{ "hearing": { "id": 42, "title": "House Committee on Appropriations: Judiciary - September 7, 2026", "hearing_date": "2026-09-07", "official_url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=D6syh9B_r7Q" }, "revision_id": 7682, "revision_number": 99, "notice": "AI-assisted working draft. AI can make errors. Always check quotations, names, rulings, and other consequential details against the official video.", "segments": [ { "stable_id": "asr-000001", "start_seconds": 0.0, "end_seconds": 1.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "said good morning po, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000001-split-2", "start_seconds": 1.62, "end_seconds": 4.88, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "good morning yes for the administrator and all the officials" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000002", "start_seconds": 4.88, "end_seconds": 12.02, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "of the courts and uh those present good morning to everyone let us wait for the justices yes your" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000003", "start_seconds": 12.02, "end_seconds": 12.35, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "honor" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000003-split-2", "start_seconds": 12.35, "end_seconds": 16.47, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "we know who are here justices who are now with the speaker" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000003-split-3", "start_seconds": 16.47, "end_seconds": 19.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "um justice maidas marquez" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000003-split-4", "start_seconds": 19.4, "end_seconds": 19.72, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "yes" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000004", "start_seconds": 19.72, "end_seconds": 29.7, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Justice Rodil Zalameda. Ah, Justice Raul Villanueva. Um, Justice Joseph Lopez is not" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000005", "start_seconds": 29.7, "end_seconds": 35.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "uh coming because he has another affair okay honor uh we have the presiding justices from" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000006", "start_seconds": 35.58, "end_seconds": 36.97, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the appellate courts" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000006-split-2", "start_seconds": 36.97, "end_seconds": 37.98, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "appellate courts" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000006-split-3", "start_seconds": 37.98, "end_seconds": 40.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "yes your honor we are presiding justice geraldine faith" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000007", "start_seconds": 40.02, "end_seconds": 46.06, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Econg. We have Presiding Justice Fernanda Lampas Peralta and Presiding Justice Ma. Belen Ringpis-" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000008", "start_seconds": 46.06, "end_seconds": 48.97, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Liban, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000008-split-2", "start_seconds": 48.97, "end_seconds": 51.88, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you very much. So let's wait. Yes. For them to come. Yes, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000010", "start_seconds": 97.68, "end_seconds": 185.98, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "welcome justice midas marquez justice uh rodil zalameda hello uh please give seats to the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000011", "start_seconds": 185.98, "end_seconds": 194.32, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "sandigan bayan sandigan bayan probably the second row and then we have the sandigan bayan" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000012", "start_seconds": 194.32, "end_seconds": 200.04, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "the court of appeals and the court of tax appeals kindly occupy the second row" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000013", "start_seconds": 200.04, "end_seconds": 246.08, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "we will start in two minutes kindly take your seats" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000014", "start_seconds": 284.07, "end_seconds": 293.7, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "uh good morning everyone the fiscal year uh okay so we'll wait for the minority" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000038", "start_seconds": 1511.6599999999999, "end_seconds": 1515.26, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "of our first and second level courts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000039", "start_seconds": 1515.9, "end_seconds": 1518.7, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "As of August 31, 2026," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000040", "start_seconds": 1519.74, "end_seconds": 1523.1, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "there are 138 newly created" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000041", "start_seconds": 1523.1, "end_seconds": 1525.76, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "first and second level courts" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000042", "start_seconds": 1525.76, "end_seconds": 1528.24, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "that remain unorganized" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000043", "start_seconds": 1528.24, "end_seconds": 1530.4, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and non-operational" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000044", "start_seconds": 1530.4, "end_seconds": 1533.26, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "pending the issuance of their corresponding" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000045", "start_seconds": 1533.26, "end_seconds": 1536.1, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "notice of organization," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000046", "start_seconds": 1536.8600000000001, "end_seconds": 1538.22, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "staffing, and compensation," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000047", "start_seconds": 1539.08, "end_seconds": 1539.54, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "or NOSCA." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000048", "start_seconds": 1539.54, "end_seconds": 1542.6399999999999, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "These courts were created precisely" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000049", "start_seconds": 1542.6399999999999, "end_seconds": 1546.44, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "to augment existing judicial capacity" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000050", "start_seconds": 1546.44, "end_seconds": 1549.62, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and respond to the growing demands" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000051", "start_seconds": 1549.62, "end_seconds": 1552.04, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "of judicial services." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000052", "start_seconds": 1552.94, "end_seconds": 1554.62, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Any prolonged delay" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000053", "start_seconds": 1554.62, "end_seconds": 1557.98, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "in the organization and operation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000054", "start_seconds": 1557.98, "end_seconds": 1561.26, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "inevitably affects the timely" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000055", "start_seconds": 1561.26, "end_seconds": 1564.1, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "administration and dispensation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000056", "start_seconds": 1564.1, "end_seconds": 1565.58, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "of justice," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000057", "start_seconds": 1565.58, "end_seconds": 1568.2, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "particularly for our people" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000058", "start_seconds": 1568.2, "end_seconds": 1569.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "who depend" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000059", "start_seconds": 1569.42, "end_seconds": 1570.28, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "on the courts" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000060", "start_seconds": 1570.28, "end_seconds": 1571.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "for the protection" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000061", "start_seconds": 1571.46, "end_seconds": 1572.8600000000001, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and enforcement" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000062", "start_seconds": 1572.8600000000001, "end_seconds": 1574.54, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "of their rights." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000063", "start_seconds": 1575.56, "end_seconds": 1577.02, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "The judiciary is therefore" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000064", "start_seconds": 1577.02, "end_seconds": 1578.3600000000001, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "seeking our support," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000065", "start_seconds": 1579.0, "end_seconds": 1581.22, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "not merely for additional resources," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000066", "start_seconds": 1581.22, "end_seconds": 1583.8200000000002, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "but for the continued implementation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000067", "start_seconds": 1583.8200000000002, "end_seconds": 1585.3600000000001, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "of reforms" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000068", "start_seconds": 1585.3600000000001, "end_seconds": 1587.02, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "that will strengthen" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000069", "start_seconds": 1587.02, "end_seconds": 1588.6599999999999, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "our justice system" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000070", "start_seconds": 1588.6599999999999, "end_seconds": 1590.54, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and make it more responsive" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000071", "start_seconds": 1590.54, "end_seconds": 1593.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "to the needs of the Filipino people." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000072", "start_seconds": 1593.88, "end_seconds": 1595.3400000000001, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "We also recognize" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000073", "start_seconds": 1595.3400000000001, "end_seconds": 1597.6799999999998, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "the judiciary's continuing efforts" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000074", "start_seconds": 1597.6799999999998, "end_seconds": 1599.22, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "under the strategic control" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000075", "start_seconds": 1599.42, "end_seconds": 1605.56, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and plan for judicial innovations or SPJI" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000076", "start_seconds": 1605.56, "end_seconds": 1608.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "under the leadership of Chief Justice" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000077", "start_seconds": 1608.46, "end_seconds": 1611.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Alexander G. Gismundo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000078", "start_seconds": 1611.46, "end_seconds": 1614.8600000000001, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Through this strategic framework," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000079", "start_seconds": 1614.8600000000001, "end_seconds": 1617.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "the Supreme Court has pursued a vision" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000080", "start_seconds": 1617.46, "end_seconds": 1620.6599999999999, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "of a judiciary that is independent," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000081", "start_seconds": 1620.6599999999999, "end_seconds": 1625.28, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "modern, efficient, and truly within the reach" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000082", "start_seconds": 1625.28, "end_seconds": 1627.28, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "of every Filipino." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000083", "start_seconds": 1627.28, "end_seconds": 1629.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "As we deliberate on the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000084", "start_seconds": 1629.42, "end_seconds": 1630.3400000000001, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "proposed budget," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000085", "start_seconds": 1630.3400000000001, "end_seconds": 1631.8400000000001, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "we look forward" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000086", "start_seconds": 1631.8400000000001, "end_seconds": 1634.8600000000001, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "to a productive and insightful discussion" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000087", "start_seconds": 1634.8600000000001, "end_seconds": 1637.4, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "on how we can best provide" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000088", "start_seconds": 1637.4, "end_seconds": 1639.98, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "the resources necessary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000089", "start_seconds": 1639.98, "end_seconds": 1641.4, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "for the judiciary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000090", "start_seconds": 1641.4, "end_seconds": 1645.6, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "to fulfill its constitutional mandate," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000091", "start_seconds": 1645.6, "end_seconds": 1648.56, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "address its operational challenges," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000092", "start_seconds": 1648.56, "end_seconds": 1652.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and ensure that justice is delivered" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000093", "start_seconds": 1652.42, "end_seconds": 1655.1599999999999, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "efficiently, effectively," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000094", "start_seconds": 1655.1599999999999, "end_seconds": 1657.78, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and without delay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000095", "start_seconds": 1657.78, "end_seconds": 1659.12, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "With the presence of the members" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000096", "start_seconds": 1659.12, "end_seconds": 1661.02, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "of the judiciary family," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000097", "start_seconds": 1661.02, "end_seconds": 1663.9, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "we welcome this opportunity" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000098", "start_seconds": 1663.9, "end_seconds": 1665.94, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "for a meaningful dialogue" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000099", "start_seconds": 1665.94, "end_seconds": 1668.24, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and a thorough examination" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000100", "start_seconds": 1668.24, "end_seconds": 1669.88, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "of the proposed budget" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000101", "start_seconds": 1669.88, "end_seconds": 1672.96, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "for fiscal year 2027." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000102", "start_seconds": 1672.96, "end_seconds": 1675.52, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you and good morning." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000103", "start_seconds": 1675.52, "end_seconds": 1677.6599999999999, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So now we proceed" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000104", "start_seconds": 1677.6599999999999, "end_seconds": 1681.52, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "with the interpolation." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000105", "start_seconds": 1681.52, "end_seconds": 1683.3200000000002, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "We first," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000106", "start_seconds": 1683.3200000000002, "end_seconds": 1684.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "you know all the rules," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000107", "start_seconds": 1684.42, "end_seconds": 1687.72, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "I will not again repeat it." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000108", "start_seconds": 1687.72, "end_seconds": 1689.3600000000001, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Ah ha!" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000109", "start_seconds": 1689.3600000000001, "end_seconds": 1690.52, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Presentation muna." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000110", "start_seconds": 1690.88, "end_seconds": 1693.76, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Dumeritso ko sa gusto kumatapos na ito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000111", "start_seconds": 1693.76, "end_seconds": 1694.1599999999999, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "But anyway." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000112", "start_seconds": 1695.06, "end_seconds": 1695.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000113", "start_seconds": 1695.6399999999999, "end_seconds": 1696.8, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Let's have the presentation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000114", "start_seconds": 1696.8, "end_seconds": 1699.6399999999999, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "by the Honorable Court Administrator," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000115", "start_seconds": 1700.38, "end_seconds": 1702.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Justice Estuesta." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000116", "start_seconds": 1703.06, "end_seconds": 1703.92, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000117", "start_seconds": 1704.2, "end_seconds": 1704.9, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Mr. Chair," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000118", "start_seconds": 1705.06, "end_seconds": 1706.42, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Honorable members of the committee," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000119", "start_seconds": 1706.92, "end_seconds": 1707.5, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "good morning." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000120", "start_seconds": 1708.02, "end_seconds": 1709.48, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "In behalf of the Supreme Court," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000121", "start_seconds": 1709.8400000000001, "end_seconds": 1712.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "represented by the Honorable Justices present," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000122", "start_seconds": 1712.56, "end_seconds": 1713.8, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Justice Rodil Zalameda," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000123", "start_seconds": 1714.1, "end_seconds": 1715.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Justice Jose Maidas Marquez," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000124", "start_seconds": 1716.04, "end_seconds": 1718.3200000000002, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "and Justice Raul Villanueva," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000125", "start_seconds": 1718.3200000000002, "end_seconds": 1720.3, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "I have the honor to present" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000126", "start_seconds": 1720.3, "end_seconds": 1720.8600000000001, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the original," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000127", "start_seconds": 1720.88, "end_seconds": 1722.08, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the original budget proposal" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000128", "start_seconds": 1722.08, "end_seconds": 1723.48, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "within the framework of the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000129", "start_seconds": 1723.48, "end_seconds": 1725.1799999999998, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Fiscal Autonomy Act." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000130", "start_seconds": 1725.1799999999998, "end_seconds": 1726.52, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But the outset, Your Honor," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000131", "start_seconds": 1726.52, "end_seconds": 1729.44, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "allow me to express our sincere appreciation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000132", "start_seconds": 1729.44, "end_seconds": 1731.48, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "to the Honorable Representative" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000133", "start_seconds": 1731.48, "end_seconds": 1732.92, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Rufus B. Rodriguez," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000134", "start_seconds": 1732.92, "end_seconds": 1734.6799999999998, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "our distinguished sponsor," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000135", "start_seconds": 1734.6799999999998, "end_seconds": 1737.54, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "for championing the judiciary's budget" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000136", "start_seconds": 1737.54, "end_seconds": 1739.3400000000001, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "and for giving us the opportunity" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000137", "start_seconds": 1739.3400000000001, "end_seconds": 1741.0, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "to present our programs," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000138", "start_seconds": 1741.0, "end_seconds": 1742.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "priorities," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000139", "start_seconds": 1742.02, "end_seconds": 1743.2, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "and resource requirements" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000140", "start_seconds": 1743.2, "end_seconds": 1745.12, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "before this honorable committee." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000141", "start_seconds": 1745.12, "end_seconds": 1747.6399999999999, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We are grateful for the Honorable Representative's" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000142", "start_seconds": 1747.6399999999999, "end_seconds": 1749.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "steadfast support for the judiciary," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000143", "start_seconds": 1749.96, "end_seconds": 1750.8600000000001, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "not simply for the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000144", "start_seconds": 1750.88, "end_seconds": 1752.3200000000002, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "resources we seek," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000145", "start_seconds": 1752.3200000000002, "end_seconds": 1754.0, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "but for his recognition" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000146", "start_seconds": 1754.0, "end_seconds": 1755.56, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "that a strong, independent," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000147", "start_seconds": 1755.56, "end_seconds": 1757.72, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "and adequately funded judiciary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000148", "start_seconds": 1757.72, "end_seconds": 1759.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "is indispensable to the rule of law" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000149", "start_seconds": 1759.96, "end_seconds": 1761.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "and to the delivery of justice." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000150", "start_seconds": 1761.96, "end_seconds": 1763.8400000000001, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, with the permission, Mr. Chair," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000151", "start_seconds": 1763.8400000000001, "end_seconds": 1766.8400000000001, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "we will now proceed with the presentation of the budget." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000152", "start_seconds": 1768.48, "end_seconds": 1769.48, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Slide 2." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000153", "start_seconds": 1771.08, "end_seconds": 1771.88, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "If we recall," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000154", "start_seconds": 1771.88, "end_seconds": 1775.76, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the 2026 General Appropriations Act Judiciary Budget," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000155", "start_seconds": 1775.76, "end_seconds": 1779.3600000000001, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "it is in the amount of 70.611 billion." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000156", "start_seconds": 1779.3600000000001, "end_seconds": 1780.0, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Um," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000157", "start_seconds": 1780.0, "end_seconds": 1782.88, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "considering the finite fiscal envelope that we have," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000158", "start_seconds": 1782.88, "end_seconds": 1786.2, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "we have limited the increase to 22% Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000159", "start_seconds": 1786.2, "end_seconds": 1791.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, if we look at the breakdown first of the 70.611 billion," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000160", "start_seconds": 1791.04, "end_seconds": 1794.24, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "it's divided or the breakdown among the following." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000161", "start_seconds": 1794.24, "end_seconds": 1796.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For the Supreme Court of the Philippines and lower courts," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000162", "start_seconds": 1796.96, "end_seconds": 1799.3600000000001, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "60.489 billion," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000170", "start_seconds": 1800.0, "end_seconds": 1807.18, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Presidential Electoral Tribunal or PET, we have 179.87 million, the Court of Appeals 6.092 billion," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000171", "start_seconds": 1807.56, "end_seconds": 1815.38, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the Sandigan Bayan 2.723 billion, and the Court of Tax Appeals 1.127 billion. Our proposed judiciary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000172", "start_seconds": 1815.38, "end_seconds": 1820.72, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "budget, Your Honor, which is now attached to the National Expenditure Program, is in the amount of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000173", "start_seconds": 1820.72, "end_seconds": 1827.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "86.271 billion pesos, the breakdown of which is as follows. For the Supreme Court and lower courts," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000174", "start_seconds": 1827.58, "end_seconds": 1838.8, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "73.837 billion, for the PET, 193.43 million, Court of Appeals 7.605 billion, Sandigan Bayan 3.282" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000175", "start_seconds": 1838.8, "end_seconds": 1847.14, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "billion, and the Court of Tax Appeals 1.354 billion. If we compare the 2026 General Appropriations Act" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000176", "start_seconds": 1847.14, "end_seconds": 1853.1, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "and the 2027 Original Budget Proposal, Your Honor, there is only a marked increase of 22 percent," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000177", "start_seconds": 1853.1, "end_seconds": 1856.6, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the breakdown of which is as follows. For the Supreme Court," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000178", "start_seconds": 1857.58, "end_seconds": 1866.54, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "from 60.489 billion, we have 73.837 billion, or an increase of 13.347 billion, an increase of 22" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000179", "start_seconds": 1866.54, "end_seconds": 1875.18, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "percent. For the PET, from 179.87 million, we have a proposed increase of 193.43 million," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000180", "start_seconds": 1875.66, "end_seconds": 1883.94, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "or an increase of 13.56 million, or 8 percent. For the Court of Appeals, from the GAAA, 6.092" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000181", "start_seconds": 1883.94, "end_seconds": 1887.56, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "billion, we now have proposed in 2027 7.605 billion, or an increase of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000182", "start_seconds": 1887.58, "end_seconds": 1889.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "1.513 billion, representing an increase of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000183", "start_seconds": 1889.58, "end_seconds": 1895.94, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "25 percent. For the Sandiganbayan," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000184", "start_seconds": 1895.94, "end_seconds": 1897.9, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "from the GAAA, of 2.723 billion, we now have a proposed" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000185", "start_seconds": 1901.34, "end_seconds": 1910.52, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "budget of 3.282 billion, or an increase of 559 million, representing an increase of 21 percent." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000186", "start_seconds": 1910.52, "end_seconds": 1914.54, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For the Court of Tax Appeals, from the GAA, 1.127 billion, we have a" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000187", "start_seconds": 1914.54, "end_seconds": 1915.5, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "proposed" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000188", "start_seconds": 1915.5, "end_seconds": 1916.5, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "budget in 2027" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000189", "start_seconds": 1916.5, "end_seconds": 1917.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000190", "start_seconds": 1917.4, "end_seconds": 1925.18, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "1.354 billion, or an increase of 227 million, or an increase of 20 percent." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000191", "start_seconds": 1925.18, "end_seconds": 1933.26, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Overall, Your Honor, the proposed 86.271 billion represents an increase of 15.66 billion in" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000192", "start_seconds": 1933.26, "end_seconds": 1935.88, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the budget, or overall 22%." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000193", "start_seconds": 1935.88, "end_seconds": 1943.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "To represent this, Your Honor, we have the Supreme Court's, we will know that the breakdown," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000194", "start_seconds": 1943.96, "end_seconds": 1949.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "there is actually an increase in the capital outlay of the Supreme Court in 3.758 billion." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000195", "start_seconds": 1950.12, "end_seconds": 1954.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Likewise, for the Court of Tax Appeals, a decrease in the budget for capital outlay" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000196", "start_seconds": 1954.62, "end_seconds": 1961.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "of 4.528 million, or representing a total in the capital outlay, a decrease of 3.218" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000197", "start_seconds": 1961.96, "end_seconds": 1964.6, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "billion, which I will explain as follows, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000198", "start_seconds": 1965.08, "end_seconds": 1971.94, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Breakdown for the Supreme Court and the lower court, we have personal services amounting" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000199", "start_seconds": 1971.94, "end_seconds": 1973.94, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "to 13.658." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000200", "start_seconds": 1974.6, "end_seconds": 1982.92, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "13.859 billion, and the MOOE, a total of 3.246 billion, but there is a decrease in capital" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000201", "start_seconds": 1982.92, "end_seconds": 1986.22, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "outlay of 3.758 billion." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000202", "start_seconds": 1986.66, "end_seconds": 1993.22, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "The reason being, Your Honor, in the 2026 GAAA, we have included the GAAA for the allocation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000203", "start_seconds": 1993.22, "end_seconds": 1998.7, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "for the Manila Hall of Justice, but for the 2027 budget, we have only represented the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000204", "start_seconds": 1998.7, "end_seconds": 2003.88, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Cebu and CDO Judiciary Complex in the amount of 200 million." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000205", "start_seconds": 2003.96, "end_seconds": 2010.2, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But as we have done with our budget briefing, the Honorable Representative Rufus Rodriguez," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000206", "start_seconds": 2010.38, "end_seconds": 2017.28, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "we have mentioned, Your Honor, that the consulting services just recently, last August 5, 2026," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000207", "start_seconds": 2017.66, "end_seconds": 2023.8, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "submitted its DAED for the construction of the HOJ in the Judiciary Complex, which will" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000208", "start_seconds": 2023.8, "end_seconds": 2030.0, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "require us now to have a budget allocation of, for Cagayan de Oro, 500 million." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000209", "start_seconds": 2030.0, "end_seconds": 2031.66, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Can we look at the slide 12?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000210", "start_seconds": 2032.1, "end_seconds": 2033.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And for Cebu City?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000211", "start_seconds": 2033.02, "end_seconds": 2040.0, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We have actually tallied the exact amount needed for Cebu City, Your Honor, of 4.541" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000212", "start_seconds": 2040.0, "end_seconds": 2044.32, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "billion, or a total of 5.041 billion." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000213", "start_seconds": 2044.68, "end_seconds": 2046.56, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you very much for Cagayan de Oro." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000214", "start_seconds": 2046.7, "end_seconds": 2046.98, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000215", "start_seconds": 2047.0, "end_seconds": 2048.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you so much, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000216", "start_seconds": 2048.5, "end_seconds": 2049.3, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you, likewise." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000217", "start_seconds": 2049.96, "end_seconds": 2054.8, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And we hope that this will likewise be carried in the 2027 GAAA." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000218", "start_seconds": 2055.22, "end_seconds": 2060.74, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We have to likewise admit, Your Honor, that in our original budget proposal, the hazard" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000219", "start_seconds": 2060.74, "end_seconds": 2062.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "pay for the judges have been carried over." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000220", "start_seconds": 2063.02, "end_seconds": 2066.26, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But the hazard pay for the sheriffs have not been included." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000221", "start_seconds": 2066.66, "end_seconds": 2072.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So we propose likewise, Your Honor, that the hazard pay for sheriffs be included in the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000222", "start_seconds": 2072.02, "end_seconds": 2073.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "amount of 303 million." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000223", "start_seconds": 2073.96, "end_seconds": 2080.6, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "In other words, Your Honor, from our original budget proposal of 86.271 billion, we are" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000224", "start_seconds": 2080.6, "end_seconds": 2085.74, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "augmenting it further in the total amount of 5.344 billion, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000225", "start_seconds": 2086.06, "end_seconds": 2086.5, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000226", "start_seconds": 2087.24, "end_seconds": 2092.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Then, likewise, a breakdown for PET, or the Presidential Electoral Tribunal, we have personal" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000227", "start_seconds": 2092.4, "end_seconds": 2092.9, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "services." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000228", "start_seconds": 2093.02, "end_seconds": 2099.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Representing an increase of 11.239 million, and MOOE for 2.320 million." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000229", "start_seconds": 2099.96, "end_seconds": 2109.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For the Court of Appeals, Your Honor, or representing a budget of 1.513 billion, personal services" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000230", "start_seconds": 2109.04, "end_seconds": 2119.14, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "will call for an increase of 522.731 million, MOOE an increase of 849.167 million, and an" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000231", "start_seconds": 2119.14, "end_seconds": 2122.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "increase in capital outlay of 140.890 million." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000232", "start_seconds": 2123.02, "end_seconds": 2130.36, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For the Sandigan Bayan, Your Honor, or a budget of 559.599 million, in the personal" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000233", "start_seconds": 2130.36, "end_seconds": 2137.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "services, there is actually an aberration because there resulted an increase or a decrease" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000234", "start_seconds": 2137.02, "end_seconds": 2143.88, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "of 27.659 million owing to a recomputation of the other personal benefits." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000235", "start_seconds": 2144.48, "end_seconds": 2149.26, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But in its entirety, Your Honor, it's not actually a decrease, but it will not violate" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000236", "start_seconds": 2149.26, "end_seconds": 2152.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the constitutional provision that the budget for the previous year required." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000237", "start_seconds": 2153.02, "end_seconds": 2163.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For MOOE, we have a total increase of 183.264 million, and capital outlay 403.994 million" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000238", "start_seconds": 2163.96, "end_seconds": 2165.64, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "for the Sandigan Bayan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000239", "start_seconds": 2165.64, "end_seconds": 2174.48, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For Court of Tax Appeals, or a total of 226.682 million, Your Honor, personal services 123.052" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000240", "start_seconds": 2174.48, "end_seconds": 2182.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "million, MOOE 108.158 million, but there is a decrease, likewise, in capital outlay of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000241", "start_seconds": 2182.4, "end_seconds": 2188.8, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "4.528 million owing to the fact, Your Honor, that compared to the last budget appropriation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000242", "start_seconds": 2188.8, "end_seconds": 2198.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "of 50.862 million, the only one included now in capital outlay or other machine and equipment," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000243", "start_seconds": 2198.62, "end_seconds": 2203.52, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "it did not include the solar panel, which were subject for procurement, having been" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000244", "start_seconds": 2203.52, "end_seconds": 2206.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "carried over with the 2026 GAA." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000245", "start_seconds": 2206.58, "end_seconds": 2212.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For case disposition, Your Honor, as our major final output, we have the judiciary's ultimate" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000246", "start_seconds": 2212.4, "end_seconds": 2219.2799999999997, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "function in the disposition of cases and brought about by SPJI's institutional transformation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000247", "start_seconds": 2219.2799999999997, "end_seconds": 2221.42, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "that improves the delivery of justice." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000248", "start_seconds": 2221.42, "end_seconds": 2227.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For the Supreme Court, Your Honor, we have an accomplishment rate of 2024, 95 percent." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000249", "start_seconds": 2227.04, "end_seconds": 2233.24, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "In 2025, there may have been a shortfall of 85 percent compared to the target disposal" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000250", "start_seconds": 2233.24, "end_seconds": 2238.8, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "of 6,000, but there has been a recovery this year, Your Honor, since this is just half" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000251", "start_seconds": 2238.8, "end_seconds": 2240.76, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "of the year, from January to June, with a target disposal of 3,000." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000257", "start_seconds": 2245.4, "end_seconds": 2246.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "In the current year, with a target disposal of 3,000 half of the year, an actual disposal" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000258", "start_seconds": 2246.4, "end_seconds": 2253.48, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "by the Supreme Court has already been made of 2,662 cases, representing an accomplishment" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000259", "start_seconds": 2253.48, "end_seconds": 2256.26, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "rate of 89 percent." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000260", "start_seconds": 2256.26, "end_seconds": 2261.38, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For our second-level courts, Your Honor, for regional trial courts, we have an accomplishment" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000261", "start_seconds": 2261.38, "end_seconds": 2269.7200000000003, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "rate in 2024 of 117 percent, 2025, 111 percent, or in 2026, since this is just half of the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000262", "start_seconds": 2269.7200000000003, "end_seconds": 2271.76, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "year from January to June, 81 percent." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000263", "start_seconds": 2271.76, "end_seconds": 2278.26, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "percent. Accomplishment rate, Your Honor, we follow the formula actual disposal over the target" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000264", "start_seconds": 2278.26, "end_seconds": 2284.64, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "disposal times 100. For our family courts, Your Honor, in 2024, we have an accomplishment rate of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000265", "start_seconds": 2284.64, "end_seconds": 2294.92, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "140 percent in 2024. 2025, we have 142 percent or in 2026 or half of the year, 91 percent. For" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000266", "start_seconds": 2294.92, "end_seconds": 2300.16, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "first-level courts, Your Honor, metropolitan trial courts, we have an accomplishment rate of 166" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000267", "start_seconds": 2300.16, "end_seconds": 2308.66, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "percent in 2024. In 2025, 129 percent and half of the year, this year, it's 95 percent or an actual" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000268", "start_seconds": 2308.66, "end_seconds": 2317.2200000000003, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "disposal of 46,033 when the target disposal is only 48,313. For municipal trial courts in cities," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000269", "start_seconds": 2317.2200000000003, "end_seconds": 2326.32, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Your Honor, an accomplishment rate in 2024 of 153 percent. In 2025, 162 percent and 2026 from" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000270", "start_seconds": 2326.32, "end_seconds": 2330.14, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "January to June, 79 percent. Municipal trial courts, Your Honor, we have an accomplishment rate of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000271", "start_seconds": 2330.14, "end_seconds": 2341.44, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "137 percent. In 2025, 157 percent and half of the year, this year, 69 percent. For first-level" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000272", "start_seconds": 2341.44, "end_seconds": 2347.12, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "courts, again, municipal circuit trial courts or the MCTCs, we have an accomplishment rate of 120" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000273", "start_seconds": 2347.12, "end_seconds": 2355.92, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "percent for 2024, 133 percent for 2025 and half of this year, 65 percent. For Sharia circuit courts," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000274", "start_seconds": 2355.92, "end_seconds": 2360.12, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "117 percent for 2024, 187 percent for 2025." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000275", "start_seconds": 2360.14, "end_seconds": 2367.76, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And half of this year, from January to June, 67 percent. For the Court of Appeals, Your Honor," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000276", "start_seconds": 2367.88, "end_seconds": 2374.74, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "our appellate courts, accomplishment rate in 2024, 108 percent. 2025, 124 percent. And half of the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000277", "start_seconds": 2374.74, "end_seconds": 2380.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "year, 2026 from January to June, 130 percent. For the Sandigan Bayan, Your Honor, it has a bigger" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000278", "start_seconds": 2380.96, "end_seconds": 2390.0, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "accomplishment rate. 2024, 290 percent. 2025, 220 percent. And 2026, January to June, 178 percent." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000279", "start_seconds": 2390.14, "end_seconds": 2399.36, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Court of Tax Appeals, likewise, 2024, 196 percent. 2025, 167 percent. And 2026, from January to June," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000280", "start_seconds": 2399.36, "end_seconds": 2406.6, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "197 percent. For our judicial reforms, Your Honor, projects and initiatives, we can only cap them" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000281", "start_seconds": 2406.6, "end_seconds": 2413.14, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "with the SPJI milestones, considering that this is the blueprint with which the judicial" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000282", "start_seconds": 2413.14, "end_seconds": 2419.88, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "transformation has carried itself from 2022 to 2027. So milestones on SPJI activity," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000283", "start_seconds": 2419.88, "end_seconds": 2425.84, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "if I only enumerate them, Your Honor. We have the artificial intelligence system for voice to" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000284", "start_seconds": 2425.84, "end_seconds": 2432.84, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "text transcription, which we call the scriptics. And then we have formulated our ICT governance" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000285", "start_seconds": 2432.84, "end_seconds": 2443.06, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "framework, and we are now starting considering or verifying what human-centered augmented" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000286", "start_seconds": 2443.06, "end_seconds": 2448.52, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "artificial intelligence can be used for the Supreme Court that can be for our judicial" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000287", "start_seconds": 2448.52, "end_seconds": 2449.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "digital infrastructure. And we have also formulated a framework for the ICT governance framework," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000288", "start_seconds": 2449.88, "end_seconds": 2451.7799999999997, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "which will be developed by the Supreme Court. The framework for digital governance and" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000289", "start_seconds": 2451.7799999999997, "end_seconds": 2455.54, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "infrastructure can be characterized by the five-year ICT strategic plan released by the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000290", "start_seconds": 2455.54, "end_seconds": 2461.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "MIS, together with the operations manual. And for our digital infrastructure, we have" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000291", "start_seconds": 2461.96, "end_seconds": 2467.94, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "begun with our software-defined wide area network, what we call the SD1. And then the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000292", "start_seconds": 2467.94, "end_seconds": 2475.84, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "cloud infrastructure and then the Wi-Fi and one GPS backup connectivity for our bandwidth." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000293", "start_seconds": 2475.84, "end_seconds": 2477.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And we have likewise developed the procurement of judiciary data center servers," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000296", "start_seconds": 2479.86, "end_seconds": 2484.08, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "and backup storage infrastructure refresh for the Supreme Court." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000297", "start_seconds": 2484.64, "end_seconds": 2491.08, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For our online learning centers, Your Honor, this has already been used by the Philippine Judiciary Academy." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000298", "start_seconds": 2491.76, "end_seconds": 2498.6, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Likewise, for the JBC, applications are now registered through online registration and application system," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000299", "start_seconds": 2498.7200000000003, "end_seconds": 2506.42, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "which we call the ORAS, or O-R-A-S, and then e-voting application, which is a system of voting for our judges." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000300", "start_seconds": 2506.42, "end_seconds": 2514.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And we have the JEPs, or the Judiciary Electronic Payment Solution, in the filing of docket fees before our trial courts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000301", "start_seconds": 2514.94, "end_seconds": 2518.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And likewise, we have the Mandatory Continuing Legal Education Information System." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000302", "start_seconds": 2519.3, "end_seconds": 2525.18, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And for our line offices, you have the Human Resource Management System, or the HRMS," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000303", "start_seconds": 2525.62, "end_seconds": 2533.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Enhanced Financial Management Information System, which we have renamed as the Financial Information Resource Development, or FIRM." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000304", "start_seconds": 2533.02, "end_seconds": 2536.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We have the e-court, or the Digital Infrastructure." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000305", "start_seconds": 2537.18, "end_seconds": 2541.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "That's what an e-court will look like, Your Honor, which has already been piloted." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000306", "start_seconds": 2541.94, "end_seconds": 2544.08, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And then we have an e-procurement application." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000307", "start_seconds": 2544.86, "end_seconds": 2551.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And for any data that is needed coming from our first and second level courts, we have the CMO Data Hub." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000308", "start_seconds": 2552.38, "end_seconds": 2556.34, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We likewise have the Halls of Justice Management and Courthouse Management System," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000309", "start_seconds": 2556.88, "end_seconds": 2560.9, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the Bar Application Registration Information System and Tech Assistance, or the BARISTA." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000310", "start_seconds": 2560.9, "end_seconds": 2563.82, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We have the Philippine Judicial Platform, or the PJP," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000311", "start_seconds": 2564.2, "end_seconds": 2566.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "all of which all our judges and court persons," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000312", "start_seconds": 2566.42, "end_seconds": 2574.42, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "and our personnel, actually have PJ365 accounts in their favor for purposes of collaborative networking." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000313", "start_seconds": 2574.42, "end_seconds": 2578.66, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We have e-notarization for our notaries public." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000314", "start_seconds": 2578.66, "end_seconds": 2588.42, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We have the United Legal Aid Service of the ULAS portal for the mandatory unified legal aid service for our private practitioners." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000315", "start_seconds": 2588.42, "end_seconds": 2591.42, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And we have the interim promulgation application." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000316", "start_seconds": 2592.42, "end_seconds": 2596.18, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "For Convergence Program, Your Honor, the Justice Sector Coordinating Council," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000317", "start_seconds": 2596.18, "end_seconds": 2599.38, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "which is the coordinating mechanism that makes the justice system." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000318", "start_seconds": 2599.38, "end_seconds": 2600.18, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you, Administrator." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000319", "start_seconds": 2600.18, "end_seconds": 2605.98, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "You have given us the budget details and also the milestone." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000320", "start_seconds": 2605.98, "end_seconds": 2620.98, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "The rest are found in this paper, briefer, and it will be okay now, unless there is an objection, to proceed with the interpellation." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000321", "start_seconds": 2622.34, "end_seconds": 2625.98, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, Administrator Estrella, can you go to page 24?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000322", "start_seconds": 2626.18, "end_seconds": 2638.37, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Page 24. Slide 24, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000323", "start_seconds": 2638.37, "end_seconds": 2639.37, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000324", "start_seconds": 2639.37, "end_seconds": 2641.37, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "All right. The milestones, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000325", "start_seconds": 2641.37, "end_seconds": 2648.19, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "The 2026 milestones, SPG." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000326", "start_seconds": 2648.19, "end_seconds": 2650.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "No, 24 is thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000327", "start_seconds": 2650.19, "end_seconds": 2651.19, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Oh." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000328", "start_seconds": 2651.19, "end_seconds": 2653.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "You go to the thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000329", "start_seconds": 2653.19, "end_seconds": 2655.19, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "The page 24. Thank you very much, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000330", "start_seconds": 2655.19, "end_seconds": 2657.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yes, okay. Palakpakan natin judiciary po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000331", "start_seconds": 2657.19, "end_seconds": 2658.19, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you, sir." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000332", "start_seconds": 2658.19, "end_seconds": 2659.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Okay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000333", "start_seconds": 2661.19, "end_seconds": 2662.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Actually, nakita ko 47." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000334", "start_seconds": 2662.19, "end_seconds": 2665.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Okay. So, with that, we therefore would like to now proceed." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000335", "start_seconds": 2665.19, "end_seconds": 2666.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Page 47." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000336", "start_seconds": 2667.19, "end_seconds": 2670.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "We proceed with the interpellation." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000337", "start_seconds": 2670.19, "end_seconds": 2673.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "We start always with the minority." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000338", "start_seconds": 2673.19, "end_seconds": 2676.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "We have Representative Renee Ko." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000339", "start_seconds": 2676.19, "end_seconds": 2679.63, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "You have five minutes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000340", "start_seconds": 2679.63, "end_seconds": 2694.63, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "And thank you, Mr. Chair, and thank you to the judiciary for the continuous work that we do to ensure that justice reaches to the farthest areas of the Philippines." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000341", "start_seconds": 2694.63, "end_seconds": 2697.63, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "At siyempre sa pinaka ordinaryong mamamayang Pilipino." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000342", "start_seconds": 2698.63, "end_seconds": 2699.63, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Yung mga tanong din po natin" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000352", "start_seconds": 2700.0, "end_seconds": 2706.42, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "ay gusto nating mabigyan, mapalamnan ng mas marami pang detalye kung paano po siya nagagawa." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000353", "start_seconds": 2707.24, "end_seconds": 2714.2, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Ang una pong tanong, may discussion na po sa proposed FY2027 Judiciary Budget," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000354", "start_seconds": 2714.68, "end_seconds": 2717.02, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "totaling 86.271 billion." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000355", "start_seconds": 2717.24, "end_seconds": 2720.82, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "This is a 22% increase from the 2026 GAA." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000356", "start_seconds": 2720.82, "end_seconds": 2727.6, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "And that first double courts such as MTCs and MCTCs posted case disposal rates" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000357", "start_seconds": 2727.6, "end_seconds": 2731.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "as low as 65 to 69% in the first half of 2026." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000358", "start_seconds": 2732.36, "end_seconds": 2737.82, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Siguro ang tanong ko po, how much of the 4.3 billion increase in MOOE" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000359", "start_seconds": 2737.82, "end_seconds": 2744.48, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "is specifically allocated to clear backlogs and enable swift, speedy processing of cases" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000360", "start_seconds": 2744.48, "end_seconds": 2749.66, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "na gusto pong mas magawa natin, especially at the lower courts?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000361", "start_seconds": 2750.12, "end_seconds": 2750.92, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000362", "start_seconds": 2751.44, "end_seconds": 2751.66, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000363", "start_seconds": 2752.8, "end_seconds": 2753.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000364", "start_seconds": 2753.92, "end_seconds": 2754.7, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yeah, please proceed." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000365", "start_seconds": 2755.24, "end_seconds": 2756.32, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you so much, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000366", "start_seconds": 2756.8, "end_seconds": 2757.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you for the question." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000367", "start_seconds": 2757.6, "end_seconds": 2759.72, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "The Honorable Representative Ko." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000368", "start_seconds": 2760.88, "end_seconds": 2767.3, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Part of a disposal target is always a performance benchmark, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000369", "start_seconds": 2767.86, "end_seconds": 2775.82, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And part of the budget that should cover a proper case disposal," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000370", "start_seconds": 2776.06, "end_seconds": 2780.82, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "especially among our first level courts, is a proper case flow management." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000371", "start_seconds": 2780.82, "end_seconds": 2786.82, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "The CMO data hub would usually have statistics to monitor the cases" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000372", "start_seconds": 2787.6, "end_seconds": 2793.84, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "and the case load and the resolutions and disposal of cases of the lower courts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000373", "start_seconds": 2794.38, "end_seconds": 2799.98, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We have a statistics and records division from the Court Management Office to interpret this data." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000374", "start_seconds": 2799.98, "end_seconds": 2807.68, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And this is how we would flow into a development of a case flow management system." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000375", "start_seconds": 2807.86, "end_seconds": 2814.8, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Because it will flow from how the cases are handled, how they are calendared, how they are heard, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000376", "start_seconds": 2815.48, "end_seconds": 2816.98, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "All in an administrative way." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000377", "start_seconds": 2817.6, "end_seconds": 2820.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "From the point of view of an administrative aspect." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000378", "start_seconds": 2821.72, "end_seconds": 2825.2, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Does that answer the question, Your Honor?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000379", "start_seconds": 2826.6, "end_seconds": 2836.16, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Ang nakuha ko po, Mr. Chair, meron pong ICT upgrades na popondohan para po mag-improve yung backlog." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000380", "start_seconds": 2836.62, "end_seconds": 2838.44, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Specifically on calendaring." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000381", "start_seconds": 2838.7, "end_seconds": 2839.2, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Tama po ba?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000382", "start_seconds": 2840.34, "end_seconds": 2840.52, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Oo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000383", "start_seconds": 2840.84, "end_seconds": 2841.32, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And digitally." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000384", "start_seconds": 2841.58, "end_seconds": 2855.04, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "And siguro ang tanong ko din po, other than na-appreciate natin yung pag-share ng details on how to better calendarize," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000385", "start_seconds": 2855.06, "end_seconds": 2862.44, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "ako, first hand ko rin nakita yung sabay-sabay na 30 cases i-assign sa isang araw." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000386", "start_seconds": 2862.96, "end_seconds": 2865.48, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "At ang matatapos lang dyan, apat or something." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000387", "start_seconds": 2865.64, "end_seconds": 2869.08, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "And then everyone else would have to be re-calendared on a different day." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000388", "start_seconds": 2869.44, "end_seconds": 2870.7, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "That is cause for delay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000389", "start_seconds": 2872.1, "end_seconds": 2879.54, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Meron po bang additional personnel na iniexplore na binubukas yung courts?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000390", "start_seconds": 2879.54, "end_seconds": 2883.54, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Or may bagong rules po ba na..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000391", "start_seconds": 2885.06, "end_seconds": 2891.76, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Ipapatupad para po mas maklear yung backlogs and to enable the swift, speedy processing of cases." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000392", "start_seconds": 2891.96, "end_seconds": 2894.56, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Right now, may na-share po kayong ICT upgrades." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000393", "start_seconds": 2895.26, "end_seconds": 2897.72, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Ano ba pong meron pa po?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000394", "start_seconds": 2898.52, "end_seconds": 2901.2, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you, the Honorable Representative Ko." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000395", "start_seconds": 2901.24, "end_seconds": 2908.08, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Other than ICT upgrades, of course, within the digital framework that our lower courts should already have," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000396", "start_seconds": 2908.08, "end_seconds": 2914.08, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the 3.959..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000397", "start_seconds": 2915.06, "end_seconds": 2919.56, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "increase or million increase in the budget for the lower court" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000398", "start_seconds": 2919.56, "end_seconds": 2924.56, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "will go to an upgrade and reclassification of the personnel, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000399", "start_seconds": 2924.56, "end_seconds": 2934.06, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And this is really important because how particularly that the salary grade of our lower court personnel" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000400", "start_seconds": 2934.06, "end_seconds": 2939.06, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "have not been upgraded since time immemorial." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000401", "start_seconds": 2939.06, "end_seconds": 2943.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So that even a salary grade 1 employee who happens to be a utility worker" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000402", "start_seconds": 2943.86, "end_seconds": 2944.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "will still have..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000403", "start_seconds": 2944.96, "end_seconds": 2948.26, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "a salary of 15,000 pesos only." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000404", "start_seconds": 2948.26, "end_seconds": 2952.96, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So if with the budget proposal, if this be included," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000405", "start_seconds": 2952.96, "end_seconds": 2958.06, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "if this be approved as a part of the appropriation of the Honorable Congress," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000406", "start_seconds": 2958.06, "end_seconds": 2964.36, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "it will really do a lot of wonders so that we can practically have a sufficient," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000407", "start_seconds": 2964.36, "end_seconds": 2968.16, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "attractive and competitive salary networking for our personnel." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000408", "start_seconds": 2968.16, "end_seconds": 2972.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And we've always believed that if there is an internal stakeholder engagement" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000409", "start_seconds": 2972.86, "end_seconds": 2974.56, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "wherein they are happy and satisfied," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000410", "start_seconds": 2974.56, "end_seconds": 2977.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "it flows with how they work into the..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000411", "start_seconds": 2977.86, "end_seconds": 2981.26, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "into the delivery of justice, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000412", "start_seconds": 2981.26, "end_seconds": 2981.66, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Okay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000413", "start_seconds": 2981.66, "end_seconds": 2984.56, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "So thank you po sa pagsagot ng tanong." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000414", "start_seconds": 2984.56, "end_seconds": 2990.76, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Ang isang nanote din po kasi sa continuous deliberations, even here in Congress," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000415", "start_seconds": 2990.76, "end_seconds": 2994.76, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "kulang po yung mga korte, kulang din yung judges." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000416", "start_seconds": 2994.76, "end_seconds": 3002.76, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Kaya kung ito po ay limited in number, in particular regions, nakaka-contribute din siya doon sa case backlog." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000417", "start_seconds": 3002.76, "end_seconds": 3003.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "So at least..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000418", "start_seconds": 3003.86, "end_seconds": 3007.16, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "now, may nanote po tayong creation of new courts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000419", "start_seconds": 3007.16, "end_seconds": 3011.16, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Pero persistent po yung problem ng lack of judges." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000420", "start_seconds": 3011.16, "end_seconds": 3015.16, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Or even yung pag-fill ng items ng personnel." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000421", "start_seconds": 3015.16, "end_seconds": 3019.66, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "And nakita po natin sa presentation yung creation of these courts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000422", "start_seconds": 3019.66, "end_seconds": 3027.16, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "But as of June 30, 2026, the Judicial and Bar Council lists only seven vacant positions open for application." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000423", "start_seconds": 3027.16, "end_seconds": 3033.66, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "And meron pong net decrease yung SC-PLC budget in capital outlay of 3.7%." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000424", "start_seconds": 3033.86, "end_seconds": 3039.66, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "So, can I ask po, despite the creation of new RTCs and family courts," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000425", "start_seconds": 3039.66, "end_seconds": 3044.16, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "how many plantelia positions for judges and court personnel remain unfilled?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000426", "start_seconds": 3044.16, "end_seconds": 3052.66, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "At ano pong ginagawa ng Korte Suprema natin to ensure personal services funding match the actual staffing needs of these new courts?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000427", "start_seconds": 3052.66, "end_seconds": 3053.66, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000428", "start_seconds": 3053.66, "end_seconds": 3055.66, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, sir. Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000429", "start_seconds": 3055.66, "end_seconds": 3063.66, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Your Honor, it depends on whether there is already a NOSCA issued or the Notice of Staffing and Classification Action." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000430", "start_seconds": 3063.86, "end_seconds": 3068.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Because if there is no NOSCA yet issued, we call it the unorganized courts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000431", "start_seconds": 3068.86, "end_seconds": 3074.16, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And despite the fact that we want to fill them in, we cannot do so because of the lack of a NOSCA." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000432", "start_seconds": 3074.16, "end_seconds": 3075.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But for those awaiting..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000433", "start_seconds": 3075.86, "end_seconds": 3076.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But for now, just to answer..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000434", "start_seconds": 3076.86, "end_seconds": 3077.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Lack of?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000435", "start_seconds": 3077.86, "end_seconds": 3079.36, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Lack of NOSCA po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000436", "start_seconds": 3079.36, "end_seconds": 3080.36, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Ah, okay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000437", "start_seconds": 3080.36, "end_seconds": 3088.36, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kasi po, yun po yung appropriation na binibigay po ng DBM para po ma-fund ang personnel, ang judge at personnel po ng isang korte." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000438", "start_seconds": 3088.36, "end_seconds": 3089.36, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Opo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000439", "start_seconds": 3089.36, "end_seconds": 3089.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "So, basically po..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000440", "start_seconds": 3089.86, "end_seconds": 3093.66, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Pero just to answer your question po, ang judge vacancies po namin, as of now," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000441", "start_seconds": 3093.86, "end_seconds": 3095.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "463 po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000442", "start_seconds": 3095.86, "end_seconds": 3103.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "It represents 16.7% of the authorized judicial positions." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000443", "start_seconds": 3103.86, "end_seconds": 3112.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Pero dahil unfilled po yung 463, kailangan po talaga na antayan namin ang NOSCA." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000444", "start_seconds": 3112.86, "end_seconds": 3121.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But hopefully, this will be remedied by the Fiscal Autonomy Act because the DBM po ay nabibigyan lang po siya ng 120 days" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000445", "start_seconds": 3121.86, "end_seconds": 3123.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "para i-issue po siya." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000446", "start_seconds": 3123.86, "end_seconds": 3132.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Otherwise, the Supreme Court will now resort to other appropriate measures just to have it funded with the DBM." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000447", "start_seconds": 3132.86, "end_seconds": 3134.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Mr. Chair, can that be submitted?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000448", "start_seconds": 3134.86, "end_seconds": 3150.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Yung list of judges and even yung list of court personnel na sa tingin ng judiciary ay kailangan pong may items pero sa kasamaang palad ay hindi po tayo nabibayaan ng DBM na mabigay po at mapondohan po siya." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000449", "start_seconds": 3150.86, "end_seconds": 3151.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Maaari po ba itong masumite?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000450", "start_seconds": 3151.86, "end_seconds": 3152.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Opo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000451", "start_seconds": 3152.86, "end_seconds": 3161.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Maaari po namin i-submite ang listahan po ng mga korte na unorganized, pati po yung funded at unorganized pa rin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000452", "start_seconds": 3161.86, "end_seconds": 3166.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Pero meron din po kaming listahan ng mga judges at kasama po yung court personnel." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000453", "start_seconds": 3166.86, "end_seconds": 3173.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But this will only reflect the total number of judges and court personnel that we have in the judiciary, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000454", "start_seconds": 3173.86, "end_seconds": 3179.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Pero pagdating po sa unorganized courts about to be created, korte pa lang po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000455", "start_seconds": 3179.86, "end_seconds": 3180.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Where it is?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000456", "start_seconds": 3180.86, "end_seconds": 3186.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "The branch number and where it should be within its territorial jurisdiction." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000457", "start_seconds": 3186.86, "end_seconds": 3188.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Thank you, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000458", "start_seconds": 3188.86, "end_seconds": 3189.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Just an interjection." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000459", "start_seconds": 3189.86, "end_seconds": 3190.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Yes, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000460", "start_seconds": 3190.86, "end_seconds": 3195.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Stop muna the time of Congresswoman Co" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000461", "start_seconds": 3195.86, "end_seconds": 3201.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Have you exercised already the 120 days?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000462", "start_seconds": 3201.86, "end_seconds": 3209.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Because DBM would seem that they could not, you know, our country needs new judges." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000463", "start_seconds": 3209.86, "end_seconds": 3213.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "To those we have approved already for creation." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000464", "start_seconds": 3213.86, "end_seconds": 3215.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, have you already exercised that?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000465", "start_seconds": 3215.86, "end_seconds": 3217.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Because you should." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000466", "start_seconds": 3217.86, "end_seconds": 3219.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So that we can fill this up." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000467", "start_seconds": 3219.86, "end_seconds": 3222.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "We will not wait for the NOSCA." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000468", "start_seconds": 3222.86, "end_seconds": 3225.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "After all, you have fiscal independence, autonomy." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000469", "start_seconds": 3225.86, "end_seconds": 3228.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, what is the answer of the Administrator?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000470", "start_seconds": 3228.86, "end_seconds": 3237.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Your Honor, as of now, we have not yet exercised that right which is provided for by the Fiscal Autonomy Act." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000471", "start_seconds": 3237.86, "end_seconds": 3245.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Because the implementing rules and regulations are still undergoing review by the Supreme Court and Bank." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000472", "start_seconds": 3245.86, "end_seconds": 3248.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "It has already been submitted, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000473", "start_seconds": 3248.86, "end_seconds": 3252.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But anytime soon, it will be issued, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000474", "start_seconds": 3252.86, "end_seconds": 3260.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, we urge the Supreme Court itself to finish and promulgate the IRR for the law." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000475", "start_seconds": 3260.86, "end_seconds": 3266.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So that we can already open them because some courts, seven years na na-create." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000476", "start_seconds": 3266.86, "end_seconds": 3268.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Five to seven years." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000477", "start_seconds": 3268.86, "end_seconds": 3278.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "And that there is a felt need in many of these districts, cities and provinces for courts to already be organized." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000478", "start_seconds": 3278.86, "end_seconds": 3280.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Grabe na rin ang backlog eh." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000479", "start_seconds": 3280.86, "end_seconds": 3289.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, when can the Supreme Court, can one of the justices reply on when you will pass the IRR for that law?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000480", "start_seconds": 3289.86, "end_seconds": 3292.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So that you start already with your own NOSCA." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000481", "start_seconds": 3292.86, "end_seconds": 3295.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "And then, anyway, you have fiscal autonomy." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000482", "start_seconds": 3295.86, "end_seconds": 3300.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So that we can already give the required budget." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000483", "start_seconds": 3300.86, "end_seconds": 3302.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Who will answer?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000484", "start_seconds": 3302.86, "end_seconds": 3306.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "From the Honorable Associate Justice of the Supreme Court." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000485", "start_seconds": 3306.86, "end_seconds": 3310.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Justice Maidas." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000486", "start_seconds": 3310.42, "end_seconds": 3312.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Associate Justice Maidas Marquez." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000487", "start_seconds": 3312.42, "end_seconds": 3313.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "My good neighbor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000488", "start_seconds": 3313.42, "end_seconds": 3319.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Can you, therefore, give us a timeline?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000489", "start_seconds": 3319.42, "end_seconds": 3323.42, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "Yes, it has already been submitted to the court and bank." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000490", "start_seconds": 3323.42, "end_seconds": 3325.42, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "And it's being reviewed." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000491", "start_seconds": 3325.42, "end_seconds": 3328.42, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "So, naka-recess lang po ngayong September." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000492", "start_seconds": 3328.42, "end_seconds": 3337.42, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "Pagbalik po ng October, I'm all, we will, kaming tatlo po, we will, we will push for its approval already." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000493", "start_seconds": 3337.42, "end_seconds": 3345.42, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "Anyway, sir, yung provisions naman po ng IRR, well, yung law naman po, yung batas, yung RA 12233," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000494", "start_seconds": 3345.42, "end_seconds": 3350.42, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "some of these provisions here are self-implementing." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000495", "start_seconds": 3350.42, "end_seconds": 3365.42, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "So, kahit hindi po natin antayin yung IRR, pwede na po natin na gampanan yung ating mandato na maging fiscally autonomous ang judiciary." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000496", "start_seconds": 3365.42, "end_seconds": 3379.42, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "So, we can already proceed, no po, for, with the filling up of these courts and the court, maibigay sa JBC para mag, mag, mag ano na po, mabuksan na po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000497", "start_seconds": 3380.42, "end_seconds": 3387.42, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "Yung position for application for judges and thereafter, lalagyan na po natin ng mga court personnel yun." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000498", "start_seconds": 3387.42, "end_seconds": 3394.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you for the suggestion. So, Administrator, no need to wait for the IRR. You can proceed already." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000499", "start_seconds": 3394.42, "end_seconds": 3398.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Now, is that included in the budget now for 2027?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000500", "start_seconds": 3398.42, "end_seconds": 3408.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "In case you will do that this year, is that included for next year? It will have to wait 2027 for 2028." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000501", "start_seconds": 3408.42, "end_seconds": 3410.42, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Your Honor, the appropriation will come." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000502", "start_seconds": 3410.42, "end_seconds": 3418.42, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "It will come from the Department of Budget and Management because with the NOSCA should come the appropriation for it, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000503", "start_seconds": 3418.42, "end_seconds": 3428.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Precisely. The URS separate branch of government with fiscal autonomy. What we're saying, the law grants you Republic Act 12233." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000504", "start_seconds": 3428.42, "end_seconds": 3438.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "That authority, after 120 days passed, you may not wait for the DBM and just proceed with including them in your budget." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000505", "start_seconds": 3438.42, "end_seconds": 3443.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Because you are so authorized and your budget is automatic." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000506", "start_seconds": 3443.42, "end_seconds": 3449.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Like now, you see, we see that the budget is, all the proposal were approved." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000507", "start_seconds": 3449.42, "end_seconds": 3456.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "And there is no variance because precisely, we believe that you should have this autonomy." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000508", "start_seconds": 3456.42, "end_seconds": 3464.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, can we get a definite answer because many of our congressmen have pending like mine, Kageyende Oro, and Misami Serentel of DAS Bambiemano." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000509", "start_seconds": 3464.42, "end_seconds": 3466.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, so that we can already, you know." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000510", "start_seconds": 3466.42, "end_seconds": 3476.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Implement what the Congress has approved. May we know?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000511", "start_seconds": 3476.06, "end_seconds": 3487.06, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "Sir, yung implementation po kasi ng RA 12233, it is the first time that it is going to be implemented." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000512", "start_seconds": 3487.06, "end_seconds": 3495.06, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "So medyo nagkaroon lang po ng konting, I would say, confusion." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000513", "start_seconds": 3495.06, "end_seconds": 3497.06, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "Because it used to be that," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000514", "start_seconds": 3498.06, "end_seconds": 3502.06, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "we have to ask, we have to wait for DBM, no?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000515", "start_seconds": 3502.06, "end_seconds": 3506.06, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "To issue all these noscas and everything." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000516", "start_seconds": 3506.06, "end_seconds": 3516.06, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "But with the passage of RA 12233, we are of the belief that we can already program all these." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000517", "start_seconds": 3516.06, "end_seconds": 3522.06, "speaker": "Associate Justice Jose Midas P. Marquez", "text": "And then ask Congress for the funding of all these concerns." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000518", "start_seconds": 3522.06, "end_seconds": 3525.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "That's correct. Because we have positive law." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000519", "start_seconds": 3525.06, "end_seconds": 3528.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "And Justice Scalia of the United States Supreme Court," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000520", "start_seconds": 3528.06, "end_seconds": 3530.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "said that in the positive law, it's clear." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000521", "start_seconds": 3530.06, "end_seconds": 3533.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "It is not subject to any interpretation." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000522", "start_seconds": 3533.06, "end_seconds": 3534.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "You implement it." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000523", "start_seconds": 3534.06, "end_seconds": 3536.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "And it takes time talaga." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000524", "start_seconds": 3536.06, "end_seconds": 3539.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Is DBM here?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000525", "start_seconds": 3539.34, "end_seconds": 3541.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yeah, we have attendance of DBM." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000526", "start_seconds": 3541.34, "end_seconds": 3543.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Because I'd like to ask them now." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000527", "start_seconds": 3543.34, "end_seconds": 3548.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "On their position on this provision." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000528", "start_seconds": 3548.34, "end_seconds": 3551.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Because this is law already." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000529", "start_seconds": 3551.34, "end_seconds": 3556.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, I don't think DBM can question this law." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000530", "start_seconds": 3556.34, "end_seconds": 3558.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, kindly implement already this one." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000531", "start_seconds": 3558.34, "end_seconds": 3561.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Because the congressmen are waiting." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000532", "start_seconds": 3561.34, "end_seconds": 3563.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "They are the initial." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000533", "start_seconds": 3563.34, "end_seconds": 3566.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "They are the initiators of these bills." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000534", "start_seconds": 3566.34, "end_seconds": 3568.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "We have Director Carlos Castro." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000535", "start_seconds": 3568.34, "end_seconds": 3570.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Can you please take the floor?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000536", "start_seconds": 3570.34, "end_seconds": 3572.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Itong microphone nandiyan, no?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000537", "start_seconds": 3572.34, "end_seconds": 3574.34, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "120 po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000538", "start_seconds": 3574.34, "end_seconds": 3577.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Kasi mahirap na mag-run VATay dito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000539", "start_seconds": 3577.34, "end_seconds": 3580.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Ito tulak sa DBM." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000540", "start_seconds": 3580.34, "end_seconds": 3582.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Tulak na naman sa Supreme Court." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000541", "start_seconds": 3582.34, "end_seconds": 3585.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, Justice Marquez said that it can be implemented." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000542", "start_seconds": 3585.34, "end_seconds": 3587.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "But I think the better procedure is," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000543", "start_seconds": 3587.34, "end_seconds": 3589.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "you pass an IRR." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000544", "start_seconds": 3589.34, "end_seconds": 3591.58, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yeah." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000545", "start_seconds": 3591.58, "end_seconds": 3594.58, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, DBM, can you please shed light?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000546", "start_seconds": 3594.58, "end_seconds": 3595.58, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yeah." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000547", "start_seconds": 3595.58, "end_seconds": 3596.58, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Director Carlos, please." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000548", "start_seconds": 3596.58, "end_seconds": 3599.58, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Can you shed light on this, our new law?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000549", "start_seconds": 3600.0, "end_seconds": 3607.92, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and how you treat the submission of this uh proposed plantilla positions under your right" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000550", "start_seconds": 3607.92, "end_seconds": 3614.0, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "to have the nosca approved by dbm yeah okay please give a microphone if there's a microphone" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000551", "start_seconds": 3614.0, "end_seconds": 3619.35, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "director carlos yeah be in the center" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000551-split-2", "start_seconds": 3619.35, "end_seconds": 3622.72, "speaker": "DBM Budget and Management Bureau-D Director Carlos M. Castro", "text": "okay uh your honor good morning po carlo from dbm" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000552", "start_seconds": 3622.72, "end_seconds": 3643.92, "speaker": "DBM Budget and Management Bureau-D Director Carlos M. Castro", "text": "Sir, note lang po namin na kasama na po sa budget proposal po ng judiciary itong creation po ng mga positions po natin. For example, yung 46 family courts worth 541.103 million, additional Sharia district and circuit" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000553", "start_seconds": 3643.92, "end_seconds": 3651.6, "speaker": "DBM Budget and Management Bureau-D Director Carlos M. Castro", "text": "uh courts judges at large judicial judicial integrity office office of the regional court" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000554", "start_seconds": 3651.6, "end_seconds": 3652.16, "speaker": "DBM Budget and Management Bureau-D Director Carlos M. Castro", "text": "managers" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000555", "start_seconds": 3652.88, "end_seconds": 3667.12, "speaker": "DBM Budget and Management Bureau-D Director Carlos M. Castro", "text": "among others po. I-note lang po namin na per coordination din po sa aming counterpart, particularly sa Organization Position Classification Bureau, mayroon na lang po silang around" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000556", "start_seconds": 3667.12, "end_seconds": 3675.12, "speaker": "DBM Budget and Management Bureau-D Director Carlos M. Castro", "text": "three pending requests po as to the creation of positions po. Nevertheless" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000557", "start_seconds": 3675.12, "end_seconds": 3683.28, "speaker": "DBM Budget and Management Bureau-D Director Carlos M. Castro", "text": "kapag ito po ay na-fill upan po ng judiciary, meron naman po tayo, Your Honor, na mapagkukuwanan po ng pondo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000558", "start_seconds": 3683.28, "end_seconds": 3691.2, "speaker": "DBM Budget and Management Bureau-D Director Carlos M. Castro", "text": "po tayo mpbf or miscellaneous personal benefits fund na niri release dinaman po natin ito upon" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000559", "start_seconds": 3691.2, "end_seconds": 3699.84, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "request for judiciary so you don't have any opposition yes for the assumption of jurisdiction" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000560", "start_seconds": 3700.4, "end_seconds": 3706.72, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "on classification and salary levels of uh court judges and personnel it's all right for you" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000561", "start_seconds": 3706.72, "end_seconds": 3712.56, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "because that's the law that's the law director carlos and we all obey the law yes you are okay" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000562", "start_seconds": 3712.72, "end_seconds": 3719.36, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "so uh see uh response from the supreme court let us already take a proactive you know position on" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000563", "start_seconds": 3719.36, "end_seconds": 3725.12, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "this so that we will now open it open the courts and uh have you appoint the judges" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000564", "start_seconds": 3726.08, "end_seconds": 3733.44, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and uh to the abc and the appointment by the president so uh any comment from the justices or" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000565", "start_seconds": 3733.44, "end_seconds": 3742.48, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "administrator on the position of the uh yes yeah yeah yeah this is recognized yes i'm mr chair uh" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000566", "start_seconds": 3743.2, "end_seconds": 3746.64, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "Yes, Mr. Chair. With the permission of Justice Rodil Zalameda and Justice Midas Marquez," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000567", "start_seconds": 3749.12, "end_seconds": 3755.2, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "may I just clarify now with respect to our position, and of course in deference to our Court Administrator" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000568", "start_seconds": 3755.2, "end_seconds": 3762.08, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "deference to our court administrator who already explained the situation regarding these newly" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000569", "start_seconds": 3762.08, "end_seconds": 3770.08, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "created courts uh with new laws but uh not included in our proposal for 2027 because usually we wait" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000570", "start_seconds": 3770.08, "end_seconds": 3778.48, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "now that we expect that the irr will be approved by by perhaps october of this year mr chair" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000571", "start_seconds": 3779.04, "end_seconds": 3787.76, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "your honors and considering the fact that within the base on the based on ra12233" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000572", "start_seconds": 3787.76, "end_seconds": 3792.32, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "if there is no action with respect to our request for the issuance of an oscar" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000573", "start_seconds": 3792.32, "end_seconds": 3797.28, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "by the dbm this is considered as approved already and we can implement it so what we will do now" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000574", "start_seconds": 3797.28, "end_seconds": 3804.8, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "your honor is that uh through of course our court administrator we will add the amount that is" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000575", "start_seconds": 3804.8, "end_seconds": 3810.64, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "needed for all the newly created courts under the laws that have been passed already by congress" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000576", "start_seconds": 3810.64, "end_seconds": 3822.08, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "as of perhaps today your honor so that uh by 2027 we can already implement them even if the dbm" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000577", "start_seconds": 3822.08, "end_seconds": 3827.12, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "would not be able to act on it within the period required as provided for by law so what will" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000578", "start_seconds": 3827.12, "end_seconds": 3827.26, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "happen" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000579", "start_seconds": 3827.28, "end_seconds": 3833.34, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "happen now your honor is that we will just have to add an additional amount with respect to all" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000580", "start_seconds": 3833.34, "end_seconds": 3839.1, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "of these courts that have been created so far based on the laws passed by congress your honor" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000581", "start_seconds": 3839.1, "end_seconds": 3847.22, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "yeah but you have to be minded that the law provides for 120 days you can only add the courts" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000582", "start_seconds": 3847.22, "end_seconds": 3854.5, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "that you have requested the dbm but there is no action 120 days we cannot have all the approvals" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000583", "start_seconds": 3854.5, "end_seconds": 3859.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "but you have no requests we have to give a chance under the law to give a chance to the dbm to act" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000584", "start_seconds": 3859.86, "end_seconds": 3860.27, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "yes your honor" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000584-split-2", "start_seconds": 3860.27, "end_seconds": 3864.5, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "so can you submit to us yeah we are very much uh your honor congressman marlo" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000585", "start_seconds": 3864.5, "end_seconds": 3866.78, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "bangkoro" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000585-split-2", "start_seconds": 3866.78, "end_seconds": 3867.31, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "yes" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000585-split-3", "start_seconds": 3867.31, "end_seconds": 3869.89, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "that's that's why pending and all the rest" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000585-split-4", "start_seconds": 3869.89, "end_seconds": 3870.01, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "yeah" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000585-split-5", "start_seconds": 3870.01, "end_seconds": 3872.16, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "pending uh judges kasi wala na talagang judges e" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000585-split-6", "start_seconds": 3872.16, "end_seconds": 3873.44, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "yes sir" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000585-split-7", "start_seconds": 3873.44, "end_seconds": 3874.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "that's right" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000586", "start_seconds": 3874.06, "end_seconds": 3881.96, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "so can you therefore submit justice uh raul uh those that you have already submitted to dbm" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000587", "start_seconds": 3881.96, "end_seconds": 3884.08, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and 120 days have already" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000589", "start_seconds": 3884.08, "end_seconds": 3886.19, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "lapsed." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000589-split-2", "start_seconds": 3886.19, "end_seconds": 3892.36, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "Your Honor, yes, we will. I think that that can be done. May I just state that if we are to move" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000590", "start_seconds": 3892.36, "end_seconds": 3899.74, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "forward for example by next year uh there are also laws that we can already implement but if we do not" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000591", "start_seconds": 3899.74, "end_seconds": 3905.12, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "provide a budget for that that will mean that we will have to wait for another year for the nosca" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000592", "start_seconds": 3905.12, "end_seconds": 3911.24, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "to be uh issued or at least for us to be able to ask again funding from congress if you will allow" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000593", "start_seconds": 3911.24, "end_seconds": 3914.2799999999997, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "us your honor we will divide those that have" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000594", "start_seconds": 3914.2799999999997, "end_seconds": 3920.82, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "already been sub those laws wherein noscas have already been requested and also those uh laws where" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000595", "start_seconds": 3920.82, "end_seconds": 3927.86, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "noscas have yet to be requested and then submit the amounts that may be needed not to fund all of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000596", "start_seconds": 3927.86, "end_seconds": 3933.82, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "this your honor for the consideration of uh the committee and of course uh of the uh of congress" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000597", "start_seconds": 3933.82, "end_seconds": 3944.14, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "your honor for purposes of our budget for 2027. suggestion but we are premature because the dbm for" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000598", "start_seconds": 3944.14, "end_seconds": 3950.54, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "the succeeding ones may already approve it and if they're approved then that's the time that it" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000599", "start_seconds": 3950.54, "end_seconds": 3956.3, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "should be included so in other words you just include now we cannot be you know already proposing" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000600", "start_seconds": 3956.94, "end_seconds": 3964.62, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "uh for next year what has not been requested to the dbm it will as it will assume that dbm will" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000601", "start_seconds": 3964.62, "end_seconds": 3970.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "not act which is not the case because we would like the dbm to be given the chance so what we" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000602", "start_seconds": 3970.46, "end_seconds": 3977.18, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "would like to have now are those that have laps already so that first it will not be that much" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000603", "start_seconds": 3977.82, "end_seconds": 3984.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "because if we include everything approved by congress i'm lucky so like the fiscal space" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000604", "start_seconds": 3985.02, "end_seconds": 3990.38, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "may not allow us and our committee on appropriations to give all of those" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000605", "start_seconds": 3990.38, "end_seconds": 3998.62, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "amounts but now can you tell us how many positions you have given to the dbm as of today" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000606", "start_seconds": 4000.46, "end_seconds": 4007.82, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "that have been that the time of 120 days have lapsed so that my idea to be able to" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000607", "start_seconds": 4008.62, "end_seconds": 4016.94, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "include that in this year's budget just to uh to complete the discussion on this point your honor" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000608", "start_seconds": 4016.94, "end_seconds": 4023.82, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "uh this one is based on uh data already records there are 135 courts that need to be funded and" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000609", "start_seconds": 4023.82, "end_seconds": 4029.26, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "where in noscast have already been requested that's an additional 1.4 billion that's fine so" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000610", "start_seconds": 4029.26, "end_seconds": 4031.58, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "now what are those that have not been acted" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000611", "start_seconds": 4032.06, "end_seconds": 4036.34, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "120 days by the dbm so that you can now proceed" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000611-split-2", "start_seconds": 4036.34, "end_seconds": 4040.62, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "how many okay all of this 135 your honor" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000612", "start_seconds": 4040.62, "end_seconds": 4044.94, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "because it was submitted already prior to today's uh uh today's uh deliberation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000613", "start_seconds": 4047.82, "end_seconds": 4050.575, "speaker": "Associate Justice Raul B. Villanueva", "text": "submitted to the dbm your honor" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000613-split-2", "start_seconds": 4050.575, "end_seconds": 4051.9, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "so you have included that or you're going to request" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000614", "start_seconds": 4051.9, "end_seconds": 4056.86, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "yes additional requests please submit to the committee that additional request for those" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000615", "start_seconds": 4056.86, "end_seconds": 4062.62, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "approved by the dbm thank you very much so it's clear please proceed the congresswoman renee" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000616", "start_seconds": 4062.62, "end_seconds": 4063.7, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Sorry for the interruption." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000616-split-2", "start_seconds": 4063.7, "end_seconds": 4076.54, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "No, it's okay, Mr. Chair. Ang punto naman po ay ayaw natin yung absurd na scenario na may 400 plus judges na kailangan pero seven lang po yung [unclear]. At least ngayon ay may effort na punan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000617", "start_seconds": 4076.54, "end_seconds": 4086.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Pero I hope po na after nito ay ma-assert yung fiscal independence ng judiciary para po mapunan very quickly" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000618", "start_seconds": 4086.86, "end_seconds": 4103.5, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "yung mga pangangailangan po sa mga rehiyon ng mga judges for the clearance of these cases. Ang isa rin pong gusto kong itanong ay ang nagpapababa ng number of judges sa judiciary ay killings." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000619", "start_seconds": 4103.5, "end_seconds": 4107.02, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Unfortunately, up until now, ito ay observable sa buong legal profession." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000620", "start_seconds": 4109.34, "end_seconds": 4116.14, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "so but the office of the judiciary marshal reports only 35 security operations and reliance on pmp" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000621", "start_seconds": 4116.14, "end_seconds": 4116.62, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "details" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000622", "start_seconds": 4117.1, "end_seconds": 4122.46, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "while human rights groups continue to document extrajudicial killings of judges and lawyers" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000623", "start_seconds": 4122.46, "end_seconds": 4135.18, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "So may I ask from the judiciary, with its proposed budget increased by 15 billion, meron po bang pag-address ng root causes na ito, na na-investigahan po ba?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000624", "start_seconds": 4135.18, "end_seconds": 4142.14, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "May investigation po bang ongoing yung judiciary sa mga killings, threats, attacks against its judges" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000625", "start_seconds": 4142.14, "end_seconds": 4142.86, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "And may number po ba sila" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000626", "start_seconds": 4143.74, "end_seconds": 4151.5, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "ng judges na naging biktima ng ganitong EJK o attacks?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000627", "start_seconds": 4161.47, "end_seconds": 4167.87, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "your your honor um the office of the judiciary marshalls is still being filled" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000628", "start_seconds": 4167.87, "end_seconds": 4171.3099999999995, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "The positions are still being filled. So although there are" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000629", "start_seconds": 4171.3099999999995, "end_seconds": 4173.79, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "perennial problems or requests" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000630", "start_seconds": 4173.79, "end_seconds": 4175.75, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "insofar as" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000631", "start_seconds": 4175.75, "end_seconds": 4179.91, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "security risks and security threats are concerned," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000632", "start_seconds": 4180.05, "end_seconds": 4183.53, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "to which our judiciary marshals have always answered to." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000633", "start_seconds": 4184.91, "end_seconds": 4189.23, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Without the number of people filling in the plantelia," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000634", "start_seconds": 4189.65, "end_seconds": 4193.73, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "it will be hard to create, as of now, what the programs are." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000635", "start_seconds": 4193.97, "end_seconds": 4197.11, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But I would like to think that when it comes to security threats," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000636", "start_seconds": 4197.27, "end_seconds": 4203.57, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "security assistance that need to be given to our judges who are at risk" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000637", "start_seconds": 4203.57, "end_seconds": 4208.57, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "insofar as their duties in their adjudicative functions are concerned," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000638", "start_seconds": 4208.91, "end_seconds": 4210.37, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the OJM is on it." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000639", "start_seconds": 4210.71, "end_seconds": 4215.35, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But it is unfortunate that they are heavily reliant on the Philippine National Police" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000640", "start_seconds": 4215.35, "end_seconds": 4217.37, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "or the National Bureau of Investigation," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000641", "start_seconds": 4217.83, "end_seconds": 4221.85, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "which is about time that we do need to fill in the plantelia level" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000642", "start_seconds": 4221.85, "end_seconds": 4225.51, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "so that we rely on our own people, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000643", "start_seconds": 4225.51, "end_seconds": 4229.32, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Baka pwede rin po ma-submit yung ilan po ba kailangan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000644", "start_seconds": 4229.5, "end_seconds": 4230.66, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes po. Meron po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000645", "start_seconds": 4231.02, "end_seconds": 4233.01, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "As to my question po, Mr. Chair," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000646", "start_seconds": 4233.01, "end_seconds": 4237.18, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "may investigation po ba independently na ginagawa ang judiciary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000647", "start_seconds": 4237.18, "end_seconds": 4241.97, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "tungkol sa mga threats na 'to, to its judges, to maybe the legal profession," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000648", "start_seconds": 4242.0, "end_seconds": 4245.01, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "na hindi lang po essentially ino-offload sa NBI?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000649", "start_seconds": 4245.12, "end_seconds": 4246.0, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Meron po ba?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000650", "start_seconds": 4246.0, "end_seconds": 4248.9, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Meron po, pero sa pagkakaalam ko po," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000651", "start_seconds": 4249.0, "end_seconds": 4254.5, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "lagi pong kasama ang NBI or PNP dahil wala pa po kaming nararapat or" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000652", "start_seconds": 4254.5, "end_seconds": 4258.63, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "sufficient na manpower to do our own investigative work." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000653", "start_seconds": 4258.63, "end_seconds": 4261.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So if you can, kung ang suporta po ay" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000654", "start_seconds": 4261.4, "end_seconds": 4265.94, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "yung request po ng OJM para pagdating po sa plantilla level" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000655", "start_seconds": 4265.94, "end_seconds": 4269.74, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "ay mapunan po, malaking bagay po iyon para sa amin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000656", "start_seconds": 4269.74, "end_seconds": 4276.44, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Mr. Chair, maaari po ba rin maka-request ng report ng mga naharap na mga threats, no," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000657", "start_seconds": 4276.44, "end_seconds": 4283.23, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "and even mga naging biktima ng EJK from the ranks of the judiciary?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000658", "start_seconds": 4283.23, "end_seconds": 4283.73, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000659", "start_seconds": 4283.73, "end_seconds": 4287.59, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Mr. Chair, can that be submitted before plenary deliberations of the judiciary?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000660", "start_seconds": 4287.59, "end_seconds": 4288.35, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000661", "start_seconds": 4288.35, "end_seconds": 4288.85, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Okay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000662", "start_seconds": 4288.85, "end_seconds": 4292.85, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "May we know, Your Honor, kung hanggang yung umpisa po ng taon," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000664", "start_seconds": 4293.01, "end_seconds": 4295.01, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "hanggang 2026," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000666", "start_seconds": 4295.45, "end_seconds": 4300.65, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "yung period po that you want po pagdating sa extrajudicial killings ang ating judges?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000667", "start_seconds": 4300.65, "end_seconds": 4304.5, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Maaari po ba yung last year?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000667-split-2", "start_seconds": 4304.5, "end_seconds": 4307.39, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Yes, since 2025." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000668", "start_seconds": 4307.39, "end_seconds": 4313.29, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "All the way to 2026. We can submit a written request naman po, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000669", "start_seconds": 4313.29, "end_seconds": 4315.29, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ng extrajudicial killings, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000670", "start_seconds": 4315.29, "end_seconds": 4319.71, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "And attacks and threats to the lives of... Sige, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000671", "start_seconds": 4319.71, "end_seconds": 4321.71, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Last question, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000672", "start_seconds": 4321.71, "end_seconds": 4322.85, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yes, please proceed." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000673", "start_seconds": 4322.85, "end_seconds": 4334.1900000000005, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Meron lang pong mga writs na continuously available as remedies to those that are aggrieved." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000674", "start_seconds": 4334.1900000000005, "end_seconds": 4339.43, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Pero up until now, for example, the writ of amparo, writ of habeas data," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000675", "start_seconds": 4339.43, "end_seconds": 4347.41, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "ay nahihirapan po yung mga nag-a-apply dito para makuha yung remedies na available sana dito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000676", "start_seconds": 4347.41, "end_seconds": 4352.6900000000005, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "And meron pong writ of kalayaan na since 2022, ang reports natin ay" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000677", "start_seconds": 4352.6900000000005, "end_seconds": 4355.51, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "sana maipasa na siya next year, next year, next year." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000678", "start_seconds": 4355.51, "end_seconds": 4357.55, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Pero hanggang ngayon wala pa rin po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000679", "start_seconds": 4357.55, "end_seconds": 4364.83, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Meron po bang updates sa pagsasagawa ng rules and guidelines para sa writ of kalayaan?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000680", "start_seconds": 4364.83, "end_seconds": 4371.45, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "At sa pag-update at pagpapalakas ng writ of amparo at writ of habeas data?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000681", "start_seconds": 4374.27, "end_seconds": 4381.63, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "All right. There are several revisions now ongoing by the Supreme Court en banc with its respective committees," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000683", "start_seconds": 4382.13, "end_seconds": 4389.57, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "in revising the rules on Amparo and HBS data, and all other rules, Kalikasan, all of them." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000684", "start_seconds": 4390.41, "end_seconds": 4398.05, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, it's actually part of the revision of the rules as part of the strategic plan for judicial innovation." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000685", "start_seconds": 4399.58, "end_seconds": 4404.95, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "So we... Kailan po inaasahan na ma-implement, maipasa yung guidelines na ito, Mr. Chair?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000686", "start_seconds": 4405.1900000000005, "end_seconds": 4410.97, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We hope that they be passed actually before our Honorable Chief Justice retires by November 6." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000687", "start_seconds": 4410.97, "end_seconds": 4417.47, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, asahan po natin in the next two months. Marami po actually nakalatag na po sa NBank." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000688", "start_seconds": 4417.97, "end_seconds": 4424.1900000000005, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, rules on civil procedure, rules on criminal procedure, ito pong rules sa mga rates of Amparo, HBS data," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000689", "start_seconds": 4424.53, "end_seconds": 4430.83, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "para mapunan yung mga procedural gaps, and hopefully before the Chief Justice retires." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000690", "start_seconds": 4430.97, "end_seconds": 4436.07, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Yung rate of kalayaan po ba ay kasama sa ma-isusumite by November 2026?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000691", "start_seconds": 4438.22, "end_seconds": 4440.14, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kasama po ang rate of kalayaan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000692", "start_seconds": 4440.14, "end_seconds": 4442.18, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Okay, we look forward to it po, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000693", "start_seconds": 4442.26, "end_seconds": 4444.5, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "And we hope na maipasa siya sa pinakakagyat." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000694", "start_seconds": 4444.76, "end_seconds": 4447.28, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Maari po ba makasabit ng draft if maari?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000695", "start_seconds": 4447.88, "end_seconds": 4450.02, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Draft? Hindi. Draft daw po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000696", "start_seconds": 4454.52, "end_seconds": 4458.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "It will be, excuse me, drafts are still internal." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000697", "start_seconds": 4459.34, "end_seconds": 4461.48, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, we cannot demand a draft." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000698", "start_seconds": 4462.32, "end_seconds": 4468.32, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "In our laws, these are just internal, but once it is approved, we can get copies." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000699", "start_seconds": 4468.62, "end_seconds": 4469.02, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Yes, po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000700", "start_seconds": 4469.02, "end_seconds": 4471.08, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Okay, so, are you winding up already?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000701", "start_seconds": 4471.5, "end_seconds": 4471.9, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Yes, po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000702", "start_seconds": 4471.9, "end_seconds": 4472.38, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Are you satisfied?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000703", "start_seconds": 4472.38, "end_seconds": 4474.08, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "That's my final question, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000704", "start_seconds": 4475.0599999999995, "end_seconds": 4479.26, "speaker": "Rep. Renee Louise M. Co", "text": "Na i-communicate na lang na reports na pwedeng ma-submit, ma-submit po, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000705", "start_seconds": 4479.36, "end_seconds": 4479.64, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you very much." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000706", "start_seconds": 4479.64, "end_seconds": 4485.9, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Please kindly submit all the requested materials by the Honorable Congresswoman Rene Co." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000707", "start_seconds": 4486.4, "end_seconds": 4489.0, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "But drafts cannot be demanded from any agency." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000708", "start_seconds": 4489.62, "end_seconds": 4491.58, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "They are still internal, still a draft." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000709", "start_seconds": 4491.84, "end_seconds": 4497.0, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "After you finish that, first thing you do, you submit to Congresswoman Rene Co." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000710", "start_seconds": 4497.5, "end_seconds": 4499.28, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, understood, Mr. Chair. Thank you, po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000711", "start_seconds": 4499.3, "end_seconds": 4499.6, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000712", "start_seconds": 4500.0, "end_seconds": 4511.68, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you. And now we would like to acknowledge, before the next interpellator, let me acknowledge the new members who have come to attend our budget hearing." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000713", "start_seconds": 4511.68, "end_seconds": 4526.3, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "First, the Representative Carl Legaspi. Then we have Congressman, my brother of Abante Mindanao Party List, Representative Maximo Rodriguez, Jr." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000714", "start_seconds": 4526.3, "end_seconds": 4537.28, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Next is Vice Chair, Keith Mika, Attorney Mike Tan. He'll be back. Then, of course, my good friend, Representative Amado Carlos Bolivia." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000715", "start_seconds": 4538.46, "end_seconds": 4552.38, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Then we have Representative Julio Cesar J. Vergara over there. Representative Sarah Jane Elago is here. And, of course, Representative Maria Teresa Talavera Lopez. Thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000716", "start_seconds": 4552.38, "end_seconds": 4555.38, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you. Now we'd like to acknowledge our..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000717", "start_seconds": 4556.3, "end_seconds": 4566.14, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Our representative, you know, ang naiwan dito are all Mindanao, no? So, be careful about answering Mindanao, including the Chairman." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000718", "start_seconds": 4566.7, "end_seconds": 4572.78, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Lias Bambi was here also a while ago. So, Congressman Tracy Cagas, the floor is yours." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000719", "start_seconds": 4573.48, "end_seconds": 4578.2, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Thank you, Mr. Chair. Bangadang umaga po sa ating lahat." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000720", "start_seconds": 4578.52, "end_seconds": 4579.24, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Maganda umaga po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000721", "start_seconds": 4579.24, "end_seconds": 4580.5, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Public servant." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000722", "start_seconds": 4580.5, "end_seconds": 4593.54, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "I know you'll agree with me that everything boils down to trust. Lahat ng mga ano natin ay pagtitiwala." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000723", "start_seconds": 4594.28, "end_seconds": 4602.22, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Pagtitiwala sa executive branch, sa legislative branch, saka sa judiciary. These are the..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000724", "start_seconds": 4602.22, "end_seconds": 4604.76, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "What do you call it? Yung pagtakbo sa ating goberno." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000725", "start_seconds": 4606.32, "end_seconds": 4610.58, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "I would like to commend the SPUR report." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000726", "start_seconds": 4611.08, "end_seconds": 4611.78, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "The..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000727", "start_seconds": 4611.78, "end_seconds": 4612.76, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "For your..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000728", "start_seconds": 4612.96, "end_seconds": 4626.38, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "performance, lalo na sa mga disposition of cases, sa Court of Tax Appeals, Sandigan Bayan," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000729", "start_seconds": 4626.38, "end_seconds": 4638.28, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "and Court of Appeals, for the accomplice rate, sobra-sobra, for CA, 130%, Sandigan Bayan," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000730", "start_seconds": 4638.28, "end_seconds": 4644.64, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "178%, and the Court of Tax Appeals, 197%." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000731", "start_seconds": 4644.64, "end_seconds": 4656.22, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, siguro, nakikita ko sa report nyo yung RTC backlogs, mas yung medyo malaki." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000732", "start_seconds": 4656.98, "end_seconds": 4664.8, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, ito din sa Supreme Court, like to ask, yung backlog ninyo, although it's very commendable," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000733", "start_seconds": 4667.16, "end_seconds": 4667.84, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "81%." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000734", "start_seconds": 4667.84, "end_seconds": 4668.8, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Ah, yung ano, 89%." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000735", "start_seconds": 4669.72, "end_seconds": 4679.02, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "As of June, so, meron pa kayong 16,509 cases na i-resolve." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000736", "start_seconds": 4680.36, "end_seconds": 4690.2, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, siguro, naintindihan ko, no, na may mga kaso na hindi ma-resolve agad-agad." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000737", "start_seconds": 4690.2, "end_seconds": 4699.56, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "But, what I'm appealing, this presentation, is yung mga, without mentioning cases," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000738", "start_seconds": 4699.72, "end_seconds": 4703.52, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "and name of cases, I don't want to touch on subjudice rule, no." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000739", "start_seconds": 4704.14, "end_seconds": 4715.16, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, sa akin lang, itong mga election cases, no, where status quo, anti-order was issued by the Supreme Court," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000740", "start_seconds": 4715.9, "end_seconds": 4720.56, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "eh, hanggang kailan ba yung mga ganong order?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000741", "start_seconds": 4720.9, "end_seconds": 4726.92, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Kailangan ba dadaan ng isang taon, na hanggang ngayon wala pang resolution, no?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000742", "start_seconds": 4726.92, "end_seconds": 4729.6, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Because, as I said, it boils down to trust, no." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000743", "start_seconds": 4729.72, "end_seconds": 4733.14, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Ah, what can you say about it?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000744", "start_seconds": 4733.14, "end_seconds": 4741.46, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Yung mga election cases, na hanggang ngayon, na bin-bin pa, o hindi pa na-rapple, even na-rapple, no, status quo, anti-order pa rin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000745", "start_seconds": 4742.94, "end_seconds": 4746.68, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Please answer, our Court Administrator, Estuesta." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000746", "start_seconds": 4756.86, "end_seconds": 4767.36, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Your Honor, insofar as election cases are concerned, which was filed pursuant to Rule 64, in relation to Rule 65," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000747", "start_seconds": 4767.36, "end_seconds": 4768.36, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "there is the..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000748", "start_seconds": 4769.04, "end_seconds": 4775.42, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "a procedure that is usually conducted, or a procedure that is observed by the Supreme Court," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000749", "start_seconds": 4775.52, "end_seconds": 4779.94, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "which is, number one, requiring the parties to comment on the same." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000750", "start_seconds": 4780.4, "end_seconds": 4788.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And once the decolation of those pleadings are made, then it is subjected or assigned to a ponente," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000751", "start_seconds": 4788.68, "end_seconds": 4792.7, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "and then subjected to deliberation by the division, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000752", "start_seconds": 4794.97, "end_seconds": 4797.55, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Thank you, Court Admin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000753", "start_seconds": 4799.59, "end_seconds": 4800.35, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Alam natin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000754", "start_seconds": 4800.41, "end_seconds": 4811.77, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Alam natin na lalo sa local government unit, hanggang three years lang yung term. So, as I said, na-file na yung kaso." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000755", "start_seconds": 4812.89, "end_seconds": 4814.97, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "It was..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000756", "start_seconds": 4814.97, "end_seconds": 4815.61, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Comelec, no?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000757", "start_seconds": 4815.65, "end_seconds": 4818.29, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Comelec, in bank resolution, dumating sa Supreme Court." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000758", "start_seconds": 4818.93, "end_seconds": 4820.23, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, it's now..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000759", "start_seconds": 4820.23, "end_seconds": 4822.99, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "nasa kamay na ng Korte Suprema." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000760", "start_seconds": 4823.51, "end_seconds": 4826.05, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, may appeal, no?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000761", "start_seconds": 4826.05, "end_seconds": 4828.99, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "As I said, without touching the issues." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000762", "start_seconds": 4830.41, "end_seconds": 4834.83, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Just, ano, gawin lang natin ating trabaho." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000763", "start_seconds": 4835.07, "end_seconds": 4836.17, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Just do our job." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000764", "start_seconds": 4838.05, "end_seconds": 4843.93, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Let's turn the wheels of justice, turn, ano ba, para naman masimulan, no?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000765", "start_seconds": 4844.13, "end_seconds": 4845.01, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Kahit na..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000766", "start_seconds": 4845.01, "end_seconds": 4845.93, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Because tagal-tagal na yan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000767", "start_seconds": 4845.99, "end_seconds": 4847.07, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Almost a year na ito, eh." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000768", "start_seconds": 4847.55, "end_seconds": 4849.85, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, yun lang po ang ano ko sa inyo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000769", "start_seconds": 4850.45, "end_seconds": 4859.37, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "I admire the Court, mga Korte Suprema, the Honorable Justice of the Supreme Court." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000770", "start_seconds": 4859.37, "end_seconds": 4860.21, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "I do." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000771", "start_seconds": 4860.41, "end_seconds": 4861.41, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, yun lang po kayo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000772", "start_seconds": 4861.41, "end_seconds": 4871.17, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "No, but just keep my, you know, my, what do you call it, idealism, para gusto ko matuloy-tuloy yung ano ko, ba." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000773", "start_seconds": 4871.17, "end_seconds": 4874.71, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "I don't want to entertain any, ano ba, mga hukus-hukus." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000774", "start_seconds": 4874.71, "end_seconds": 4885.15, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, yun lang po ang ano ko sa mga kay Justice Villanueva, andito ngayon, Justice Marquez, Justice Salameda." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000775", "start_seconds": 4885.15, "end_seconds": 4889.07, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, I hope you can relay that to your fellow justices, no?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000776", "start_seconds": 4889.07, "end_seconds": 4889.57, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Na..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000778", "start_seconds": 4889.77, "end_seconds": 4890.27, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Na..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000780", "start_seconds": 4891.03, "end_seconds": 4894.87, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So, okay. May I proceed with my second..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000781", "start_seconds": 4894.87, "end_seconds": 4902.93, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Before you proceed, so there is really the request of our Vice Chairman, John Tracy Cagas." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000782", "start_seconds": 4904.15, "end_seconds": 4912.05, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Pag-election cases, we are limited by three terms, our three-year term for congressmen and the local officials." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000783", "start_seconds": 4912.05, "end_seconds": 4919.59, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So, the request is that the Supreme Court will have a procedure to fast-track these cases." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000784", "start_seconds": 4920.27, "end_seconds": 4921.11, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Kasi kung late nga eh," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000785", "start_seconds": 4921.11, "end_seconds": 4921.71, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "wala na, tapos na yung" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000786", "start_seconds": 4921.71, "end_seconds": 4922.65, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "term." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000787", "start_seconds": 4924.03, "end_seconds": 4925.45, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So ganoon ang request." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000788", "start_seconds": 4925.45, "end_seconds": 4930.05, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "I think you should give give them, what case is that?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000789", "start_seconds": 4930.79, "end_seconds": 4935.43, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Because this is already appending, ano, part of your request." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000790", "start_seconds": 4935.43, "end_seconds": 4936.43, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000791", "start_seconds": 4936.43, "end_seconds": 4938.41, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "He will give that after, after the hearing." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000792", "start_seconds": 4938.41, "end_seconds": 4938.91, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000793", "start_seconds": 4938.91, "end_seconds": 4939.41, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "I mean..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000794", "start_seconds": 4939.41, "end_seconds": 4942.05, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "I mean uh, these are facts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000795", "start_seconds": 4942.05, "end_seconds": 4945.89, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "On the request that are present in uh..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000796", "start_seconds": 4945.89, "end_seconds": 4946.89, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "the congressman." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000797", "start_seconds": 4946.89, "end_seconds": 4948.17, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Please proceed with the second one, okay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000798", "start_seconds": 4948.17, "end_seconds": 4951.47, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "May I be allowed, Your Honor, just to" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000804", "start_seconds": 4951.47, "end_seconds": 4958.43, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "keep the idealism of our honorable representative john tracy kagas in so far as the election protest" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000805", "start_seconds": 4958.43, "end_seconds": 4963.47, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "or brought up on the rule 64 and 65 with the supreme court i have here the three members of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000806", "start_seconds": 4963.47, "end_seconds": 4969.79, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "the supreme court your honor assuring you your honor that they are made aware of the time-bound" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000807", "start_seconds": 4969.79, "end_seconds": 4976.27, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "uh petition with which an election protest is and that hopefully your honor that election protest" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000808", "start_seconds": 4976.27, "end_seconds": 4982.91, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "case be resolved even before for the next election thank you your honor uh thank you for the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000809", "start_seconds": 4982.91, "end_seconds": 4989.79, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "assurance uh justices salamat okay may i proceed now to my second point uh young uh" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000810", "start_seconds": 4991.87, "end_seconds": 4999.0, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Hall of Justice buildings. Doon sa amin, matagal na yun. May lupa na kami." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000811", "start_seconds": 4999.0, "end_seconds": 5005.0, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "We have a lot. Problema yung building." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000812", "start_seconds": 5005.0, "end_seconds": 5014.6, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So you do not have to purchase a lot anymore. Building na lang. Maliit yung request namin, only about 150 million pesos" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000813", "start_seconds": 5014.6, "end_seconds": 5027.71, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "yung cost of constructing that. So we really need it. Sana mabigyan pansin ninyo yung distrito ko, Davao del Sur." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000814", "start_seconds": 5027.71, "end_seconds": 5030.52, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "House of Justice." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000814-split-2", "start_seconds": 5030.52, "end_seconds": 5032.14, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000814-split-4", "start_seconds": 5032.14, "end_seconds": 5034.2, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Response? Yes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000814-split-3", "start_seconds": 5034.2, "end_seconds": 5042.8, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Court Administrator, only 150 million. Davao del Sur needs that new House of Justice." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000815", "start_seconds": 5042.8, "end_seconds": 5046.0, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, yes, Your Honor, we've actually given the indicative" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000816", "start_seconds": 5046.0, "end_seconds": 5052.5599999999995, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "budget cost for the construction of the hoj your honor if it is in a 5000 square meter property" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000817", "start_seconds": 5052.5599999999995, "end_seconds": 5056.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "it is in the amount of 500 million pesos your honor" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000818", "start_seconds": 5061.92, "end_seconds": 5064.4, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Ah hindi, unlike Cagayan de Oro, okay lang sa amin 150 million." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000819", "start_seconds": 5066.0, "end_seconds": 5066.8, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Ano lang yun," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000820", "start_seconds": 5068.16, "end_seconds": 5072.16, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "one story lang, kasi ayaw namin ng mataas na building dahil sa lindol." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000821", "start_seconds": 5072.16, "end_seconds": 5078.16, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Na-trauma yung mga tao doon, ayaw na nila ng matataas na building kasi maraming fault line sa amin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000822", "start_seconds": 5078.16, "end_seconds": 5082.16, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So okay lang sa amin, 150 million, sapat na yun sa amin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000823", "start_seconds": 5082.16, "end_seconds": 5092.16, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "So please revise. They do not want a two- or three-story building, just a one-story building at 150 million." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000824", "start_seconds": 5092.16, "end_seconds": 5093.16, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, sir." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000825", "start_seconds": 5093.16, "end_seconds": 5095.16, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Can you kindly include that in the request?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000826", "start_seconds": 5095.16, "end_seconds": 5096.16, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, sir." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000827", "start_seconds": 5096.16, "end_seconds": 5099.16, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "We're going to strongly recommend that to the Committee on Justice." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000828", "start_seconds": 5099.16, "end_seconds": 5100.16, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000829", "start_seconds": 5100.16, "end_seconds": 5101.16, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We will look for a funding." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000830", "start_seconds": 5101.16, "end_seconds": 5104.16, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "I have likewise the assurance of the Honorable Raul Villanueva." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000831", "start_seconds": 5104.16, "end_seconds": 5110.16, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We will realign our funds for the same, Your Honor, if it's just 150 million as requested." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000832", "start_seconds": 5110.16, "end_seconds": 5115.04, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Last point." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000833", "start_seconds": 5115.04, "end_seconds": 5122.04, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "We have a court that has just been created, but there is still no NOSCA." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000834", "start_seconds": 5122.04, "end_seconds": 5129.04, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "But after hearing the discussion today, I don't want to pursue it in detail." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000835", "start_seconds": 5129.04, "end_seconds": 5134.04, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "I'm enlightened that there is a way." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000836", "start_seconds": 5134.04, "end_seconds": 5137.04, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "It's been a long time, about two years." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000837", "start_seconds": 5137.04, "end_seconds": 5141.04, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Until now, it's still unfilled, unorganized." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000838", "start_seconds": 5141.04, "end_seconds": 5144.04, "speaker": "Rep. John Tracy F. Cagas", "text": "Okay, maraming salamat po. Mabuhay po ang Korte Suprema." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000839", "start_seconds": 5144.04, "end_seconds": 5146.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you very much, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000840", "start_seconds": 5146.04, "end_seconds": 5150.04, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you, Congressman John Tracy Cagas." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000841", "start_seconds": 5150.04, "end_seconds": 5158.04, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Before we proceed with the next interpellator, let me recognize additional members who are present today." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000842", "start_seconds": 5158.04, "end_seconds": 5163.04, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "And we have Congressman Edgar Egay Elise." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000843", "start_seconds": 5163.04, "end_seconds": 5166.04, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Over there, the handsome gentleman there." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000844", "start_seconds": 5166.04, "end_seconds": 5174.57, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "And of course, we have Representative King Richard Gomez." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000845", "start_seconds": 5174.57, "end_seconds": 5181.57, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Next to interpellate from the minority is Representative Sara Ilago. The floor is yours." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000846", "start_seconds": 5181.57, "end_seconds": 5187.04, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Thank you, Mr. Chair, and a pleasant day to the judiciary." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000847", "start_seconds": 5187.04, "end_seconds": 5190.04, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Greetings from Gabriela Women's Party." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000848", "start_seconds": 5190.04, "end_seconds": 5192.04, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "First, the Supreme Court." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000849", "start_seconds": 5192.04, "end_seconds": 5199.04, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "The Supreme Court's strategic plan for judicial innovations is from the years 2022 to 2027." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000850", "start_seconds": 5199.04, "end_seconds": 5209.04, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "And considering that it's already the middle of the year 2026, is the schedule for the SC's strategic plans on time?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000851", "start_seconds": 5209.04, "end_seconds": 5211.04, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Is the plan still on track?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000852", "start_seconds": 5211.04, "end_seconds": 5217.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, Your Honor. It's actually highlighted by the digital infrastructure of our courts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000853", "start_seconds": 5217.04, "end_seconds": 5220.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "2027 is actually a very critical year for the Supreme Court." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000854", "start_seconds": 5220.04, "end_seconds": 5235.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Because it will spell the transition between the SPJI as defined by the Honorable Chief Justice and the new Chief Justice to be appointed by the President of the Philippines." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000855", "start_seconds": 5235.04, "end_seconds": 5242.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So that the transition reflects the budget proposals that we have for 2027." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000856", "start_seconds": 5242.04, "end_seconds": 5249.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So that it opens a gateway for the next projects to be had by the new Chief Justice." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000857", "start_seconds": 5250.04, "end_seconds": 5261.04, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Mr. Chair, meron po bang specific activities in the SPJI na nag-i-integrate ng gender and development mandate?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000858", "start_seconds": 5261.04, "end_seconds": 5262.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000859", "start_seconds": 5262.04, "end_seconds": 5269.46, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "At maaari ho itong maibahagi ng ating judiciary?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000860", "start_seconds": 5269.46, "end_seconds": 5279.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Very much, Your Honor, because there is the biggest membership, actually, of the committee in the Supreme Court is on gender and responsiveness." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000861", "start_seconds": 5279.46, "end_seconds": 5282.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So we just go beyond." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000862", "start_seconds": 5282.46, "end_seconds": 5294.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We just go beyond from orienting employees of what gender sensitivity and gender sensitivity training is." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000863", "start_seconds": 5294.46, "end_seconds": 5297.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But we have identified several projects." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000864", "start_seconds": 5297.46, "end_seconds": 5299.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "I just do not have the list with me, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000865", "start_seconds": 5299.46, "end_seconds": 5304.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But the committee is very much active in identifying those projects." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000866", "start_seconds": 5304.46, "end_seconds": 5308.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "It is said that this is headed by, actually, Justice Jenny Ong." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000867", "start_seconds": 5308.46, "end_seconds": 5310.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Would you..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000868", "start_seconds": 5310.46, "end_seconds": 5311.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "May she be..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000869", "start_seconds": 5311.46, "end_seconds": 5314.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Recognize, Your Honor, because she is really an active member." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000870", "start_seconds": 5314.46, "end_seconds": 5316.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Would you know?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000871", "start_seconds": 5316.46, "end_seconds": 5317.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000872", "start_seconds": 5317.46, "end_seconds": 5318.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "You are recognized?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000873", "start_seconds": 5318.46, "end_seconds": 5319.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Justice Ong." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000874", "start_seconds": 5319.46, "end_seconds": 5320.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Justice Ong." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000875", "start_seconds": 5320.46, "end_seconds": 5321.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000876", "start_seconds": 5321.46, "end_seconds": 5322.46, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "Good morning, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000877", "start_seconds": 5322.46, "end_seconds": 5323.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Please proceed." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000878", "start_seconds": 5323.46, "end_seconds": 5325.83, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Good morning." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000879", "start_seconds": 5325.83, "end_seconds": 5326.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "Thank you for the question." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000880", "start_seconds": 5326.83, "end_seconds": 5340.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "So under the CGRJ, or the Committee on Gender Responsiveness in the Judiciary, headed by three Supreme Court Justices, Justice J.P. Inting, Justice Yolo Lopez, and Justice Monette Singh." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000881", "start_seconds": 5340.83, "end_seconds": 5344.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "There have already been several activities that have been done." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000882", "start_seconds": 5344.83, "end_seconds": 5350.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "So we have institutionalized gender sensitivity training among the different courts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000883", "start_seconds": 5350.83, "end_seconds": 5357.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "So it's being done not only for the judges, but also for the court personnel from the top to bottom." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000884", "start_seconds": 5357.83, "end_seconds": 5363.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "So even our utility workers in the court, we have this gender sensitivity training." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000885", "start_seconds": 5363.83, "end_seconds": 5368.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "And we also have gender fair language, which is being rolled out to our court attorneys." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000886", "start_seconds": 5368.83, "end_seconds": 5377.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "Because as we know, in the decisions of the courts, in the Supreme Court, in the Court of Appeals, gender fair language is very important." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000887", "start_seconds": 5377.83, "end_seconds": 5390.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "And aside from that, for our physical facilities, we also have instituted gender neutral comfort rooms among others." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000888", "start_seconds": 5390.83, "end_seconds": 5396.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "So we also have a legal feminism study conducted by our Justice Monette Singh, led by her." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000889", "start_seconds": 5396.83, "end_seconds": 5398.83, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "So she studied the different cases." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000899", "start_seconds": 5400.0, "end_seconds": 5404.98, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "which emphasizes or which focuses on gender issues." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000900", "start_seconds": 5405.26, "end_seconds": 5408.2, "speaker": "Court of Appeals Associate Justice Jennifer Joy C. Ong", "text": "So thank you very much." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000901", "start_seconds": 5408.2, "end_seconds": 5413.72, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "And Mr. Chair, just to add to these notable accomplishments," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000902", "start_seconds": 5414.26, "end_seconds": 5420.04, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "the judiciary likewise launched the Digital Gender and Development Corner" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000903", "start_seconds": 5420.04, "end_seconds": 5424.82, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "for easier access to gender-related information related to laws and jurisprudence." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000904", "start_seconds": 5424.82, "end_seconds": 5432.46, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "This is a good initiative, Mr. Chair, as it not only compiles gender-related legislation," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000905", "start_seconds": 5432.9, "end_seconds": 5437.14, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "but it makes recent gender-related laws accessible to the public." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000906", "start_seconds": 5438.46, "end_seconds": 5444.64, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "This is also one of the most important recommendations of the 9th Periodic Report" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000907", "start_seconds": 5444.64, "end_seconds": 5447.8, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "of the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000908", "start_seconds": 5447.8, "end_seconds": 5453.96, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "There is a long section on the role of the judiciary in gender and development." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000909", "start_seconds": 5454.44, "end_seconds": 5454.8, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "It is very important." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000910", "start_seconds": 5454.82, "end_seconds": 5462.7, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "We believe that from the level of training to capacity building" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000911", "start_seconds": 5462.7, "end_seconds": 5467.9, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "and the firmness that gender and development mandates are really integrated" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000912", "start_seconds": 5467.9, "end_seconds": 5470.54, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "in all programs, projects, and activities," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000913", "start_seconds": 5471.16, "end_seconds": 5477.88, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "our representation will request a report from the judiciary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000914", "start_seconds": 5477.88, "end_seconds": 5482.3, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "that is not only related to the utilization of the budget," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000915", "start_seconds": 5482.3, "end_seconds": 5484.06, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "but also to its compliance." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000916", "start_seconds": 5484.06, "end_seconds": 5486.74, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "We believe that this is a very important part of its gender and development mandate." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000917", "start_seconds": 5487.44, "end_seconds": 5493.48, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Now, Mr. Chair, the Supreme Court also issued its amendments" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000918", "start_seconds": 5493.48, "end_seconds": 5496.54, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "to the Guidelines on the Conduct of Video Conferencing." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000919", "start_seconds": 5497.08, "end_seconds": 5500.52, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "And based on these guidelines, the conduct of video conferencing is allowed" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000920", "start_seconds": 5500.52, "end_seconds": 5503.88, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "in all cases in the first and second level courts," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000921", "start_seconds": 5503.88, "end_seconds": 5507.48, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "the Court of Appeals, the Sandigan Bayan, and the Court of Tax Appeals." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000922", "start_seconds": 5508.5, "end_seconds": 5513.28, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Do you have information on how many Filipinos overseas" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000923", "start_seconds": 5514.06, "end_seconds": 5521.44, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "are working or staying until our migrant workers avail video conferencing?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000924", "start_seconds": 5521.44, "end_seconds": 5524.23, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000925", "start_seconds": 5524.23, "end_seconds": 5530.09, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Actually, we have a lot of requests for video conferencing" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000926", "start_seconds": 5530.09, "end_seconds": 5534.23, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "of our overseas Filipino workers abroad because they cannot just do it" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000927", "start_seconds": 5534.23, "end_seconds": 5536.23, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "pertinent to our rules." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000928", "start_seconds": 5536.23, "end_seconds": 5538.23, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "They need to be in the embassy." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000929", "start_seconds": 5538.23, "end_seconds": 5540.23, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, we have a lot of requests." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000930", "start_seconds": 5540.23, "end_seconds": 5545.29, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "But if you need information, Your Honor, our Court Management Office will be able to provide the data." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000931", "start_seconds": 5545.29, "end_seconds": 5547.29, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Thank you very much, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000932", "start_seconds": 5547.29, "end_seconds": 5555.2, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Sinabi ho sa Guidelines, it indicates that for requests for international video conferencing," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000933", "start_seconds": 5555.2, "end_seconds": 5561.2, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "the movement pays for all costs and expenses related to video conferencing." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000934", "start_seconds": 5561.2, "end_seconds": 5566.1, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Kapag gagamit po ba ng facilities natin overseas," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000935", "start_seconds": 5566.1, "end_seconds": 5568.0, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "may bayad din po ba yung ating mga OFWs," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000936", "start_seconds": 5568.0, "end_seconds": 5570.9, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "yung ating mga migrant workers para rito?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000937", "start_seconds": 5570.9, "end_seconds": 5572.29, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Saan po" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000938", "start_seconds": 5572.29, "end_seconds": 5573.29, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "napupunta yung mga nakukolekta" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000939", "start_seconds": 5573.29, "end_seconds": 5579.4, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "kung sakali na may mga binabayaran sa mga facilities?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000940", "start_seconds": 5579.4, "end_seconds": 5583.8, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Dahil yan po ay nangyayari sa mga embassies po natin," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000941", "start_seconds": 5583.8, "end_seconds": 5587.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "napupunta pong nakukolekta sa kanila," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000942", "start_seconds": 5587.4, "end_seconds": 5589.0, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "hindi po sa korte yan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000943", "start_seconds": 5589.0, "end_seconds": 5592.29, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Maraming salamat, Mr. Chair. Dahil hindi" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000944", "start_seconds": 5592.29, "end_seconds": 5597.29, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "po lahat ng mga kaso ng migrant workers, ng ating mga OFWs," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000945", "start_seconds": 5597.29, "end_seconds": 5601.29, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "ay nakakaya po nila yung iba't ibang gastos na may kinalaman dito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000946", "start_seconds": 5601.29, "end_seconds": 5606.3, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Meron naman po tayo sa DFA, may assistance to nationals," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000947", "start_seconds": 5606.3, "end_seconds": 5609.2, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "meron din po tayo sa DMW na pondo para diyan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000951", "start_seconds": 5609.7, "end_seconds": 5616.7, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "At nais lang din natin na matiyak na kahit anong mga expenses na may kinalaman sa international video conferencing" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000952", "start_seconds": 5616.7, "end_seconds": 5620.29, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "ay maku-cover ng mga naturang programa na ito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000953", "start_seconds": 5620.29, "end_seconds": 5622.29, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Now, finally," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000954", "start_seconds": 5622.29, "end_seconds": 5628.29, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "tungkol ho sa designation ng OSAEC at CSAEM trafficking Justice Zones," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000955", "start_seconds": 5628.29, "end_seconds": 5633.29, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "the Supreme Court is one of the members of the JSCC." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000956", "start_seconds": 5633.29, "end_seconds": 5644.79, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Dito po sa designation ng ating Justice Zones, na-mention niyo po sa inyong presentation na anim sa mga Justice Sector Coordinating Council Justice Zones" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000957", "start_seconds": 5644.79, "end_seconds": 5649.51, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "na ka-focus sa trafficking, online sexual abuse, and exploitation of children." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000958", "start_seconds": 5650.03, "end_seconds": 5659.17, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Saan-saan po ang mga zones na ito? At bakit po ito yung mga napiling mga lugar para sa anti-trafficking and sexual abuse and exploitation Justice Zones?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000959", "start_seconds": 5659.17, "end_seconds": 5664.87, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Please, nakapagtaguyod na po kami ng 20 na Justice Zones." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000960", "start_seconds": 5665.39, "end_seconds": 5675.27, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Sa Luzon po, matatagpuan po ito sa Quezon City, Angeles City, Balanga, Baguio, Tagaytay, Puerto Princesa, Dagupan, Calamba, at Naga." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000961", "start_seconds": 5675.73, "end_seconds": 5678.95, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Sa Visayas po, dito po ay sa Cebu at Bacolod." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000962", "start_seconds": 5679.33, "end_seconds": 5689.05, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Mindanao po, matatagpuan po ito because most of our executive judges are the convenors or the champions for the holding of the Justice Sector Coordinating Council." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000963", "start_seconds": 5689.17, "end_seconds": 5695.39, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Makikita po ito sa Davao, Cagayan de Oro, Iligan, Ozamis, at Zamboanga City." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000964", "start_seconds": 5696.23, "end_seconds": 5707.43, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Nung na 2024 po, Your Honor, I'm sorry, in 2025, nagkaroon po ng establishment ng JSEC sa Tri-City ng Tacloban, Ormoc, at Calbayog." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000965", "start_seconds": 5707.77, "end_seconds": 5710.39, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Pinaka-recent po ang San Fernando, La Union." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000966", "start_seconds": 5711.45, "end_seconds": 5714.07, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Iba-iba po ang tema ng mga Justice Zones." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000967", "start_seconds": 5714.59, "end_seconds": 5718.79, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Sa Tacloban, Ormoc, at Calbayog, sa akin pong pagkakaalam at pagkatanda," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000968", "start_seconds": 5719.17, "end_seconds": 5721.51, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "po ay ang OSAEC at OSAEM, no?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000969", "start_seconds": 5721.59, "end_seconds": 5721.95, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Tama ba?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000970", "start_seconds": 5722.31, "end_seconds": 5722.87, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, oo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000971", "start_seconds": 5723.31, "end_seconds": 5727.39, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And then, ang Tagaytay po, ang pagkakaalam ko ay Green Environment." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000972", "start_seconds": 5728.29, "end_seconds": 5733.07, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang Puerto Princesa, ganoon din po, Green Environment." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000973", "start_seconds": 5736.21, "end_seconds": 5737.75, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "How about Cagayan de Oro?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000974", "start_seconds": 5738.09, "end_seconds": 5743.25, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Cagayan de Oro, ganoon din po, OSAEC at OSAEM." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000975", "start_seconds": 5743.95, "end_seconds": 5746.11, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, Human Trafficking po, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000976", "start_seconds": 5749.13, "end_seconds": 5750.59, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Maraming salamat, Mr. Chairman." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000977", "start_seconds": 5750.71, "end_seconds": 5755.13, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Mayroon po ba tayong specific budget item para rito?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000978", "start_seconds": 5755.45, "end_seconds": 5760.71, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "At magkano ang ating proposal, akumpara dun sa napasama sa NAP?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000979", "start_seconds": 5761.03, "end_seconds": 5768.43, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ito pong tinatawag naming Justice Sector Convergence Program in the amount of 150 million?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000980", "start_seconds": 5768.69, "end_seconds": 5769.67, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Tama ba? Sorry." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000981", "start_seconds": 5770.55, "end_seconds": 5774.67, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ito po, 227,063,000 po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000982", "start_seconds": 5774.67, "end_seconds": 5780.41, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, yun po ang total proposed namin po sa Justice Convergence Program." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000983", "start_seconds": 5780.71, "end_seconds": 5784.55, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Yun po ang proposal na nakasama sa NAP?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000984", "start_seconds": 5784.87, "end_seconds": 5788.11, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ideally po, kasama na po dapat sa NAP." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000985", "start_seconds": 5788.43, "end_seconds": 5791.71, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Magkano ang inyong original proposal?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000986", "start_seconds": 5792.13, "end_seconds": 5794.73, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang pagkakaalam ko po, 150,000." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000987", "start_seconds": 5794.95, "end_seconds": 5795.89, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Last gaa." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000988", "start_seconds": 5796.27, "end_seconds": 5797.75, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "150 million, I'm sorry." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000989", "start_seconds": 5798.17, "end_seconds": 5799.01, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "150 million." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000990", "start_seconds": 5799.15, "end_seconds": 5802.63, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ngayon po, 227,063,000." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000991", "start_seconds": 5803.35, "end_seconds": 5803.59, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Okay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000992", "start_seconds": 5803.59, "end_seconds": 5810.59, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Natanong ko, Mr. Chair, kasi mga nga ilangan ng hindi lang sapat pero substantial na malaking pondo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000993", "start_seconds": 5810.71, "end_seconds": 5815.57, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Para magawa ng convergence effort na ito, ang kanyang mga layunin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000994", "start_seconds": 5815.99, "end_seconds": 5818.61, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Meron pa akong kaunting oras, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000995", "start_seconds": 5818.83, "end_seconds": 5823.49, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "At hihingin ko na lang po ang detalye ng pagpapatupad ng convergence program na ito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000996", "start_seconds": 5823.79, "end_seconds": 5828.15, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Ngunit pagdating sa execution ng spousal at child support order," }, { "stable_id": "asr-000997", "start_seconds": 5828.87, "end_seconds": 5833.23, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "batay ho sa aming ongoing na anti-VAWC law review sa ngayon." }, { "stable_id": "asr-000998", "start_seconds": 5833.95, "end_seconds": 5839.13, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Isa ho yan sa pinakamalaki na issue ng mga kababaihan at kanilang mga anak" }, { "stable_id": "asr-000999", "start_seconds": 5839.13, "end_seconds": 5839.71, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "na nakaranas." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001000", "start_seconds": 5840.71, "end_seconds": 5841.73, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "ng VAWC." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001001", "start_seconds": 5842.89, "end_seconds": 5848.07, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Ilan po bang cases ng spousal at child support ang naihain sa mga korte?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001002", "start_seconds": 5848.73, "end_seconds": 5851.23, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "For these cases filed, how many have been granted?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001003", "start_seconds": 5851.75, "end_seconds": 5857.01, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "For those granted spousal or child support, how many cases have been successfully executed?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001004", "start_seconds": 5858.13, "end_seconds": 5862.71, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "How do the courts ensure that the orders for spousal and child support are executive regularly?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001005", "start_seconds": 5865.06, "end_seconds": 5867.08, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Mahaba-haba po ito, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001006", "start_seconds": 5867.08, "end_seconds": 5871.94, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Kung maari lang pong magbahagi sa atin ng mga key." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001007", "start_seconds": 5872.12, "end_seconds": 5887.4, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "figures or statistics na kinakailangan para rin maitulak ang Kongreso na gumawa ng hakbang para mapalakas ang ating mga batas na may kinalaman sa spousal at child support." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001007-split-2", "start_seconds": 5887.4, "end_seconds": 5895.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Sa aming data hub po, Your Honor, hindi po natin makakarakterize na ito ay in particular sa child or spousal support." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001008", "start_seconds": 5895.46, "end_seconds": 5902.1, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Pero naka-classify po siya, naka-cluster as violence against women and children under Republic Act 9262." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001009", "start_seconds": 5902.12, "end_seconds": 5909.98, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang pending cases po natin as of December 31, 2025 ay 8,620." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001010", "start_seconds": 5910.4, "end_seconds": 5914.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang newly filed cases po natin ay 3,520." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001011", "start_seconds": 5915.0599999999995, "end_seconds": 5917.78, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang revived po ay 684." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001012", "start_seconds": 5918.42, "end_seconds": 5922.14, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang decided po ay 3,751." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001013", "start_seconds": 5922.5, "end_seconds": 5924.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Archived, 542." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001014", "start_seconds": 5924.4, "end_seconds": 5930.5599999999995, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So pending po as of June 30, 2026, 8,532." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001015", "start_seconds": 5932.12, "end_seconds": 5933.4400000000005, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Maraming salamat, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001016", "start_seconds": 5933.4400000000005, "end_seconds": 5947.02, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "At tayo rin ho ay maghahain ng proposal sa Judiciary para sa isang dialogo at magkaroon ng aktibong pakikilahok sa sinasagawa ngayon na pag-review at pagpapalakas ng ating anti-VAWC law." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001017", "start_seconds": 5947.24, "end_seconds": 5948.3, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Maraming salamat, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001018", "start_seconds": 5948.36, "end_seconds": 5949.4400000000005, "speaker": "Rep. Sarah Jane I. Elago", "text": "Maraming salamat sa Judiciary." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001019", "start_seconds": 5949.62, "end_seconds": 5951.48, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We will welcome the dialogue, po, your honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001020", "start_seconds": 5951.62, "end_seconds": 5951.98, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001021", "start_seconds": 5952.4400000000005, "end_seconds": 5956.38, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you very much, Congresswoman Chara Jane Elago." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001022", "start_seconds": 5956.38, "end_seconds": 5959.38, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So we now go to the next interpellator." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001023", "start_seconds": 5960.96, "end_seconds": 5961.38, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "The Honorable..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001024", "start_seconds": 5962.12, "end_seconds": 5965.1, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Representative Tony Roman Patan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001025", "start_seconds": 5966.38, "end_seconds": 5967.3, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Good morning." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001026", "start_seconds": 5967.62, "end_seconds": 5968.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Good morning, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001027", "start_seconds": 5968.76, "end_seconds": 5970.76, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Actually, it's good afternoon, ho." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001028", "start_seconds": 5971.86, "end_seconds": 5974.38, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Okay pa ho kayo? Di pa kayo nagugutom? Okay lang po?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001029", "start_seconds": 5976.86, "end_seconds": 5979.5, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Just parang gutom na ho, ha? Walang sumagot." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001030", "start_seconds": 5980.9400000000005, "end_seconds": 5981.82, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "A question." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001031", "start_seconds": 5981.82, "end_seconds": 5990.32, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "I note that for 2027, you proposed an increase of about just over 15 billion pesos." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001032", "start_seconds": 5991.34, "end_seconds": 5991.82, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "And..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001033", "start_seconds": 5992.12, "end_seconds": 5997.24, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "In your chart, it says that the DBM submitted comments and recommendations" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001034", "start_seconds": 5997.24, "end_seconds": 6002.42, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "with respect to your proposed 2027 budget." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001035", "start_seconds": 6002.92, "end_seconds": 6003.52, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Tama po ba?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001036", "start_seconds": 6004.2, "end_seconds": 6005.36, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Can you..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001037", "start_seconds": 6005.36, "end_seconds": 6009.82, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "It says it was appended to the NEP." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001038", "start_seconds": 6010.54, "end_seconds": 6015.66, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Can you share with us some of the comments and recommendations of the DBM?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001039", "start_seconds": 6015.66, "end_seconds": 6019.86, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Your Honor, as of yesterday, actually until now," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001040", "start_seconds": 6020.16, "end_seconds": 6022.1, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "we have not yet received the comment from DBM." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001041", "start_seconds": 6022.12, "end_seconds": 6022.82, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001042", "start_seconds": 6023.08, "end_seconds": 6023.32, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Okay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001043", "start_seconds": 6023.64, "end_seconds": 6030.68, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "So the 86.27 billion reflected on your presentation is what you propose?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001044", "start_seconds": 6030.96, "end_seconds": 6031.6, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001045", "start_seconds": 6031.82, "end_seconds": 6032.1, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Okay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001046", "start_seconds": 6032.72, "end_seconds": 6040.1, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "And with the increase in the budget, you can pursue all the programs that you had in mind?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001047", "start_seconds": 6040.42, "end_seconds": 6041.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We hope so, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001048", "start_seconds": 6041.82, "end_seconds": 6043.46, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, but that is the goal, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001049", "start_seconds": 6043.62, "end_seconds": 6043.74, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Yes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001050", "start_seconds": 6045.24, "end_seconds": 6051.12, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "You, ano ho, I'm particularly concerned or interested in the status of your e-discovery project." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001051", "start_seconds": 6051.12, "end_seconds": 6051.24, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "E-discovery?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001052", "start_seconds": 6052.12, "end_seconds": 6054.08, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Electronic discovery project." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001053", "start_seconds": 6055.66, "end_seconds": 6059.12, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "The reason being that it is..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001054", "start_seconds": 6059.82, "end_seconds": 6063.64, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "I think in courts, in the first instance, right?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001055", "start_seconds": 6063.98, "end_seconds": 6064.86, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "First instance." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001056", "start_seconds": 6065.78, "end_seconds": 6072.38, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Ang kutsino ho ang mas maraming information, yun po ang usually nananalo sa kaso." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001057", "start_seconds": 6073.34, "end_seconds": 6079.88, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "And ang tingin ko po, especially when you have a consumer" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001058", "start_seconds": 6079.88, "end_seconds": 6081.88, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "or an individual litigant," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001059", "start_seconds": 6082.12, "end_seconds": 6090.9400000000005, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "litigating against a company or a corporation because of information asymmetry." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001060", "start_seconds": 6091.92, "end_seconds": 6095.52, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "And usually, I mean, the companies have the upper hand," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001061", "start_seconds": 6095.8, "end_seconds": 6099.18, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "not just in terms of resources, but in terms of information." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001062", "start_seconds": 6100.14, "end_seconds": 6107.32, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "So paano ho pinagtutuunan ng Supreme Court yung bagay na yan" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001063", "start_seconds": 6107.32, "end_seconds": 6108.1, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "ng sa ganon?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001064", "start_seconds": 6108.1, "end_seconds": 6111.0, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "And then, ma-democratize po, mapalaki po yung access" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001065", "start_seconds": 6111.0, "end_seconds": 6112.1, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "ng mga..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001066", "start_seconds": 6112.12, "end_seconds": 6122.18, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "individual, sa mga information na hawak po ng, malimbawa, mga kumpanya, through knowing" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001067", "start_seconds": 6122.18, "end_seconds": 6130.1, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "that, especially yung emails, yung email, dahil it's a rich source of information," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001068", "start_seconds": 6130.1, "end_seconds": 6140.14, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "a lot of discussion is done electronically, and so how is this made available to individual" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001069", "start_seconds": 6140.14, "end_seconds": 6142.02, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "litigants in a case?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001070", "start_seconds": 6145.39, "end_seconds": 6152.67, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "When it comes to discovery modes of procedure, Your Honor, the recently amended Rules on" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001071", "start_seconds": 6152.67, "end_seconds": 6157.59, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Civil Procedure, which was just in 2020, but there is now again another amendment of the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001072", "start_seconds": 6157.59, "end_seconds": 6162.75, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "rules, which is pending approval by the en banc, I do know that they have bolstered modes of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001073", "start_seconds": 6162.75, "end_seconds": 6164.95, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "procedure as part of pre-trial." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001074", "start_seconds": 6165.85, "end_seconds": 6172.71, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Insofar as electronic mails, Your Honor, this will form part of the now ongoing" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001075", "start_seconds": 6172.71, "end_seconds": 6178.49, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "revisions on the Rules on Evidence, part of which is electronic evidence." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001076", "start_seconds": 6178.49, "end_seconds": 6185.99, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "It is through Your Honor that electronic evidence is now a big bulk of evidence presentation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001077", "start_seconds": 6185.99, "end_seconds": 6194.95, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "before the court, considering the present times that we have, that we converse through" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001078", "start_seconds": 6194.95, "end_seconds": 6200.37, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "electronic mails, through messages, with instant messaging applications." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001079", "start_seconds": 6200.37, "end_seconds": 6201.37, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, it's..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001080", "start_seconds": 6201.37, "end_seconds": 6202.37, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "It's..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001081", "start_seconds": 6202.37, "end_seconds": 6208.25, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "It's now undergoing review with the current revisions of the Rules on Evidence, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001082", "start_seconds": 6208.25, "end_seconds": 6213.61, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Without, what do you call this, jumping the gun, knowing that it's a pending review." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001083", "start_seconds": 6213.61, "end_seconds": 6215.85, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Pero how aggressive is that?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001084", "start_seconds": 6215.85, "end_seconds": 6225.91, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Are you now requiring sort of disclosure, the two parties to come up with a protocol" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001085", "start_seconds": 6225.91, "end_seconds": 6231.03, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "on how to gain access to electronic information?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001086", "start_seconds": 6231.03, "end_seconds": 6237.91, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Would it include metadata, the form that it will be delivered to the other party?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001087", "start_seconds": 6237.91, "end_seconds": 6243.79, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Ito ho yung mga bagay, because potentially, if you're talking about email, for example," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001088", "start_seconds": 6243.79, "end_seconds": 6248.1900000000005, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "that's millions of pages, you know?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001089", "start_seconds": 6248.1900000000005, "end_seconds": 6260.87, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "So ano ho yung mga, what protocols do you have in place, or that will be in place to" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001090", "start_seconds": 6260.87, "end_seconds": 6268.99, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "address this, yung volume of information, the relevant custodian, the time frame, the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001091", "start_seconds": 6268.99, "end_seconds": 6276.59, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "form of production, the metadata available, yung mga bagay na po niyan na, you know," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001092", "start_seconds": 6276.59, "end_seconds": 6281.87, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "usually yung tinatawag na smoking gun, makikita po sa email, yun po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001093", "start_seconds": 6281.87, "end_seconds": 6284.95, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, yes po, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001094", "start_seconds": 6284.95, "end_seconds": 6288.39, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Actually, there is a lot going on in the..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001095", "start_seconds": 6288.39, "end_seconds": 6290.75, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Because that goes on into the appreciation of..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001096", "start_seconds": 6290.75, "end_seconds": 6291.71, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "That's right." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001097", "start_seconds": 6291.71, "end_seconds": 6293.55, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "...evidence before the court ." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001098", "start_seconds": 6293.55, "end_seconds": 6299.53, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Especially when it comes to electronic mails or even Facebook posts for instance, and instant" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001099", "start_seconds": 6299.53, "end_seconds": 6299.87, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "messaging application..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001100", "start_seconds": 6300.0, "end_seconds": 6307.68, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "especially when the sender is anonymous so if you if you go into forensic" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001101", "start_seconds": 6307.68, "end_seconds": 6311.44, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "evidence let's say it's part of discovery mode of procedure sometimes" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001102", "start_seconds": 6311.44, "end_seconds": 6316.24, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "your honor we have to contend with data privacy it is not often that it we it is" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001103", "start_seconds": 6316.24, "end_seconds": 6323.7, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "easily disclosed who the sender is especially when it should be weighed as" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001104", "start_seconds": 6323.7, "end_seconds": 6332.34, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "an as an as an evidentiary if the evidentiary value of such email or or is" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001105", "start_seconds": 6332.34, "end_seconds": 6337.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "weighed we have to consider likewise other than data privacy the relevance" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001106", "start_seconds": 6337.02, "end_seconds": 6343.08, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "and materiality of the evidence. Sana ho mapabilis po at ma-finalize na ho" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001107", "start_seconds": 6343.08, "end_seconds": 6348.46, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "yung electronic discovery protocols and rules at maibaba" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001108", "start_seconds": 6348.46, "end_seconds": 6353.14, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "nang sa ganoon ho yung mga nasa ibaba, yung mga mamamayan, talagang magamit nila" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001111", "start_seconds": 6353.14, "end_seconds": 6361.92, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "para mabigyan ng, ano, to inform their cases and also guide them on whether" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001112", "start_seconds": 6361.92, "end_seconds": 6383.66, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "to settle or not. Kasi yun po ang dapat nangyayari para maiwasan din po yung taguan ng information. So that?s one. Second po, nakita ko roon sa listahan ng mga projects ninyo na meron yung electronic notarization." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001113", "start_seconds": 6383.66, "end_seconds": 6396.94, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "can you inform us of the status and whether it is uh whether it will be scaled up" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001114", "start_seconds": 6396.94, "end_seconds": 6404.66, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Kasi marami pong because of distance and inconvenience hindi po humaharap sa notary so why make this a" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001115", "start_seconds": 6404.66, "end_seconds": 6413.0, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "problem if you if through innovation you can address the concerns about ah personal appearance before the notary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001116", "start_seconds": 6413.66, "end_seconds": 6428.2, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Your Honor, I am happy to inform you that applications for lawyers to become electronic notaries public or what we call ENPs have been opened just last August 10, 2026." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001117", "start_seconds": 6428.2, "end_seconds": 6434.76, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So yung electronic, yung public access po sa live e-notary services, maaari na pong ma-commission yan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001118", "start_seconds": 6434.76, "end_seconds": 6444.54, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And then, the Supreme Court has established already the legal framework for these electronic documents." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001119", "start_seconds": 6444.54, "end_seconds": 6457.5, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "As a matter of fact, Your Honor, ang submission po ngayon ng notaries, the documents that are from notaries public, is now through?how?s that?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001120", "start_seconds": 6457.94, "end_seconds": 6459.06, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Through pay?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001121", "start_seconds": 6459.86, "end_seconds": 6460.5, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Paano ba? Yung electronic payment na po" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001122", "start_seconds": 6460.7, "end_seconds": 6464.74, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "puwede nang bayaran sa aming tinatawag na" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001123", "start_seconds": 6464.76, "end_seconds": 6469.14, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "JEPS, the Judiciary Electronic Payment System." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001124", "start_seconds": 6469.7, "end_seconds": 6477.22, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Tapos yung submission po na online na rin po para we don?t have to deal with a lot of paper-based documents." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001125", "start_seconds": 6478.28, "end_seconds": 6481.12, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Mr. Chair, just last question. I still have one second." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001126", "start_seconds": 6483.18, "end_seconds": 6484.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yes, please proceed." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001127", "start_seconds": 6486.3, "end_seconds": 6494.08, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Isa hong practice na nagaganap, or actually malpractice na nagaganap sa ibaba," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001128", "start_seconds": 6494.76, "end_seconds": 6505.44, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "halimbawa sa mga criminal cases, na yung mga complainant na nananadya para ma-default yung respondent," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001129", "start_seconds": 6505.44, "end_seconds": 6511.34, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "ang ginagawa po nila, ang binabanggit na address noong respondent ay mali." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001130", "start_seconds": 6513.08, "end_seconds": 6520.08, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Meron ho bang pagbabago o solusyon na naiisip ang Supreme Court para sa ganoon?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001131", "start_seconds": 6520.08, "end_seconds": 6523.9, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Maiwasan na yan at matigil na po yung practice na iyon?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001132", "start_seconds": 6523.9, "end_seconds": 6524.4, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Opo" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001133", "start_seconds": 6524.76, "end_seconds": 6530.76, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Kasi ang mangyayari, pagka maling address, hindi sasagot yung respondent." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001134", "start_seconds": 6530.76, "end_seconds": 6541.88, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Pag hindi sumagot ang respondent, the cases will be filed in court because you only get one side of the story." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001135", "start_seconds": 6541.88, "end_seconds": 6547.64, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "So nangyayari, they?re effectively denied preliminary investigation. Nandoon na ho sa korte." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001136", "start_seconds": 6547.64, "end_seconds": 6554.62, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Ano hong reporma ang naiisip ng Supreme Court para tugunan yung problem na iyon?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001137", "start_seconds": 6554.62, "end_seconds": 6559.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Sa totoo po, Your Honor, strikto po ang Supreme Court pagdating po sa service ng processes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001138", "start_seconds": 6559.62, "end_seconds": 6567.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kunyari po merong complaint at nag-issue na po ang korte ng summons para makapagsumite ang isang defendant ng answer," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001139", "start_seconds": 6567.62, "end_seconds": 6574.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "especially if it's a personal action, ang una pong nire-require ng korte ay personal service" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001140", "start_seconds": 6574.62, "end_seconds": 6581.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "para po yung mga sheriff natin or process servers ay ma-confirm po kung talagang doon nakatira ang isang defendant." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001141", "start_seconds": 6581.62, "end_seconds": 6582.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kung sakaling hindi man po, that's the only time" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001142", "start_seconds": 6582.62, "end_seconds": 6583.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "that they can resort to substituted" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001143", "start_seconds": 6583.62, "end_seconds": 6584.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "service." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001144", "start_seconds": 6584.62, "end_seconds": 6585.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Tapos hindi lang po minsan mangyayari ito. Ang minimum po ngayon na" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001145", "start_seconds": 6585.62, "end_seconds": 6586.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "nire-require ng ating Supreme Court ay" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001146", "start_seconds": 6586.62, "end_seconds": 6587.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "tatlong beses." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001147", "start_seconds": 6587.62, "end_seconds": 6592.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Para po every time po bumalik si sheriff or si process server," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001148", "start_seconds": 6592.62, "end_seconds": 6604.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "masigurado po na yung defendant ay talagang nandoon. Kung talaga pong wala," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001149", "start_seconds": 6604.62, "end_seconds": 6610.48, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "ay mare-reflect po iyon sa kanyang return." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001150", "start_seconds": 6610.48, "end_seconds": 6612.12, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So masyado pong strikto ngayon" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001151", "start_seconds": 6612.12, "end_seconds": 6613.62, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "po ang returns ng processes natin para nga po maiwasan na ang isang defendant" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001152", "start_seconds": 6613.62, "end_seconds": 6618.9, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "ay ma-declare na hindi po in default. Ngayon ang aming proseso ay para po magkaroon ng ex parte" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001153", "start_seconds": 6618.9, "end_seconds": 6625.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "presentation. Iniiwasan po talaga iyon kung hindi lahat na-verify na walang personal service" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001154", "start_seconds": 6625.02, "end_seconds": 6630.44, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "o substituted service tatlong beses hindi rin nangyari. That's the only time." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001155", "start_seconds": 6630.44, "end_seconds": 6639.42, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "so i think with all this um with all this um uh the rules that we have on strict uh service and" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001156", "start_seconds": 6639.42, "end_seconds": 6647.3, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "processes. Tingin ko po makikita po kung ang defendant ay talagang hindi nakatira sa isang binigay na address ng isang complainant." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001156-split-2", "start_seconds": 6647.3, "end_seconds": 6649.85, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Maybe it is a matter of implementation." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001156-split-3", "start_seconds": 6649.85, "end_seconds": 6650.45, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001156-split-4", "start_seconds": 6650.45, "end_seconds": 6666.7, "speaker": "Rep. Antonino B. Roman III", "text": "Because marami pa rin hong kuwento na nakakarating sa akin na yung mga respondent hindi nila nalalaman na meron palang kaso naka-file laban sa kanila, tapos nasa korte na ho at meron nang warrant of arrest. So sana ho masolusyunan iyon. Maraming salamat po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001157", "start_seconds": 6667.1, "end_seconds": 6668.14, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "uh thank you very much" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001158", "start_seconds": 6669.42, "end_seconds": 6675.74, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Now we have a predicament because we were supposed to declare a break" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001159", "start_seconds": 6675.74, "end_seconds": 6683.4, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "about Justice Villanueva as we proceed. Now the problem is at two o?clock we have to" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001160", "start_seconds": 6683.4, "end_seconds": 6692.52, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "finish then because there's no other room so we have to finish finish there is no room available" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001161", "start_seconds": 6693.02, "end_seconds": 6698.52, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "so we don't want our justices and our judiciary to come back" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001162", "start_seconds": 6698.52, "end_seconds": 6699.36, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "so i" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001163", "start_seconds": 6699.42, "end_seconds": 6707.58, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "urge that those who have some issues that may be taken up already by the judiciary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001164", "start_seconds": 6709.42, "end_seconds": 6718.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "the judiciary, I would just declare a 10-minute break so that you can discuss with the justices." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001165", "start_seconds": 6719.34, "end_seconds": 6723.98, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Wala na, there?s no other room available. So we are at 11:00 ang start natin, wala na." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001166", "start_seconds": 6725.5, "end_seconds": 6729.26, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "so we don't want them to to come back or for you so can you just" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001167", "start_seconds": 6729.42, "end_seconds": 6737.1, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Therefore, we have a 10-minute talk to the justices. Bring your concerns so that we will" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001168", "start_seconds": 6737.1, "end_seconds": 6743.82, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "end up here at two o?clock. It?s already one o?clock, so we just have one hour. Is that okay with you?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001169", "start_seconds": 6743.82, "end_seconds": 6751.82, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Because otherwise we have to come back. Approach the bench, okay? Is that okay? Let?s approve the budget na para" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001170", "start_seconds": 6751.82, "end_seconds": 6752.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "tapos na." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001171", "start_seconds": 6753.5, "end_seconds": 6758.7, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Yeah, yeah, but you have to break now for 10 minutes precisely, and we will" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001172", "start_seconds": 6758.7, "end_seconds": 6759.26, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "have about" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001173", "start_seconds": 6759.42, "end_seconds": 6766.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "50 minutes more. We have no other room; there are hearings, there are continuations of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001174", "start_seconds": 6766.46, "end_seconds": 6772.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "hearings. Wala na, wala. So at two o?clock we have to vacate this because" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001175", "start_seconds": 6773.18, "end_seconds": 6776.78, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "the session will start at three o'clock and to prepare many things" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001176", "start_seconds": 6777.42, "end_seconds": 6785.26, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "So the Chair declares a 10-minute break." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001177", "start_seconds": 7211.12, "end_seconds": 7213.84, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "uh good afternoon again and uh we have an announcement" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001178", "start_seconds": 7214.4, "end_seconds": 7220.8, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "The Chair is here. He is concerned that others may need to really have a break, so" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001179", "start_seconds": 7220.8, "end_seconds": 7228.7, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "we will declare a 10-minute lunch break?sorry, 30-minute lunch break. We resume here at..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001180", "start_seconds": 9612.08, "end_seconds": 9619.44, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Good afternoon again. Let us resume the consideration of the budget of the judiciary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001181", "start_seconds": 9619.44, "end_seconds": 9630.46, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "for fiscal year 2027. We are very happy to note that because of our break, our many congressmen," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001182", "start_seconds": 9630.64, "end_seconds": 9638.02, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "representatives, have been able to present to the judiciary their concerns. And because of that," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001183", "start_seconds": 9638.02, "end_seconds": 9648.14, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "we have now fewer representatives to ask questions to the judiciary. So let me just also" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001184", "start_seconds": 9648.14, "end_seconds": 9657.18, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "acknowledge additional members to this meeting, to this hearing. Deputy Minority Leader Jesus Bong" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001185", "start_seconds": 9657.18, "end_seconds": 9664.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Suntay, Representative Elijah San Fernando, Assistant Minority Leader Robert Nazal," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001186", "start_seconds": 9664.42, "end_seconds": 9667.3, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Representative Dada Esmula," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001187", "start_seconds": 9668.02, "end_seconds": 9678.12, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and Deputy Majority Leader Vice Chair Jam Baronda. So at this point, we will go now to the minority" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001188", "start_seconds": 9678.12, "end_seconds": 9683.72, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "with a short manifestation. Representative Elijah San Fernando." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001189", "start_seconds": 9684.3, "end_seconds": 9690.8, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Thank you, Mr. Chair. To our Honorable Justices and the judiciary family, magandang hapon po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001190", "start_seconds": 9691.06, "end_seconds": 9698.0, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Firstly, we'd like to convey our full support for the judiciary. Dahil naniniwala po kami na kapag" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001191", "start_seconds": 9698.0, "end_seconds": 9703.98, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "malakas po ang hudikatura, ultimately po ang makikinabang ay ang mga manggagawa at ordinaryong Pilipino." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001192", "start_seconds": 9704.42, "end_seconds": 9711.9, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Mr. Chair, I just have few clarifications. Kasi di po ko abugado at gusto ko pong maintindihan" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001193", "start_seconds": 9711.9, "end_seconds": 9717.9, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "sa lente po ng mga manggagawa yung ilang mga usapin po tungkol sa mga proseso ng ating batas." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001194", "start_seconds": 9718.5, "end_seconds": 9726.54, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Sa Rule 58 po ng Rules of Civil Procedure, pwede niyo po ba kaming bigyan ng kalinawan doon po sa Section 4B?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001195", "start_seconds": 9726.54, "end_seconds": 9726.64, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Ah may nakasulat po" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001196", "start_seconds": 9728.0, "end_seconds": 9733.6, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Kasi dito, upon approval of the requisite bond, a writ of preliminary injunction shall be issued." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001197", "start_seconds": 9734.12, "end_seconds": 9737.54, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Pwede niyo po ba kaming paliwanagan sa matter na ito?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001198", "start_seconds": 9738.46, "end_seconds": 9747.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Thank you po, Your Honor. Kapag po nag-grant, an injunction is usually a prayer, an ancillary remedy." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001199", "start_seconds": 9747.94, "end_seconds": 9755.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So provisional remedy siya to a main action. So kung yung action na yun, after hearing, ay gagrant na ng court." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001200", "start_seconds": 9755.04, "end_seconds": 9757.04, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "To answer for the damages that may..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001201", "start_seconds": 9758.0, "end_seconds": 9770.0, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "That the other, the adverse party will have, kailangan po talaga mag-post ng bond itong movant." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001202", "start_seconds": 9770.62, "end_seconds": 9779.66, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "And that will answer for, as I've said, the damages in the event that the injunction is already, the writ of injunction is already implemented." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001203", "start_seconds": 9780.52, "end_seconds": 9781.5, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Thank you, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001204", "start_seconds": 9781.5, "end_seconds": 9785.92, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Just for example po, in an example, hypothetical case." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001205", "start_seconds": 9786.04, "end_seconds": 9787.5, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "So sabi po doon, let a writ of preliminary..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001206", "start_seconds": 9788.0, "end_seconds": 9792.48, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "preliminary injunction be issued upon putting a bond of X amount." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001207", "start_seconds": 9792.86, "end_seconds": 9799.62, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Halimbawa po, yung petitioner hindi po nakapaglagak ng bond. Ano pong mangyayari doon sa injunction?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001208", "start_seconds": 9800.56, "end_seconds": 9804.74, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Hindi po siya ma-i-implement, hindi po siya ma-i-issue ng court." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001209", "start_seconds": 9805.32, "end_seconds": 9812.3, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kasi po, kailangan po talaga yung bond is a prerequisite before the writ of injunction or preliminary injunction will issue." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001210", "start_seconds": 9812.52, "end_seconds": 9817.28, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Thank you po. So ibig sabihin po, if there is no bond, then there is no injunction." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001211", "start_seconds": 9817.54, "end_seconds": 9817.98, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001212", "start_seconds": 9818.0, "end_seconds": 9822.34, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Maraming salamat po sa kalinawan na ibinigay po ng hudikatura on this matter." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001213", "start_seconds": 9822.92, "end_seconds": 9825.96, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "So gusto ko lang po ilinaw yan na no bond, no injunction." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001214", "start_seconds": 9826.58, "end_seconds": 9829.44, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Susunod ko po na tanong, ano naman po yung mga pamamaraan?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001215", "start_seconds": 9829.52, "end_seconds": 9841.0, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Halimbawa naman po, merong mga judges na tingin po natin ay merong erring decision on matters na talagang pinangihimasukan yung mga bagay na wala namang jurisdiction." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001216", "start_seconds": 9841.8, "end_seconds": 9843.12, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Halimbawa po ang korte." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001217", "start_seconds": 9843.12, "end_seconds": 9847.36, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Ano po yung mga pamamaraan para i-correct po ito?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001218", "start_seconds": 9848.0, "end_seconds": 9855.84, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang tanong po ninyo, Your Honor, kung ang isang korte ay walang jurisdiction?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001219", "start_seconds": 9856.3, "end_seconds": 9859.14, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Halimbawa po, wala siyang jurisdiction on the matter." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001220", "start_seconds": 9859.32, "end_seconds": 9866.5, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Or halimbawa po, nang himasok siya sa isang pasok na clearly nagba-violate po ng mga nakasaad sa batas natin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001221", "start_seconds": 9866.98, "end_seconds": 9870.26, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "So ano po ang proseso dito, ma'am?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001222", "start_seconds": 9872.55, "end_seconds": 9873.87, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ano po, marami." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001223", "start_seconds": 9874.15, "end_seconds": 9879.01, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang pagkakaalam po, ang isang judge dapat po, dapat well-versed sa batas." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001224", "start_seconds": 9879.01, "end_seconds": 9887.23, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang judge po, dapat alam din if they are exercising jurisdiction over a subject matter, over the person of an accused." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001225", "start_seconds": 9887.61, "end_seconds": 9892.89, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So kasi po talagang territorial tayo kung criminal cases or subject matter sa civil cases." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001226", "start_seconds": 9893.45, "end_seconds": 9899.97, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kung wala pong jurisdiction at yung judge ay biglang nagsabi sa kanyang decision or order ay may jurisdiction siya." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001227", "start_seconds": 9900.0, "end_seconds": 9915.64, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "May remedyo naman po yun that you can either appeal the case if it's really a decision in court or let's say it's an interlocutory order, pwede naman po siyang gawan din ng kaso under Rule 65 ng certiorari." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001228", "start_seconds": 9915.64, "end_seconds": 9939.45, "speaker": "Rep. Elijah Rumbaoa San Fernando", "text": "Rule 65 po. Maraming salamat po sa paglilinaw na iyan, Mr. Chair. Iyon lang naman po yung ilang mga katanungan ng kinatawang ito at hopefully po, sa pamamagitan po ng sagot ng ating mga kasama sa hudikatura, ay magsilbi po ito na guidance sa mga manggagawa at sa mga kasong kinasasangkutan ng mga manggagawa. Iyon lamang po. Maraming salamat po and we support the judiciary. Salamat po, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001228-split-2", "start_seconds": 9939.45, "end_seconds": 9945.62, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you very much, Congressman Elijah San Fernando. We go now to the next." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001229", "start_seconds": 9945.64, "end_seconds": 9956.96, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Line 3 have already given up their slot because they have talked with the judiciary. So we go now to Representative J.P. Padernos." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001230", "start_seconds": 9957.66, "end_seconds": 9971.38, "speaker": "Rep. Jan \"Atty. JP\" Padiernos", "text": "Thank you, Mr. Chair. Magandang hapon po sa ating Judiciary Department, sa lahat po natin mga justices from the Supreme Court, Court of Appeals, Tax Appeals, Sandigan Bayan. Good afternoon." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001231", "start_seconds": 9971.56, "end_seconds": 9975.38, "speaker": "Rep. Jan \"Atty. JP\" Padiernos", "text": "Mr. Chair, I would just like to respectfully manifest my..." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001232", "start_seconds": 9975.64, "end_seconds": 9992.48, "speaker": "Rep. Jan \"Atty. JP\" Padiernos", "text": "full support for the proposed budget of the judiciary. The judiciary is supposed to be the equalizer for the common man. The institution where every Filipino, regardless of wealth or influence, can seek fair treatment under the law. But justice delayed is justice denied." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001233", "start_seconds": 9992.48, "end_seconds": 10004.38, "speaker": "Rep. Jan \"Atty. JP\" Padiernos", "text": "Kaya dapat sapat ang pondo para mapunan ang vacancies, mabawasan ang backlog, mapabilis ang proceedings, at maging accessible ang courts nationwide." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001234", "start_seconds": 10004.82, "end_seconds": 10005.48, "speaker": "Rep. Jan \"Atty. JP\" Padiernos", "text": "Our support," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001235", "start_seconds": 10005.64, "end_seconds": 10030.28, "speaker": "Rep. Jan \"Atty. JP\" Padiernos", "text": "however, is not blank check. A larger budget must produce measurable results, fewer delayed cases, shorter waiting times, stronger digital systems, and greater transparency. Judicial independence and fiscal accountability must go together. Subject to these commitments, I respectfully support the proposed budget of the judiciary. Maraming salamat po at magandang hapon." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001236", "start_seconds": 10030.5, "end_seconds": 10032.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Maraming salamat din po, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001237", "start_seconds": 10032.06, "end_seconds": 10035.32, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Palakpak tayo. That was a statement of support." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001238", "start_seconds": 10035.64, "end_seconds": 10038.66, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you, Congressman J.P. Padernos." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001239", "start_seconds": 10039.68, "end_seconds": 10050.48, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Next, again, many have already been able to talk with the judiciary on their request. The next will be Representative Dada Esmula." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001240", "start_seconds": 10051.6, "end_seconds": 10062.68, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Assalamualaikum, marahmatullahi wabarakatuhu. Maraming salamat po, Mr. Chair, to the judiciary family. Magandang tanghali po sa inyong lahat." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001241", "start_seconds": 10063.8, "end_seconds": 10065.6, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Ako po ay kasamahan ni" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001242", "start_seconds": 10065.64, "end_seconds": 10068.3, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Representative Chel Diokno." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001243", "start_seconds": 10068.3, "end_seconds": 10072.8, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "At ito pong mga katanungan ay nais niya pong ipaabot sa inyo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001244", "start_seconds": 10073.62, "end_seconds": 10082.26, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Una po, dederecho ko nang tatanungin yung tungkol po sa Unified Legal Assistance Service po ng judiciary." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001245", "start_seconds": 10083.2, "end_seconds": 10095.88, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Itinatag ng Supreme Court ang Unified Legal Aid Service o ULAS upang mapalawak ang libreng serbisyong legal para sa mga" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001252", "start_seconds": 10095.88, "end_seconds": 10099.0, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "indigent at marginalized Filipinos." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001253", "start_seconds": 10099.8, "end_seconds": 10110.26, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Para po sa unang katanungan, can you discuss briefly po to this committee kung paano ginagawang mas accessible ang legal aid sa ULAS?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001254", "start_seconds": 10112.72, "end_seconds": 10123.82, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Unang una po, bawat abogado na covered ng Unified Legal Aid Services ay mandatory po sa kanilang mag-render ng 36 hours of service." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001255", "start_seconds": 10123.82, "end_seconds": 10127.1, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kaya ang IBP po, or Integrated Bar" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001256", "start_seconds": 10127.3, "end_seconds": 10129.6, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "of the Philippines, ay na-systematized na po ito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001257", "start_seconds": 10130.0, "end_seconds": 10145.48, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kadalasan po, sila ay nag-talagang, meron po silang, it's not a portal, but they have their own access points wherein they represent, as you said po, the marginalized people." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001258", "start_seconds": 10146.54, "end_seconds": 10148.16, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Wala na pong kondisyon ng mga ito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001259", "start_seconds": 10148.16, "end_seconds": 10156.76, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "They just represent these litigants in court and then they register it as part of their service." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001260", "start_seconds": 10157.3, "end_seconds": 10159.64, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, fill in the 36 hours." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001261", "start_seconds": 10160.98, "end_seconds": 10171.1, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kadalasan din po ang mga judges, nag-a-appoint na rin po sila ng membro ng IBP through the ULAS para kung alam po nila ng isang litigante ay walang abogado." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001262", "start_seconds": 10171.42, "end_seconds": 10173.66, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So, malaking tulong po talaga itong ULAS." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001263", "start_seconds": 10174.22, "end_seconds": 10176.74, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Yes. Tama po kayo dun, no, Mr. Chair?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001264", "start_seconds": 10177.46, "end_seconds": 10185.74, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Magkano na po ang inilaan at nagastos ng judiciary para sa pagpatupad po ng ULAS?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001265", "start_seconds": 10187.3, "end_seconds": 10200.58, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Unang-una po sa opisina nila, 139 million po ang nakalaan kasi importante pong meron pong opisina to monitor the compliance of the lawyers covered sa ULAS." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001266", "start_seconds": 10201.08, "end_seconds": 10207.94, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So ang tawag po natin doon ay ULASO, hindi ba? ULAS Services. So ?139,098,000 po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001267", "start_seconds": 10207.94, "end_seconds": 10216.94, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Maraming salamat po. Para sa pangatlong katanungan, ilan na po ang aktuwal na natulungang indigent Filipino" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001268", "start_seconds": 10217.3, "end_seconds": 10220.26, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "mula nung ipinatupad po ito?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001269", "start_seconds": 10220.62, "end_seconds": 10231.2, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "We will just submit the data, Your Honor, but there is actually a portal to monitor compliance by lawyers, but we can submit the report. We do not have the figures now." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001270", "start_seconds": 10231.2, "end_seconds": 10247.2, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Yes. Okay lang po. Mr. Chair, since tingin ko po itong next po ay need din pong isasubmit na lang, can you also provide to us the regional breakdown ng mga qualified beneficiaries?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001271", "start_seconds": 10247.3, "end_seconds": 10258.52, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "And sa ang mga region o probinsya ang may pinakamababang access sa legal assistance sa ilalim ng ULAS?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001272", "start_seconds": 10258.72, "end_seconds": 10267.52, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Mr. Chair, maraming salamat po. Malinaw na mahalaga ang ULAS sa pagpapalawak ng access to justice." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001273", "start_seconds": 10267.52, "end_seconds": 10277.18, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Gayunman, hindi sapat na sukatin lamang ang tagumpay ng programa sa pamamagitan ng mga nakatalang oras." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001274", "start_seconds": 10277.3, "end_seconds": 10290.66, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Ang higit na mahalaga ay kung paano natitiyak ng hudikatura na ang serbisyong legal ay aktual na naipa rarating at nararamdaman ng mga mahihirap na Pilipino," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001275", "start_seconds": 10291.14, "end_seconds": 10297.26, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "lalo na mga nasa malalayong lugar na madalas hindi naaabot ng tulong legal." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001276", "start_seconds": 10297.9, "end_seconds": 10304.52, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Para po sa huling katanungan, Mr. Chair, ito naman po ay tungkol sa Sharia Courts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001277", "start_seconds": 10304.52, "end_seconds": 10304.9, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001278", "start_seconds": 10307.3, "end_seconds": 10314.14, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Ang Sharia Courts ay mahalaga para sa aming mga Muslim Pilipinos, lalo na sa mga usapin ng family law." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001279", "start_seconds": 10314.68, "end_seconds": 10324.1, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Pero sa mga naging konsultasyon po namin, lumalabas na mahirap pa rin po ang access ng kababaihang sa serbisyong ito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001280", "start_seconds": 10324.1, "end_seconds": 10339.0, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Ano po ang specific programs para sa 2027 ng Judiciary para siguraduhin na ang Sharia Courts ay magiging mas accessible at responsive sa pangangailangan ng mga kababaihan?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001281", "start_seconds": 10340.08, "end_seconds": 10347.78, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Sa Sharia District Court at Sharia Circuit Court, importante po na ma-fill upan po yung mga positions" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001282", "start_seconds": 10347.78, "end_seconds": 10355.08, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "kasi kadalasan po ang mga judges na qualified na mag-preside ng mga Sharia Courts ay kulang po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001283", "start_seconds": 10355.42, "end_seconds": 10358.02, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So importante po talaga na ma-fill upan ang mga yun." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001284", "start_seconds": 10358.02, "end_seconds": 10368.75, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang figure po natin sa Sharia Court, we have 104.635 million" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001285", "start_seconds": 10369.03, "end_seconds": 10369.55, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Pesos." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001286", "start_seconds": 10370.01, "end_seconds": 10371.95, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Lalong-lalo na po sa kanilang training." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001287", "start_seconds": 10372.45, "end_seconds": 10380.21, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "May naka-antabay po kaming training para sa mga Sharia, what we call the Sharia training program." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001288", "start_seconds": 10380.51, "end_seconds": 10393.75, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Dahil po bago nga mag-preside ang isang passer ng, sorry, sa Sharia Circuit Court kasi other than being a member of the bar," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001289", "start_seconds": 10394.21, "end_seconds": 10398.21, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "kailangan knowledgeable siya ng Islamic law and jurisprudence." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001290", "start_seconds": 10399.03, "end_seconds": 10407.55, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Unlike yung Sharia District Court, okay na yung two years minimum ng pagkakalam niya sa Islamic law and jurisprudence." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001291", "start_seconds": 10407.97, "end_seconds": 10421.33, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So in-expand po namin ito para mas marami nga ang makapag-apply at ma-fill upan na ang mga vacancies para sa ating particularly Sharia Circuit Courts and Sharia District Courts." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001292", "start_seconds": 10421.47, "end_seconds": 10425.39, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Yes. Maraming salamat po sa sagot na ito, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001293", "start_seconds": 10427.01, "end_seconds": 10428.91, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Actually, supportado ko po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001294", "start_seconds": 10429.03, "end_seconds": 10429.95, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Salamat po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001295", "start_seconds": 10429.95, "end_seconds": 10441.65, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "But it's just that gusto ko lamang pong ipaabot sa judiciary na marami po sa aming mga Muslim Filipinos ang patuloy pa rin pong nahihirapan sa access dito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001296", "start_seconds": 10442.19, "end_seconds": 10451.67, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Sana po ay mapabilis po natin yung pag-fill in ng mga judiciary courts po natin or Sharia courts po natin. I'm sorry." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001297", "start_seconds": 10452.41, "end_seconds": 10459.01, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Bukod sa pondo, malaking issue din ang vacancies o kakulangan ng mga judges sa mga Sharia." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001298", "start_seconds": 10459.03, "end_seconds": 10474.27, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Halimbawa, nang pumanaw ang isang Sharia judge sa trahedya ng MV Trisha Kerstin 3 noong January of this year, naiwan na walang judge ang mga korte sa kanyang pinaglilingkuran." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001299", "start_seconds": 10474.65, "end_seconds": 10483.93, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Ang ganitong sitwasyon ay direktang nakakaapekto sa kung gaano kabilis masolve ang mga cases ng mga Muslim Pilipino." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001300", "start_seconds": 10483.93, "end_seconds": 10488.93, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Sa pagkakaalam ko po, siya po ay maraming probinsyang pinagseserbisyuhan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001301", "start_seconds": 10489.03, "end_seconds": 10510.03, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Isa na rin po yung sa Sulu, North Cotabato, Kabacan, Marawi, Lanao. So ibig sabihin po, sa ganitong kalaking probinsyang pinagseserbisyuhan niya po at siya ay nawala na at wala pa rin pong nag-fill in." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001302", "start_seconds": 10510.03, "end_seconds": 10515.87, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Kung sakali, marami pong Muslim Pilipinos talaga ang maaapektuhan nito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001303", "start_seconds": 10516.25, "end_seconds": 10519.01, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Ngayon, gusto ko pong malaman sana ano po ang plan." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001304", "start_seconds": 10519.03, "end_seconds": 10524.95, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Ano ang judisyari patungkol dito at kailan po kaya natin makukomit na magkakaroon na ito?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001305", "start_seconds": 10525.47, "end_seconds": 10530.63, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Una-una po ang training, capacity building po ng maaaring mag-apply po ng judges." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001306", "start_seconds": 10530.89, "end_seconds": 10535.21, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Nakalaan po yan this October or if not November para po sa training." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001307", "start_seconds": 10535.63, "end_seconds": 10539.69, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "As of now, according to our Philippine Judicial Academy, 78 na pong nag-register." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001308", "start_seconds": 10539.69, "end_seconds": 10548.45, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So hopefully po kung yung 41 na unfilled positions po ng ating Sharia Circuit Court tapos 5 po ang Sharia District Court ay mapabilis po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001310", "start_seconds": 10550.37, "end_seconds": 10552.97, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Pangalawa po, yung safety po ng judges." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001311", "start_seconds": 10553.47, "end_seconds": 10558.99, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang sinasabi po ninyo, hindi po namin makalimutan iyon. That is the Honorable Judge Alfredo Romoros." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001312", "start_seconds": 10558.99, "end_seconds": 10570.21, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yung pag-transport po niya, he uses land, water, and air para lang po makapunta, makarating from Tawi-Tawi, from Sulu, Maranao-Sulu to Zamboanga." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001313", "start_seconds": 10570.63, "end_seconds": 10574.15, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Sa high seas po ng Zamboanga, doon lumubog po yung kanyang ano." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001314", "start_seconds": 10574.55, "end_seconds": 10578.99, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So nakipag-coordinate po kami, may negotiation po kami ngayon with the Philippine Coast Guard." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001315", "start_seconds": 10579.03, "end_seconds": 10592.45, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "They volunteered to bring in our judges from their port kung saan po sila manggagaling hanggang sa coastal area po, let's say Zamboanga, Tawi-Tawi, or Sulu, para mapabilis po at masecure yung kanilang travel." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001316", "start_seconds": 10593.27, "end_seconds": 10599.51, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "With this, Mr. Chair, nagpapasalamat po ako at masaya akong marinig ito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001317", "start_seconds": 10600.35, "end_seconds": 10605.11, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Sana po yung October ay mabilis na lamang at ma-fill in na po ito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001318", "start_seconds": 10605.11, "end_seconds": 10608.81, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "And nagpapasalamat ako na sinisecure na po talaga natin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001319", "start_seconds": 10609.03, "end_seconds": 10614.79, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Ating mga lawyers po or mga judges po natin sa mga courts na ito." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001320", "start_seconds": 10615.13, "end_seconds": 10623.69, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "With that, I manifest my support to the judiciary para po sa kanilang budget po for 2027." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001321", "start_seconds": 10623.93, "end_seconds": 10624.79, "speaker": "Rep. Dadah Kiram Ismula", "text": "Maraming salamat, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001322", "start_seconds": 10624.79, "end_seconds": 10625.83, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Maraming salamat din po." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001323", "start_seconds": 10627.53, "end_seconds": 10629.99, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you, Representative Dada Esmula." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001324", "start_seconds": 10629.99, "end_seconds": 10637.81, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Now we go back to the majority and we'd like to ask Representative Jay Vergara to ask his questions." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001325", "start_seconds": 10638.27, "end_seconds": 10638.99, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001326", "start_seconds": 10639.03, "end_seconds": 10641.45, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Magandang tangali po, Mr. Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001327", "start_seconds": 10643.85, "end_seconds": 10659.03, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Gusto ko lang po malaman, doon sa 86.27 billion natin na pondo, ano po ang allotted for digitalization?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001328", "start_seconds": 10661.22, "end_seconds": 10661.52, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "ICT" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001329", "start_seconds": 10669.01, "end_seconds": 10671.09, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Kung ano na lamang po ay?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001330", "start_seconds": 10671.75, "end_seconds": 10674.09, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Pagpaubaya po ninyo, titignan lang po namin yung figures namin." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001331", "start_seconds": 10674.95, "end_seconds": 10683.37, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Ipakipadala na lamang po yung dato sa akin kung hindi maibigay kaagad." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001332", "start_seconds": 10683.57, "end_seconds": 10687.51, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Tsaka nag-improve po ba dahil sa digitalization?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001333", "start_seconds": 10691.51, "end_seconds": 10691.77, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Okay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001334", "start_seconds": 10692.29, "end_seconds": 10697.83, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "So ito po ang figure na galing na po sa aming Management Information System Office or MISO." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001335", "start_seconds": 10697.83, "end_seconds": 10707.83, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Ang kailangan po ay ang total po na kailangan nilang pondo para sa digital infrastructure po ng Supreme Court ay P5," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001336", "start_seconds": 10707.99, "end_seconds": 10713.25, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "208,182,274.71." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001337", "start_seconds": 10714.25, "end_seconds": 10717.77, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Ang training po ng personnel ninyo ay kasama dyan ?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001338", "start_seconds": 10718.77, "end_seconds": 10720.89, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kasama na po, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001339", "start_seconds": 10721.81, "end_seconds": 10725.69, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Sa cybersecurity po kung sakaling ma-hack tayo?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001340", "start_seconds": 10726.25, "end_seconds": 10731.15, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Meron po ba kayong sistema para ito ay [unclear]?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001341", "start_seconds": 10731.71, "end_seconds": 10733.51, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kasama po yun, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001342", "start_seconds": 10734.85, "end_seconds": 10735.79, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Kasama po?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001343", "start_seconds": 10736.79, "end_seconds": 10737.29, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Okay." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001344", "start_seconds": 10737.99, "end_seconds": 10741.37, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Do you need the specific figures, Your Honor? We can provide it." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001345", "start_seconds": 10741.37, "end_seconds": 10743.41, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Just provide it in my office, ma'am." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001346", "start_seconds": 10743.43, "end_seconds": 10744.89, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Kasama po ang cyber security." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001347", "start_seconds": 10744.89, "end_seconds": 10764.72, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Yes. So, sa lahat po ng lalawigan, marami rin pong lalawigan na kulang ang, o cramped na yung spaces natin for the Hall of Justices." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001348", "start_seconds": 10764.72, "end_seconds": 10772.42, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Yes. MTC and RTC. Kasama po ang PAO. Nagsasama-sama na naman po sila eh." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001349", "start_seconds": 10772.7, "end_seconds": 10779.34, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "At sa amin po sa Nueva Ecija, malaki po ang Kabanatuan City." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001350", "start_seconds": 10781.3, "end_seconds": 10787.64, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Maganda po, meron po kaming government center na 32 hectares." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001351", "start_seconds": 10787.64, "end_seconds": 10793.96, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "Kung hindi po kaya ng pondo ngayong taon na ito, kahit na po sa susunod ng mga taon po," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001352", "start_seconds": 10794.46, "end_seconds": 10794.64, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "ay ma-consider po sana." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001353", "start_seconds": 10794.72, "end_seconds": 10799.58, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "At with that, Mr. Chair," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001354", "start_seconds": 10800.0, "end_seconds": 10807.28, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "i'd like to manifest my full support for the approval of the proposed budget of the judiciary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001355", "start_seconds": 10807.28, "end_seconds": 10809.35, "speaker": "Rep. Julius Cesar \"Jay\" V. Vergara", "text": "thank you your honor" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001355-split-2", "start_seconds": 10809.35, "end_seconds": 10815.5, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "thank you representative jay vergara we now go to the minority with the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001356", "start_seconds": 10816.14, "end_seconds": 10819.22, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "representative robert nazal" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001356-split-2", "start_seconds": 10819.22, "end_seconds": 10823.5, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "thank you mr chair mr chair on the part of the minority" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001357", "start_seconds": 10824.06, "end_seconds": 10826.9, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "i would just like to make a manifestation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001357-split-2", "start_seconds": 10826.9, "end_seconds": 10827.9, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "proceed" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001357-split-3", "start_seconds": 10827.9, "end_seconds": 10830.86, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "first i would like to commend the judiciary for" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001358", "start_seconds": 10830.86, "end_seconds": 10838.14, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "its very high absorptive capacity in 2025 you were able to obligate almost 99 percent of your" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001359", "start_seconds": 10838.14, "end_seconds": 10847.5, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "Available allotments with disbursements also closely tracking your obligations. Sana po tularan kayo ng ibang ahensya ng gobyerno." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001360", "start_seconds": 10848.78, "end_seconds": 10852.3, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "we always say that agencies should not ask congress for more money" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001361", "start_seconds": 10853.18, "end_seconds": 10858.78, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "if they cannot spend what we already gave them but the reverse should also be true" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001362", "start_seconds": 10858.78, "end_seconds": 10860.78, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "when an institution demonstrates that" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001363", "start_seconds": 10860.86, "end_seconds": 10867.34, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "it can responsibly utilize its budget then that should be considered when congress determines" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001364", "start_seconds": 10867.34, "end_seconds": 10873.98, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "whether an increase is warranted i would also like to congratulate the judiciary on its GAD program" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001365", "start_seconds": 10874.94, "end_seconds": 10881.26, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "this was an issue previously raised in the budget hearings because there was a time when" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001366", "start_seconds": 10881.26, "end_seconds": 10889.26, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "GAD utilization was practically zero so salamat po diyan we are therefore very pleased to see that the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001367", "start_seconds": 10889.26, "end_seconds": 10895.18, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "judiciary is now actually implementing GAD programs and has even published its GAD" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001368", "start_seconds": 10895.18, "end_seconds": 10903.26, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "accomplishment report so mr chair considering both its absorptive capacity and the improvements" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001369", "start_seconds": 10903.26, "end_seconds": 10909.42, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "we are seeing in the utilization of its GAD budget i believe the judiciary has demonstrated" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001370", "start_seconds": 10909.42, "end_seconds": 10915.98, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "that additional resources can be put to use on the part of the minority we support an adequate" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001371", "start_seconds": 10915.98, "end_seconds": 10918.62, "speaker": "Rep. Roberto Nazal", "text": "increase in the judiciary's budget thank you mr chair" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001372", "start_seconds": 10923.25, "end_seconds": 10928.53, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "thank you very much congressman robert nazal last in the interpretation is the honorable vice" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001373", "start_seconds": 10928.53, "end_seconds": 10930.28, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "chair jam baronda" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001373-split-2", "start_seconds": 10930.28, "end_seconds": 10931.49, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "thank you mr chair" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001373-split-3", "start_seconds": 10931.49, "end_seconds": 10933.89, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "but before you would speak i would just like to thank the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001374", "start_seconds": 10933.89, "end_seconds": 10940.05, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "following who had already signified they will not ask questions anymore but support wholly" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001375", "start_seconds": 10940.05, "end_seconds": 10945.97, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "the budget and the additional augmentation for the judiciary the following from the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001376", "start_seconds": 10945.97, "end_seconds": 10953.01, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "minority we thank Congressman Egay Erice we also thank from the majority Congressman Marlo" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001377", "start_seconds": 10953.17, "end_seconds": 10961.97, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Bancoro, Representative Joboy Aquino, Congressman Amado Bolilia, Congressman Maximo Rodriguez" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001378", "start_seconds": 10961.97, "end_seconds": 10967.9, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and Congressman Richard Gomez. Pasalamatan, palakpakan natin sila." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001379", "start_seconds": 10967.97, "end_seconds": 10973.66, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "they are supporting the budget of the judiciary yes vice chairman jam" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001379-split-2", "start_seconds": 10973.66, "end_seconds": 10975.41, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "thank you miss mr chair" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001380", "start_seconds": 10975.97, "end_seconds": 10980.85, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "actually i even joked you i will not support the budget of judiciary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001381", "start_seconds": 10980.85, "end_seconds": 10983.9, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "kasi hindi nasama yung construction" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001382", "start_seconds": 10983.93, "end_seconds": 10992.5, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "for Iloilo, for Hall of Justice in Iloilo. In 1992, you opened the Hall of Justice in Iloilo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001383", "start_seconds": 10992.53, "end_seconds": 10994.0, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "And in 2012," }, { "stable_id": "asr-001384", "start_seconds": 10994.5, "end_seconds": 11001.01, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "nagkaroon ng major retrofitting ang Hall of Justice and in 2025 it was" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001385", "start_seconds": 11001.01, "end_seconds": 11002.38, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "discussed na" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001386", "start_seconds": 11002.39, "end_seconds": 11004.05, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "unsafe for you to stay there" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001387", "start_seconds": 11004.85, "end_seconds": 11005.65, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "but until" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001388", "start_seconds": 11005.65, "end_seconds": 11009.09, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "now you are still occupying the hall of justice" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001389", "start_seconds": 11009.97, "end_seconds": 11011.73, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "and with that mr chair i hope" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001390", "start_seconds": 11011.73, "end_seconds": 11014.0, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "isama natin sa" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001391", "start_seconds": 11014.0, "end_seconds": 11019.33, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "augmentation request on the construction of Hall of Justice for Iloilo City and" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001392", "start_seconds": 11019.33, "end_seconds": 11026.47, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "with that also we need also to exercise due diligence where to transfer because" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001393", "start_seconds": 11026.47, "end_seconds": 11035.25, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "ayaw natin na mangyari ang nangyari sa Iloilo. Like in 1992 when you" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001394", "start_seconds": 11035.25, "end_seconds": 11041.09, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "transferred or when you opened Hall of Justice it was found out na very low [unclear] pala yung area." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001395", "start_seconds": 11041.09, "end_seconds": 11049.61, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "And with that I would like also to ask of course the chair and the good chair if you also help us" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001396", "start_seconds": 11049.61, "end_seconds": 11059.27, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "in securing fund. Especially in adding Iloilo City or Hall of Justice in Iloilo City. With that" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001397", "start_seconds": 11059.27, "end_seconds": 11064.37, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "Mr. Chair I would like to manifest to include Iloilo City Hall of Justice as part of the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001398", "start_seconds": 11064.37, "end_seconds": 11070.79, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "priority programs of the proposed budget of the judiciary here in the House of Congress." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001399", "start_seconds": 11071.09, "end_seconds": 11073.03, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "Thank you so much Mr. Chair. Thank you." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001399-split-2", "start_seconds": 11073.03, "end_seconds": 11073.8, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Thank you very much." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001399-split-3", "start_seconds": 11073.8, "end_seconds": 11074.6, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "Thank you sir." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001399-split-4", "start_seconds": 11074.6, "end_seconds": 11076.07, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Our Vice Chair" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001400", "start_seconds": 11076.07, "end_seconds": 11082.97, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Jam Baronda. We have been instructed by the Speaker to terminate proceedings but we gave" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001401", "start_seconds": 11082.97, "end_seconds": 11089.56, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "a chance to Congressman Beloso to be able to speak very short." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001401-split-2", "start_seconds": 11089.56, "end_seconds": 11092.56, "speaker": "Rep. Girlie E. Veloso", "text": "No further question Mr. Chair" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001402", "start_seconds": 11092.56, "end_seconds": 11101.62, "speaker": "Rep. Girlie E. Veloso", "text": "but since you've given me the opportunity to speak I would like to manifest my full support for the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001403", "start_seconds": 11103.36, "end_seconds": 11110.5, "speaker": "Rep. Girlie E. Veloso", "text": "approval of the proposed 2027 budget of the judiciary. Daghang salamat [unclear]." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001404", "start_seconds": 11110.86, "end_seconds": 11118.7, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "Okay now I turn over to the Honorable Real Chairman of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001405", "start_seconds": 11118.7, "end_seconds": 11124.6, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "the committee. No, you have to be here. Ikaw yung ano, the big boss, chair of the most powerful committee. Robert" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001406", "start_seconds": 11124.6, "end_seconds": 11128.92, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "wala ka pa? Okay na. Yeah, so we now turn the gavel back to our real." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001406-split-2", "start_seconds": 11128.92, "end_seconds": 11133.24, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Good afternoon po, Your Honorable Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001416", "start_seconds": 11133.24, "end_seconds": 11140.6, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "chairperson of the Super Committee on Appropriations. The floor is yours, my dear" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001417", "start_seconds": 11140.6, "end_seconds": 11166.06, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "chairperson. Okay, upon instructions of the chairperson, we asked the Supreme Court" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001418", "start_seconds": 11166.06, "end_seconds": 11173.18, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "and other courts and of course sandigan bayan court of tax appeals and the c a court of appeals" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001419", "start_seconds": 11173.82, "end_seconds": 11181.42, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "to submit what you think should be augmented we thank you for a very very exemplary performance" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001420", "start_seconds": 11182.06, "end_seconds": 11188.78, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "in the disposition of cases also in your dispensation of justice and the chairperson" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001421", "start_seconds": 11188.78, "end_seconds": 11196.22, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "is ready to accept those i know that all your budgets were approved under our republic act 1" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001422", "start_seconds": 11196.22, "end_seconds": 11204.62, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "12233, but our chairperson is here to be able to accept the four letters of augmentation" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001423", "start_seconds": 11204.62, "end_seconds": 11209.36, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "from the four courts so thank you madam chair you have the floor" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001423-split-2", "start_seconds": 11209.36, "end_seconds": 11210.86, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "thank you very much vice chair" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001424", "start_seconds": 11211.74, "end_seconds": 11217.42, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "Rufus Rodriguez. Thank you. First and foremost, thank you for your exemplary management of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001425", "start_seconds": 11217.42, "end_seconds": 11225.18, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "today's hearings. Maraming maraming salamat po. As you know po, I left you in very good hands, the best" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001426", "start_seconds": 11225.18, "end_seconds": 11233.98, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "the best person to be the budget sponsor for the judiciary so thank you very much um i'd like to" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001427", "start_seconds": 11233.98, "end_seconds": 11240.94, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "reiterate siguro po what Chair Rufus said. As you know, one of the most important reforms that we've" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001428", "start_seconds": 11241.74, "end_seconds": 11247.02, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "seen in the committee on appropriations is to subject all of the requests for institutional" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001429", "start_seconds": 11247.02, "end_seconds": 11253.9, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "amendments emanating from all of the different branches and the agencies through the budget" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001430", "start_seconds": 11253.9, "end_seconds": 11258.7, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "amendments review subcommittee so we openly deliberate on them and we show the public" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001431", "start_seconds": 11258.7, "end_seconds": 11265.66, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "line by line as to where the funds are allocated. So magre-request lang po kami if it is okay. I know it is a" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001432", "start_seconds": 11265.66, "end_seconds": 11270.38, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "little bit short notice but since we're heading through plenary next week we're hoping to convene" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001433", "start_seconds": 11271.74, "end_seconds": 11279.26, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "um this week uh before the plenary so if we may request paul if we could have the the additional" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001434", "start_seconds": 11279.26, "end_seconds": 11288.14, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "items that you would like us to consider for additional funding. Kaya po ba bukas, or would" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001435", "start_seconds": 11288.14, "end_seconds": 11290.43, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "that be too short of a notice" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001435-split-2", "start_seconds": 11290.43, "end_seconds": 11295.9, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "we we uh we do love the fact that you are willing to accommodate our" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001436", "start_seconds": 11295.9, "end_seconds": 11301.1, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "request for augmentation your honor so by thursday alone we are ready to submit now from all courts" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001437", "start_seconds": 11301.74, "end_seconds": 11303.0, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "Thank you very much. Or by Wednesday?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001437-split-2", "start_seconds": 11303.0, "end_seconds": 11304.3, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Wednesday, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001437-split-3", "start_seconds": 11304.3, "end_seconds": 11306.0, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "Just two days from now." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001437-split-4", "start_seconds": 11306.0, "end_seconds": 11306.94, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, Your Honor." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001438", "start_seconds": 11306.94, "end_seconds": 11311.34, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "Wednesday po would be great. Wednesday before lunch, would that be okay po?" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001439", "start_seconds": 11311.34, "end_seconds": 11313.18, "speaker": "Court Administrator Theresa Dolores Gomez-Estoesta", "text": "Yes, Your Honor. Yes, Your Honor. Opo." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001439-split-2", "start_seconds": 11313.18, "end_seconds": 11316.38, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "Because we're now in the process of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001440", "start_seconds": 11316.38, "end_seconds": 11323.52, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "compiling all of the requests for institutional amendments from all the agencies po. And, yeah, siguro po I would like to" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001441", "start_seconds": 11323.52, "end_seconds": 11327.5, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "second what Chair Rufus said. Thank you po to" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001442", "start_seconds": 11327.5, "end_seconds": 11331.58, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "the Judiciary for the exemplary performance. We commend you for" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001443", "start_seconds": 11331.74, "end_seconds": 11338.16, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "your exemplary performance po. And we're so grateful for all the great work that you are doing for our" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001444", "start_seconds": 11338.16, "end_seconds": 11343.28, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "country and the best that we can do on the part of the house of representatives to express our" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001445", "start_seconds": 11343.28, "end_seconds": 11348.58, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "gratitude for the great work that you are doing is to provide you with the resources to be able" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001446", "start_seconds": 11348.58, "end_seconds": 11356.3, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "to perform your mandate um in the in the coming fiscal year so and above whichever we can um with" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001447", "start_seconds": 11356.3, "end_seconds": 11362.0, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "the caveat that we have to be cognizant of the limited fiscal space uh we will do our best to be" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001448", "start_seconds": 11362.0, "end_seconds": 11368.64, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "able to um accommodate uh the the items for consideration which you will be submitting to us" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001449", "start_seconds": 11368.64, "end_seconds": 11373.12, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "so i um yes yes but chair rufus" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001449-split-2", "start_seconds": 11373.12, "end_seconds": 11378.0, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "i now with that on that note your congratulations to the judiciary" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001450", "start_seconds": 11378.0, "end_seconds": 11386.0, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "i moved that the committee terminate its hearing on the proposed fiscal year 2027 budget to the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001451", "start_seconds": 11386.0, "end_seconds": 11387.82, "speaker": "Rep. Rufus B. Rodriguez", "text": "judiciary. I so move." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001452", "start_seconds": 11387.82, "end_seconds": 11400.78, "speaker": "Rep. Julienne \"Jam\" L. Baronda", "text": "I second the motion Mr Chair." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001452-split-2", "start_seconds": 11400.78, "end_seconds": 11404.5, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "There is a motion to terminate the hearing on" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001453", "start_seconds": 11404.5, "end_seconds": 11411.64, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "the proposed fiscal 2027 budget of the judiciary. It has been duly seconded. The motion is carried." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001454", "start_seconds": 11411.64, "end_seconds": 11421.54, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "thank you very much to our um esteemed justices thank you to our judiciary family for for the" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001455", "start_seconds": 11421.54, "end_seconds": 11422.66, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "time um that you have been with us today thank you very much" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001456", "start_seconds": 11422.68, "end_seconds": 11425.5, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "um your contributions um our testimony and and the efforts that you have given us today and of" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001457", "start_seconds": 11425.5, "end_seconds": 11430.5, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "course thank you to our honorable members of um the committee on appropriations in our colleagues" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001458", "start_seconds": 11430.5, "end_seconds": 11435.18, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "in the house for active participation in today's deliberations madam chair thank you your honor" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001459", "start_seconds": 11435.18, "end_seconds": 11436.67, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "yes um representative pagernas" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001459-split-2", "start_seconds": 11436.67, "end_seconds": 11440.76, "speaker": "Rep. Jan \"Atty. JP\" Padiernos", "text": "madam chair i move that we suspend the committee hearing" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001460", "start_seconds": 11440.76, "end_seconds": 11444.0, "speaker": "Rep. Jan \"Atty. JP\" Padiernos", "text": "here at the plenary hall on House Bill No. 10858. I so move." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001460-split-2", "start_seconds": 11444.0, "end_seconds": 11444.86, "speaker": "Committee participant (seconding member)", "text": "Second." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001460-split-3", "start_seconds": 11444.86, "end_seconds": 11448.42, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "There is a motion" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001461", "start_seconds": 11448.44, "end_seconds": 11452.56, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "that has been duly seconded to suspend the committee hearing here in the plenary hall on House Bill No. 10858." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001462", "start_seconds": 11452.68, "end_seconds": 11458.32, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "Again, it has been duly seconded. The motion" }, { "stable_id": "asr-001463", "start_seconds": 11458.32, "end_seconds": 11461.53, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "is carried. Thank you very much, everyone." }, { "stable_id": "asr-001463-split-2", "start_seconds": 11461.53, "end_seconds": 11464.36, "speaker": "Rep. Mikaela Angela B. Suansing", "text": "Thank you po. Thank you po." } ] }