 million, 629,718. Okay. When in fact, the GenCorp representative only said, and this is part of the court records, 2,142,369.14. So, around 100 times po off or 100 times mali yung so-called expert. Dito lang po sa column na to. My only question is this. In financial investigations, how important is it to meticulously go through the records one by one instead of considering summaries based on mere conjectures?

751
04:16:27,670 --> 04:16:34,850
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Objection, Your Honor, to the use of the phrase mali. I'm an expert. That again is a conclusion on the part of the lawyer.

752
04:16:34,850 --> 04:16:42,930
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Let's convert it to divergent or different from. If that's okay, Attorney Mark. 100 times different or divergent from.

753
04:16:43,430 --> 04:16:45,630
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Yes, divergent from.

754
04:16:45,650 --> 04:16:45,890
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We're

755
04:16:45,890 --> 04:16:58,800
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: fine with that, Your Honor. So, that's the only question in financial investigations. How important is it to meticulously go through the records one by one instead of considering summaries based on mere conjectures?

756
04:16:59,420 --> 04:17:13,080
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Very important, Your Honor. Attention to detail is very important. Again, if there is a material deviation from the computation, it casts doubt dun sa computation.

757
04:17:13,600 --> 04:17:17,500
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And how would you characterize a report po that uses conjectures?

758
04:17:18,480 --> 04:17:33,590
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, we cannot base, especially if it concerns financial investigation, hindi ho lang base sa conjectures. Dapat ho, ito ay May facts. Ito ay base sa mga actual na nangyari.

759
04:17:34,140 --> 04:17:41,680
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Salamat po. And para lang po madaling maintindihan para rin po sa mga publiko, ano po ba yung conjecture sa Filipino? If you know.

760
04:17:42,790 --> 04:17:45,530
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa akin kong paghalang, ito ay mga haka-haka.

761
04:17:46,880 --> 04:18:02,130
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay. So based on haka-haka. Alright. Now, by the way, in your years in AMLC, in relation to financial investigation, para po diretso na, how much do you value findings? From so-called experts that are based on conjectures.

762
04:18:03,150 --> 04:18:39,740
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, sa AMLC po na trabaho, magagaling ho yung mga tao natin sa AMLC. They're the top-tier government agency insofar as doing financial investigation. So, I don't see the need of outsourcing this information. Sa batas ho, sa kanila lang nakalagak ang mandato na yan. At nakita ko kasi first hand din gaano ka professional, ka dedicated ito mga tao natin sa sekretaryat. So why give it, why outsource it to another person when you have one agency, it is exclusively reserved to that agency, that function.

763
04:18:40,280 --> 04:18:58,030
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Maraming salamat po. Isa pa pong tanong dito, how much the, pero parang na-at-sagot yun na rin po, pero diretso yun ko na lang. How much does the AMLC rely? On third-party forensic analysts vis-a-vis its own financial investigators.

764
04:18:58,570 --> 04:19:10,930
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi po sila nagre-rely. The AMLC is not bound to admit, rebut, or even suspend its activities pending the review of these private documents.

765
04:19:11,630 --> 04:19:25,170
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright po. And between the prosecution and the defense, I'm not just talking about this case, but in general. Between the prosecution and the defense, who has the burden of proving that an allegation is not based on conjectures?

766
04:19:25,780 --> 04:19:27,200
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The prosecution.

767
04:19:27,720 --> 04:19:49,690
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: One last point on this. Kung sa raw records po, such as CTRs and STRs from AMLC, may double entries. May double entries. Pero may report po ng isang so-called financial expert na nagsasabi na walang double entries. What holds more value? Records ba ng AMLC o yung report ng so-called expert?

768
04:19:50,410 --> 04:19:54,390
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The records of the AMLC po, no, should prevail.

769
04:19:54,810 --> 04:20:05,670
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, maraming salamat po. Let's move on. What is the function of lifestyle checks of public officials in financial investigation?

770
04:20:06,750 --> 04:20:30,290
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, again, Your Honor, no, the purpose is to check if, again, the... The finances of that particular official is already beyond what is expected from him or her given the income and the declared business interests. So it checks if there's a disparity. Meron kong pagkakaiba. Ito sa in-expect at ito sa actual.

771
04:20:31,200 --> 04:21:09,970
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Now let me direct your attention to Article 11 entitled Accountability of Public Officers. Article 11, Accountability of Public Officers. Section 1, Public Office is a Public Trust. Public officers and employees must at all times be accountable to the people, serve them with utmost responsibility, integrity, loyalty, and efficiency, act with patriotism and justice, and lead modest lives. Let me first ask you po, in relation to financial investigation of public officials, what is your view on public office as a public trust?

772
04:21:10,510 --> 04:21:23,170
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: That is again the foundation of our government. Cannot have a government without the people behind it supporting it. And support is again predicated on trust.

773
04:21:24,430 --> 04:21:31,950
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. And based on the provision that we just read, very briefly lang po, what does the command to lead modest lives entail?

774
04:21:33,620 --> 04:21:47,420
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, it must, again, they must be public officials, must lead modest lives. So again, not... Extravagant lifestyle. Do not adopt extravagant lifestyle but lead.

775
04:21:50,100 --> 04:21:54,740
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Have a lifestyle that is again what is expected from these public officials.

776
04:21:55,320 --> 04:22:04,420
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Ito quite personal na po, but you may or may not answer. But as a people, what should their attitude be towards public officers who do not lead modest lives?

777
04:22:06,590 --> 04:22:15,730
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, it degrades public trust. If it's, again, outside what is expected from these officials.

778
04:22:16,190 --> 04:22:20,390
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, I'll just use a more vivid scenario just to drive this point. Say hypothetical.

779
04:22:22,110 --> 04:22:51,630
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: There's a public officer who claims to be anti-poverty and he owns this type of vehicle. This is a 2026 Mercedes-Benz G-Wagon, all-electric, obsidian black metallic. and the starting price of this vehicle is around 13.5 million pesos. Grabe talaga. So, what does this scenario say about leading a modest life? In your opinion?

780
04:22:52,790 --> 04:22:54,630
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I'd rather not answer that.

781
04:22:54,810 --> 04:23:16,520
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Not answer? Okay. So, for example, this public officer accuses another of unexplained wealth and ostentatious lifestyle. My question is, in that scenario po, Again, hypothetical only. What does this say about the integrity of the accusation made by this kind of accuser? Kung ganyan yung public officer na nag-accusa.

782
04:23:17,050 --> 04:23:21,540
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Same your honor, same answer. I'd rather not delve upon this.

783
04:23:21,740 --> 04:23:23,400
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you. Let's just move on.

784
04:23:25,240 --> 04:23:37,000
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: When you conduct financial investigation on a public official, what is the propriety of upholding that person's rights?

785
04:23:38,350 --> 04:24:02,810
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, very important po yan. Along the course of the financial investigation, intact po ang rights ng ating subject. So, insofar as going into bank inquiry order, bank inquiry, even up to the civil forfeiture and filing of the money laundering case, meron po laging legal remedy ang ating subject, ang ating respondent.

786
04:24:04,860 --> 04:24:59,790
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Let me draw your attention to Article 11, Section 2. Section 2. The President, the Vice President, the members of the Supreme Court, the members of the Constitutional Commissions, and the Ombudsman may be removed from office on impeachment for and conviction of culpable violation of the Constitution, treason, bribery, graft and corruption, other high crimes, or betrayal of public trust. All other public officers and employees may be removed from office as provided by law, but not by impeachment. Sorry, please bear with me, Atty. Dela Fuente. I just have to go through this portion kasi meron pong financial investigation conducted in this impeachment. My question is, how will you describe the nature of the list of impeachable officers found in this section? If you can recall lang from your constitutional law.

787
04:25:01,150 --> 04:25:02,990
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: This is an exclusive list, Your Honor.

788
04:25:04,420 --> 04:25:10,560
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Exclusive. And how will you describe the nature of the grounds of impeachment in terms of seriousness?

789
04:25:11,940 --> 04:25:23,040
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, very serious po ito. On top of the hierarchy sila as to the degree of the offense.

790
04:25:23,620 --> 04:25:42,290
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you. And conviction in impeachment carries, alam naman po natin lahat to, the penalties of removal from position. and perpetual disqualification to hold public office. Now, how would you describe or characterize these penalties in terms of gravity or seriousness?

791
04:25:42,940 --> 04:25:57,620
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, very serious, Your Honor. Other than removal from office, absolute disqualification from holding further government offices. It leaves a stigma on the official.

792
04:25:58,920 --> 04:26:34,590
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay. We learned from mga amici curiae that the Court invited that the provisions of the Constitution kagaya po neto must not be read in isolation but in conjunction with each other. So let me relate the effects of the impeachment with another article under the Constitution, Article 5 on Suffrage. Let me read Section 1. Suffrage may be exercised by all citizens of the Philippines, not otherwise disqualified by law. For at least 18 years of age, have resided in the Philippines for at least one year in the place.

793
04:26:34,810 --> 04:26:41,210
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: With the permission of Attorney Mark, yes, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Raffy Tulfo?

794
04:26:41,290 --> 04:27:26,000
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Is he a super witness, omni-witness? Ano bang klaseng witness ng pine-present ng defense? Pati ba naman pati amici curiae, pakialaman niya, Supreme Court, pakialaman niya, o Ombudsman, DOJ. Who is he? Who is this guy? I'm really very, very curious about the qualification of this gentleman para lahat na lang ng topic, kayang-kaya niyang sagutin mula sa kanyang handler, or excuse me, sa Defense. I don't think he's capable of answering those questions kasi hindi niya territory yun eh, Mr. Presiding Officer. Parang nakakaantok na, parang hindi kapani-paniwala. Parang binobola lang tayo nito. Nakangiti nga siya. Smile means yes. Anyway, Mr. Presiding Officer, siguro medyo put him in a short leash.

795
04:27:28,460 --> 04:28:18,590
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Atty. Mark, Along these lines of questions, how many more do you have? I think I get the point and drift of Senator Judge Raffy. He seems to be an expert in all already. But these are basic concepts and interpretations of the law, which the court can and will do on its own, given that we can and have taken judicial notice, especially of the constitutional and other legal provisions. Especially given that he is not presented nor was he qualified as a constitutional expert but merely expressing his opinion as a lawyer. Similar to both parties and those are lawyers in this impeachment court. So either wind up with this line of questioning or move on to your next point, Attorney Mark.

796
04:28:18,820 --> 04:28:21,980
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Mr. Presiding Officer, if I may, Mr. Presiding Officer.

797
04:28:22,960 --> 04:28:24,720
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge...

798
04:28:24,720 --> 04:31:59,160
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Yes, Mr. Presiding Officer. I wanted to share the sentiment of my seatmate, Senator Raffy Tulfo because we have been giving a lot of leeway to the respondent's line of questioning but I was looking at the subpoena issued to the witness and it says here The witness, Attorney De La Fuente, will testify on fundamental legal concepts relating to the Anti-Money Laundering Act as amended. Identify documents relevant to his testimony and such other relevant matters. The issuance of a subpoena duces tecum and ad testificandum is requested directing the witness to appear and give his testimony. Using his curriculum vitae and other documents relevant to his qualifications and testimony. I'm just wondering, Mr. Presiding Officer, if the witness here will only talk about and be our resource person with regards to what was written in the subpoena. Because if you listen carefully to... What we have been hearing, number one, bagamat maaari po siyang magbigay ng expert opinion sa kanyang larangan bilang eksperto sa anti-money laundering, Hindi naman usap. Siguro pwedeng magdeklara na mali o invalid ang findings ng AMLA. At nasa Korte po yung pagpapasya kung gaano kabigat yung ebidensyang inilalahad po dito. Ikalawa, ginawang pangulaw, matagal na diniscuss kanina yung bank secrecy law. And malinaw naman po doon sa Section 2 na ang isang impeachment proceedings ay exemption sa bank secrecy. And in the November 5 order of this court, pinayagan po na ang AMLA records na may sumiti pursuant doon sa lawful subpoena subject to confidentiality safeguards. At panghuli ginong Pangulo, Mr. Presiding Officer, yung expertise po kasi ng witness sa anti-money laundering, bagamat may iba siguro na hindi mag-agree na siya isang eksperto, ako na ho, I give him the benefit of the doubt, Pero ang maaari niya pong ipaliwanag ang AMLA at banking practices pero na-ba-bother po ako, ginong Pangulo, at naa-alarma na hindi po siya ang DOJ, hindi po siya ang ombudsman, lalo na hindi po siya ang parte ng korte para magbigay po ng binding legal conclusions o mag-desisyon kung meron nga pong criminal liability. Mr. Presiding Officer, my only question is, dapat ba doon lang po umiikot yung kanyang pagiging isang testigo doon sa inisyo na subpoena? Or ang dahilan po ba kung bakit siya naririto ay para i-refute yung pong sinasabing financial expert ng prosecution? Because if that's the case, I have no problem with that, Mr. Presiding Officer.

799
04:32:00,630 --> 04:32:13,270
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Atty. Mark, kindly respond to the query. Noted, Senator Judge Villanueva, kindly respond to the query of the Presiding Officer. How long will your questions be along these lines?

800
04:32:14,230 --> 04:32:46,190
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Just a couple of pages worth of questions, Your Honor. Anyway, just to respond also for the guidance of the Senator Judges, part of our offer is for... The witness to testify on other relevant matters and we deem that these are all relevant matters. Considering your honor, my prior question that how important is upholding The rights of the person being financially investigated apply as well. So, just a couple more questions. Again, Your Honor, we ask for leeway considering...

801
04:32:46,190 --> 04:32:50,970
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We have been giving... You must acknowledge that we have been giving leeway.

802
04:32:51,070 --> 04:33:01,110
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And we very much appreciate, Your Honor, the leeway that has been given to us. But just to answer the question of the presiding officer, there's a couple pages worth of questions, Ron.

803
04:33:01,620 --> 04:33:03,540
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Just one follow-up question on that.

804
04:33:03,560 --> 04:33:05,300
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly turn on the mic of Senator Judge Villanueva.

805
04:33:05,420 --> 04:33:11,690
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Just one follow-up question on that. Did you give the witness a copy of the forensic report?

806
04:33:13,340 --> 04:33:14,200
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: No, your honor.

807
04:33:14,850 --> 04:33:30,570
Sen. Joel Villanueva: No, because I was wondering, Mr. Presiding Officer, a while ago, if I heard it right from the witness, that he himself did not even get a chance to actually read the forensic report. So he doesn't have any copy of that.

808
04:33:31,560 --> 04:33:42,210
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: That's accurate, your honor. That's why... Part of our questioning is to confront actual portions of that report and asking him of his general comments there.

809
04:33:42,230 --> 04:33:53,450
Sen. Joel Villanueva: I'm just wondering because if he is to refute the report, then he should have seen the report, should have read the report. I'm just wondering. Thank you, Mr. President.

810
04:33:53,670 --> 04:34:02,940
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: With all due respect, Your Honor, we just wanted to do it in open court. We didn't want to have any prior correspondence with the subpoenaed witness.

811
04:34:03,140 --> 04:34:22,960
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Because that's the thing that I'm going to do later on when we get the chance to ask questions. We will be asking him about the forensic report because we feel that he is the best person to refute the forensic report. Now, if he cannot answer these questions, then... For me, it's going to be useless.

812
04:34:23,320 --> 04:34:30,800
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We are okay with that, Your Honor, with that methodology. It's really up to, we submit to the court's wisdom on how they want to confront this witness later.

813
04:34:30,800 --> 04:34:42,520
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Okay, thank you. Thank you for that clarification. How the senator judges will ask or make interjections and how the senator judges in the court will appreciate the testimony of this witness. Yes, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Raffy Tulfo?

814
04:34:42,780 --> 04:36:05,840
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Thank you, Mr. President. Dudugtuhan ko lang ang sinabi kanina ni Senator Villanueva. Kung i-refute niya ang forensic expert witness and yet hindi pala siya nabigyan ng kopya ng mga dokumento present ng expert witness. So hindi dapat siya pwedeng mag-refute o kumontra dahil in the first place wala siyang idea kung ano yung mga nakasaad doon sa sinabi ng testigo yung forensic expert witness. At pinasenta rito, maliban na lamang sa on the spot, pinagtatanong ng defense. So dapat, beforehand, he was given a copy of those documents para makapag-aralan niya, para makapagawa siya ng research, para in that case, magiging intelligent, he will be well informed, and he can give intelligent assessment doon sa pag-refute. Sa mga sinabi nung forensic witness, sa ngayon kasi wala eh. Wala siyang kaalam-alam, Mr. Presiding Officer. Wala talaga. Zero. Nagtakangaw kanina, pati ba naman yung, ano ba to? G-Wagon, mag-witness sa G-Wagon, ano ba to? Salesman na rin. I mean, baka mamaya eh.

815
04:36:05,840 --> 04:36:12,820
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: The court reminds the gallery to kindly not react or avoid reacting to statements made by anyone in this chamber.

816
04:36:12,980 --> 04:36:37,740
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: I mean, sorry, parang gina - Maybe it's not your fault. I'm not gonna fault you on this. Maybe ang problema sa defense, sobrang bilib sila sa iyo, pero hindi mo siguro kayang panindigan yung kasobrang kabiliban nila sa iyo na kung ano na lang pinapasok at sinusubo sa iyo na hindi mo kayang panindigan, hindi mo kayang sasagot. Nagmumakatuloy ikaw na parang alam mo na, hindi mo kagagawa niyong kundi kagagawa ng defense. Maraming salamat po, Mr. President Officer.

817
04:36:38,860 --> 04:36:43,280
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, Duly noted, Senator Judge Raffy, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Bam?

818
04:36:44,760 --> 04:36:47,980
Sen. Paolo Benigno “Bam” Aquino: On this note, Mr. President Officer, Mr. Witness,

819
04:36:50,200 --> 04:36:54,520
Sen. Paolo Benigno “Bam” Aquino: Any documents provided to you before appearing here?

820
04:36:55,520 --> 04:36:56,160
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: None, Your Honor.

821
04:36:57,460 --> 04:37:16,130
Sen. Paolo Benigno “Bam” Aquino: So, none of the AMLA records that we subpoenaed were shown to you? Yung mga bank statements, insurance, placements, GIS ng mga kumpanya, were any of these shown to you?

822
04:37:16,470 --> 04:37:17,350
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: None, Your Honor.

823
04:37:17,690 --> 04:37:24,670
Sen. Paolo Benigno “Bam” Aquino: None? Okay, so I take it the defense is asking you about the report in terms of concepts.

824
04:37:25,610 --> 04:37:40,210
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And on the basis, Your Honor, of actual portions. Because it's a 50-page report, Your Honor, so we just wanted to focus on several portions of that report by confronting him in open court of those portions and then asking him about concepts.

825
04:37:40,230 --> 04:38:33,650
Sen. Paolo Benigno “Bam” Aquino: Okay, so it's really concepts and general ideas about... Amla, and Financial Investigations. Okay? Kasi, Mr. Witness, and again, di mo naman itong kasalanan, but many times, we have witnesses here, pag tinatanong na namin, ang sagot sa amin, di ho namin alam. So, gusto namin ng mga witness na pwede kaming saguting diretso talaga. Because we just want to find out, we just want to find out the truth, we want to know your opinion. but on specific matters also. So, anyway, you're here and later on may cross, later on magtatanong kami, pero ang ayaw naming marinig is yung sunod-sunod na hindi ko po alam, hindi ko po nabasa, hindi ko po, di ba? Kasi ang nangyayari parang wala rin tayong narating na totoong opinion o totoong pananaw dito sa mga bagay-bagay. Thank you, thank you, Mr. President.

826
04:38:33,890 --> 04:38:38,470
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: What is the pleasure of Senator Judge Erwin, the remarks of the Hon. Aquino are generally noted.

827
04:38:40,780 --> 04:40:15,200
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Mr. Presiding Officer, quick manifestation lamang po. Kung wala pong nakakita ng mga dokumento itong testigo po na ito, lahat po na sinasabi niya kanina pa, kanina pang umaga, may aabutin na tayo ng alas 6 ng gabi, lahat po ito ay theoretical and cannot be rebutted, documented as documented financial intelligence, Mr. Presiding Officer. Kahit na nanggaling pa siya dyan sa AMLC, etc. na yung kanyang expertise. Kung hindi naman niya po nakita pala ay mga dokumento, STRs, CTRs. What good is it? Para anong titistigo niya? E puro ito theory sa kanyang paningin, sa kanyang paniniwala. I think the defense. I know that you can do better than that. Siguro this coming days, get a witness. Now, who can really stand up? I'm just telling you now to prepare. Get somebody who can really stand up, who can really answer questions from the senator judges. Because mamaya ito, papawisan ito, baka hindi na makasagot ito. I mean, medyo mahina po, I'm sorry ha, mahina po yung the witnesses that you're presenting here these past few days. I cannot dictate that, but I'm just saying, that's my opinion there. Against somebody who can really ika nga na professional, na who can rebut yung mga sanasabi ng prosecution, makakasagot po. Maraming salamat po.

828
04:40:15,200 --> 04:40:18,080
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We respect the opinion. We know the manifestations of the Senator.

829
04:40:18,180 --> 04:40:20,860
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, what is the pleasure of Senator Judge Risa Hontiveros?

830
04:40:24,550 --> 04:40:34,640
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: If I may, Mr. Presiding Officer, just a quick follow-up question to the questions raised right now by the colleague Senator Judges. If I may.

831
04:40:34,720 --> 04:40:35,060
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes.

832
04:40:35,420 --> 04:40:36,940
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Salamat po, Mr. Presiding Officer.

833
04:40:37,000 --> 04:40:37,520
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You may proceed.

834
04:40:37,940 --> 04:40:50,700
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Atty. Dela Fuente, kasasabi niyo na lamang po ngayon na hindi niyo po nabasa ang forensic report na earlier inihain sa korteng ito ni Atty. Cabrera. Tama po?

835
04:40:50,980 --> 04:40:51,680
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor.

836
04:40:52,160 --> 04:41:11,790
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Pero at least nabasa niyo po ba o nasimulan man lang iscan, natignan niyo po ba yung mga iba't ibang records na sinupinas, sinumite sa korteng ito na pinagbasehan? Atty. Cabrera sa kanyang inihaing forensics report sa amin.

837
04:41:11,850 --> 04:41:17,350
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor, hindi po kasi ito ay confidential. Wala akong authority to look into those documents.

838
04:41:18,110 --> 04:41:39,930
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: So, ibig sabihin, with all due respect po, sa ngayon, wala po kayo sa solid na posisyon na suriin. Yung kalidad or katotohanan or solidong basehan kahit po sa general principles nung forensic report na iyon ni Atty. Cabrera.

839
04:41:40,070 --> 04:41:57,310
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Meron po, Your Honor. As flashed on the screen, I echo what the law says. So base lang po sa batas, maaari ko na akong sagutin kung ano yung nasa... Na ito ba ay lawful or hindi? Yun po ang ginagawa ko ngayon.

840
04:41:57,410 --> 04:42:30,460
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Alright. So lastly, follow up sa ngayon, Atty. De La Fuente. Kasunod ng mga prinsipyo ngayon na kung bibigyan niyo po ng benefit of the doubt si Atty. Cabrera noon na nagsisikap siyang sumunod din sa mga batayang prinsipyo ng inyong propesyon, dahil kayo po ay peer, kayo po ay colleague kay Atty. Cabrera, Masasabi niyo po ba na may misrepresentation kay Atty. Cabrera na tawagin siyang supposed expert sa field ninyo?

841
04:42:30,460 --> 04:43:17,300
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, I have a high respect for, respect for Atty. Cabrera. His professional and personal opinions po ay nirerespeto natin siya. But pagdating sa batas, again, we have to abide kung ano yung tama ba, nasa tamang proseso po ba, ang kanyang methodologies po ba ay tama. So ang ginagawa ko lang po, binabangga ang kanyang ginawa doon sa kung ano ang meron sa batas. Kung ito po ba ay mag-a-align. Yun ang aking role dito. Kaya nga sabi ko, I don't need to, ito sa sarili ko, to read the full report even before going here. Because kahit i-flash yan ngayon pa lang, makikita niyo na po, aligned po ba ito sa mga provisions ng AMLA? or hindi.

842
04:43:17,500 --> 04:43:49,970
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Sa huli po, at least, salamat naman sa pinahayag niyong pagrespeto bilang peer ninyo kay Atty. Cabrera and I'm willing to guess kung itinanong namin sa kanya noon, sasabihin din niya sa kahit sinong colleague. So at the very least po, and in closing dito sa interjection ko, dahil tinanggap po ng Korte na isa sa mga expert witnesses sa trial na ito si Atty. Cabrera, at the very least, nire-respeto niyo po ba? Yung ganyang pagtanggap ng Korte kay Atty. Cabrera bilang isa sa mga expert witnesses sa trial na ito.

843
04:43:49,990 --> 04:43:50,370
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes,

844
04:43:50,370 --> 04:43:50,530
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Your Honor.

845
04:43:50,750 --> 04:43:54,130
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Maraming salamat po, Atty. De La Fuente. Salamat, Mr. Presiding Officer.

846
04:43:54,410 --> 04:43:56,450
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Senator Judge Imee, what is your pleasure, ma'am?

847
04:43:58,770 --> 04:44:24,990
Sen. Imee Marcos: Yes, maraming salamat sa ating presiding judge. At nakikinig po ako sa aking mga kasamahan dito sa Senado. Subalit, ipapaalala ko lang sa lahat na si Lady Justice o yung babaeng justisya ay bulag na katakipang mata. Kasi hindi kinakailangan na basahin ang bawat dokumento, alamin ang mga personalidad, dahil pantay-pantay ang timbang sa batas. Yun lang po.

848
04:44:26,220 --> 04:44:29,840
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Senator Judge Camille? What is your pleasure, ma'am?

849
04:44:34,280 --> 04:45:29,860
Sen. Camille Villar: Yes, hello, good afternoon po. Just a quick manifestation. I think we've been listening to this witness and I have to say that while he probably hasn't seen the documents that were given by the AMLC, I distinctly remember even the supposed expert witness ng prosecution, si Atty. Cabrera, meron po siyang mga figures dun sa kanyang report of the alleged unexplained wealth that was based on, and it was in the forensic report, that was based on research on the internet. There were also certain facts that he put that also he had very little or no basis for saying. And I think we respected that and accepted that.

850
04:45:32,860 --> 04:46:27,080
Sen. Camille Villar: Personally, I would like to hear the thoughts and opinions of our witness, especially regarding theories because I think while some of his answers to the questions that are being asked by both the defense and the prosecution is of his expert opinion, I think they are of universal principles. Some accounting principles are also universal. So he can answer that even without seeing the specific documents. And I think we listened to the expert witness, to the forensic witness, the financial forensic witness of the prosecution. I think we should also give due time to the expert witness of the defense.

851
04:46:30,220 --> 04:46:35,350
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Chair notes. Kala ko pupunta ka sa kantin eh.

852
04:46:35,960 --> 04:47:48,000
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Yes. Just one quick manifestation, Mr. Presiding Officer. Number one, let me again put on record that we have been listening attentively to the respondent's line of questioning despite the fact that it's beyond the issuance of the subpoena and the boundaries set forth by the court inasmuch as the process is concerned. We have no problems with that, Mr. President. In fact, I wanted to palawigin nga, Mr. President, Mr. Presiding Officer, yung ginagawa ng depensa kung siya ay isang forensic expert, kung siya ay magre-refute noong forensic report. I'm more than willing to listen. In fact, kayo na po nagsabi, Mr. President, at inamin na po ng defense lawyer na nagbibigay tayo ng leeway sa kanila. And we have been, we should be continuously giving leeway to be able to understand clearly. But ang hindi po kasi maganda kung unlimited yung magiging

853
04:47:50,600 --> 04:48:47,330
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Scope ng pagiging testigo ng isang witness. And again, we respect the witness. We feel that he is indeed an expert sa issue ng money laundering activities. And again, Mr. Presiding Officer, we're willing to listen to him as long as nandun pa rin sa tamang jurisdiction. At yun nga pong aking masidhing pagnanais ay Matanong po siya mamaya dun sa forensic report para nang sa ganoon makita po natin yung kabilang side, yung kabilang face. Noong pong nangyaring pag-testigo, noong pong forensic expert ng prosecution. Now, if he is not the forensic expert ng defense, I am more than willing to listen in the coming days kung meron pong forensic expert ang defense to refute yung mga binanggit naman ni Atty. Cabrera. Maraming salamat, Mr. Presiding Officer. Thank you.

854
04:48:47,550 --> 04:48:53,270
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, Senator Judge Raffy. Kindly turn on the mic of Senator Judge Raffy.

855
04:48:53,710 --> 04:49:11,680
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Kasi... Kanina pa tayo dito at parang nagiging super witness na siya, ika nga sabi kanina. Now, very simple question lang dito kay Mr. Witness. Kanina, if you remember, I asked you kung ikaw ba ay nakapagkompleto na ng isang kaso while you were in AMLC. You said yes?

856
04:49:11,740 --> 04:49:11,980
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes.

857
04:49:12,320 --> 04:49:13,780
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: You sure? You're under oath?

858
04:49:14,080 --> 04:49:14,460
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, sir.

859
04:49:14,520 --> 04:49:16,160
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Okay, and ano yung kaso ngayon?

860
04:49:16,620 --> 04:49:22,140
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi ko po siya dahil... As part of the confidentiality, hindi ko po masabi.

861
04:49:22,140 --> 04:49:31,560
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: What if I would present to you an evidence later on na wala kang naikompletong kaso at wala ka pang naifile na kaso whatsoever while you were in AMLC? What if I can present that evidence?

862
04:49:31,560 --> 04:49:34,560
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Personally, Your Honor, it's the agency who files, hindi ko ako yung personal.

863
04:49:34,680 --> 04:49:44,260
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Kasi sabi mo kanina nung tinanong kita, kanina-kanina pa, na ikaw pa yung nakapag-investigate, nakapagbuo na ng isang kaso. What if I can show you proof later on na wala talaga, so pwede ka makontempt?

864
04:49:45,940 --> 04:49:48,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: As far as I can remember, Your Honor, I signed.

865
04:49:48,740 --> 04:49:49,520
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: You signed?

866
04:49:49,880 --> 04:49:51,040
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, sir.

867
04:49:51,340 --> 04:50:15,390
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Pwede ma-refute yan later on. So doon pa nga lang, Mr. Presiding Officer, nagkaka-problema na eh. Sinasabi niya na meron na siyang nabuo na kaso hanggang sa na-efile, when in fact, ang pagkakaalam ko, wala. Wala pa talaga. And he's just claiming it, and like I said, later on, pwede akong kukuha ng ebidensya na wala pa siyang nabuo ng kaso at baka makontemplan ito. Thank you, Mr. Presiding Officer.

868
04:50:16,650 --> 04:50:41,470
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We note, The manifestations made by all of the senator judges. However, the court cannot dictate nor impinge upon how either party will present their evidence in chief, much less dictate their strategy in choosing their respective witnesses. I urge our colleagues to...

869
04:50:43,720 --> 04:51:30,250
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Exercise more leeway and patience with the presentation being made by the counsel for the respondent. Senator Imee is correct. Habang sinisimbolo ng babaeng sumisimbolo sa ustisya na nakatakip ang mata niya, hindi po nakatakip yung kanyang mga tenga. Ibig sabihin, huwag tayong magbasa base sa panlabas na kanyuan. Makinig at pakinggan din natin kung anong sinasabi, hindi lamang ng mga testigo, pero ganyan din, ng magkabilang panig. I ask for the indulgence of our colleagues and ask Attorney Mark II to take note of the manifestations made and be sensitive to them to a certain extent in continuing with this direct examination with this witness. You may proceed, Attorney Mark.

870
04:51:31,460 --> 04:52:05,630
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you, Your Honor. Okay, so I'll just abbreviate some of the portions, Your Honor. In respect of what the Senator Judges have manifested. So, we're talking about financial investigation about public officials as well. My question is, in an impeachment process, how does the Bill of Rights apply insofar as that impeachable officials' rights when financial investigations are being conducted against that person?

871
04:52:06,220 --> 04:52:15,800
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: During the course of the financial investigation, Your Honor, Bill of Rights, the rights of the accused are still intact. In fact, meron ho siyang mga legal remedies along the way.

872
04:52:17,410 --> 04:52:25,190
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And how does due process, which is part of the Bill of Rights, apply in financial investigations of an impeachable official, if at all?

873
04:52:25,800 --> 04:52:35,780
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, it is still intact. Meron ho legal remedies, right of the accused to answer, opportunity to present evidence in his or her defense.

874
04:52:37,500 --> 04:53:27,050
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, I'll just abbreviate other portions of the Bill of Rights, but let me direct your attention to Article 14, Section 3 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights to which the Philippines is a signatory. And I'll just end with this point, Your Honor, for this portion. In the determination of any criminal charge against him, everyone shall be entitled to the following minimum guarantees in full equality. A. To be informed promptly and in detail in a language which he understands of the nature and cause of the charge against him. My question is in line with that provision that we just read. What is the value of informing the person that you're investigating promptly and completely of the charges against him?

875
04:53:27,720 --> 04:53:42,630
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, this is financial investigation, Your Honor. Again, the right of the accused. To confront the evidences presented and also answer with the proper court. Yun po ay importante pa rin.

876
04:53:42,790 --> 04:56:47,140
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you. Sige, move on na po tayo. Dito po sa impeachment na to, Atty. De La Fuente, yung conviction or acquittal ni VP Sara, she was voted in 2022 by 32,208,417 na Pilipino. Nakasalalay po ito sa boto ng ating mga mahal na senador ngayon, 24 of them. And ang pagboto and conviction ay nakabase na lamang sa isang article of impeachment. Yun po yung unexplained wealth, alleged unexplained wealth. These constitute the formal charges against the impeachable officer. Just to eliminate doubt, balikan lang po natin yung article na yun. Again, yung tatlo kasing article na withdraw na. Kapag binalikan natin itong Article 2, attorney de la Fuente, says here, Respondent Vice President Sara Z. Duterte committed culpable violation of the Constitution and betrayed public trust when she, letter A, amassed unexplained wealth manifestly disproportionate to her lawful income and earnings during her incumbency as a public official. Letter B, failed to fully and truthfully disclose all her and her spouse's assets, liabilities, and net worth in her statement of assets, liabilities, and net worth, or SALN, including in her SALN for the years 2022, 2023, and 2024. And Letter C, failed to divest and instead willfully continued all her business interests during her tenure as Vice President. For the years 2022, 2023, 2024, and 2025. So as regards letter A, so we don't mislead the public, we just want to be more precise. This is what the articles of impeachment charge or is part of their charge. And I'll read. From 2007 to 2024, the net worth of respondent and her spouse rose from 7 million to 88 million. or a total increase of around 80 million. However, as shown earlier, the lawful income of respondent and her spouse for the same period only amounts to roughly 30 million. The difference between their lawful income of 30 million and the increase in their net worth of around 80 million, resulting in a disparity of approximately 50 million, clearly constitutes unexplained wealth. So yun po yung charge. Financial investigator po kayo. Base lang po sa bahaging ito po ng charges, may approximation po na 50 million na unexplained wealth daw po. Okay, according to that charge. Ano pong masasabi niyo po sa kalidad na paratang na ito bilang basihan ng pag-convict or pag-acquit kay VP Sara?

877
04:56:47,910 --> 04:57:01,130
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Objection, Your Honor. Given that the witness has admitted that he has not read the entire report, and that he has not been given access to any of the documents in this case, he would not be competent to render an opinion on that.

878
04:57:01,330 --> 04:57:03,270
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Yeah, but this is not the report. This is the articles

879
04:57:03,270 --> 04:57:08,210
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: of impeachment. If he knows, if you know, Attorney Rainer, kindly respond.

880
04:57:08,570 --> 04:57:17,090
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor, for this one, I leave it to the discretion of our Honorable Impeachment Court and I leave it to the wisdom of our Impeachment Court.

881
04:57:18,220 --> 04:57:22,580
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, I'll move on to a new allegation or part of the allegation.

882
04:57:24,520 --> 04:59:31,110
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Let me direct your attention to pages 13 to 14 of the articles of impeachment. Former Senator Antonio Trillanes IV disclosed that a significant portion of this wealth was sourced from illegal activities, including funds linked to illegal drug operations and associations with drug syndicates, and identified specific transactions and individuals connected to the drug trade. These disclosures are corroborated by the findings of the AMLC, which flag billions of pesos in transactions involving respondent and her spouse, reflecting patterns consistent with money laundering and predicate offenses. Notably, a certain name identified in the AMLC records corresponds with those publicly disclosed by Trillanes. Taken together, these facts establish a pattern of criminal enrichment and demonstrate that respondent's wealth is manifestly unlawful, grossly disproportionate to legitimate income, and constitutes ill-gotten wealth. Clear grounds for impeachment. Alright, I'll just go straight to the point, Atty. De La Fuente. Those are the charges, but number one, former Senator Trillanes was not presented. No illegal activity was ever identified. No drug operations with drug syndicates were discussed. No discussion about money laundering and the amount laundered. And no discussion also about any predicate crime. And yet the paragraph ends with, and I quote, Taken together, these facts establish a pattern of criminal enrichment and demonstrates that respondent's wealth is manifestly unlawful, grossly disproportionate to illegal. Legitimate income and constitutes ill-gotten wealth. Clear grounds for impeachment. My only question is this. As a seasoned financial investigator, how clear or viable are these charges of unexplained wealth against the Vice President?

883
04:59:31,550 --> 04:59:43,010
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: As to viability, as to the viability of the charges, again, Your Honor, I leave it to the Court to decide if these charges would warrant

884
04:59:44,980 --> 04:59:48,120
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Decision on conviction or acquittal. So, it's really up to the court.

885
04:59:48,360 --> 05:01:25,760
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Punta naman po tayo dun sa letter B or yung nondisclosure in the SALN. Last couple of pages, Your Honor, if I may be allowed to just finish. Contrary to her declarations in the SALN, Respondent and her spouse owned and acquired billions of pesos which were deposited from 2007 to 2024 in their bank accounts. These funds deposited in their bank accounts were not declared in Respondent's SALNs, including in her SALNs covering the years 2022, 2023, and 2024. Despite the billions of pesos deposited in respondent and her spouse's bank accounts from 2007 to 2024, these deposits were not declared as cash on hand, cash in bank, or other personal assets in respondent's SALNs, including in her SALNs for 2020 to 2023 and 2024. Again, ganun lang po yung allegation na nakalagay sa articles of impeachment. And I quote, owned and acquired billions of pesos. which were deposited from 2007 to 2024 in their bank accounts. And then these funds deposited in their bank accounts were not declared in respondent SALNs, including in their SALNs covering the years 2020 to 2024. Again, my only question as a financial investigation, ano ang effect? Maybe you can answer not in lieu of the facts of this case, but what is the effect if the accusation of financial wrongdoing is vague?

886
05:01:27,520 --> 05:01:28,560
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, Your Honor, the last

887
05:01:28,560 --> 05:01:34,740
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: part. What is the effect of a vague accusation of financial wrongdoing as a financial investigator?

888
05:01:35,720 --> 05:01:41,520
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Objection, Your Honor. There's nothing vague about the quoted portion that is a conclusion on the part of the...

889
05:01:41,520 --> 05:01:49,140
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly reform your question, Attorney Mark. Just ask him directly what his opinion is of the allegation you read in the articles. If you can.

890
05:01:50,730 --> 05:02:08,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Opinion on this, Your Honor. Again, the question... If there's ambiguity or vagueness, well, that would weaken. But again, I defer to the wisdom of the Honorable Impeachment Court how they appreciate these observations.

891
05:02:09,820 --> 05:02:12,100
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We respect that. Okay.

892
05:02:18,310 --> 05:02:18,870
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay.

893
05:02:19,230 --> 05:02:29,670
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Your Honor, I'm very sorry to interrupt. Before we continue, could we have a very brief CR break? It's a one or two minute break. I think the witness also may need to...

894
05:02:30,180 --> 05:02:31,880
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Do you need to go, Atty. Rainer?

895
05:02:32,480 --> 05:02:33,080
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

896
05:02:34,790 --> 05:02:38,630
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Chair declares a three-minute bathroom break.

897
05:02:39,070 --> 05:02:40,550
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Thank you, Your Honor. Thank you, Your Honor.

898
05:08:37,580 --> 05:08:46,630
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you, Your Honor. I'm winding up, Your Honor. We decided to obviate certain portions.

899
05:08:46,970 --> 05:08:48,030
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly proceed, Atty. Morris.

900
05:08:48,210 --> 05:09:27,360
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you, Your Honor. Alright, let me direct your attention to Article 3, Section 3 of the 1987 Constitution. It says here, The privacy of communication and correspondence shall be inviolable except upon lawful order of the court or when public safety or order requires otherwise as prescribed by law. Any evidence obtained in violation of this or the preceding section shall be inadmissible for any purpose in any proceeding. In line with this provision and your experience also as a financial investigator, kindly explain the concept of fishing expedition. If you know. or if you can recall.

901
05:09:28,800 --> 05:10:25,510
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, on fishing expedition, Your Honor, this is again initiated under that constitutional provision. It protects the individual from any arbitrary state intrusion, ensuring that privacy of communication and also information relating to the individual is being safeguarded. So pinaprotectahan po ng ating Constitution. Ang panghihimasok, walang habas na panghihimasok sa informasyon na ito provided na kung ito man ay in relation sa ongoing investigation o sa isang kaso, dapat sundin pa rin ang mga safeguards provided ng batas. Hindi ho ito unlimited authority to disclose and... Discloses information.

902
05:10:26,110 --> 05:10:34,530
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, and what is the effect of fishing expedition in terms of documents used as evidence in an impeachment trial, if at all?

903
05:10:35,030 --> 05:10:41,170
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: So ito ay considered na fruits of a poisonous tree. These are inadmissible as evidence.

904
05:10:41,790 --> 05:10:56,080
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you po. I'm about to conclude. Yung term na ill-gotten wealth actually appears once in the Constitution. Let me direct your attention to Article 18, Section 26.

905
05:10:57,600 --> 05:11:34,470
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Let me read. The authority to issue sequestration or freeze orders under Proclamation No. 3 dated March 25, 1986 in relation to the recovery of ill-gotten wealth shall remain operative for not more than 18 months after the ratification of this Constitution. However, in the national interest as certified by the President, the Congress may extend such period. My only question about this article is this. If you know, based on the history of our 1987 Constitution, kaninong ilgaten wealth po ba yung tinutukoy ng probisyong ito?

906
05:11:37,020 --> 05:11:52,180
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: For this specific provision, there's no specific individual, official, or entity mentioned po dito sa Section 26 in Article... At any rate,

907
05:11:52,260 --> 05:12:02,780
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: how important po ba is it to look back on the history of our Constitution as we undertake the impeachment process today? If you can just give your opinion on that.

908
05:12:03,500 --> 05:12:14,560
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Napaka-importante ho. Our history would dictate our future. So we have to look back kung ano man ang sarkomstansyang nakapaligid nung naisulat ho ang batas na ito.

909
05:12:15,610 --> 05:12:26,800
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. Last set of figures before I end. Let me show you VP Sara's recent ratings in the 2028 Presidential Preference Surveys. So I'll just show you three surveys.

910
05:12:30,890 --> 05:13:52,070
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: So Sara Duterte leads 2028 Presidential Preference in Pulse Asia. So there's the rating. And then next survey, Sara Duterte maintains commanding lead in 2028 Presidential Preferences. And then there's the one with, I think this is OCTA, Current Presidential Voting Preference. And I'm about to end. We all know that impeachment carries the penalty of disqualification to hold any office under the Republic of the Philippines. This is my second to the last question and it is quite a personal one. Since iisa na lang naman po yung charge against VP Sara. Again, you can answer based on the factual milieu of what you know from this case or based on your opinion. What is the seriousness po? What is the seriousness of financial wrongdoing that warrants a conviction in an impeachment case? Your Honor, again, let me repeat the question, considering also, granting that these surveys, that VP Sara, the, well, the choice of the people based on these surveys, what is the seriousness of financial wrongdoing that warrants VP Sara's conviction?

911
05:13:53,960 --> 05:13:56,900
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Seriousness of financial wrongdoing that warrants...

912
05:13:56,930 --> 05:14:03,160
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Conviction in this impeachment case. Gusto niyo po bang tagalogin para mas may time kayo?

913
05:14:03,680 --> 05:14:04,540
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sige nga po.

914
05:14:04,740 --> 05:14:19,020
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Gano po ba kagrabe or ano po ba yung bigat ng financial wrongdoing that will warrant yung conviction ng isang tao sa isang impeachment proceeding?

915
05:14:19,750 --> 05:14:42,320
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Dapat ito ay may absolute certainty po tayo. Given we are impeaching a high-ranking official, the findings should be based on facts, not conjectures. At dapat ito, yung magiging desisyon ng ating impeachment court must

916
05:14:42,320 --> 05:14:44,900
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: uphold the rule of law.

917
05:14:45,810 --> 05:14:57,350
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: So ang ating magiging desisyon, it should... Encapsulate yung prinsipyo na our law should protect the innocent as aggressively as it pursues the guilty.

918
05:14:58,020 --> 05:15:30,650
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you. One last question, Your Honor. And I'll end with a preamble. The preamble states we, the sovereign Filipino people, imploring the aid of Almighty God. And then the lawyers would know the rest of the preamble. But my question is this, and it's again quite a personal question. You are a lecturer. You mentioned that you have students and you have an influence on the next generation. How important is it to implore the aid of Almighty God in such a time as this when the ongoing impeachment has greatly divided our beloved country?

919
05:15:31,630 --> 05:15:53,780
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, very important, Your Honor. There are things that are beyond our explanation, beyond our comprehension. So it's really important that all of our decisions should be guided. by the Divine. And again, we have to be aware that whatever our decision will be, will have long-lasting effects sa ating bansa.

920
05:15:54,160 --> 05:16:50,510
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you. Your Honor, just no more questions, just a manifestation, Your Honor. Again, we respect the sentiments, Your Honor, of our senator judges. But again, and this is coming from a personal standpoint, and I know I'm not authorized to speak on behalf of this witness, Your Honor, but as a colleague in the profession, We have an oath, Your Honor, and we're just doing our job, trying to do our job in the best possible way, Your Honor. We do not want to impede on any rights of other peoples, as well as the rights of the prosecution to make their own case. But, Your Honor, our goal in this whole exercise is really to ferret out the truth and provide two sides of the coin, Your Honor. And we hope, Your Honor, that this will be well taken as well by the Senate Impeachment Court. Thank you, Your Honor.

921
05:16:50,690 --> 05:17:07,870
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We note the manifestation of Attorney Mark as stated by the Presiding Officer earlier. Liyue has been given and patience has been extended not only by the Presiding Officer but by members of the Impeachment Court as well. Attorney, Honorable Chel Cross.

922
05:17:08,270 --> 05:17:10,490
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: With the permission of the Honorable Court.

923
05:17:10,910 --> 05:17:11,890
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You may proceed, sir.

924
05:17:12,780 --> 05:17:14,640
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Good afternoon, Mr. Witness.

925
05:17:14,960 --> 05:17:16,180
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Good afternoon, Your Honor.

926
05:17:16,920 --> 05:17:23,560
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You started out in the Anti-Money Laundering Council in July of 2015.

927
05:17:23,820 --> 05:17:25,760
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: July of 2015, Your Honor. Correct.

928
05:17:26,000 --> 05:17:35,670
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And you were part of the Compliance and Investigation Group only until August of 2017. Is that correct?

929
05:17:36,450 --> 05:17:40,430
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2018. Yes, Your Honor. But I'm still part of the Secretariat after.

930
05:17:41,100 --> 05:17:55,520
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: August 2017. Let's be clear about that. You were only a financial investigator for a period of 24 months. July 2015 up to August 2017. 25 months. Is that correct?

931
05:17:56,540 --> 05:17:57,480
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Roughly, Your Honor.

932
05:17:58,330 --> 05:18:15,780
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Yes. You were only a financial investigator for 25 months at the AMLA. You started in July of 2015. and ended as a financial investigator in August of 2017. Isn't that correct?

933
05:18:16,260 --> 05:18:17,040
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

934
05:18:17,180 --> 05:18:37,340
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: In fact, in August of 2017, you were taken out of the compliance and investigation group and reassigned to the technical services staff under the office of the Executive Director. No longer doing any form of investigation. Isn't that true?

935
05:18:38,770 --> 05:18:40,790
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The first part of the statement is...

936
05:18:40,790 --> 05:18:50,410
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: My answer, my question is very simple. Sir, you're a lawyer, you're a CPA. You can answer it by yes or no. Your defense counsel can ask you to explain later if they want to.

937
05:18:51,370 --> 05:18:52,830
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The question again, Your Honor?

938
05:18:53,690 --> 05:19:13,920
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You were only a... After you were assigned from the... or taken out of the compliance and investigation group and transferred to the TSS... or Technical Services Staff under the Office of the Executive Director. Your work was really more on information campaign awareness, right?

939
05:19:14,140 --> 05:19:23,730
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Your Honor, before the witness answers, can we just ask for leeway so that the witness will be allowed to answer freely without interruption?

940
05:19:23,890 --> 05:19:32,970
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: He's on cross, counsel. You can address whatever issues he needs to clarify on redirect. Witness, will please answer the question.

941
05:19:33,310 --> 05:19:33,830
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The answer is

942
05:19:33,830 --> 05:19:34,010
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: yes,

943
05:19:34,070 --> 05:19:35,530
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: but can I explain, Your Honor?

944
05:19:35,670 --> 05:19:38,310
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Later, if your lawyer wants to ask you to explain.

945
05:19:38,370 --> 05:19:40,250
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Can he be allowed at this time, Your Honor?

946
05:19:40,350 --> 05:19:50,870
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Counsel, the Honorable Diokno already got his answer. Again, without prejudice to you asking him to explain and redirect, we will not prohibit him.

947
05:19:52,040 --> 05:20:01,400
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: The Technical Services Staff under the Office of the Executive Director is a totally different office from the Compliance and Investigation Group, correct?

948
05:20:01,950 --> 05:20:02,590
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, your honor.

949
05:20:02,750 --> 05:20:11,690
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: In fact, the technical services staff serves as staff to the office of the executive director. It has no investigative functions at all.

950
05:20:11,830 --> 05:20:12,430
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, your honor.

951
05:20:12,740 --> 05:20:30,120
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: In other words, your only background or expertise, quote-unquote, claimed expertise as a financial investigator is the 25 months you served as an FI under the compliance and investigation group. Is that correct?

952
05:20:31,210 --> 05:20:32,830
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: May I explain, Your Honor?

953
05:20:32,950 --> 05:20:37,530
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You may answer my question. Perhaps later you may explain if your lawyer wants to ask you.

954
05:20:37,710 --> 05:20:38,170
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

955
05:20:38,760 --> 05:20:45,160
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, you started out, what was your position, Sir? BSP ranking?

956
05:20:45,460 --> 05:20:46,440
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Bank Officer 2.

957
05:20:46,460 --> 05:20:51,900
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And Bank Officer 2. So that is not a senior management position, am I correct?

958
05:20:52,400 --> 05:20:54,300
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. Yes. That's entry level.

959
05:20:54,900 --> 05:21:00,590
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Entry level. And you were never promoted from bank officer too?

960
05:21:00,830 --> 05:21:01,290
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: No, Your Honor.

961
05:21:01,430 --> 05:21:20,220
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So your expertise or your claimed expertise as a financial expert in financial investigation only comes from the 25 months you were an entry-level investigator for the AMLC. Is that correct?

962
05:21:20,640 --> 05:21:21,400
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

963
05:21:23,900 --> 05:21:33,560
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You would agree with me that a financial investigation under the AMLA involves investigation of money laundering and its predicate crimes. Tama po ba iyon?

964
05:21:33,860 --> 05:21:36,580
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Money laundering, Your Honor, not the predicate crime.

965
05:21:36,860 --> 05:22:00,850
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Ah, money laundering. Thank you. I stand corrected. So iba po ang trabaho ng isang financial investigator kung ang iniinvestigahan niya ay unexplained wealth, non-declaration ng SALN, At participation in business. Wala pong kinalaman ang financial investigator ng AMLA doon sa mga bagay na iyon, hindi po ba?

966
05:22:01,090 --> 05:22:04,750
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes po. Yun po kasi ay predicate crime, iba pong ahensya.

967
05:22:05,290 --> 05:22:24,560
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Tama po iyon. Now, as a member of the TSS, yung pong technical services staff under the office of the executive director, Ang naging trabaho niyo ay capacity building at information awareness campaign. Di po ba?

968
05:22:24,820 --> 05:22:26,060
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Isa po sa mga trabaho.

969
05:22:26,400 --> 05:22:46,770
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So your employers felt that you would be more appropriate to serve AMLA no longer as a financial investigator. I'm not yet finished, Your Honor, please. But rather, you would best... Provide services to AMLA as a member of the TSS.

970
05:22:47,270 --> 05:22:52,130
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. The witness will not be competent to answer that question. It's also argumentative.

971
05:22:52,350 --> 05:22:56,730
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: If he knows, counsel. It's not argumentative, but if he knows.

972
05:22:57,310 --> 05:23:04,450
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Iniwan ko po yan sa discretion ng aming leadership during that time. So ako ko kasi kung ano man ang iba tong trabaho, kagawin ko natin yan.

973
05:23:05,570 --> 05:23:16,590
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Alright. Noong dalawang taon na kayo ay isang AMLA financial investigator, how long... On the average, would it take for you to complete one investigation?

974
05:23:17,950 --> 05:23:23,210
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Depende ho kung simple or complex cases. Depende ho ito.

975
05:23:24,350 --> 05:23:33,170
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Let's talk about complex cases. Sorry to interrupt you. Mga more or less, gaano katagal po yung isang investigation na gano'n?

976
05:23:35,680 --> 05:23:49,640
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Para ho makapag-come up ng isang financial investigation report, normally, three weeks to one month, or even, but it won't go beyond two months.

977
05:23:51,280 --> 05:24:07,780
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So, in other words, your only experience actual on the ground during those 25 months was the assigned cases given to you, which according to you, complex, could take several months. Is that correct?

978
05:24:08,480 --> 05:24:11,900
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: For complex, but it's mixed with other cases, Your Honor.

979
05:24:12,040 --> 05:24:30,270
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So let's say from July 2015 up to August of 2017, if every complex investigation took several months, you would not have been able to complete more than 20 or 30 of those. Would that be a fair statement?

980
05:24:30,630 --> 05:24:35,220
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: If the witness knows, Your Honor.

981
05:24:35,400 --> 05:24:37,980
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I would have to overrule, counsel. Witness may answer.

982
05:24:38,320 --> 05:24:39,700
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The question again, Your Honor.

983
05:24:41,170 --> 05:25:04,530
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Sabi po ninyo kanina na yung mga komplikadong mga investigasyon ay umaabot minsan ng ilang buwan. Considering po na kayo ay dalawang taon lamang naging financial investigator ng AMLA, yung mga natapos nyong complex na financial investigation, hindi po maaaring lumampas ng mga dalawampu o tatlumpung kaso.

984
05:25:05,830 --> 05:25:21,640
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Maaaring lumampas kasi during that time, Lean Manpower ang AMLC. So we are really multitasking. Kaya humabalik ako doon sa kanina inyong nabanggit. Ako ay nasa TSS. But the cases that I was initially assigned, I still continue handling them.

985
05:25:23,270 --> 05:25:32,650
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: At yun lang po ang masasabi niyong experience ninyo sa pag-iinvestiga ng mga pinansyal na bagay na nasa AMLC kayo.

986
05:25:32,770 --> 05:25:34,090
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: As an answer, Your Honor.

987
05:25:34,350 --> 05:25:35,310
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Move on, counsel.

988
05:25:36,220 --> 05:25:46,350
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Ngayon, You only became an accredited AMLA trainer, you said earlier, after you left already the Anti-Money Laundering Council.

989
05:25:46,790 --> 05:25:47,810
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2019, Your Honor.

990
05:25:48,030 --> 05:26:02,230
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: In fact, you are testifying here today based on your short stint as a financial investigator and also on your knowledge of general principles of anti-money laundering. Is that not correct?

991
05:26:02,810 --> 05:26:03,590
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

992
05:26:03,960 --> 05:26:13,760
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Wala po kayong... Nakita o nabasa ng kabuuan na forensic report ni Atty. Cabrera. You did not read the entire report.

993
05:26:14,340 --> 05:26:16,740
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi po, Your Honor. Sa mga news lang po.

994
05:26:17,020 --> 05:26:23,420
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You did not look at any of the bank records that Atty. Cabrera examined.

995
05:26:24,220 --> 05:26:26,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi po dahil confidential po ito.

996
05:26:26,640 --> 05:26:35,520
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You did not have a look at any of the records produced by the Bureau of Internal Revenue to this Court. Hindi niyo rin po naalam yun.

997
05:26:35,640 --> 05:26:37,960
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Same answer, Your Honor. Confidential po kasi ito.

998
05:26:37,960 --> 05:26:47,580
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Hindi niyo rin po nakita yung records ng SEC o Securities and Exchange Commission na binigay po nila dito sa hukumang ito.

999
05:26:47,900 --> 05:26:48,980
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ah, hindi po, Your Honor.

1000
05:26:49,280 --> 05:26:58,660
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Pati po yung mga records na binigay ng insurance companies, lahat po ng ebidensya na nandito sa loob nitong hukumang ito, wala kayong binasa.

1001
05:26:59,390 --> 05:27:03,050
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi po dahil hindi po ako yung intended end user.

1002
05:27:03,730 --> 05:27:13,910
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So, any opinions that you may give have no basis in any factual evidence provided in this court.

1003
05:27:13,910 --> 05:27:21,810
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. That's misleading. It already calls for a conclusion of law that only this honorable court has the function to do.

1004
05:27:21,910 --> 05:27:25,610
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly reform. I know where you're getting at, Honorable Chel. Kindly reform.

1005
05:27:27,490 --> 05:27:47,050
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You have stated, you have made a variety of opinions about The report of Atty. Cabrera about methodologies that were employed. But you have no personal knowledge of what exactly was done by Atty. Cabrera in preparing his report. Is that right?

1006
05:27:47,350 --> 05:27:47,890
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor.

1007
05:27:49,460 --> 05:27:57,100
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So ano ngayon ang bigat ng inyong opinion kung wala naman pala kayong alam tungkol sa mga ginawa ni Atty. Cabrera?

1008
05:27:57,320 --> 05:28:04,040
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. Question is argumentative, Your Honor. And already, again, calls for a conclusion of fact and law.

1009
05:28:06,760 --> 05:28:10,480
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: He said ano-anong ayan ang halbigat or halaga.

1010
05:28:10,740 --> 05:28:15,500
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: No, I heard a question. If you know, Attorney Rainer, if you wish to answer and if you know.

1011
05:28:15,700 --> 05:28:47,350
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. Ang akin lang hung saligan ay ang ating amla, ang ating batas. So I can answer based on the law. I echo, I mirror what the law says. So hindi ko daw kailangan... Ako personally ayokong basahin yung report because coming here... and awala rin akong akses sa report. Coming here, reading that report, I will develop biases. I will be swayed doong report na iyon. So ang akin lang kung sinasandalan dito ay kung ano ang nasa batas.

1012
05:28:48,710 --> 05:29:01,230
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, your knowledge of AMLA operations is limited, your personal knowledge of AMLA operations is limited to your brief stint as a financial investigator of AMLA. Isn't that correct?

1013
05:29:01,940 --> 05:29:03,840
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Brief but meaningful. Yes, Your Honor.

1014
05:29:04,140 --> 05:29:15,620
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And as far as any current policies, practices, procedures of the AMLA, wala po kayong personal knowledge doon mula nung kayo'y umalis noong 2018.

1015
05:29:16,380 --> 05:29:20,920
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Internal policies, none. But those that would affect covered persons, yes.

1016
05:29:22,780 --> 05:29:29,900
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Yung kaalaman ninyo about the anti-money laundering concepts ay...

1017
05:29:31,590 --> 05:29:45,300
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Na-acquire ninyo after you left. Well, let me reform. What you know about the anti-money laundering concepts is the same as what any other lawyer who reads the law would know. Isn't that right?

1018
05:29:46,100 --> 05:30:02,340
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, I respect po. Na-develop po ito nung ako'y nasa loob pa at nung ako'y lumabas na. Mas lalo na-develop because aside from getting the insights sa public sector, nakita ko rin ho, I was able to harmonize, marry kung ano ba yung meron sa private sector.

1019
05:30:02,960 --> 05:30:18,500
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Nabasa ko po yung inyong curriculum vitae. Tama po ba na wala naman ako nakita doon na meron kayong special knowledge, experience, training, or education in investigating cases of unexplained wealth. Tama po ba yan?

1020
05:30:18,700 --> 05:30:43,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Meron po, Your Honor. I think this was trainings conducted by USAID, anti-corruption, and then meron din po sa international. ILEA, International Law Enforcement Academy in Thailand. So meron siyang financial investigation po, session 7. So I was able to, I was sent by the office to go there and participate, represent the office po namin.

1021
05:30:44,080 --> 05:30:52,580
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: But as you mentioned earlier, your work is for the AMLA, involved financial investigation of money laundering. Tama po?

1022
05:30:52,960 --> 05:30:53,700
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor.

1023
05:30:53,920 --> 05:31:12,460
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Yes. Now, I noticed as well from your background that you, while you did serve in other agencies... Let me go through this one by one. Yung una niyong trabaho ay sa BIR, hindi po ba?

1024
05:31:12,580 --> 05:31:13,020
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct po.

1025
05:31:13,220 --> 05:31:17,460
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Earlier on direct, you said you served there at least one year. Is that correct?

1026
05:31:17,460 --> 05:31:19,320
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. Working student po ako doon.

1027
05:31:19,320 --> 05:31:25,180
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: But it would appear that you were only working there for 11 months.

1028
05:31:25,600 --> 05:31:26,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Short of one year.

1029
05:31:27,500 --> 05:31:31,480
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Short of one year. Short of

1030
05:31:31,480 --> 05:31:31,920
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: one month.

1031
05:31:32,300 --> 05:31:43,580
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: One year short of one month with the BIR. Your second job was with Punong Bayan and Aralio. How many months did you work at Punong Bayan and Aralio?

1032
05:31:43,660 --> 05:31:45,100
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Just for two months, Your Honor.

1033
05:31:45,420 --> 05:31:56,640
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Two months. And your third job was with the GCG, Governance Commission for GLCCs. How many months did you serve in that office?

1034
05:31:57,260 --> 05:32:03,720
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Two years, Your Honor. Before, I think, almost a few months after two years.

1035
05:32:04,740 --> 05:32:11,480
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: My records indicate that you started in April 2012 and ended in January 2014. Would that be accurate?

1036
05:32:11,480 --> 05:32:12,500
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Around that time, yes, Your Honor.

1037
05:32:12,620 --> 05:32:14,820
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So that's not two years. That's 21 months.

1038
05:32:16,930 --> 05:32:17,630
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Roughly, yeah.

1039
05:32:18,030 --> 05:32:23,610
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And your next job was at the Commission on Elections where you served there for 17 months.

1040
05:32:23,870 --> 05:32:24,350
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1041
05:32:24,350 --> 05:32:26,990
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: January 2014 to June 2015.

1042
05:32:27,710 --> 05:32:28,570
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1043
05:32:29,210 --> 05:32:37,570
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And that is the summa total of your qualifications as a financial expert that you are peddling before this court?

1044
05:32:37,890 --> 05:32:55,210
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: No, Your Honor. That is the history of my government and private employment. Insofar as financial investigation, that would start with AMLC up to until now that I'm into private practice. It continues up to the present.

1045
05:32:55,670 --> 05:33:15,210
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, you said you worked for Punong Bayan and Aralio for two months. So this did not give you any opportunity to learn how to conduct forensic audits, how to conduct compliance and due diligence, and other auditing services that are usually offered by these kinds of firms. Isn't that right?

1046
05:33:15,310 --> 05:33:30,690
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I was assigned at the tax division. I am a senior tax associate. So the engagements that we handle are tax assessments. and also due diligence review. Yeah, we did that.

1047
05:33:30,990 --> 05:33:34,150
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So wala po kayong ginawa o sinagawang forensic audits?

1048
05:33:34,490 --> 05:33:36,710
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Wala po. Iba pong grupo ang audit.

1049
05:33:37,840 --> 05:34:00,050
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Alright. Now, let me move on to, well, first of all, insofar as your work as a financial investigator, ever since you left the Anti-Money Laundering Council, Wala na po kayong contact sa mga nasa opisina ng AMLA?

1050
05:34:00,230 --> 05:34:18,930
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Wala po. After leaving the service 2018, I started my own, well, with a friend po, we started a law office. So I imposed a one year, wala po talaga, that's for one year, no AML related work. That's a, kumbaga, delikadesa na rin po namin.

1051
05:34:20,680 --> 05:34:36,310
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Thank you. You were asked about Section 8-A of Republic Act 9160. May I know, how many times was the Anti-Money Laundering Law amended?

1052
05:34:36,730 --> 05:34:37,350
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Seven times.

1053
05:34:37,830 --> 05:34:43,530
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, when was the Section 8A put in to the Anti-Money Laundering Law?

1054
05:34:43,630 --> 05:34:46,690
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: That's 2021 by virtue of Republic Act 11521.

1055
05:34:47,190 --> 05:34:49,070
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So wala na po kayo sa AMLA noon?

1056
05:34:49,810 --> 05:34:50,710
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1057
05:34:51,310 --> 05:35:04,080
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And am I correct in reading that law, that particular section? That there is an exception for the orders of the Court of Competent Jurisdiction.

1058
05:35:04,320 --> 05:35:07,040
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. That's on paragraph 2.

1059
05:35:08,230 --> 05:35:15,890
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And since the Impeachment Court is a creation of this Constitution, the Impeachment Court is a Court of Competent Jurisdiction. Is that not right?

1060
05:35:15,950 --> 05:35:16,330
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1061
05:35:17,030 --> 05:35:38,700
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, once that exception applies and now information is subpoenaed by the Impeachment Court, From the Anti-Money Laundering Council. At binigay na po ng Anti-Money Laundering Council yan sa court. That is now within the custody of the court. Is that not right?

1062
05:35:39,040 --> 05:35:39,800
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The last part?

1063
05:35:39,960 --> 05:35:46,400
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Once that information is submitted to the court, that information is now in the custody of the court.

1064
05:35:46,480 --> 05:35:46,900
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor.

1065
05:35:47,100 --> 05:35:56,520
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And it is the court that then will decide on whether what conditions that can be imposed in terms of using that

1066
05:35:58,000 --> 05:36:04,780
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor, subject to the same paragraph of Section 8-A.

1067
05:36:04,780 --> 05:36:13,520
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Yes, and in fact it's not only the impeachment court that issues subpoenas to the AMLA, even the Sandiganbayan does, am I correct?

1068
05:36:13,520 --> 05:36:14,380
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1069
05:36:14,380 --> 05:36:22,940
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And once the AMLA submits the information to the Sandiganbayan, that can now be included in the decision of the Sandiganbayan.

1070
05:36:22,940 --> 05:36:24,100
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor.

1071
05:36:24,400 --> 05:36:36,720
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Even up to the Supreme Court, that can be mentioned, right? So, wala na pong espasyo sa confidentiality yan. Basta compelled by court order ang information. Di po ba?

1072
05:36:37,180 --> 05:36:49,580
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor. Nakalagay ko kasi doon. Merong mga procedures that must be implemented for the protection, handling, and storage of access over such information.

1073
05:36:52,420 --> 05:36:54,020
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I'm sorry, please continue.

1074
05:36:54,760 --> 05:37:03,060
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yung confidentiality na yan, hindi nahuhubad kapag yan ay napunta na sa Korte. It travels with the information.

1075
05:37:04,200 --> 05:37:18,740
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I have to... I wonder about that because I've read and I'm... Have you ever read any Supreme Court decisions that came from an appeal from the Sandigan Bayan that discuss what was presented by AMLA?

1076
05:37:19,720 --> 05:37:20,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sorry, Your Honor.

1077
05:37:22,530 --> 05:37:37,980
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Is it not a fact that once the AMLA reports are submitted to the Sandigan Bayan, as you said, they can be incorporated in the decision and therefore accessible to the public?

1078
05:37:38,820 --> 05:37:48,600
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Your Honor, the witness won't be competent to answer without the good counsel confronting him with the documents.

1079
05:37:49,140 --> 05:37:54,000
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: If he knows of a case, he was presented as an AMLC expert.

1080
05:37:54,800 --> 05:38:02,350
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct me if I'm wrong, Your Honor. Can the decision cite portions of the report?

1081
05:38:02,550 --> 05:38:22,960
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Is that a question? You are familiar with the cases of Ligot, among others. And you will confirm that in the decision of the Supreme Court, Mention there was made of what was presented by the Anti-Money Laundering Council, if not in the legal case, in similar cases of unexplained wealth. Okay.

1082
05:38:23,000 --> 05:38:23,660
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1083
05:38:23,920 --> 05:38:35,000
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So in that respect, ay hindi na po confidential yung galing sa AMLA kasi mismo ang Supreme Court na naglabas ng mga nilalaman ng AMLA documents.

1084
05:38:36,480 --> 05:38:50,220
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: If my memory serves me right, Your Honor, these are findings already. Process information. What... is prohibited is the raw data, intelligence report data, which is subject to verification.

1085
05:38:50,740 --> 05:38:59,560
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So now you're making these finer distinctions that you did not make earlier. Ang sinasabi po ninyo ngayon, yung raw data lang po ang confidential.

1086
05:39:00,400 --> 05:39:05,260
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Including the investigation report, Your Honor, not just the raw data, which is a derivative.

1087
05:39:05,260 --> 05:39:12,500
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Pero yung investigation report nga po ay sinasight mismo ng Supreme Court. So paano siya magiging confidential kung ganon?

1088
05:39:12,860 --> 05:39:19,140
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. Counsel is already arguing with the witness, Your Honor. Anyway, the witness already gave his answer.

1089
05:39:20,160 --> 05:39:21,980
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Move on to your next point, Attorney Chell.

1090
05:39:22,660 --> 05:39:31,700
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, earlier on your direct examination, you testified that there's no such thing as sensitivity analysis.

1091
05:39:32,620 --> 05:39:33,580
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa batas.

1092
05:39:33,700 --> 05:39:34,560
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Sa batas.

1093
05:39:34,700 --> 05:39:35,160
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Wala po.

1094
05:39:35,480 --> 05:39:39,860
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Ngayon, kayo po ay certified public accountant, hindi po ba?

1095
05:39:40,120 --> 05:39:41,020
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1096
05:39:42,640 --> 05:39:50,460
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Am I correct in saying that that concept of sensitivity analysis is recognized in the field of accountancy?

1097
05:39:50,680 --> 05:39:51,300
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1098
05:39:51,920 --> 05:39:57,560
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So, nagagamit po yan ng mga accountants sa kanilang pag-iinvestiga, hindi po ba?

1099
05:39:57,760 --> 05:39:58,220
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1100
05:39:58,680 --> 05:40:09,000
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And there's nothing wrong with a forensic expert applying a sensitivity analysis test in his or her examination. Would that be correct?

1101
05:40:09,260 --> 05:40:09,780
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1102
05:40:10,460 --> 05:40:25,120
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, In connection with that sensitivity analysis, meron din kayong kanina nabanggit na piercing the corporate veil can only be done by the court. Did I get you right?

1103
05:40:26,420 --> 05:40:32,420
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. I base it on my limited knowledge of our revised corporation code.

1104
05:40:32,840 --> 05:40:51,200
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Limited knowledge of the revised corporation code. Ibig niyo bang sabihin na sa pag-analyze ng isang accountant, Odikaya, financial investigator. Hindi niya pwedeng tingnan kung sino ang totoong may-ari ng isang kumpanya?

1105
05:40:51,880 --> 05:40:55,780
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. Misleading and already assumed sa fact that it has not been established.

1106
05:40:57,320 --> 05:41:01,060
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: It's not misleading, Your Honor. It's based on the testimony of the witness given.

1107
05:41:01,060 --> 05:41:10,580
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Misleading, Your Honor, because that's not even the concept that is contemplated by the piercing, the veil of corporate fiction, Doctor.

1108
05:41:11,120 --> 05:41:20,400
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Actually, court would like to hear the witness answer. Court has its own questions with respect to his theory in that regard at the proper time. If you know, Attorney Rainer?

1109
05:41:20,840 --> 05:41:22,320
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: May I ask again?

1110
05:41:22,320 --> 05:41:23,900
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Can you repeat the question, Honorable Chel?

1111
05:41:25,680 --> 05:41:47,700
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Let me just rephrase it. Kanina po, sinabi ninyo na ang korte lang ang pwedeng mag-pierce ng corporate veil. Ang tanong ko po, ibig nyo bang sabihin na hindi maaaring i-apply yung doctrine na yan ng isang CPA o forensic investigator?

1112
05:41:48,200 --> 05:41:50,320
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa kanya hong analysis, maaari.

1113
05:41:51,500 --> 05:42:03,000
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So, wala naman pong palang pagkakamali ang ginawa ng forensic experts sa impeachment court na ito sa pag-apply ng piercing the corporate veil sa kasong ito.

1114
05:42:03,080 --> 05:42:16,100
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. That's already misleading. Considering, Your Honor, that the good counsel already added his own interpretation to what the forensic analyst allegedly did.

1115
05:42:16,380 --> 05:42:24,710
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: No, Atty. Mark, the witness answered that it is possible, it can be used. Witness may answer. It came from his own answer.

1116
05:42:24,910 --> 05:42:34,570
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The question again, Your Honor, kung tama ba? Yes, Your Honor, tama naman. Maaari niyang gawin yun. At ano po niyong pangalawang tanong?

1117
05:42:34,570 --> 05:42:45,520
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Wala pong ginawang pagkakamali si Atty. Cabrera nung in-apply po niya yung doctrine of piercing the corporate veil. Sa kanyang analysis sa kasong ito?

1118
05:42:45,640 --> 05:42:53,060
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa kanyang professional report. Wala naman po. Walang nagbabawal sa kanya na gamitin iyon.

1119
05:42:54,850 --> 05:42:56,490
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Thank you. Thank you for that.

1120
05:43:07,150 --> 05:43:16,010
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Earlier, you said that you have quote-unquote limited knowledge of constitutional law. Kayo na mismo po na nag-amin yan, di ba?

1121
05:43:16,550 --> 05:43:20,050
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. I was subpoenaed for AML matters.

1122
05:43:20,740 --> 05:43:44,490
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So your opinions about What is found in the Constitution are really, don't really have much... Paano po kami makakapaniwala sa sinasabi ninyo sa mga nabanggit ninyong constitutional law opinions kung mismo kayo nagsabi na limited po ang inyong kaalaman tungkol sa saligang batas?

1123
05:43:44,550 --> 05:43:54,720
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. The witness is already incompetent to answer that question considering that he cannot delve on the minds of... His own listeners, Your Honor.

1124
05:43:54,900 --> 05:43:57,340
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I will withdraw the question, Your Honor.

1125
05:43:57,600 --> 05:44:00,000
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you. You may proceed, Atty. Arnabuchel.

1126
05:44:03,670 --> 05:44:21,670
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, earlier as well, you said that you were asked about legitimate income and you answered to the effect that legitimate income would include income derived from one's profession or business activities. Did I hear you right?

1127
05:44:22,400 --> 05:44:24,240
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor. Correct, Your Honor.

1128
05:44:24,940 --> 05:44:48,710
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: But if a certain official of the Executive Department is expressly prohibited by the Constitution from receiving any emoluments other than what they receive from their salary, ay hindi na rin po legitimate income yung kita mula sa profesyon. Kasi pinagbabawal mismo ng Constitution eh.

1129
05:44:51,010 --> 05:44:58,730
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: To the impeachment court to decide whether they would consider this as legitimate or illegitimate given the facts surrounding the case.

1130
05:44:59,150 --> 05:45:14,670
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: But you would agree with me that under Section 13, Article 7 of the Constitution, the Vice President is not allowed to receive any emoluments other than her salary as Vice President. You would agree with that legal statement?

1131
05:45:15,070 --> 05:45:26,560
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. Again, already calls for a conclusion of law. And that's precisely the question that the court needs to resolve in this impeachment case.

1132
05:45:26,800 --> 05:45:30,940
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I think the Honorable Chel is quoting the constitutional provision itself. Would that be correct?

1133
05:45:31,160 --> 05:45:31,940
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Yes, Your Honor.

1134
05:45:32,600 --> 05:45:38,920
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: But he's asking already for an interpretation of such provision, Your Honor, that favors their position, Your Honor.

1135
05:45:39,120 --> 05:45:45,500
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: He also did that, Atty. Mark, but the witness simply answered he defers to the court. He may do so again now.

1136
05:45:45,880 --> 05:45:46,900
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: We will submit, Your Honor.

1137
05:45:48,460 --> 05:45:50,120
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, Atty. Rainer, if you know.

1138
05:45:50,580 --> 05:45:52,780
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: If it is what is written in the Constitution, yes, Your Honor.

1139
05:45:53,990 --> 05:46:07,910
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So, would your answer now change about what is legitimate income, considering that for the Vice President, income from a profession is not allowed while the Vice President is sitting as such?

1140
05:46:08,700 --> 05:46:11,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, I leave it to the discretion of the Honorable Court, Your Honor.

1141
05:46:13,170 --> 05:46:34,270
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, question. Earlier, you were shown snippets of the report of Attorney Cabrera. You have already testified that you didn't read the whole report. Wouldn't you agree that context means a lot in terms of evaluating the veracity of a financial report?

1142
05:46:34,610 --> 05:46:38,970
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection. Question is vague, Your Honor. Context means a lot. What does that mean?

1143
05:46:40,760 --> 05:46:42,960
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I think the witness is intelligent enough

1144
05:46:42,960 --> 05:46:44,740
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: to be able to understand the question.

1145
05:46:45,900 --> 05:46:47,380
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Witness may answer if you know.

1146
05:46:47,580 --> 05:47:02,930
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: As much as I want to read. Your Honor, I have no access over this information. I did my research, reading the news, watching some of the audio clips, and that's it.

1147
05:47:04,010 --> 05:47:16,010
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Let's turn this around. Let's say that I were going to evaluate your investigation report. Kayo po ba ay nakapagsubmit hindi po ba ng investigation report sa Anti-Money Laundering Council?

1148
05:47:16,030 --> 05:47:16,370
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1149
05:47:16,850 --> 05:47:28,770
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Pero sa pag-husga ko, sa pag-evaluate ko ng inyong report, hindi ko muna babasahin yung kabuuan. Hahanap lang ako ng ilan ng mga portion doon. Don't you think that would be unfair to you?

1150
05:47:29,250 --> 05:47:32,270
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. It's a speculative question, Your Honor.

1151
05:47:32,820 --> 05:47:36,020
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I think the witness is capable of answering that, Your Honor.

1152
05:47:36,080 --> 05:48:02,480
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Allow me, Counsel. Atty. Rainer, ang pinupunto lamang naman po ni Hon. Diokno, importante ang konteksto. Ibig sabihin, yung kabuuan... Report para maunawaan yung parte nito at yung mga conclusion nito. Sangahin po ba kayo sa statement na yun na mahalaga ang konteksto at medyo may pagkukulang kapag hindi nyo nakita yung kabuhang report sa pagbibigay ng komentaryo kaugnay sa parte o bahagi lamang ng report?

1153
05:48:02,960 --> 05:48:14,720
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor. Pero ang pagbabahagi ho ng aking opinion sa report ay base lamang ibabanggahos kung ano mang provided ng batas. So I am not countering his or her conclusions.

1154
05:48:22,660 --> 05:48:42,980
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: As to the acceptability or not, again, we respect the professional, personal opinion of the forensic accountant who did that. But it should have been done within the bounds of law. Yun lang ang aking role. I do not question. Nasa sa ating impeachment court na huyon kung kanila bang tatanggapin o hindi.

1155
05:48:43,680 --> 05:48:46,360
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You cannot

1156
05:48:46,360 --> 05:48:52,020
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: cite any specific action done by Atty. Cabrera that violates the law.

1157
05:48:52,810 --> 05:49:00,800
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Based on the circumstances, again, it's up to the impeachment court.

1158
05:49:00,860 --> 05:49:10,400
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Sir, my question is very simple. Meron pa ba kayong maipapakita ng mismong paglabag ng batas doon sa report ni Atty. Cabrera?

1159
05:49:13,280 --> 05:49:18,300
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Your Honor, again, the witness was not able to peruse the actual report, Your Honor.

1160
05:49:18,560 --> 05:49:47,500
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: As to the portion shown to you, Atty. Rainer, as to the portion shown to you, you testified, you made observations earlier, you expressed your opinion earlier. The question of Atty. The Honorable Chel is quite clear. On the portion shown to you and methodology used as described by the counsel when he was asking questions, were any laws, did Atty. Cabrera in his methodology and their presentation violate any laws. In your opinion?

1161
05:49:48,350 --> 05:49:59,870
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: At Section 8 of RA 9160 as amended. On confidentiality. On confidentiality to a private individual.

1162
05:50:00,310 --> 05:50:08,070
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Ito yung pagbibigay ng prosecution o ng komite sa kanya ng kopya para pag-aralan, suriin, at pagbasihan ng report. That's the violation.

1163
05:50:08,470 --> 05:50:17,950
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Pero ito ay, again, depende na ho sa aggrieved party. If he or she will... Pursue that case. So again, nandun na po tayo nakadepende. And

1164
05:50:17,950 --> 05:50:22,850
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: that is the only legal provision that you can cite? Nothing else?

1165
05:50:24,320 --> 05:50:35,920
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: That's the only legal provision on confidentiality, Your Honor. Section 8-A, in relation to that, we have the penal provision on Section 14-D.

1166
05:50:36,300 --> 05:50:38,460
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Yes, so those two related provisions.

1167
05:50:38,800 --> 05:50:39,160
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1168
05:50:39,380 --> 05:50:59,710
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, considering that the impeachment court itself has allowed Presentation of the Anti-Money Laundering Council Records and also allowed the testimony of Attorney Cabrera. Is it your opinion that that provision is still being violated by the Impeachment Court?

1169
05:50:59,810 --> 05:51:30,500
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. Question is misleading. What the witness answered was that it was a violation of 8A because the AMLC documents or materials were provided by the prosecution. A third party. Now the counsel is implying your honor that the court authorized such disclosure but the court will never admit your honor that it issued any order authorizing the release of those AMLC documents to attorney Cabrera.

1170
05:51:31,080 --> 05:51:46,470
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Share confirms that and I believe the prosecution admitted that they gave a copy to attorney Cabrera much much earlier based on the documents received by the Committee on Justice, by virtue of a subpoena issued by the Committee on Justice. Move along, counsel.

1171
05:51:46,730 --> 05:52:10,420
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Thank you, Your Honor. Earlier, you questioned the report's reliance or, according to you, use of official receipts from Jollibee Corporation. Ayun pong pinakita sa inyong mga resibo. Those are considered as official receipts from the branches involved, right?

1172
05:52:11,020 --> 05:52:11,500
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, sir.

1173
05:52:11,550 --> 05:52:16,370
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So in other words, those documents have evidentiary weight.

1174
05:52:17,590 --> 05:52:20,990
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Depende ho yan sa ating impeachment court if they will take it.

1175
05:52:21,350 --> 05:52:31,270
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: In fact, if a corporation issues a receipt and states that it is their corporation that is issuing the receipt, that is in the nature of an admission by the corporation, is it not?

1176
05:52:31,270 --> 05:52:37,420
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. It already calls for conclusions of facts and law, and the witness will not be able to testify on those.

1177
05:52:37,420 --> 05:52:42,100
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Your Honor, the witness is a lawyer and a CPA. I believe if he knows, he can provide an answer. But

1178
05:52:42,100 --> 05:52:44,260
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: it was not covered in his testimony.

1179
05:52:44,460 --> 05:52:47,480
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I am entitled to question him on this point on cross-law.

1180
05:52:47,480 --> 05:52:52,200
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We're giving him enough leeway, counsel. Witness may answer if he knows on the receipts.

1181
05:52:52,420 --> 05:52:55,100
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ano po, Lee, yung specific question, Your Honor?

1182
05:52:55,980 --> 05:53:03,360
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Yung pong mga official receipt na ini-issue ng isang kumpanya ay meron pong evidentiary weight yun, di ba?

1183
05:53:04,320 --> 05:53:13,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: It's not the best evidence obtainable, po. There are... Better evidences po sa ating official certified true copies.

1184
05:53:13,760 --> 05:53:29,540
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Well, thank you for that. That really wasn't my question. My question is very simple. When a company issues an official receipt and states that it was that company that issued the receipt, mapikat po na ebidensya yun, hindi po ba?

1185
05:53:29,720 --> 05:53:40,110
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection. As an answer, Your Honor, the witness already distinguished Your Honor. The evidentiary weight of such document vis-a-vis other official documents.

1186
05:53:40,110 --> 05:53:41,820
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Move on, counsel. We get the point.

1187
05:53:41,820 --> 05:53:58,660
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Thank you, Your Honor. I just have a few more questions on cross-examination, but if I may be given just a minute or two to confer with my colleagues, there may be other points that I will raise, if I may, Your Honor.

1188
05:53:58,660 --> 05:54:00,840
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Without calling a recess, you may do so, counsel.

1189
05:54:11,540 --> 05:54:13,980
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We will entertain some interjections then.

1190
05:54:16,210 --> 05:54:17,350
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: From one or two,

1191
05:54:25,120 --> 05:54:27,980
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Senator Judge Sotto, former Senate President is recognized.

1192
05:54:31,080 --> 05:54:33,400
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You may proceed with the interjection, sir. You have two minutes.

1193
05:54:39,680 --> 05:54:44,220
Sen. Vicente C. Sotto III: Actually, I have one or two questions, only Mr. Presiding Officer. Thank you.

1194
05:54:47,060 --> 05:54:54,250
Sen. Vicente C. Sotto III: Mr. Witness, Attorney Dela Fuente, when did you author that AML handbook?

1195
05:54:55,580 --> 05:55:03,620
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: July of 2025, Your Honor. It was published, but initial works here started in 2024.

1196
05:55:05,870 --> 05:55:12,790
Sen. Vicente C. Sotto III: You worked with the AMLC from 2015 to 2018 only, correct?

1197
05:55:13,110 --> 05:55:13,710
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1198
05:55:16,940 --> 05:55:19,980
Sen. Vicente C. Sotto III: Where were you in January 2021?

1199
05:55:22,090 --> 05:55:30,180
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: January pandemic work, Your Honor, or the actual place?

1200
05:55:30,400 --> 05:55:32,580
Sen. Vicente C. Sotto III: What work? What was your work then?

1201
05:55:33,040 --> 05:55:36,080
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I was a partner at Gialogo de la Fuente and Associates.

1202
05:55:36,220 --> 05:55:37,700
Sen. Vicente C. Sotto III: No longer with AMLC.

1203
05:55:38,020 --> 05:55:38,720
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1204
05:55:38,940 --> 05:55:42,580
Sen. Vicente C. Sotto III: Yes. We amended the law in January 2021.

1205
05:55:42,920 --> 05:55:43,520
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ah, yes, Your Honor.

1206
05:55:43,760 --> 05:55:44,160
Sen. Vicente C. Sotto III: Thank you.

1207
05:55:46,490 --> 05:55:53,420
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Honorable Chel, are you ready? Senator Judge Lacson, what is your pleasure, sir? Okay. Honorable Chel, you're ready?

1208
05:55:58,350 --> 05:56:01,430
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Not yet? Senator Judge Lacson, what is your pleasure, sir?

1209
05:56:04,430 --> 05:56:35,540
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson: Thank you, sir. Presiding Officer. I had actually... Interjected on the issue involving the claim of the same defense counsel about weaponizing AMLC, the AMLC, for political persecution and harassment, when then Executive Director Buenaventura was our witness. Since Atty. Vinluan brought it up again, pinapull out ko na po yung TSN para mas accurate.

1210
05:56:35,740 --> 05:56:37,560
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I remember, Honorable Lacson.

1211
05:56:38,310 --> 05:56:50,610
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson: And ang tanong ko po sa witness, familiar pa kayo sa history or provenance ng Section 16 ng AMLA? Kung saan ang galing yung Section 16?

1212
05:56:51,030 --> 05:56:52,370
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Attorney Rainer, kindly respond.

1213
05:56:52,630 --> 05:56:54,170
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Not that familiar,

1214
05:56:54,370 --> 05:56:54,630
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor.

1215
05:56:54,930 --> 05:57:19,020
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson: But I'll tell you, no? Historical. Yeah. Ang nag-introduce niyan, Senator Sotto, Sotto Amendment. Actually, yung kasama niya nag-introduce dito, patay na rin pareho. Si late Joker Arroyo, Senator Arroyo, and Senator Ople, as well as Senator Angara. Siya na lang po ang naiwan.

1216
05:57:21,300 --> 05:58:04,980
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson: Well, I can say na, following yung interjection ni Senators Sotto and Ople, pwede natin madeduce natin na yung present provision of Section 16 on prohibitions against political harassment of the money laundering law including the AMLC on the prohibition against political persecution and harassment was really for the protection not only of trade and commerce but also of a candidate sa eleksyon. Diyan po nagsimula yan. So general lang yung paragraph 1, actually yung 2 yung specific, yun nga inintroduce ni Senator Sotto at that time.

1217
05:58:07,180 --> 05:59:13,610
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson: Kaya nasa amin yung trade and commerce kasi yun yung mga contributors eh. Baka maharas. So hindi pwedeng i-interpret na in a general sense like an impeachment trial na i-apply yung political persecution. Kasi po ako noong 2001 hanggang 2000 when I ended my term in 2013, subject po ako ng political persecution. Money laundering din. Sinasabi nung dating administration ay stashed sa mga foreign banks hundreds of millions of US dollars. Yun ang political persecution. Hindi ko ginamit yung prohibition kasi hindi applicable. Kasi nga applicability ng Section 16, papunta lamang doon sa election period para huwag maharas yung kandidato. I would just like to reiterate that kasi laging nabibring up yung political harassment. Asaka persecution dito sa impeachment trial. Hindi po yung intent and purpose of that provision. Yun lamang po, Mr. Presiding Officer.

1218
05:59:13,830 --> 05:59:20,570
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you, Senator Judge Lacson. Honorable Chell, you may proceed with your cross and wind up.

1219
05:59:21,140 --> 05:59:38,730
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Thank you. Thank you, Your Honor. Earlier, Mr. Witness, good afternoon. You testified that you felt that two weeks was medyo mahirap para magpapagsagawa ng isang financial... Investigation. Tama po ba yan?

1220
05:59:39,290 --> 05:59:41,810
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Challenging po yan. Mahira po.

1221
05:59:42,170 --> 06:00:00,830
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: But that is on the assumption that the person involved only had two weeks. If that person had several months to begin their examination and as records came in, continued to examine the documents, walang pong issue ang two weeks. Tama po ba?

1222
06:00:01,350 --> 06:00:01,910
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1223
06:00:02,130 --> 06:00:12,560
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Thank you. Now, let me just wind up. I just want to summarize several points that you have mentioned.

1224
06:00:15,220 --> 06:00:25,100
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You're not saying to this Court that the AMLA records, that the records submitted by AMLA are inaccurate or untruthful. Wala namang kayong sinasabing ganun.

1225
06:00:25,140 --> 06:00:25,920
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Wala po iyon.

1226
06:00:26,080 --> 06:00:29,220
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You're not saying that the records submitted by the BIR

1227
06:00:31,230 --> 06:00:37,330
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: SEC, and other government agencies are tampered or fabricated. Hindi mo rin sinasabi yun.

1228
06:00:37,450 --> 06:00:38,030
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: None, Your Honor.

1229
06:00:38,330 --> 06:00:45,550
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Hindi niyo rin sinasabi na hindi totoo yung mga bank records na sinabmit ng mga bank o sa hukumang ito.

1230
06:00:46,230 --> 06:00:47,050
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: None, Your Honor.

1231
06:00:47,330 --> 06:01:00,820
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Hindi niyo rin sinasabi, aside from yung mga nabanggit niyo, mga snippets ng report ni Atty. Cabrera, Meron pang ibang mga questionable parts ng report niya dahil hindi mo naman nabasa yung kabuuan.

1232
06:01:01,120 --> 06:01:03,340
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kung ano lang po yung napakita sa akin, Your Honor.

1233
06:01:04,580 --> 06:01:14,920
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Hindi niyo rin sinasabi na, in fact, kanina pinupurin niyo yung qualifications ni Atty. Cabrera bilang forensic expert. So you're not questioning his qualifications.

1234
06:01:15,420 --> 06:01:18,240
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I still respect him as a fellow professional.

1235
06:01:18,660 --> 06:01:38,420
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: No question. Kasi baka po magka hindi kayo maintindihan o hindi malinaw sa publiko. Kayo po ba, sinasabi ba ninyo na pag walang money laundering, wala rin unexplained wealth? Ano po? Pag walang money laundering, walang unexplained wealth?

1236
06:01:39,000 --> 06:01:48,070
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Baliktad po. Money laundering is a derivative offense. So, it has to depend on a... Wala kong ilo-launder kung walang krimeng nangyari.

1237
06:01:48,290 --> 06:02:27,770
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So, kahit na wala kayong mahanap na ebidensya ng money laundering, pero... Mapatunayan yung requirements ng unexplained wealth sa ilalim ng Republic Act 3019 Section 8 ay pwede pa rin po magka-finding ng unexplained wealth. So tama po yung sinabi ko. Even if there is no case or finding of money laundering, a case for unexplained wealth can still prosper If the evidence is there to prove unexplained well.

1238
06:02:27,790 --> 06:02:28,230
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1239
06:02:28,450 --> 06:02:30,390
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Thank you. Ngayon,

1240
06:02:32,340 --> 06:02:38,840
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: nakausap niyo si Defense Counsel bago po kayo na upo dito?

1241
06:02:39,120 --> 06:02:40,700
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Unfortunately, hindi po.

1242
06:02:42,480 --> 06:02:53,110
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So, hindi po niya naipaliwanag sa inyo kung ano talaga yung nasa loob ng Article 2 ng Articles of Impeachment?

1243
06:02:53,390 --> 06:02:54,570
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi po, Your Honor.

1244
06:02:54,860 --> 06:02:58,720
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: At hindi nyo rin nabasa bago ngayon yung laman.

1245
06:02:58,720 --> 06:03:01,780
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa balita po, nabasa po yung laman ng article.

1246
06:03:01,800 --> 06:03:02,700
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I'm sorry, hindi ko.

1247
06:03:02,880 --> 06:03:03,840
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa balita po, Your Honor.

1248
06:03:04,140 --> 06:03:09,350
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Ah, sa balita. Pero yung mismong dokumento na Article 2, you have not read?

1249
06:03:09,550 --> 06:03:09,870
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Not.

1250
06:03:10,810 --> 06:03:29,380
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Now, that may perhaps be the difficulty in your testimony. Kasi po, ang batayan ng Article 2, kung babasahin po ninyo yung laman, Ay hindi naman po Republic Act 9160.

1251
06:03:30,080 --> 06:03:31,500
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. Sorry to interrupt.

1252
06:03:31,640 --> 06:03:32,640
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I have no question yet.

1253
06:03:32,640 --> 06:03:57,370
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: I understand that. But Your Honor, Good Counsel already used the terms difficulty. So in other words, again, Your Honor, with all due respect, it's not the prosecution's function to interpret the... or give probative value to the testimony of the witness. It is the function of the court. He can just ask questions, Your Honor, to test his credibility.

1254
06:03:57,930 --> 06:04:08,610
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: I haven't heard a question yet, Attorney Mark. Kindly restate your question, Honorable Chell. I don't believe you've asked a question yet.

1255
06:04:08,790 --> 06:04:22,260
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Not yet, Your Honor. Since you did not get to read Article 2 of the Articles of Impeachment, you do not know that This article is based on Republic Act 3019.

1256
06:04:22,680 --> 06:04:32,860
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Based on the news, Your Honor, and the research that I did before coming in here, yes, I know that it's based on that Republic Act.

1257
06:04:32,860 --> 06:04:44,360
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So you confirm that this article on unexplained wealth is based, one of the laws is Republic Act 3019, anti-graphic corrupt practices law. You confirm that?

1258
06:04:44,660 --> 06:04:45,040
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1259
06:04:45,120 --> 06:04:54,170
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You confirm as well that Law is in relation to the provisions of Republic Act 1379 on civil forfeiture.

1260
06:04:55,820 --> 06:04:56,800
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1261
06:04:56,960 --> 06:05:05,920
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: You also confirm that Article 2 is based on Republic Act 6713, your code of conduct of public officials and employees.

1262
06:05:06,540 --> 06:05:07,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1263
06:05:07,480 --> 06:05:37,000
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: And most especially, you confirm that the allegations of unexplained wealth, amassing of wealth manifestly disproportional to the lawful income of the respondent, the allegations of participation in business that is prohibited by law, as well as the non-declaration of salary. These are all based on the Constitution of our country.

1264
06:05:37,440 --> 06:05:38,200
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, sir.

1265
06:05:39,060 --> 06:05:40,580
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Thank you. No

1266
06:05:45,320 --> 06:05:46,140
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: more questions, Your Honor.

1267
06:05:46,380 --> 06:05:47,140
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Redirect, Your Honor.

1268
06:05:47,300 --> 06:05:48,520
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Redirect, Attorney Mark.

1269
06:05:49,580 --> 06:06:14,430
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Good afternoon. Kunti na lang po, Attorney De La Fuente. During cross-examination, you were questioned about your limited time with the AMLC or particularly the AMLC Secretariat. However, you also characterized your stint with the AMLC as brief and meaningful. Can you explain that? Bakit yung po nasabi yan?

1270
06:06:15,050 --> 06:06:57,430
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yung aking competence and experience, it's not counted by the quantity of years that I have been with the Secretariat. So it's not on the quantity but the quality of work. Kung mahaba nga akong oras ninyo, pero for lack of better term, pabanjing-banjing ka lang, wala rin yung, it's not meaningful experience. Now, when I left the Council na Secretariat noong 2018, if hindi maganda ang aking record, probably they won't accredit me 2019. Other than that, I also got another accreditation from PAGCOR. Again, if hindi naging maganda ang aking record, ang aking trabaho, I won't be able to get those approvals.

1271
06:06:57,870 --> 06:07:03,830
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Art, you mentioned yung accreditation na yun from AMLA. This is already beyond your stint sa AMLC?

1272
06:07:05,010 --> 06:07:08,910
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. That's 2019, a year after I left the service.

1273
06:07:09,250 --> 06:07:20,460
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Correct. But yet, you described... Another function which is an accredited trainer of the AMLC. Paano po ba ito? Can you describe your functions kahit nawala na po kayo sa AMLC?

1274
06:07:20,780 --> 06:07:40,760
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, napaka-importante kasi, no, that we make the public, especially the covered persons, aware of their obligations, no, AML obligations. Sa dami ho ng ating covered persons, hindi ho yan na-accommodate lahat ng ating AMLC Secretariat. So they accredit private

1275
06:07:42,320 --> 06:08:10,700
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Individuals and also institutional training providers. They subject to vetting process. Ini-screen ho yan. Do you have the proper experience, competence? So meron din hong tine-check. Nagkaroon ng demo lectures. If we follow the syllabus of the AMLC. So hindi ho siya basta-basta pinoprovide. Meron hong proseso bago kabigyan ng accreditation.

1276
06:08:11,230 --> 06:08:22,870
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you for that clarification. So, in terms of training of or training with AMLC people, how would you characterize your work kahit na wala na po kayo sa AMLC?

1277
06:08:24,310 --> 06:08:30,850
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I still do maintain good relationship with them. But again, hiwalay ko ang personal sa professional.

1278
06:08:31,390 --> 06:08:35,850
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright. And then you also mentioned that you have extensive...

1279
06:08:37,370 --> 06:08:46,450
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Experience in financial investigation despite your limited time with the AMLC. Paano niyo po nasabi na extensive yung naging experience niyo?

1280
06:08:46,910 --> 06:08:53,770
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Lahat ho ng klase ng trabaho ng isang financial investigator na daanan na ho. In fact, that's the reason why I left the service.

1281
06:08:55,390 --> 06:09:15,660
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Natatakot na ho ang aking pamilya dahil sa risk. So, when I reached that point, I think I already contributed enough. For the service, that's the time for me to think about my family and also my personal career. That's why I left the service and also tried to establish my own law office.

1282
06:09:16,020 --> 06:09:48,700
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you po for that clarification. On cross, you also mentioned about yung Section 8A ng AMLA. And again, we don't have any question with the authority of this court. In fact, yung questions po on direct. Really pertained on the proceedings or processes before the House Committee on Justice. If you can just distinguish po ba, paano po ba naiiba yung proceedings ng impeachment court na ito sa ibang mga proceedings na hindi naman po court?

1283
06:09:49,480 --> 06:10:15,730
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, normally, when we go to the financial investigation part, marami po munang pinagdadaanan yan. Council approval, and then you file a petition with the Court of Appeals for freeze order. and Bank Inquiry. So marami kong pinagdadaan ng proseso yan. Dito sa ating impeachment court, again, the court is free to adopt its own rules and request subpoenaed documents from agencies such as AMLOC po.

1284
06:10:15,970 --> 06:10:37,170
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Alright, thank you po. Now, you also mentioned that subpoenaed documents, no? I understand that may mga subpoenaed documents yung court. But again, just to clarify, what is the propriety of disclosing even subpoenaed documents to a third party? If you can just answer.

1285
06:10:38,620 --> 06:11:01,840
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, that would contravene the second paragraph. It is authorized disclosure but re-disseminating, re-forwarding that information without observing the proper guidelines is I think a violation. Section 8-A.

1286
06:11:03,080 --> 06:11:17,280
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay. Na-mention din po yung maraming question on cross yung kay Atty. Cabrera. Yung disclosure po kay Atty. Cabrera, what is the propriety of that without the proper court order? If you just can answer.

1287
06:11:17,520 --> 06:11:36,940
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, sorry. I have no personal knowledge as to how it was submitted to him, how it was shared to him. Ako po ay nakabase lang sa batas. At plainly, nasa ating Section 2, Section 8-A, na dapat ho may sinunod na proper protocols.

1288
06:11:38,060 --> 06:12:03,680
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you po. You were also asked about piercing the corporate veil. Sinabi nyo on direct na it is the court that has the authority to do that pero on cross sinabi nyo naman din na if I can recall that wala namang problema kung gawin nyo ng forensic act. How do you reconcile those two concepts?

1289
06:12:04,360 --> 06:12:05,380
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, Your Honor, sorry.

1290
06:12:05,680 --> 06:12:18,080
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Kasi sinabi niyo po on direct na it is the court that has the authority to pierce. Pero on cross, tinatanong kayo si Atty. Cabrera kasi nag-pierce din siya ng corporate. So how do you reconcile po?

1291
06:12:18,400 --> 06:12:54,490
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, the so-called piercing made by the forensic is only for analysis. It's not, again, dalabaho ang... Financial intelligence, which is analytical, at saka financial investigation. In my own humble opinion, what he did is, on the first part, analytical. It's not yet evidence gathering that would trigger yung mga compulsive or coercive processes. So, in that case, that is only for case build-up. Fact-finding lang ho yun. Hindi pa siya ebidensya.

1292
06:12:58,960 --> 06:13:17,840
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: You were also confronted with the fact that you did not access yung mga actual CTRs and STRs para hindi niyo po, and you said na hindi niyo po mako-confront yung report ni Atty. Cabrera on this. Ano nga po ulit yung reason why you did not access these reports?

1293
06:13:18,300 --> 06:13:39,000
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, the only reason, Your Honor, is that, well, that's confidential. I do what I preach. If I'm saying that this is confidential, I also observe that. Even if maganda sana makita ko, but I am not the intended end user of the documents. So why would I bother looking into those documents?

1294
06:13:39,910 --> 06:13:54,110
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Thank you po. You were also confronted about the idea, yung money laundering versus yung unlawful activity case. Can you just explain to us ano nga po ba yung pagkakaiba nito?

1295
06:13:55,870 --> 06:14:17,090
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Money laundering is a derivative offense. It has to depend on the prior unlawful activity. Hindi nakadepende ang pagpapafile ng unlawful activity kung mayroong money laundering. Baliktad, dapat nakadepende ang money laundering sa existence ng unlawful activity.

1296
06:14:17,780 --> 06:14:21,480
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And yung unlawful activity na po yun, yun po yung source?

1297
06:14:23,880 --> 06:14:27,080
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Sino po yung may responsibility to prove that?

1298
06:14:27,770 --> 06:14:35,410
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: In our current proceedings, it is the Honorable Impeachment Court who will be determining if there is an unlawful activity or not.

1299
06:14:35,790 --> 06:14:37,770
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Okay. Based on the allegations?

1300
06:14:38,070 --> 06:14:38,870
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Based on the allegations.

1301
06:14:41,490 --> 06:14:53,370
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And sino po ba yung may responsibility to gather or collate the necessary evidence to prove that unlawful activity? Kung meron pong mga...

1302
06:14:55,010 --> 06:14:56,510
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Allegations on money laundering.

1303
06:14:56,650 --> 06:15:17,650
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Your Honor, please. This line of questioning is very misleading. The presiding officer himself has stated categorically that the respondent is not being charged with money laundering and yet the defense counsel is making it appear that it is the impeachment court that will make a decision about unlawful activities. Wala po sa issue dito pa yan.

1304
06:15:17,850 --> 06:15:18,850
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: If he knows, Your Honor.

1305
06:15:19,180 --> 06:15:32,560
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: For the information of the witness, it is not part of the charges against the Vice President, given your admission that you have not yet read the actual articles of impeachment. It is not. With that in mind, kindly answer the question of Attorney Mark.

1306
06:15:32,560 --> 06:15:35,200
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Can you repeat the question?

1307
06:15:35,200 --> 06:16:00,680
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Because you were, you were explaining the logical sequence between a Logical sequence involving predicate crime or unlawful activity and money laundering. My question is very simple. Who has the burden of gathering evidence for unlawful activity or predicate crime to support any money laundering?

1308
06:16:00,880 --> 06:16:02,080
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: In this case, the prosecution.

1309
06:16:05,100 --> 06:16:14,920
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: If your honor, please, I move to strike the answer of the witness considering that the presiding officer himself already informed this witness that money laundering is not...

1310
06:16:15,340 --> 06:16:18,140
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: It is not one of the charges, Atty. Raynor.

1311
06:16:18,160 --> 06:16:19,080
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes.

1312
06:16:19,080 --> 06:16:20,060
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Asked and answered, Your Honor.

1313
06:16:20,420 --> 06:16:24,600
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: It's not up for the prosecution, Atty. Raynor.

1314
06:16:27,130 --> 06:16:36,250
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: With the knowledge that it's not part of the articles of impeachment that the Vice President is supposed to answer to or respond to, that's your answer? It's up for the prosecution?

1315
06:16:37,030 --> 06:16:43,710
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I think the question is who has the burden of proving the unlawful activity?

1316
06:16:44,480 --> 06:16:54,180
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Yes, Your Honor. In that sequence, only based on that scenario that there is an unlawful activity or predicate crime and then there's a money laundering aspect as well.

1317
06:16:54,700 --> 06:17:02,660
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I would object then, Your Honor. The question is irrelevant in the material since the respondent is not being charged with any money laundering offense.

1318
06:17:03,020 --> 06:17:10,800
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: No, I'll allow it because it presupposes a predicate crime, which the counsel for the prosecutors also asked. Witness may answer.

1319
06:17:13,450 --> 06:17:20,120
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly answer, Attorney Reg. Who has the burden of proving? What was your question, Attorney Mark?

1320
06:17:22,380 --> 06:17:31,320
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Who has the burden of proving that particular aspect on unlawful activity? The unlawful activity. The predicate crime, yes.

1321
06:17:32,130 --> 06:17:38,420
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: The prosecution, your honor. Yes. Burden of proving the existence of the unlawful activity.

1322
06:17:38,940 --> 06:17:44,160
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: And again, just for clarity, what is the burden of proof in these types of accusations or allegations?

1323
06:17:45,160 --> 06:17:57,450
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, in impeachment. Or normally, if the normal case is, Your Honor, well, I'll prove beyond reasonable doubt. This is a criminal case.

1324
06:17:58,600 --> 06:17:59,960
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: That will be all, Your Honor.

1325
06:18:00,220 --> 06:18:02,280
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Rick Ross, Honorable Chell.

1326
06:18:02,580 --> 06:18:04,300
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: With the permission of the...

1327
06:18:04,300 --> 06:18:04,980
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You may proceed, sir.

1328
06:18:06,690 --> 06:18:11,850
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Don't you think that your statement about the quality of your work is self-serving?

1329
06:18:13,810 --> 06:18:14,290
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Well...

1330
06:18:14,290 --> 06:18:15,390
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor.

1331
06:18:15,450 --> 06:18:16,430
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I know myself, Your Honor.

1332
06:18:18,460 --> 06:18:19,840
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Question is argumentative, Your Honor.

1333
06:18:20,000 --> 06:18:22,040
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: It is argumentative, Honorable Chad.

1334
06:18:22,080 --> 06:18:36,490
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I will move on. In other words, Mr. Witness, your own evaluation of your work, you have concluded that you have high quality work. That's why you said your stint in the AMLC has been brief and meaningful.

1335
06:18:37,510 --> 06:18:38,910
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Objection, Your Honor. Same objection.

1336
06:18:39,790 --> 06:18:43,870
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: It was phrased properly, Counsel. Witness, may answer?

1337
06:18:46,750 --> 06:19:20,980
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I did not mention the... Word high quality. I just mentioned quality. So it's based on perception. So I see myself, well, during my time, I think the cases that I handled, they showcased it when we had meetings with law enforcement agencies. Yung mga kasong hinawakan ko, yun yung mga pinapakita namin with our counterparts to show how it is done. So that recognition from my superiors, I think, is... An affirmation of the quality of work that I did.

1338
06:19:22,100 --> 06:19:34,270
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: I'll go back to that in a minute. I just have one other question, sir. Yung nabanggit niyo ang burden of proof, proof beyond reasonable doubt, applicable lang po yan sa mga criminal cases, hindi po ba? Yes, po?

1339
06:19:34,830 --> 06:19:42,670
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. That's the, yun po yung nilatagganin ang question sa akin. Kaya I also, that's the normal burden of proof po.

1340
06:19:43,210 --> 06:20:03,260
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Going back to your statement of having a brief but meaningful stint at AMLA and that you have quality work, tama po ba ako na nung kayo ay naging financial investigator sa AMLA, meron din ibang posisyon na financial analyst? Tama po ba yan?

1341
06:20:03,460 --> 06:20:04,900
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes po, iba pong grupo yan.

1342
06:20:05,100 --> 06:20:11,240
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So ang trabaho ng financial investigator ay mag-investiga ng money laundering cases.

1343
06:20:11,520 --> 06:20:12,160
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Tama po.

1344
06:20:13,750 --> 06:20:16,870
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: Ano po ang trabaho ng financial analyst?

1345
06:20:17,210 --> 06:20:24,790
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ang financial analyst po, they receive, they analyze, and disseminate financial intelligence. So magkaiba po ang intelligence sa investigation.

1346
06:20:25,290 --> 06:20:41,480
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: So tama po ba ang statement na it is the financial analyst who examine and analyze CTRs and STRs, covered transactions and suspicious transactions, not the... Financial Investigator.

1347
06:20:41,760 --> 06:20:42,320
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor.

1348
06:20:42,700 --> 06:20:44,000
Rep. Jose Manuel “Chel” I. Diokno: No more questions, Your Honor.

1349
06:20:44,600 --> 06:20:46,020
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you, Honorable Chel.

1350
06:20:46,020 --> 06:20:47,240
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Just a short manifestation, Your Honor.

1351
06:20:47,500 --> 06:20:49,840
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, what is the manifestation of Atty. Vinluan?

1352
06:20:50,260 --> 06:21:04,820
Atty. Mark C. Vinluan: Considering, Your Honor, that there have been a lengthy debate on the credentials also, we just want to express, Your Honor, our gratitude to the witness for attending and for taking the time off from his family and just testifying today. That will be all.

1353
06:21:04,940 --> 06:21:07,580
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Of course, but you're not yet done, Attorney Rainer.

1354
06:21:08,720 --> 06:21:19,090
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We still have some interjections from Senator Judges. Senator Judge Raffy Tulfo is recognized. First interjection. You have two minutes, sir. You may proceed when you're ready. Thereafter, Senator Judge Erwin.

1355
06:21:27,330 --> 06:21:39,940
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: For the record, they're exchanging positions. Senator Judge Pangilinan, first. After Senator Judge Raffy. Senator Judge Raffy, you may proceed, sir. You have two minutes.

1356
06:21:41,920 --> 06:21:57,750
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Mr. Expert Witness, the way you are being painted by the defense like you're omniscient. Omniscient, like Omni-witness, like you know everything. Sobrang bilib sila sa'yo, which ako naman may bilib din sa'yo kasi magaling ka na sumagot agad-agad. Tanong ko lang, ano po yung plantilya nyo?

1357
06:21:58,050 --> 06:22:01,150
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Bank Officer 2 position po nung akwita sa AMLA.

1358
06:22:01,210 --> 06:22:03,250
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Correct. Hindi pa entry-level position niya?

1359
06:22:03,310 --> 06:22:03,610
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes po.

1360
06:22:03,950 --> 06:22:09,190
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Good. At meron pa ng Bank Officer 3, Attorney 3, Attorney 4. And yet hindi ka na-promote?

1361
06:22:09,860 --> 06:22:10,520
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi po.

1362
06:22:10,520 --> 06:22:10,960
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Sa 3 or 4?

1363
06:22:11,220 --> 06:22:13,120
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes po. For that brief statement.

1364
06:22:14,560 --> 06:22:16,760
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Why were you not promoted? Ba't hindi ka na-promote?

1365
06:22:17,150 --> 06:22:36,740
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I leave it to the discretion po of my superiors, but if I may continue, Your Honor, before leaving, I was offered a higher position. Now, out of delicadesa, I don't want to make it look like I am bargaining for that position. So I still stick with my decision to leave the service. So, yun po.

1366
06:22:37,280 --> 06:22:43,460
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Actually, after ng bank officer 2, nalipat ka sa office of the executive director, ata, as training staff.

1367
06:22:44,140 --> 06:22:47,870
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ako po ay... Hineram, kasi may... Pero hindi

1368
06:22:47,870 --> 06:22:48,850
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: promotion yun, tama?

1369
06:22:49,030 --> 06:22:49,930
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi po, hindi po siya promotion.

1370
06:22:50,230 --> 06:22:53,370
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: So, inoperang ka ng promotion, pero tinanggihan mo?

1371
06:22:53,650 --> 06:22:54,450
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Nung ako ay palis na po.

1372
06:22:54,450 --> 06:22:55,810
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Pero tinanggap mo yung last training staff?

1373
06:22:56,610 --> 06:23:00,510
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kasi po, I have to follow kung ano po ang discretion ng aming executive director.

1374
06:23:00,910 --> 06:23:11,490
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Yeah, so anyway, entry-level position yung plantilya mo when you were sa AMLAC. Now, kanina natanong ko sa'yo kung meron ka na natapos na kaso.

1375
06:23:12,110 --> 06:23:12,770
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1376
06:23:13,050 --> 06:23:16,210
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Sa AMLAC as financial investigator, ilan?

1377
06:23:17,070 --> 06:23:19,710
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Marami po. There are notable cases.

1378
06:23:20,050 --> 06:23:24,630
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Approximately ilan? 20, 50, 60? For that 36,

1379
06:23:24,950 --> 06:23:37,430
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: almost 36 months, almost close to, lahat-lahat po ah. Around almost 80 to 90 cases. Kasi I would assume for each month, marami po nire-refer sa aming kaso.

1380
06:23:37,670 --> 06:23:41,170
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Is that so? So kayo bang elite investigator o cosigner lang kayo?

1381
06:23:41,570 --> 06:23:42,350
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ano po, sir?

1382
06:23:42,410 --> 06:23:54,670
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Co-signer lang kayo doon sa dokumento na isasumite sa Sandigan Bayan. Co-signer. Kasi alim ka doon, di ba? Magpipirma doon sa report.

1383
06:23:55,230 --> 06:23:57,330
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Marami po kami nagpipirma. So we also sign.

1384
06:23:57,330 --> 06:23:58,050
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Marami ka pipirma.

1385
06:23:58,170 --> 06:23:58,570
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct.

1386
06:23:58,750 --> 06:24:00,070
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: So ang tawag sa iyo, co-signer.

1387
06:24:01,030 --> 06:24:03,270
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: If that's the definition you're...

1388
06:24:03,270 --> 06:24:20,660
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Well, yan ang definition ng AMLAC. Sa katulad sa iyo, na hindi ikaw ang lead investigator, you were just part, kumbaga pro forma lang. Kailangan ka mag-sign dahil kasama ka sa team. So hindi ka talaga ang pinaka-main investigator, hindi talaga nag-initiate sa'yo yung pagbuo ng kaso.

1389
06:24:20,760 --> 06:24:21,380
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Meron po.

1390
06:24:21,680 --> 06:24:31,380
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Kaya nga, mga kasama mo. Kasi otherwise, ikaw yung pinaka-main. Ikaw ay kasama lamang doon as co-signer. Hindi ako co-signer po pala.

1391
06:24:31,460 --> 06:24:44,420
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi po. Ako po yung main investigator. May mga kaso po na main investigator or kapag kukompleks ang kaso, Team ho kayo. Para if not available yung isa, mayroon ho magte-testify na isa pa.

1392
06:24:45,130 --> 06:24:55,170
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Kaya nga. But in some cases, lumilitaw na co-signer ka. Hindi ka talaga... Kung meron man yung sinasabi mo na ikaw ay lead investigator, ilan yun?

1393
06:24:56,400 --> 06:25:00,100
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi ko na ho mag... Hindi ho ako nag-inventory... And

1394
06:25:00,100 --> 06:25:08,460
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: mapapanindigan mo yun kung magbibigna certification ng AMLAC na kinokontra po yung sinasabi mo ngayon? Kung re-request ng impeachment court.

1395
06:25:09,110 --> 06:25:10,770
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor.

1396
06:25:11,520 --> 06:25:59,290
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Okay. And then two points na lang. Kasi sabi mo, inamin mo na first time mo lang makita yung report na pinakita sa screen na sinumite ni Attorney Cabrera, yung isang expert ng prosecution, forensic. Now first time mo lang makita, and yet, kinukontra mo, nire-refute mo yung nasa report without even studied it first, without having it reviewed. And then agad-agad nakakapagbigay ka na agad ng expert opinion mo. Okay, sige. Thank you po. Mr. Presiding Officer.

1397
06:25:59,970 --> 06:26:04,330
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly wrap it up. Senator Judge Raffy, witness will please answer.

1398
06:26:04,790 --> 06:26:08,210
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Yeah, so, di ba? Nag-guess mo yung point ko?

1399
06:26:08,430 --> 06:26:17,430
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. So, yun po, no? Kahit ho maigsi ang aking naging stint, sa isang tingin ko pa lang po kanina, alam ko na po kung ano yung mga problema.

1400
06:26:17,450 --> 06:26:31,030
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Wow! So sa isang tingin mo pa lang, parang kang supercomputer. Nakikita mo agad, parang kang ChatGPT. Isang kita lang, alam mo na agad kung saan ang mali doon. Without even studying it, without even reading it, without even analyzing it.

1401
06:26:31,310 --> 06:26:32,850
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi ho, I'm not saying na mali yun.

1402
06:26:32,850 --> 06:26:34,110
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Hindi, kasabi mo sa isang kita lang.

1403
06:26:34,350 --> 06:26:38,100
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yung mga problema. Sa kanyang report.

1404
06:26:38,440 --> 06:26:49,480
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: So how can you tell that there's a problem with the report? In fact, you haven't even looked at it for 10 minutes at least. Dito pinakita lang sa'yo, parang seconds lang eh. And then agad-agad, you were able to form an opinion and judgment.

1405
06:26:49,600 --> 06:26:55,020
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Binangga ko na kasi ito, your honor, sa aming normal financial investigation process.

1406
06:26:55,020 --> 06:27:06,180
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Exactly, but still, you have to have at least reviewed the report for let's say 10 minutes, 15 minutes siguro, enough na. Pero kanina, seconds lang ata, wala pang isang minuto. Agad-agad, nakapagbigay ka ng opinion mo.

1407
06:27:06,600 --> 06:27:11,460
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: At saka yung po aking opinion kanina ay binangga ko kung ano yung meron sa batas.

1408
06:27:11,540 --> 06:27:48,730
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: That is correct. Pero still, for you to be an intelligent witness, expert witness that is, you have to study, analyze, do some research doon sa ipinipresenta sa iyo na dokumento na work. Wherein you were asked to give your expert opinion. So how can you give a proper expert opinion to a certain degree in a certain report or document of you not having full knowledge of it by way of having at least reviewed it, having at least analyzed it? Yan lang sa akin.

1409
06:27:48,990 --> 06:27:56,810
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor. I agree po that if you will be doing a full-blown analysis, it takes time.

1410
06:27:57,020 --> 06:27:57,800
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: It takes time.

1411
06:27:57,840 --> 06:27:58,700
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kanina ho kasi guided.

1412
06:27:58,940 --> 06:28:00,560
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Hindi lang segundo, tama?

1413
06:28:00,620 --> 06:28:15,020
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Opo, guided ho kasi kanina yung naging analysis, tinuro ho sa akin yung mga items. So guided din ho yung aking, I'm not discounting the entire report, just the portion shown to me.

1414
06:28:15,240 --> 06:28:26,300
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Right. Yung sa portion na yun, like you said, isang tingin mo lang agad-agad, alam mo na kung saan, kung ano yung mali doon. Because of your being an expert Bank Officer Two sa AMLC.

1415
06:28:26,460 --> 06:28:35,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I'm not saying that I'm an expert, your honor. I'm again applying as an AML practitioner, my experience.

1416
06:28:35,500 --> 06:29:13,280
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Kasi sir, nirefute mo, binabangga mo ang isang expert witness na si Atty. Cabrera na katulad mo, or I'm sorry, hindi naman kita masyado kilala, na napakalawak yung credentials din. At ikaw sabi mo na respeto mo si Attorney Cabrera, na isang tao na ginagalang mo yung kanyang credentials, kilala mo. Eh, siyempre, hindi mo basta-basta i-refute yung mga binigay niyang report unless kung talagang sure ka na pag-aralan mo siya, na pag-aralan mo yung mga report na binigay niya, at gumawa ka ng malalim na saliksik at research, then only then makapagbigay ka ng expert opinion, siguro, I suppose.

1417
06:29:13,580 --> 06:29:28,210
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: If I may explain, Your Honor, kanina ko kasi, nung pinakita yung mga sa ating PowerPoint presentation, hypothetical po yung mga questions. Again, I mentioned I have no personal knowledge about the report. I cannot give a definite analysis or conclusion.

1418
06:29:29,550 --> 06:29:31,210
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: You cannot give indefinite analysis.

1419
06:29:31,850 --> 06:29:40,370
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: As to his methodology, as to paano po yun. So ang tinanong mo sa akin kanina, hypothetical. So I answered also on hypothetical trials. So

1420
06:29:40,370 --> 06:29:43,070
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: hypothetical yung binigay mo answer because the question was hypothetical.

1421
06:29:43,510 --> 06:29:43,870
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, sir.

1422
06:29:44,010 --> 06:29:54,090
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: So hindi ka talaga very much aware or well knowledgeable doon sa report at hand na pinakita.

1423
06:29:54,250 --> 06:29:56,270
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kung ano lang po yung napakita, yun lang po.

1424
06:29:56,290 --> 06:29:58,690
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Kung ano lang pinakita, agad-agad nagbigay ka ng iyong opinion.

1425
06:29:59,010 --> 06:30:17,090
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: And there is a high... As much as possible, again, I haven't read the full text. I avoid making conclusions contradicting whatever he did. So kung ano po yung nandoon at ginawang hypothetical yun, again, without discounting other documents, yun lang po ang limitado.

1426
06:30:17,270 --> 06:30:18,550
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Kindly wind up, Senator Judge Raffy.

1427
06:30:18,550 --> 06:30:23,670
Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo: Maraming salamat po sa iyong pasensya, Mr. Witness. Thank you. Thank you po, Mr. Presiding Officer.

1428
06:30:23,950 --> 06:30:28,390
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you, Senator Judge Raffy. Senator Judge Kiko is recognized. You may proceed, sir. You have two minutes when you're ready.

1429
06:30:33,070 --> 06:30:35,130
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Magandang hapon, Mr. Witness.

1430
06:30:35,450 --> 06:30:36,170
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Good afternoon, Your Honor.

1431
06:30:36,490 --> 06:30:41,620
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Kanina nabanggit mo na wala kang political affiliation. Tama?

1432
06:30:42,620 --> 06:30:43,440
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: None, Your Honor.

1433
06:30:43,580 --> 06:30:49,140
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: In fact, sabi mo the last time hindi ka bumoto nga since 2019. Tama?

1434
06:30:49,420 --> 06:30:54,540
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi po. Mga sirkomstansya po hindi ako pinayagang makaboto.

1435
06:30:54,840 --> 06:31:00,360
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Pero si Atty. Edward Gialogo is your law firm partner.

1436
06:31:01,100 --> 06:31:07,580
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: When I left the service, 2018 up to 2021.

1437
06:31:08,640 --> 06:31:10,400
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: So, he was your law firm partner?

1438
06:31:10,840 --> 06:31:11,420
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1439
06:31:11,620 --> 06:31:14,600
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: So, you are aware? So, ngayon hindi na?

1440
06:31:15,520 --> 06:31:19,600
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Starting 2021 po. When I started the consulting firm, hindi na po.

1441
06:31:19,800 --> 06:31:31,150
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Okay. So, are you aware na si Atty. Gialogo, a lawyer for the Duterte Youth Party List?

1442
06:31:31,790 --> 06:31:46,970
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, I have no personal knowledge but could be. Because ang naging practice ho niya, election practice, after ho naming mag-part ways, medyo hindi ho kami nag-uusap for years. Ngayon lang ho kami nag-uusap.

1443
06:31:47,130 --> 06:31:48,430
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: So hindi mo alam?

1444
06:31:48,630 --> 06:31:50,590
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi ko po alam kung ano man yung...

1445
06:31:50,590 --> 06:31:53,570
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Na naging counsel siya ng Duterte Youth.

1446
06:31:53,810 --> 06:31:56,450
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Opo. Possible po kasi ang practice talaga niya is election.

1447
06:31:56,690 --> 06:31:58,490
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Pero hindi mo nga alam. Possible lang.

1448
06:32:01,230 --> 06:32:06,770
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: May information from legal circles. How long have you known Atty. Gialogo?

1449
06:32:07,010 --> 06:32:11,410
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kami po ay magkaibigan from law school days pa sa San Beda College.

1450
06:32:12,410 --> 06:32:24,500
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: May information from legal circles and pati na rin sa Facebook na si Atty. Gialogo supported the campaign of the previous president. Are you aware?

1451
06:32:25,380 --> 06:32:29,000
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, after 2021, Your Honor, wala na kaming communication.

1452
06:32:30,000 --> 06:32:41,020
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Yes, pero we're talking about 2016. 2016. Sabi niyo matagal na kayong magkakilala. So hindi mo alam kung sinuportahan niya?

1453
06:32:41,180 --> 06:32:45,040
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, your honor. It's his personal matters na po.

1454
06:32:47,280 --> 06:32:55,740
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Curious. Sabi mo 2019 hindi ka bumoto. Since 2019. Sino binoto mo noong 2016 sa presidential election?

1455
06:32:57,270 --> 06:32:58,930
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2016. I

1456
06:32:58,930 --> 06:32:59,670
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: mean, you're under oath.

1457
06:33:02,510 --> 06:33:03,070
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2016.

1458
06:33:06,140 --> 06:33:07,280
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Nakaboto pa ba ako noon?

1459
06:33:07,440 --> 06:33:08,200
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Presidential election.

1460
06:33:08,700 --> 06:33:10,940
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I'm just recalling your honor if I voted.

1461
06:33:12,540 --> 06:33:14,640
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Okay. So you cannot recall?

1462
06:33:17,250 --> 06:33:18,270
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Long time ago.

1463
06:33:18,790 --> 06:33:26,450
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: It's okay. Kung hindi mo alam, hindi mo alam. Okay. I'll go to another point.

1464
06:33:30,170 --> 06:33:44,580
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Sabi niyo na kanina nung tinatanong ka sa direct examination, sabi mo, mahirap. Pero kaya gumawa ng forensic report sa loob ng two weeks. You said that, no?

1465
06:33:44,720 --> 06:33:45,120
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, po.

1466
06:33:45,640 --> 06:33:53,460
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Okay, so two weeks na pag-aaral o pagbabuo ng forensic report, mahirap pero kaya. Pero dalawang linggo, tama?

1467
06:33:54,170 --> 06:33:54,850
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, sir.

1468
06:33:54,970 --> 06:34:00,090
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Okay. Pero kanina rin sinabi mo, nakita mo ka agad, alam mo na.

1469
06:34:01,900 --> 06:34:11,460
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: So, parang... Mahirap gumawa ng forensic report, pero pagka nakita mo yung portion ng forensic report, agad-agad alam mo na. Tama?

1470
06:34:12,560 --> 06:34:20,940
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kanina po, may mga tanong lang na hypothetical. It's not about the full report po.

1471
06:34:21,550 --> 06:34:25,110
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Yes. And therefore, pag hypothetical, kaya mong sagutin.

1472
06:34:25,290 --> 06:34:27,290
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kasi po, themed lang. Limited ang scope.

1473
06:34:27,290 --> 06:34:48,310
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: So what is the probative value of your testimony if you answer hypothetically? In an impeachment trial wherein we look at the evidence and we determine the law necessary or applicable based on the evidence. What is the probative value of your testimony?

1474
06:34:48,810 --> 06:34:56,730
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I was called upon, Your Honor, to testify on AML standards, how financial investigation is usually conducted. So dun lang po.

1475
06:34:56,950 --> 06:35:13,710
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Okay. You also said in your commentary kanina na... You are able to provide legal opinion or you can analyze whether or not an act is within the bounds of the law. Tama? Sabi mo kanina?

1476
06:35:14,190 --> 06:35:16,410
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, I just rely po on the law.

1477
06:35:17,030 --> 06:35:21,690
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: But how will you know if it is within the bounds of the law if you don't know the facts?

1478
06:35:27,890 --> 06:35:30,290
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, the question, Your Honor?

1479
06:35:30,290 --> 06:35:30,630
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Yes.

1480
06:35:30,790 --> 06:35:37,090
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, the question propounded ay limited lang po doon sa mga hypothetical questions.

1481
06:35:37,090 --> 06:36:16,580
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: I hope you understand, ikaw eh nag law school, pareho tayo nag law school, sanay tayo sa recitation, hindi ba? Di ba pag nagre-recite tayo, kailangan we apply the law based on the facts, hindi ba? Pag sinabi ng ating professor, tinawag tayo sa recitation at sinabi sa atin, what is the law, recite the case of people versus etc. Pwede mo bang sabihin dun sa professor? Professor, hindi ko po nabasa yung case, yung decision, pero I can give my comments. Pagdaganon, anong grade mo?

1482
06:36:18,390 --> 06:36:19,130
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Bagsak po.

1483
06:36:19,250 --> 06:36:33,710
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Well, again, in fairness to the witness, he's admitted that his manifestations are all hypothetical. And therefore, we should be guided accordingly. No other questions?

1484
06:36:34,520 --> 06:36:36,640
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you. Senator Judge Erwin Tulfo is recognized.

1485
06:36:43,480 --> 06:36:47,140
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Ah, palit talaga. Senator Riza is recognized then.

1486
06:36:50,370 --> 06:36:51,910
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You may proceed, ma'am. You have two minutes.

1487
06:37:01,480 --> 06:37:05,940
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Salamat, Mr. Presiding Officer. At magandang hapon muli, Atty. Dela Fuente. Good

1488
06:37:05,940 --> 06:37:07,520
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: afternoon, ma'am. Good afternoon, sir.

1489
06:37:08,920 --> 06:37:12,740
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Napanggit niyo po kanina na consultant kayo ng CESA.

1490
06:37:14,450 --> 06:37:24,140
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Nakatawag pansin yun po sa akin dahil marami po nagsasabi na... Doon sa CESA, unang ipinanganak ang POGO.

1491
06:37:26,190 --> 06:37:30,710
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Tapos trainer din po kayo sa PAGCOR para sa casino sector.

1492
06:37:33,580 --> 06:37:52,670
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Regulatory compliance po ang expertise nyo. So tama po ba na ibig sabihin tinuturuan nyo po yung mga kumpanya ang mga dapat nilang gawin para makaiwas sa investigasyon at makaiwas din sa liability. Tama po ba yun?

1493
06:37:52,910 --> 06:38:16,920
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi. Mag-cooperate with the investigation. At yun po ang natin. These are law-abiding entities. We only deal with registered covered persons po. Kasi sila na din po ang mga ngailangan ng ganitong suporta. So, again, hindi para makaligtas sa investigation. Mag-comply if there is an investigation.

1494
06:38:19,690 --> 06:38:21,590
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Be aware of their AML obligations.

1495
06:38:22,580 --> 06:38:53,820
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Sige po, pag-usapan natin ng konti pa itong mga registered covered persons, itong mga law-abiding entities. At any point po ba, nagkaroon po ba kayo ng kliyente na gambling firms? o POGO. Hindi nyo po kailangan banggitin kung sino po ah, kung nagkaroon. Para lang mas malinawan po tayo in relation sa inyong work experience. Nagkaroon po ba ng POGO or online gambling firms na mga kliyente? Sa

1496
06:38:53,820 --> 06:39:06,220
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: PAGCORP po, yes po. Yung mga covered persons po nila because may AML requirements po sila. So, training kasama po yun at saka paggawa po ng mga manuals, risk assessment.

1497
06:39:07,610 --> 06:39:12,510
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Okay. So sa PAGCOR, nagkaroon po kayo ng POGO na kliyente?

1498
06:39:13,640 --> 06:39:15,460
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: During those times, yes, Your Honor.

1499
06:39:15,540 --> 06:39:22,980
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: And nagkaroon din ba kayo sa PAGCOR ng gambling firms na kliyente? Online gambling firms na kliyente?

1500
06:39:23,700 --> 06:39:26,940
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: If they are covered by AMS, yes, Your Honor.

1501
06:39:31,100 --> 06:39:43,060
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Sabi niyo rin po kanina, ang AMLAC lamang ang pwedeng mag-imbestiga ng money laundering. Pero tama po ba na sa ngayon, hindi na po kayo parte ng AMLAC?

1502
06:39:43,260 --> 06:39:43,760
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor.

1503
06:39:45,020 --> 06:39:56,720
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: And then, so, ibig sabihin, hindi nyo na po masasabi ngayon kung nagkaroon o hindi nagkaroon ng mga krimen sa kasong pinag-uusapan dito?

1504
06:39:56,940 --> 06:39:58,600
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor. I am in the private sector.

1505
06:39:58,920 --> 06:40:01,020
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Yes, nasa private sector na po kayo.

1506
06:40:03,840 --> 06:40:20,840
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Alam nyo po ba kung meron na pong naibigay na lehitimong paliwanag ang Cale88 dun sa mga covered transaction reports at suspicious transaction reports na ipinadala sa AMLOC. Would you know?

1507
06:40:21,100 --> 06:40:22,100
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Know, Your Honor.

1508
06:40:23,970 --> 06:40:56,620
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Pero, sige, medyo may pagka-hypothetical din. Pero, kumpara sa ibang kumpanya na medyo parehong size ng Cale88. Masasabi niyo po bang unusual itong total of wrapping up Mr. Presiding Officer? Masasabi niyo po bang unusual itong total of 757 CTRs at STRs na may halagang 1,254,736,297 pesos and 8 centavos?

1509
06:40:56,820 --> 06:40:58,880
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kung ito po ay suspicious or unusual?

1510
06:40:59,220 --> 06:41:08,930
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Kung unusual po ba yung ganyang karaming 757 na CTRs? CTRs at STRs total. Sa kasing laking kumpanya tulad ng Cale88.

1511
06:41:09,410 --> 06:41:27,970
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, ang makakapag-determine po niya ay ang AML sila kung ito ay suspicious. Again, pag sinabi ko kasing suspicious, it doesn't mean that directly merong unlawful activity agad. This is still subject to further checking or further validation. It invites scrutiny.

1512
06:41:28,950 --> 06:41:50,970
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Pero kumpara dun sa... Walumpu o siyam na pong kasong hinawakan nyo dati nung panahon nyo sa AMLOC. I'm sure meron din kasing laki na kumpanya tulad sa Cale88. Usual po ba na more than 700 plus yung CTRs at STRs? Or usually mas kaunti sa kasing laking kumpanya tulad ng Cale88?

1513
06:41:50,970 --> 06:41:54,310
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Nakakita na po ako na mas marami pa. Kumpanyang mas marami pa,

1514
06:41:54,350 --> 06:41:56,070
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 'Di hamak, ang kanilang combined

1515
06:41:56,070 --> 06:41:57,630
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: CTRs and STRs.

1516
06:41:57,980 --> 06:42:02,200
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Okay. Mga ilan dun sa 80 or 90 cases yung may mas marami pa?

1517
06:42:02,480 --> 06:42:03,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Libo po. Libo po yung iba.

1518
06:42:03,600 --> 06:42:08,520
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Ah, hindi po. Dun sa 80 or 90 cases na hinawakan nyo nung panahon nyo sa AMLOC?

1519
06:42:08,560 --> 06:42:09,780
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ah, hindi ko na malaman.

1520
06:42:09,780 --> 06:42:13,980
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Ilan sa kanila may mas marami sa 700 plus CTRs at STRs?

1521
06:42:14,720 --> 06:42:21,730
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Pag mga corporations po kasi normally ganyan. Kasi... Very malikot ho ang kanilang financial transactions.

1522
06:42:22,370 --> 06:42:23,570
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Lahat nung 80 at 90 na yun?

1523
06:42:23,570 --> 06:42:25,030
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Hindi po. Not 100%.

1524
06:42:25,030 --> 06:42:27,270
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Or mga 8 or 9 nila? Or ilan?

1525
06:42:27,390 --> 06:42:30,390
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Safe po siguro. We can say 30% of that.

1526
06:42:30,810 --> 06:42:44,750
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: 30%. So, ibig sabihin, ang Cale88 ay nagkaroon ng mas maraming CTRs at STRs total ng mga 70%. At least dun sa mga kasong hinawakan nyo nung panahon nyo sa anglap.

1527
06:42:44,770 --> 06:42:50,990
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Baligtad po. May mas mga korporasyon pa pong mas marami doon sa nabanggit na numero.

1528
06:42:51,070 --> 06:42:55,570
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: So 30% ay mas konti ang number?

1529
06:42:56,790 --> 06:42:58,470
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Libo po. Iyon sinabi ko, libo.

1530
06:42:59,110 --> 06:43:04,190
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Ilan po ang may mas marami sa 700 plus? 30% o 70%?

1531
06:43:04,450 --> 06:43:07,270
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa akin pong mga nahawakan, umabot hanggang libo.

1532
06:43:08,860 --> 06:43:10,100
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Mga 30% po siguro.

1533
06:43:10,180 --> 06:43:14,880
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Kaya nga po. So 30% ang mas marami na CTRs at STRs.

1534
06:43:14,880 --> 06:43:17,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Opo, ang benchmark po natin si yung company po na yun.

1535
06:43:17,820 --> 06:43:22,240
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: So mas maraming CTRs at STRs ang Cale88 sa 70% na hinawakan.

1536
06:43:22,260 --> 06:43:26,720
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kasi kung pag korporasyon po, napakadami po talagang in and out transactions. That's normal.

1537
06:43:26,900 --> 06:43:36,440
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: And lastly po, sa official records din ng Cale88, taon-taon itong diumanong lugi, dalawa lang diumanong empleyado.

1538
06:43:36,440 --> 06:44:12,490
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: At 208 million pesos lamang di umano ang idineklarang benta. Pero ayon sa AMLAC, halos 776 million pesos ang flagged as covered or suspicious sa nagpumasok na pera at 319 million pesos dyan galing sa China. So sa mga bank account nitong ipinakita sa Korte, Wala pang 400,000 pesos ang natitira sa katapusan ng bawat taon. Lastly po, Atty. Dela Fuente, hindi po ba yan posibleng mga red flags?

1539
06:44:13,090 --> 06:44:23,490
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, these are red flags po that merit maimbestigahan po, scrutiny review. But again, red flags po are not direct evidence of wrongdoing.

1540
06:44:24,570 --> 06:44:28,330
Sen. Risa Hontiveros: Marami salamat, Atty. Dela Fuente. Salamat po, Mr. Presiding Officer. Thank

1541
06:44:28,330 --> 06:44:30,990
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: you. For the third time, Sen. Judge Erwin Tulfo.

1542
06:44:43,760 --> 06:44:46,600
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Maraming salamat po, Ginoong Presiding Officer.

1543
06:44:48,620 --> 06:44:58,810
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Mr. Witness, kanina po natanong kayo tungkol sa Constitution natin at ang inyong mga pananawhingil dito. Ano po? At sinagot nyo naman.

1544
06:45:01,010 --> 06:45:08,430
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Tutal, natanong po kayo dyan, ano po ang interpretasyon ninyo sa Article 7, Section 13 ng Constitution?

1545
06:45:12,360 --> 06:45:24,700
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Ito po yung Pangulo at Vice Presidente, hindi paaring kumuha ng ibang trabaho o mag-aari ng mga negosyo. Ano po ang interpretation niyo po dyan?

1546
06:45:25,040 --> 06:45:41,060
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, we apply verbal legis, the plain meaning of the law, Your Honor. Kung ano po ang nakasulat doon, kung may pagbabawal, yun po. But again, it's up to the impeachment court. Leave it to the wisdom of the impeachment court, how they will interpret.

1547
06:45:42,180 --> 06:45:48,760
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: No, I'm asking you as a lawyer, sir, and as an accountant, how do you interpret this?

1548
06:45:48,760 --> 06:45:52,180
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, we apply po verbally the plain meaning of the law.

1549
06:45:52,260 --> 06:45:59,940
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: So, hindi pwede po silang dalawa at kanilang mga cabinet secretaries and assistants na mag-ari ng negosyo. Tama po ba?

1550
06:46:00,120 --> 06:46:03,320
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yan po ay aking humble personal opinion.

1551
06:46:03,560 --> 06:46:35,860
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: That's your personal opinion. Very good. So, sa SEC po, hindi inamin ni VP Sara Ang negosyo niya, ito pong Cale88, o part owner siya. Sa SAL-N niya, nilagay niya po ito. So, anong dokumento po ang paniniwalaan natin kayo ho bilang investigador? Hindi mo ba tinicheck niyo rin ang SEC at saka SAL-N ng isang government official?

1552
06:46:36,480 --> 06:46:39,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct, Your Honor. If there's an ongoing investigation, lahat ho yan.

1553
06:46:40,100 --> 06:47:00,150
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Okay. I-check SEC, SALN. Kung magkaiba po, sino ang paniniwalaan niyo? Meron dito, sabi sa SEC, hindi siya bahagi ng kumpanya na yan. Pero sa SALEN po sabi niya, hindi, meron akong hold dyan sa company na yan. Sino ang paniniwalaan mo bilang investigador?

1554
06:47:00,390 --> 06:47:06,630
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Bilang investigador, dapat neutral muna ang iyong pananaw. Ihintayin mo kung saan ka dadalhin ng ebidensya.

1555
06:47:07,250 --> 06:47:07,810
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: So

1556
06:47:07,810 --> 06:47:29,670
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: you don't take sides. Para walang prejudice, walang bias. So you gather as much evidence as possible. Kaya sa ating AMLA may compulsive process. Bank inquiry. You interview the witnesses. You do on-sites. And then you prepare your report. So magtitilt ho ang report whether for or against the accused kung ano ho ang mas mabigat na ebidensya.

1557
06:47:29,970 --> 06:47:53,320
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Okay, panghuling katanungan na lamang ginaong witness. Doon po sa nabanggit ho ninyo, sa inyong pananaw, Yung interpretation po ninyo sa Article 7, Section 13, bawal po ang mga matataas na opisyal natin, ang Pangulo, Vice Presidente, Cabinet Secretaries, etc., na mag-ari o maging bahagi ng isang negosyo. Tama po?

1558
06:47:53,800 --> 06:47:54,560
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1559
06:47:54,920 --> 06:48:07,800
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Okay. So, hingin ko lang po ang inyong pananaw din at this point. Totale, natanong mo kayo ilang beses kanina at magaling po kayo sumagot. Sa tingin mo ba may nalabag na sa konstitusyon ang Vice Presidente?

1560
06:48:08,540 --> 06:48:16,620
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ito, Your Honor, is a question of law. Again, I leave it to the wisdom of the Honorable Impeachment Court to decide if meron o wala.

1561
06:48:17,440 --> 06:48:21,420
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Maraming salamat po ginoong testigo. Mr. Presiding Officer. Thank you.

1562
06:48:21,420 --> 06:48:25,380
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Senator Judge Erwin. Senator Judge Joel Villanueva is recognized. You may proceed, sir. You have two minutes.

1563
06:48:28,842 --> 06:48:36,760
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Thank you, sir, Presiding Officer. Thank you, Mr. President. Just a few questions to Attorney Rainer.

1564
06:48:38,810 --> 06:49:05,870
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Chair din po ako ng Committee on Banks dito sa Senado and we look at how MLC uses financial records to understand the purpose of a transaction. From your experience po as an AMLC investigator, when bank records show that a company paid an individual, what can you verify from the check and the bank entries and what other records would you examine to determine why the company made the payment?

1565
06:49:07,990 --> 06:49:20,450
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Number one po, ang question, is it out of the profile ng company that would merit scrutiny? Misan po kasi it is explainable, there is a contractual obligation, etc.

1566
06:49:21,350 --> 06:49:36,850
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Halimbawa po, para mas klaro, halimbawa po a company says it was returning an earlier investment, how would you verify the original contribution, the amount still owed, and whether the payment was actually applied against that balance?

1567
06:49:37,960 --> 06:49:59,660
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, number one, you check po yung kanilang SEC records. You request for certified copies ng kanilang GIS to determine the holdings. So, i-compile niyo po yan. SEC records, if there is a private contract between the company and that individual, you compile them if there is legal basis for that returned money.

1568
06:50:00,000 --> 06:50:06,920
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Pag-return po ng money, pwede po ba niyo i-differentiate sa akin return on capital versus return of capital?

1569
06:50:08,280 --> 06:50:20,370
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Return of capital, binabalik ang puhunan. Ito ay hindi considered income. Return on capital, ito ay tubo, kita.

1570
06:50:20,890 --> 06:50:37,570
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Ngayon kung ang return of capital na sinasabi niyo binalik yung puhunan, let's say 48,000 lang ang puhunan, pero ang binalik ay 2,142,000, masasabi niyo na po ba ito ngayon na return on capital?

1571
06:50:38,730 --> 06:50:43,090
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, this is, again, limited, this is hypothetical based on that.

1572
06:50:43,090 --> 06:50:45,770
Sen. Joel Villanueva: I'm trying to find out.

1573
06:50:45,990 --> 06:50:53,130
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 48 po ang capital pero ang binalik ay more than 2 .1 million.

1574
06:50:54,980 --> 06:50:57,540
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ang tanong po ay is it a return of?

1575
06:50:57,920 --> 06:51:16,690
Sen. Joel Villanueva: That's why I'm asking the difference between return of capital and return on capital because you mentioned a while ago if it is return of capital. Return of capital, it only means binabalik yung puhunan. Pero ang puhunan ay 48,000 lang. So, di ba naging return on capital na po ito?

1576
06:51:16,890 --> 06:51:26,870
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: So, ang tanong po, this can be explained. Possibly po itong nag-accrue na dividendo, hindi niya kiniklaim ang kanyang dividendo. Again, we are...

1577
06:51:26,870 --> 06:51:30,550
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Ang claim po kasi walang dividendo na nilabas.

1578
06:51:30,590 --> 06:51:33,190
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: So, it merits scrutiny po.

1579
06:51:34,730 --> 06:51:38,550
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yung aking nabigay na teorya ay isa lamang but again we have to test this.

1580
06:51:38,690 --> 06:51:57,350
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Thank you. And just to be more, to be clarified on this, if payments continue after the recorded capital balance has been fully paid or fully repaid, what records would you look for to determine the basis for the later payments if it is return of capital?

1581
06:51:57,810 --> 06:52:13,310
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Now, based on that hypothetical scenario, Your Honor, I will check if this is a sort of compensation. Compensation po. Baka sweldo po ito. Hindi na in the capacity of a shareholder but capacity of an employee or officer. Isa po yan.

1582
06:52:13,410 --> 06:52:14,930
Sen. Joel Villanueva: And it becomes an income?

1583
06:52:16,840 --> 06:52:25,880
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Yeah. Thank you for that. Attorney, gusto kong tanungin itong... So

1584
06:52:33,270 --> 06:53:05,380
Sen. Joel Villanueva: suppose a company explains that credits to its bank accounts came from... It's regular export business. From an investigator standpoint, paano po ninyo biniverify yun? And what would you compare in the bank records and the company's records, company's books, para po ma-establish who made the payment, which sale or shipment it covered, and whether the company had already recorded the sale before the money came in?

1585
06:53:05,620 --> 06:53:27,920
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Number one, sir, yung invoices. Suppliers' invoices, contractual agreements, bill of lading, warehouse receipts. So that would verify if there's really an economic transaction that transpired. So ito kasi ay dokumentong pang-komersyo. So ito ay dokumentado.

1586
06:53:28,630 --> 06:54:00,820
Sen. Joel Villanueva: At kung yung kumpanya po nag-presenta ng BOI or FDA registrations and evidence of participation in trade fairs, What further records would you look for to connect a particular remittance to an actual sale? Kasi nga po diba sabi ng Section 3 B.1.1 concerns the purpose of or economic justification of the particular transaction. I'm sure you are very much aware of that.

1587
06:54:01,360 --> 06:54:07,440
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. So normally yung kontrata po behind the transaction should be intact.

1588
06:54:09,380 --> 06:54:18,420
Sen. Joel Villanueva: At para humalaman kung bayad po talaga, for example, sa export sale, aling shipment at aling invoice ang tinutukoy.

1589
06:54:18,540 --> 06:54:19,180
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes po.

1590
06:54:19,240 --> 06:54:19,860
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Tama po ba?

1591
06:54:19,960 --> 06:54:30,020
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: It can be verified. Lalo na kung ito ay may export or import, meron hong record yan ng ating gobyerno for the goods that really went in and out.

1592
06:54:30,280 --> 06:54:35,140
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Sige po. Salamat, Mr. Witness. I'll just do the round two, Mr. President. Thank you.

1593
06:54:35,460 --> 06:54:40,180
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: The Senate President is recognized. You have two minutes, sir. You may proceed when you're ready. Thank you,

1594
06:54:40,220 --> 06:54:42,900
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Mr. Presiding Officer. Good afternoon, Atty. De La Fuente.

1595
06:54:43,180 --> 06:54:44,340
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Good afternoon, Your Honor.

1596
06:54:44,500 --> 06:54:48,480
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Dahil kayo ay expert witness sa AMLOC, I'll focus on AMLOC.

1597
06:54:50,080 --> 06:55:31,850
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Tinitignan ko itong report ng AMLOC na sinamit dito sa impeachment. At between 2009, ito yung mga transactions ni VP Sara. So nagsubmit sila sa amin per year yung volume at yung value ng transactions from 2007 all the way to 2025. So nakita ko dito from 2009 to 2013, 2.7 billion pesos ang naging transaction out of the 3.9 billion pesos.

1598
06:55:34,380 --> 06:56:01,720
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Just a few years. 2009, 700 million. 2010, 648 million. 2011, 597 million. Ngayon, pinasubmit rin sa amin yung taxable income or net taxable income net of tax ng BIR. At lumalabas sa 2009, 600,000. 2010, 700,000. 2011.

1599
06:56:03,330 --> 06:56:17,840
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: 1 million. So malayong malayo. Malayong malayo. So ganitong mga data na sinabit sa amin, hindi ko inimbento ito, sinabit ito sa amin. Ano ang analysis nyo dito?

1600
06:56:18,480 --> 06:56:55,350
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, yan po ay, it would merit further investigation, Your Honor. Iyan po mag-trigger ng other compulsory processes like freeze order, bank inquiry. So that we can dig into the details. Makita sa statement of accounts the actual deposit slips, withdrawal slips. Yung conclusion natin ay magkakaroon tayo ng conclusion if we get those documents. We gather those documents. As much as possible, no conclusion is being made. We only make the conclusions after exhausting all the legal remedies.

1601
06:56:56,100 --> 06:57:03,200
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: So in other words, based on your experience, kailangan ito further investigation and application of a freeze order kaagad?

1602
06:57:04,040 --> 06:57:06,920
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yan po sa normal case and bank inquiry.

1603
06:57:08,020 --> 06:57:27,600
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Okay. And base sa sinabi nyo, ito bang mga ganito ay tingin nyo highly unusual, malaking red flag? Ano ang personal assessment nyo dito sa ganitong data?

1604
06:57:28,420 --> 06:57:37,370
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Again, sinubmit ito sa amin. Hindi ko inimbento ito. So based on your analysis, how can you describe these differences?

1605
06:57:37,890 --> 06:58:15,890
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ang nagde-determine, Your Honor, kung yan ay suspicious or irregular ay yung mga covered persons po natin. Ibabato nila yan sa AMLC for further checking. Si AMLC naman, sila po kasi nakakakita. They can scan. Other STRs, CTRs submitted by other covered persons. So sila ho yung magdidikit-dikit, bubuuin ho nila yung puzzle and check if they can make a picture out of it. Doon naman ho malalaman kung meron talagang, it merits further investigation or kung wala naman, move on to other cases.

1606
06:58:15,890 --> 06:58:36,280
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Ano pa bang kailangan dokumentong hingin? Dahil meron ng, from the BIR, net, income net of tax. What else ang kailangan pa? Dahil may income side ka na, andun na lahat yun. Compensation income, business income. So ano pa bang information ang kailangan para for the investigation?

1607
06:58:36,720 --> 06:58:41,100
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I think, Your Honor, the bank records. The source documents.

1608
06:58:43,150 --> 06:59:06,570
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Dun yung malalaman, sino ang pinuntahan, kaninong nagpunta ang pera, ano ang transaction codes. Kasi ang CTRs and STRs, these are just snapshots. Hindi nyo nakikita talaga yung in-between na mga nangyayari. So makikita nyo yan, if you dig deeper, makita nyo yan sa bank inquiry. Doon nyo makikita ngayon ang buong picture. Mabubuo na ang kwento.

1609
06:59:07,390 --> 06:59:15,990
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Base rin sa mga bank information, meron rin mga amounts outside of SAL-N.

1610
06:59:17,880 --> 06:59:40,820
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Ang aking focus dito kasi yung source which is yung income. Diyan naman manggagaling yung source. So base, again, nababalik ako dito, my last question is, base dito sa mga information na binigay sa amin ng AMLAC and BIR, do you think itong discrepancy is an impeachable offense?

1611
06:59:42,800 --> 06:59:52,880
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: That, Your Honor, is a question of law and I would defer again to the Honorable Impeachment Court if it is or if it is not an impeachable offense.

1612
06:59:53,260 --> 06:59:54,820
Sen. Sherwin T. Gatchalian: Thank you, Mr. Presiding Officer.

1613
06:59:57,580 --> 06:59:59,560
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Senator Judge Marcos is recognized.

1614
07:00:03,820 --> 07:00:39,750
Sen. Imee Marcos: Yes, maraming salamat, presiding judge. Pagod na yung witness natin, konting tanong na lang. Okay, so unang-una, what is the evidentiary value of AMLOC reports? Ano ba yung timbang nito? Ano ba yung bigat nito? Yung financial intelligence report tungkol kay VP Sara, talagang ginagamit natin, sabi mo kanina, analytical ang ginamit, analytical judgment. At bahagi pa lamang ito ng case build-up at fact-finding. So hindi pa ito yung kompleto. Tama po ba?

1615
07:00:39,890 --> 07:00:55,400
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. Under our law, yung susunod hung steps to, yung section 10, 11, and 12, please order bank inquiry. Yun ho yung mas mabusisi na talaga. Evidence gathering and there is a compulsory process. Kaya ho dadaan ito sa Korte.

1616
07:00:55,540 --> 07:01:05,100
Sen. Imee Marcos: Sorry. Kapag financial intel report pa lamang, hindi pa ito ebidensya, kumbaga? Hindi pa napreba ito? Wala pa siyang bigat, kumbaga?

1617
07:01:05,710 --> 07:01:12,750
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: May bigat na po ito but hindi pa siya yung ebidensya. Ito ay clues pa lang. Ituturo ho tayo sa ebidensya.

1618
07:01:12,830 --> 07:01:38,330
Sen. Imee Marcos: Tama. Kasi may direksyon na siyang sinasabi. It expressly advises the recipients to verify information and states that its analytical judgment may be based on only incomplete or fragmentary information. At bilang abogado, would you agree na yung mga media, news articles, mga report na lumalabas sa dyaryo ay hearsay lamang?

1619
07:01:40,130 --> 07:01:47,590
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: It's second-hand information, Your Honor. Kaya dapat maingat din sila sa paglalabas ng information.

1620
07:01:47,730 --> 07:01:51,110
Sen. Imee Marcos: Maingat yung amla, o yung nagbabasa, o yung dyaryo?

1621
07:01:51,150 --> 07:01:52,010
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yung dyaryo po.

1622
07:01:53,490 --> 07:02:43,520
Sen. Imee Marcos: Tama. Maraming palsipikadong report ngayon. Uso yun. Isa pa, napansin ko at nabanggit kanina yung tungkol sa dalawang insurance company na STR na flinag ng AMLA bilang suspicious transaction. Yung isa, July 2019. Yung isa naman, November 2019. Ngayon, ang dahilan na binibigay na flinag ito bilang suspicious ay dahil lumabas daw sa media na naman na ang mga individual at korporasyon may kinalaman sa flood control investigation sa DPWH. Kaya nagkaroon ng suspicious transaction report. Ngayon, pinagtatakahan ko, 2019 to, kailan ba yung flood control issue? Meron na bang flood control noon? Sa pagkaalam mo, wala pa yan.

1623
07:02:44,600 --> 07:02:48,140
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ang pagkaalam

1624
07:02:48,140 --> 07:03:22,300
Sen. Imee Marcos: ko, hindi ba lumabas lang yan sa zona noong nakaraang taon? So bago-bago pa lang siya. At isa pa, ang tinatanong ko, kung sakasakali lumitaw yung issue ng flood control ng 2025, alimbawa, tapos 2019 ang tinutukoy, meron bang retroactive flagging? May ganun ba? Legal nung panahon na nangyari, baka tapos five years down the line, pinagbawal na. Pwede pong sabihin na suspicious yung nangyari five years ago?

1625
07:03:22,880 --> 07:03:38,020
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Posible, Your Honor. During that time, kasi clueless pa ang ating mga bangko. Wala pa silang kaalaman. From the time they learn of this information, they can backtrack. They can check the records.

1626
07:03:38,910 --> 07:03:44,410
Sen. Imee Marcos: So, it can keep going back? Hanggang 10 years, 15 years, 20 years? Pwede bang ganon?

1627
07:03:44,950 --> 07:03:50,190
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Normally po ang retention, well, yes, yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor.

1628
07:03:50,250 --> 07:03:54,110
Sen. Imee Marcos: So, mayroon retroactive flagging. So, pwede ganon?

1629
07:03:54,230 --> 07:03:59,790
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes po. At dahil ito po ay red flags lang, this is subject to further checking, further scrutiny.

1630
07:04:00,570 --> 07:04:22,530
Sen. Imee Marcos: E paano kung bibili ka ng insurance ngayon na hindi naman na illegal, lihiti mo, pagkatapos five years down the line, sasabihin na bawal na to, hindi ba unfair na sabihin bigla na suspicious transaction yung ginawa mo? Na legal naman sa pagkaalam mo at sa pagkaalam ng lahat, at nasa batas naman at sa regulasyon na wala namang pinagbabawal, biglang magiging illegitimate.

1631
07:04:23,230 --> 07:04:40,770
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Okay lang po yun. Hindi ho siya magmimerit ng agad freezing. Again, suspicious from the word itself. Hindi ho siya criminal transaction report. So, it will only activate checking, verification. Pag sinek at muka naman na... At na-verify, okay na po yun.

1632
07:04:40,850 --> 07:04:41,550
Sen. Imee Marcos: Okay na yan.

1633
07:04:42,750 --> 07:04:49,930
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kahit retroactive. Yes po, hindi na ho siya magpo-proceed sa ibang mga proseso. Freeze order, bank inquiry for future.

1634
07:04:50,360 --> 07:05:20,060
Sen. Imee Marcos: Isang huling tanong na lang. May in-identify na 4.4 billion labas-pasok sa iba't ibang mga account. Yung aggregate amount, yung suma total nun lahat, pwede bang sabihin na income or accumulated wealth ng tao na may-ari nung account? Yung labas-pasok kahit repeated rollover ng iba't-ibang amount, tapos ito-total mo, yun na ba talaga yung pag-aari at kayamanan nilang buo?

1635
07:05:20,260 --> 07:05:24,540
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Malalaman po ito, Your Honor, sa full financial investigation.

1636
07:05:24,840 --> 07:05:29,320
Sen. Imee Marcos: Kung nagkaroon ng double counting or at saka yung inflow at outflow.

1637
07:05:30,170 --> 07:05:33,490
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Doon na po malalaman yan sa full financial investigation. Pero

1638
07:05:33,490 --> 07:05:39,050
Sen. Imee Marcos: hindi mo pwedeng isumatotal lamang yung lahat ng pumasok, lahat ng lumabas.

1639
07:05:39,070 --> 07:05:39,730
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Correct your honor.

1640
07:05:40,290 --> 07:05:40,810
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Okay,

1641
07:05:40,950 --> 07:05:43,470
Sen. Imee Marcos: those are all my questions. Maraming salamat, attorney.

1642
07:05:43,810 --> 07:05:48,210
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you, Senator Judge Jaime. Senator Judge Villanueva is recognized. You have two minutes, sir. You may proceed when you're ready.

1643
07:05:55,070 --> 07:05:57,030
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Thank you, Sir Presiding Officer.

1644
07:06:01,290 --> 07:06:29,120
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Attorney, Mr. Witness, kanina po binanggit natin kung walang dividends hindi pasok doon sa kumpanya na nagbibigay ng nabanggit niyo po kanina, maaari itong compensation. Pero anong masasabi niyo? Kasi kung compensation, wala nga pong empleyado actually. In fact, 23 and 24, dalawa po yung employees. Anong masasabi niyo dito? Pwede pa rin bang compensation yun o hindi na pwedeng tawaging compensation?

1645
07:06:30,000 --> 07:06:32,860
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again, ito po ay theoretical lang po, no? Based on that hypothetical.

1646
07:06:33,200 --> 07:06:50,750
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Hindi po. Lahat po nung tinanong ko sa inyo, nangyari po yun. At in fact, binanggit nyo nga po na ito'y papasok na dun sa income. Gusto ko lang malaman dun sa binanggit nyo na ba ari itong compensation. Eh kung compensation, eh wala naman po empleyado. Pwede ho bang gamitin yun as compensation?

1647
07:06:51,630 --> 07:06:54,490
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Pwede ho ang may-ari mismo ang nag-aakas empleyado.

1648
07:06:54,950 --> 07:06:56,510
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Ah kung may-ari po siya?

1649
07:06:56,840 --> 07:07:00,240
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Kung may-ari. Opo. Kasi sila ang nag-work.

1650
07:07:00,340 --> 07:07:30,230
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Lalo na kung yan po ay bagong kumpanya lang. Attorney, base po dun sa dokumentong na isumiti dito sa Korte, nakatanggap po kasi itong... Kale88 ng malalaking halaga ng salapi mula po sa iba't ibang bansa. Kabilang na China, Russia, Ukraine. At sa ilalim po ng Anti-Money Laundering Act at BSP Regulations, ano po ang mga obligasyon ng bangko para tiyakin na legitimate ito at ang mga transaksyong ito ay tugma din dun sa aktwal at nakadiklarang negosyo ng kumpanya?

1651
07:07:30,490 --> 07:08:10,030
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Number one, Your Honor, they have to ask, yung mga bangko natin, what's the purpose for those transactions? Number two, if it will originate from a high-risk jurisdiction, they have to report it. Yan po yung mga triggers. What's the legitimate business purpose? Tapos ititingnan nila, iscreen nila, saan ba ang pinanggalingan ng pera that would merit reporting. Yan po ipapasok sa client and transaction monitoring system ng ating mga bangko. Part of their KYC. Know your client and customer due diligence, CDD.

1652
07:08:10,210 --> 07:09:05,790
Sen. Joel Villanueva: High risk at purpose. Doon po sa forensic report na sinubmitibo dito sa Korte, may approximately 222.62 million pesos. foreign remittances ang Cale88 mula po 2023 to 2025. Ang gusto po natin kasing malinawan eh kung anong verification ang dapat gawin ng mga bangko para matukoy po na consistent ang remittance sa declared business activities ng isang kumpanya. In fact, yung legal basis and I'm sure you know about this section 9 letter A ng RA 9160. Sabi po doon, it provides that covered persons shall establish and record the true identity of their clients. Ang tanong ko po, if a company claims that these are export payments, is that declaration sufficient or should additional verification be required depending on the risks identified and why?

1653
07:09:06,150 --> 07:09:06,890
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Again,

1654
07:09:07,010 --> 07:09:08,010
Sen. Joel Villanueva: self-serving

1655
07:09:08,010 --> 07:09:26,300
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: po yung verbal declarations. Normally po, it is backed by documents. Kung ganun kalalaki ang pera, Ito po ay dapat may dokumento, may paper trail. So, normally po, kontrata to support the remittance in or out of the bank.

1656
07:09:26,760 --> 07:10:12,430
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Maraming pong salamat. Last na po, Atty. Dela Puente. Noong din pong hearing natin dito, October 9, nabanggit po na ang Artmen LLC, isa pong kumpanya sa Ukraine na nagpapadala po ng salapi sa KL88. ay naiugnay umano sa isang investigasyon sa ibang bansa tungkol po sa panluloko at money laundering. Sa ilalim po ng mga regulasyon ng AMLC, kapag may ganito pong informasyon, kayo po yung isang eksperto dito tungkol sa isang foreign company na nagpapadala ng salapik, ano po ang karagdagang pagsusuri at karagdagang pagbabantay na dapat gawin ng mga bangko po na tumatanggap ng remittance?

1657
07:10:12,860 --> 07:10:16,520
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, number one po, private obligation for them is to report it as suspicious.

1658
07:10:18,880 --> 07:10:52,820
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yun po ang isang immediate obligation ng mga bangko. Number two, ask the client for justifications regarding the transaction. So, depende na po yan sa internal policy ng mga bangko if they will accept the explanation or not. Kasi may mga covered persons po tayo na hindi nila ina-accept, nagkakaroon po ng de-risking, kinuklose nila yung account. Kapag hindi na nila, they can no longer accommodate the risk with that particular client.

1659
07:10:53,060 --> 07:11:09,970
Sen. Joel Villanueva: At kahit po wala pang final conviction, can credible information concerning a foreign criminal... Investigation. Justify enhanced due diligence or suspicious transaction reporting.

1660
07:11:10,470 --> 07:11:12,950
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. So, it invites scrutiny.

1661
07:11:13,530 --> 07:11:14,470
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Para po?

1662
07:11:14,770 --> 07:11:34,330
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Enhanced due diligence, ibig sabihin, mas maraming dokumentong hihingin, more paperwork. They could delay the transaction, subject to verification. Yun po yung ginagawa natin sa EDD. Bago mag-transact, maraming kailangang senior management approval. Ito po yung mga safeguards na meron ang ating mga bangko bago nila payagamot.

1663
07:11:34,330 --> 07:11:52,210
Sen. Joel Villanueva: When you talk about safeguards, ang legal basis po nito, yung Section 3, B1, 5, and 6 ng AMLA law that provides the transactions deviating from the client's profile for past transactions or related to unlawful activities may be considered suspicious transactions. Is that correct?

1664
07:11:52,210 --> 07:12:01,530
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor. So doon po natatapos ngayon ang obligasyon ng covered person sa STR. Ang bola po naman ngayon ay napapasa na sa AMLAC. para mag-investiga.

1665
07:12:01,770 --> 07:12:04,830
Sen. Joel Villanueva: Okay. Maraming salamat po for that clarification. Thank you, Mr. Vice President.

1666
07:12:04,830 --> 07:12:06,030
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Senator Judge Kiko, finally.

1667
07:12:07,990 --> 07:12:09,750
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You have two minutes, sir. You may proceed when you're ready.

1668
07:12:15,200 --> 07:12:33,080
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Thank you. Ang gandang hapon ulit, attorney. I just want to go back dun sa legal position mo na you cannot divulge information to this impeachment court because you're not an end user. Is that right?

1669
07:12:35,160 --> 07:12:36,740
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I cannot access, Your Honor.

1670
07:12:37,170 --> 07:12:47,080
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Yes, you cannot access. And therefore, because you cannot access, therefore, you cannot divulge. So you are not an end user?

1671
07:12:48,310 --> 07:12:49,050
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1672
07:12:49,310 --> 07:12:51,870
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Even as you testify before this impeachment court?

1673
07:12:52,230 --> 07:12:52,990
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1674
07:12:53,230 --> 07:12:54,010
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Why is that?

1675
07:12:54,560 --> 07:13:00,580
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I was not the addressee of the... We were talking about the investigation report, Your Honor, here, no?

1676
07:13:00,840 --> 07:13:04,400
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: No, we're talking about the AMLA report. Yes,

1677
07:13:04,440 --> 07:13:08,600
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Your Honor. I'm not the intended end user. It is the honorable impeachment court.

1678
07:13:08,800 --> 07:13:13,760
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: And how do we become the end user if not through witnesses like

1679
07:13:16,990 --> 07:13:17,310
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: yourself?

1680
07:13:20,960 --> 07:13:28,240
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Well, it is directly directed po sa ating impeachment court. Witnesses are not part of those.

1681
07:13:29,240 --> 07:13:40,380
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: So how will you prove a case of anti-money laundering or money laundering if you cannot produce witnesses who will divulge information before the Sandigan Bayan? Or in this case the impeachment...

1682
07:13:40,430 --> 07:13:49,880
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: AMLC, your honor, is the proper agency to process the information, not any other person.

1683
07:13:49,880 --> 07:13:55,000
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: So you're saying that this impeachment court violated the law? Is that what you're saying?

1684
07:13:55,160 --> 07:14:02,400
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: No, your honor. What I'm saying is that you can ask assistance from the AMLC in doing the financial investigation.

1685
07:14:02,640 --> 07:14:17,510
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Yes, but the forensic expert accessed the information. Impeachment Court allowed it. So you're saying that the impeachment court, in your opinion, committed a violation of the anti-money laundering law?

1686
07:14:17,750 --> 07:14:24,350
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: No, your honor. The premise you allowed it, then it is already permitted.

1687
07:14:24,750 --> 07:14:45,160
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: So if we compel you to review, I mean hypothetically, since you like to review the report, the forensic report, and ask you to come back and testify as to What you know about the forensic report, then that would be legal.

1688
07:14:46,190 --> 07:14:59,810
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: If it's the order of the impeachment court, that would be legal. But again, under the law, kasi si AMLC lang ang sole agency that should be doing that job.

1689
07:15:00,110 --> 07:15:11,320
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Well, with respect to unauthorized disclosures, but the AMLC... are allowed to provide, is allowed to provide information on authorized disclosures.

1690
07:15:11,360 --> 07:15:11,860
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1691
07:15:12,000 --> 07:15:22,630
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Okay. So, no, and therefore, impeachment court, when it commands or it subpoenas or it compels, that is an authorized disclosure.

1692
07:15:23,030 --> 07:15:23,550
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes, Your Honor.

1693
07:15:23,730 --> 07:15:26,950
Sen. Francis “Kiko” Pangilinan: Okay, no other questions. Thank you. Thank you for that clarification, Attorney.

1694
07:15:27,410 --> 07:15:29,210
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you. No other.

1695
07:15:33,840 --> 07:15:39,940
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Senator Judge Erwin, my mistake that Senator Kiko was the last. What's your pleasure, Senator Judge Erwin?

1696
07:15:40,120 --> 07:15:42,080
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Just a clarificatory question, uh,

1697
07:15:43,590 --> 07:15:53,560
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: uh, presiding officer, sir. Uh, you know, testigo, kailan po kayo nagumpisa magtrabaho sa gobyerno? At anong ahensya po ito?

1698
07:15:53,660 --> 07:15:56,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2009, Your Honor, BIR. BIR.

1699
07:15:56,720 --> 07:15:58,560
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Kailan po kayo mali sa BIR?

1700
07:15:58,740 --> 07:15:59,960
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2010, Your Honor, October.

1701
07:16:00,020 --> 07:16:03,540
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: 2010. Ano po sinulod na pinasukan ninyong ahensya?

1702
07:16:05,140 --> 07:16:11,680
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Uh... Nag-private po muna ako, punong bayan ni Roland, then Governance Commission for GOCCs noong 2012.

1703
07:16:15,140 --> 07:16:15,700
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2012.

1704
07:16:16,700 --> 07:16:18,680
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Hanggang kailan po kayo doon sa GOCCs?

1705
07:16:18,680 --> 07:16:19,520
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2014, Your Honor.

1706
07:16:19,700 --> 07:16:22,560
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: 2014. Afternoon po, saan po kayo?

1707
07:16:22,660 --> 07:16:24,000
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa Commission on Elections po.

1708
07:16:24,160 --> 07:16:26,980
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Commission on Elections. Anong year naman po kayo doon?

1709
07:16:27,540 --> 07:16:32,700
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2014, before I entered AMLC po.

1710
07:16:33,180 --> 07:16:34,760
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Hanggang kailan po kayo doon?

1711
07:16:35,990 --> 07:16:39,590
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: June, around June or May, Your Honor, 2015.

1712
07:16:41,460 --> 07:16:42,700
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: 2014, 2015.

1713
07:16:42,960 --> 07:16:43,400
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Yes.

1714
07:16:44,480 --> 07:16:45,540
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: After who noon?

1715
07:16:47,050 --> 07:16:49,710
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Sa AMLC Secretariat na po, Your Honor.

1716
07:16:50,070 --> 07:16:51,590
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Hanggang kailan po kayo doon?

1717
07:16:51,630 --> 07:16:55,430
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2018, July of 2018.

1718
07:16:55,970 --> 07:17:01,930
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Alright. After that, sir, tama po ba consultancy na lang po kayo sa...

1719
07:17:03,480 --> 07:17:09,060
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Nag-low office pa po, Your Honor. This is a private general professional partnership.

1720
07:17:09,480 --> 07:17:11,580
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: And then 2021,

1721
07:17:12,300 --> 07:17:14,120
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: sarili ko na po hanggang ngayon.

1722
07:17:14,950 --> 07:17:21,390
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Pero consultant, kailan po kayo naging consultant or trainer ng AMLOC ng PAGCOR?

1723
07:17:21,670 --> 07:17:27,310
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: 2019 po sa AMLOC, PAGCOR, if I remember it right, Your Honor, 2023 or 2022.

1724
07:17:27,710 --> 07:17:29,450
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Sa CESA po, kailan?

1725
07:17:29,830 --> 07:17:34,360
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Around that same year po, 2022, 2023.

1726
07:17:35,560 --> 07:17:38,320
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Sa Aurora Pacific Economic Zone.

1727
07:17:38,580 --> 07:17:39,380
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Same year, Your Honor.

1728
07:17:39,920 --> 07:17:47,960
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Matanong ko lamang po. Bakit po parang hindi kayo tumatagal sa isang trabaho? I mean, BIR is good agency.

1729
07:17:50,160 --> 07:18:10,980
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: GOCC also. Maganda po ang sweldo roon. Commission on Election, lalo na po. Lalo ng Anti-Money Laundering Council because you have all the power. Kinakatakutan kayo. Why? Why? Why? Parang pansin ko yung pinakamatagal nyo na three years po sa isang agency. Ano po nangyari? Hindi ko kayo happy sa trabaho nyo. Anong siste?

1730
07:18:11,300 --> 07:19:12,660
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Number one, Your Honor, sa BIR, I was a working student. I'm on my fourth year. I have to choose. No? Whether I... Continue with my work or focus on my fourth year. Graduating na ako nun. Sa San Pedro kasi yung fourth year, ang mga klase umaga, hindi upang gabi. So I don't want to shortchange the government. Nauubos na ang aking leave. I have to make a decision. Kaya ako umalis kahit malabag sa aking loob. Pangalawa, sa GCG, okay naman po. Now I was offered a position within the late... Chairman Sixto Brillantes to be part of his team. So I took the chance po, after rendering sa GCG, I think, dumatating ho ang punto ng tao na sa tingin niyo tapos na ang inyong mission. So I have to move to another. And I was invited by a friend. So sumama ho ako doon. Sa kumalik ko, nag-expire na kasi ang term ni Chairman Brillantes noong 2015.

1731
07:19:15,420 --> 07:20:12,160
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: So talaga ho automat. coterminous ang aking posisyon within Chairman Brillantes. Kaya ako yung nag-apply sa AMLAC at awa naman ng Diyos, nakapasok tayo. Now, sabi ko nga kanina, short but meaningful years. Marami kasi talagang trabaho. Nagsisimula ako ng aking pamilya. I have to make time sa binubuo ko ang pamilya. Kaya ito, dream ng bawat abogado, magkaroon ng sariling opisina, makilala. Ininvite ako ng aking kaibigan, sumama ako. Maganda na nga ang compensation eh. Secured na ang aking future sa benepisyo pa lang sa BSP. Pero I still took that chance. So, dumating nga yung mga point na tama ba yung aking desisyon. Pero ito, nandito ako ngayon.

1732
07:20:14,620 --> 07:20:45,650
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Alam mo ho, Ginoong Testigo. Hindi ho, Kung kayo mag-a-apply ng trabaho, dito po ilalagay niyo sa resume. From 2009, naka-apat, limang co-agency po. Hindi mo maganda tignan sa HR po ito. Pag kayo po in-interview. Ang tatanungin mo sa iyo, tinatanong ko bakit ka umalis sa BIR, bakit ka umalis sa GOCC, COMELEC, anti-money laundering Council. Kasi hindi po parang either kayo may problema. Or hindi ho kayo marunong makisama, I don't know.

1733
07:20:45,650 --> 07:21:04,670
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Ang ganda lahat po, Your Honor, hanggang ngayon, I still maintain good relationship with my former colleagues. So, I don't burn bridges. So, yan ho, no? Naging mga personal ko na ho silang kaibigan. At yung mga dahilan nung aking pag-alis, it's beyond my control. I have to make hard choices, difficult choices.

1734
07:21:05,090 --> 07:21:07,750
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: And do you think you made the right choice by leaving AMLC?

1735
07:21:08,380 --> 07:21:23,770
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: I think... Right now, your honor, nung ako'y nagsisimula, mag-isa lang ako sa aking opisina. Hindi ko alam kung saan pupunta ang practice na to. At naniwala ho yung aking mga naging estudyante, naging kliyente. So, I think I'm on the right track. Hindi ko rin ho 'y isipin na ako'y mapupunta dito sa impeachment court.

1736
07:21:23,930 --> 07:21:28,650
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Kaya nga po, I was asking you kung did you make the right choice? Did you make the right choice?

1737
07:21:28,950 --> 07:21:30,250
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Only God knows, your honor.

1738
07:21:31,050 --> 07:21:34,410
Sen. Erwin Tulfo: Thank you. Thank you. No further questions, presiding officer.

1739
07:21:34,630 --> 07:21:38,150
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Any other senator or judge who wishes to make an introduction? There being none.

1740
07:21:40,940 --> 07:21:55,660
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Chair, we'll now excuse the witness. Atty. Raynor, maraming salamat po sa inyong panahon. Pasensya. Gayon din po sa pagsagot sa katanungan ng mga magkabilang partido, gayon din ang senator-judges. Thank you for your time and patience, sir. You are excused, sir.

1741
07:21:55,960 --> 07:21:57,740
Atty. Rainer P. Dela Fuente: Thank you, Your Honor. Thank you.

1742
07:21:58,540 --> 07:22:33,270
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Before we adjourn, the chair is in receipt of subpoenaed documents from the three witnesses of the respondent, Dr. Rodolfo, Ms. Pagayunan, and the representative of Ms. Mendoza from CITEM as earlier indicated by the Chair. Chair instructs that copies of the subpoenaed documents be furnished to the parties so that there will not be any inordinate delay tomorrow whether during direct or cross with respect to the documents that the witness may be confronted with. So ordered.

1743
07:22:34,970 --> 07:22:40,370
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: What is the pleasure of the lead counsel for the respondent, Attorney Sheila? Anything before we adjourn?

1744
07:22:40,530 --> 07:22:41,910
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Yes, Your Honor. Good afternoon.

1745
07:22:42,350 --> 07:22:42,910
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Good afternoon.

1746
07:22:43,750 --> 07:22:45,650
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Just some manifestations, Your Honor.

1747
07:22:45,770 --> 07:22:46,650
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You may proceed, ma'am.

1748
07:22:46,730 --> 07:23:21,350
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: After the entire day of hearing and receiving the testimony of our first witness for today and for this week... We have observed that the court and members of this court as well as the prosecution are interested in the proper application of Article 7, Section 13. And so, since this court may take mandatory judicial notice of Supreme Court decisions as well as decisions of the Sandigan Bayan in criminal cases acquitting the accused charging.

1749
07:23:24,020 --> 07:23:42,380
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Individuals with purported violations of this provision in relation to RA 6713 or the Code of Ethical Conduct for Public Officers and Employees. We would like to direct the attention of this Court to the following provisions of the law.

1750
07:23:44,100 --> 07:23:45,080
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: You may proceed.

1751
07:23:45,360 --> 07:23:46,220
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Yes, Your Honor.

1752
07:23:48,140 --> 07:27:14,050
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Generally, divestment and conflict of interest are defined under sections 3, paragraph I of Republic Act 6713. Divestment is defined under Section 3, paragraph K of the same law. And in relation to that, the implementing rules and regulations of Republic Act 6713 under Rule 7 provides for the contents of SAL and under Section 1, paragraph A, subparagraph. Subparagraph 1 and Section 1, Subparagraph A, Subparagraph 2 provides for a disclosure of business interests and financial connections in relation to the requirement under Section 13, Article 7 of the 1987 Constitution. Now, in relation to that also, we have Rule 9 of the Implementing Rules and Regulations of RA 6713 providing actually and explicitly providing For the elements of conflict of interest to arise and the necessity of divestment. In fact, this is provided under Section 1, Subparagraph B of Rule 9 of RA 6713, Implementing Rules and Regulations. And I will read just for the record and so that the public may also hear. Under Section 1, Subparagraph B, conflict of interest occurs When the official or employee is a substantial stockholder or a member of the board of directors or an officer of the corporation or an owner or has substantial interest in a business or a partner in a partnership and number two, the interest of such corporation or business or his rights or duties therein are opposed to or affected by the faithful performance of official duty. Now, with respect to that conflict of interest, the said implementing rules and regulations, meaning the law, provides that under Section 2, subparagraph B, divestment is mandatory only if all the conditions in Section 1, subparagraph B, All the elements enumerated under the preceding paragraph must first concur before the public official or employee may be required to divest himself of such financial or alleged financial interest in any firm or company. Now, I will be citing two Supreme Court decisions which form part of the law of the land. These are, the first one is Trieste. Sr. v. Sandigan Bayan, GR number L-70332-43. This was decided by the Supreme Court on November 13, 1986. And the Court said in that decision of Trieste that what is contemplated in Section 3, Paragraph H of the Antigraph Law is the actual intervention in the transaction. In which one has financial or pecuniary interests in order that liability may attach. And the official... May I just finish, Your Honor? I will also listen to the good prosecutor after I'm done.

1753
07:27:14,270 --> 07:27:14,870
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: The

1754
07:27:14,870 --> 07:27:15,330
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: official

1755
07:27:15,330 --> 07:27:16,490
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: need

1756
07:27:16,490 --> 07:27:16,690
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: not...

1757
07:27:16,690 --> 07:27:20,910
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: To continue.

1758
07:27:21,190 --> 07:27:57,080
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: The official need not dispose his shares in the corporation as long as he does not do... Anything for the firm in its contract with the office. For the law aims to prevent the use of influence, authority, and power. And the court cited the deliberations on Senate Bill 293, May 6, 1959. This is part of the Congressional Record, Volume 2, page 603, as well as page 604 of the Congressional Record, May 9, 1959. Now, more recently, in 2007,

1759
07:28:02,000 --> 07:28:59,940
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: The Supreme Court also rendered a decision in Caballero v. Sandigan Bayan. It reiterated the Trieste ruling that what is contemplated in the law is the actual intervention in the transaction in which one has financial or pecuniary interest in order that liability may attach. And finally, we also found a decision In People v. Dimaala of the Sandigan Bayan, where the prosecution witness was the presiding justice or chairperson of the 3rd Division that acquitted the accused in that case, criminal cases numbers 27, 208, 10, 12, 14, 16, 17, 19, 23, 24-28 in an amended decision dated June 22, 2018, Your Honor. That's the gist of my manifestation.

1760
07:28:59,960 --> 07:29:10,020
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Court takes judicial notice of the law cited as well as the decision cited which form part of the law of the land. Yes, Honorable Ridon, you are entitled to your own manifestation.

1761
07:29:10,370 --> 07:29:24,010
Rep. Terry L. Ridon: No, we will not make a manifestation, Your Honor. I think that is a proper subject of a written memorandum or closing arguments, but we will respect their time that they had spent on the matter. Thank you. We will move forward, Your Honor.

1762
07:29:24,010 --> 07:29:27,690
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Thank you for your magnanimity. Honorable Ridon.

1763
07:29:29,510 --> 07:29:37,550
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Maybe I may ask, Attorney Sheila, we have three witnesses for tomorrow. Dr. Rodolfo, Ms. Pagayunan, and the replacement of Ms. Mendoza, correct?

1764
07:29:37,830 --> 07:29:38,550
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Yes, Your Honor.

1765
07:29:38,550 --> 07:29:39,030
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: In that order?

1766
07:29:39,490 --> 07:29:51,950
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Yes, Your Honor. But before I confirm, Your Honor, just a brief response to the prosecutor for his magnanimity in allowing me time.

1767
07:29:51,990 --> 07:29:54,410
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Not in allowing you, in not commenting anymore, actually.

1768
07:29:54,430 --> 07:30:22,430
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: In not commenting. To my manifestation, Your Honor, but... I think the records will also show that in so many instances, the prosecution also asked this court orally for certain matters to be taken up mandatorily for judicial notice, Your Honor. And since this is a matter for a mandatory judicial notice, Your Honor, motion is not needed, Your Honor.

1769
07:30:22,710 --> 07:30:25,010
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Again, it's more for not commenting, Atty. Silla.

1770
07:30:25,190 --> 07:30:55,720
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor. We confirm that we will proceed to the presentation of our last three witnesses for this week, Dr. Rodolfo, Dr. Pagayunan, and the CITEM witness, Ms. Rowena G. Mendoza. But I understand that from the announcement of this presiding of the court early this morning that Ms. Mendoza will not be able to testify and instead CITEM will...

1771
07:30:55,720 --> 07:30:59,630
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, it will be Attorney Eva Marie Mariquina with a Q.

1772
07:31:00,800 --> 07:31:07,820
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Okay, Your Honor. In that case, Your Honor, may we also inquire if we have received any documents from CITEM?

1773
07:31:07,980 --> 07:31:27,390
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Yes, the Chair just said earlier that we have received all of the subpoena documents from the three witnesses and we will be furnishing both parties with a copy of the same so that you can peruse it and there won't be any further delay with respect to... The identification and or possible stipulation of either the documents or testimony of the witnesses tomorrow.

1774
07:31:27,730 --> 07:31:39,950
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: Thank you, Your Honor. And we will also ask the court to also provide the prosecution copies of those documents so that tomorrow they will no longer need to ask us to give them copies, Your Honor. For more time. Yes. Thank you.

1775
07:31:40,930 --> 07:31:43,110
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: Senator Judge Lacson, what is your pleasure, sir?

1776
07:31:43,490 --> 07:31:50,370
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson: Just a point of clarification. Did I hear it right? The three mentioned names are the last witnesses?

1777
07:31:51,100 --> 07:31:52,240
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: For this week, Your Honor.

1778
07:31:52,420 --> 07:31:56,820
Sen. Panfilo “Ping” M. Lacson: Thank you. Sorry. For purposes of planning, sir.

1779
07:31:56,980 --> 07:32:23,020
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: We will announce tomorrow the scheduled hearings for next month and or next week depending on how the decision of the Senate President, the majority is with respect to the budget as we have done so in the past, especially for the month of December. Is there any other matter any other party wish to take up? None? Honorable Ridon? Attorney Sheila?

1780
07:32:23,360 --> 07:32:23,620
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: None.

1781
07:32:23,660 --> 07:32:24,320
Atty. Sheila C. Sison: None here.

1782
07:32:24,780 --> 07:32:49,440
Sen. Francis "Chiz" G. Escudero: There being no other matters to be taken up, trial is adjourned until tomorrow at 10 a.m., November 20, 2026. Pardon for the aircon. It was a holiday for three days. We weren't able to switch on the aircon ahead of time in order for it to cool, cool a bit. So tomorrow, expect it to be a bit cooler. Again, apologies from the Clerk of Court. Trial is adjourned.
